Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be annoyed that my mum doesn't want to be called Gran, Granny, Grandma, Nan.....

132 replies

sar123 · 22/03/2007 09:28

..... or anything else vaguely grannyish sounding? My dad is happy with grandad. Just can't help feeling that it's a bit selfish of her. After all she IS a grandparent, no getting away from that! Ok she's young in comparison to many of my friends mothers but all the same....Should I insist? Or seek a suitable alternative?
And anyway, what alternatives are there to the obvious? What do your dc's call their grandparents?

OP posts:
Mossie · 22/03/2007 16:17

Exact opposite of my mil; the moment I got pg she started (surreptitiously) referring to herself as Gran! Made me pmsl! She is 64 and very young-acting / looking but all her friends have had grandchildren for years so she has felt a bit left out.

twinklingstar · 22/03/2007 16:05

Charlottegeorgiaoliversmums, thanks for that - it is tricky, isn't it? Ds's partner and her dd are lovely and we see them quite often. It struck me yesterday when her mum said 'show twinklingstar........' and I thought it would be a step too far for me to be called any grandmotherly kind of name at this point (she is 13 months) but what if ds and her mum had a child together who called me Gran (or whatever)? I wouldn't mind if she did call me a grandmotherly name, but would calling me twinklingstar for however long first mean it would be impossible for her to switch from calling me by my christian name to Gran?

charlottegeorgiaolivermums · 22/03/2007 15:55

My sc call my parents by their Christian names as they were all over 8yrs old when dh and I got together our children call then nanny and grandad.

But they call their mothers dh parents nan first name and grandad first name as they where younger.

Whatever happens your grandchildren will now that your their nanny. My dd1 us nearly 4 and understands she has 2 older brothers and a sister who are not mine, but can't understand why they call her daddy 'dad'. She get confused but always falls back on what we have told her that they are her brothers and sisters. Can't explain half families and ex wifes to a 4 year old the other day she asked about why my sd calls someone else mummy and asked why I tried to explain and she just looked totally lost.

twinklingstar · 22/03/2007 15:45

Anyone have any experience of this situation:- ds has a partner with a child by a previous partner. It seems very likely that ds and she may have children in the future, so if her lo calls me by my christian name, what will happen when a sibling comes along? Any ideas or experiences to share?

CAM · 22/03/2007 15:19

Agree with bundle, in reality its got to be her choice. I'm a grandmother who is not called any of the traditional gp names, my choice.

Can't stand dictatorial people.

charlottegeorgiaolivermums · 22/03/2007 15:11

Sar123

My fil said he was 2 young to be a grandad when my dh had 1st 3 children with 1st wife. They all call him by his 1st name.

I hate this like the children sound totally disrespectful but they always called him by that so when I came along had no say.

However, when I had my dd1 nearly 4 years ago I told dh that they would call him grandad and thats that if he doesn't like it it's his problem not mine my children will be respectful and it would confuse them as all their friends will have nanny's and grandad's so why do they have nanny and (yes he is a true grandad - he's by dh biological father) Could understand more if he was a step father etc.

He never pushed it and all my dc call him grandad it appears he's old enough now - but he's now an old grandad as he's friends are becoming great-grandads at 70 and he's just had another grandchild my ds3.

My mum said she doesn't like the name nanny or grandma and said she'd prefer Nana - but when I told her this just reminded me of the Collie from Disney's 'Snow Dogs' she changed her mind.

Surely your mum would understand that you don't want your children to feel left out by not having a nanny when their friends all do?
Also a good lesson for children in respect to elders etc.

In the book I'm reading the children call their grandmother 'OMA' which is the Dutch term for grandmother. doesn't sound nannyish to my British ears would this or any other languages word do?

Tanee58 · 22/03/2007 15:11

Nona is nice - it's Italian.

gscrym · 22/03/2007 15:10

How about a foreign translation of grandma.

gscrym · 22/03/2007 15:09

DS picked his own name for them. My mum is GaGa and my dad is Jone. He heard someone shouting hello to my dad and just copied it. He won't call him grandad, granpa, papa or anything else. My dad doesn't mind.

twelveyeargap · 22/03/2007 15:08

I would leave it for now. She does seem to have issues around losing her identity or whatever it is that made her funny about you calling her mum.

When your child is older you can refer to her as "Grandma " but always call her her chosen name to her face and your child will follow suit.

juicychops · 22/03/2007 15:07

my mum is only 49 and doesn't like being called gran granny or grandma. But she likes being called nanny

Boobsgonesouth · 22/03/2007 15:02

my mum and dad are very proud to be called nany & grandad, FIl to be called "pamper" but MIL, oh no, she wanted to be different., insisted on NOT being called grandma and announced "i want to be called Nina" no idea why....

so I get the children to call her grandma Nina...she can like it or lump it !!!!

GreatGooglyMoogly · 22/03/2007 15:00

I don't think you're being unreasonable. In the end, your child will call their grandparents what you tell them their names are, so you decide. My parents are Kiwi Nana (in NZ) and Grandad and ILs are Nanna and Grandpa. Both of the grandmothers wanted Nan(n)a so we came to a compromise once ds1 started getting confused. The grandfathers were told what they would be called! My father was like your mother in that he didn't want to have a grandparent-type name and was coming up with ridiculous alternatives so in the end we decided he was Grandad and ds1 learnt that that was his name so he conceded.

MintChocChippyMinton · 22/03/2007 14:52

My DC call all their grandparents 'Grandma first name' and 'Grandad first name'. And very proud of their titles they are too.

3easterbunniesandnomore · 22/03/2007 14:42

what a shame really...I mean surely it's a wellearned title, something to be proud off!

Twiglett · 22/03/2007 14:24

I find it funny that both Cod and Enid who are self-professed fashionistas with strong ideas of style think that the grandmother is just being Vain

mummylin2495 · 22/03/2007 12:36

i have three grandchildren and am very proud to be called nan,my dh used to be called dan-dan but it has now progressed to grandad,i am just proud to have them all,children will usually make up their own names anyway.

tibsy · 22/03/2007 12:25

we have nanny and granga (ds named my dad, when he started talking), was previously grandad. il's are gramma and bampa

humpydumpy · 22/03/2007 12:24

My Grandma insisted we called her by her proper name, which was fine and all we knew. It was only really a problem when as a child I would talk about her to friends and I never knew what to call her then. If I said her name I had to give an explanation of who she was and why I called her by her name and calling her Grandma felt wrong. Far too confusing as a child.

Libra · 22/03/2007 12:11

When my sister first gave birth, my parents were officially informed by her parents in law that THEY were grandma and grandad and that no other grandparents were 'allowed' these names. They have seven children and apparently made the same notification at every single grandchild's birth. My parents think they are barking, but are happy with the Welsh equivalents anyway.
MY MIL refused 'farmor', the Danish version, and insists on 'bedstemor', which is more formal. She changed her mind about two years ago and got very cross when the children refused to change her name.... mad.

nappyaddict · 22/03/2007 12:10

what about nonno? that's a normal grandmother name but sounds slightly modern?

nappyaddict · 22/03/2007 12:08

i remember 2 girls at school calling theirs nunu (i get images off teletubbies though with that one now) and nanoo and grandmummy too. think that's all the ones i can think of for the moment.

PinkTulips · 22/03/2007 12:07

dc's randparents are granny and opa (although she signs cards oma and opa but dd uses granny) and nana and granddad

could you use a foreign name for granny? surely she doesn't expect them to call her by her name?!

Muminfife · 22/03/2007 12:04

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

nappyaddict · 22/03/2007 12:03

my cousins used to call them grammy/grams and grandpa and there other ones grandmamy/mama and grandad.

2 ladies up the road are called nonna and granna by their GC.

how about g-mama!!! pmsl sounds like some rapping granny!