Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not want dd to go on a school day trip that involves 2 trips to McDonalds

142 replies

robinpud · 21/03/2007 09:28

1 for breakfast and 1 for dinner in the evening?

OP posts:
clumsymum · 21/03/2007 11:26

I don't think this will kill her, as a 'once in a lifetime' experience. Eating at McDs twice in one day might even put her offwanting to go to McDs again for a while.

Before I had DS, when I spent a lot of work time on the road, it wasn't unknown for me to have breakfast and dinner(evening) at McD, as I found the food generally more palatable and filling than the crap they sold at UK motorway service station "restaurants". I'm still here (and not fat either).

I would perhaps mention to the school that it seems a surprising choice tho'.
I wouldn't make an issue of it with my child either, that would just fuel the fire.

ScummyMummy · 21/03/2007 11:22

Me too, hmc. I don't think McDs occasionally is the end of the world (though it is somehow intrinsically a rather depressing place, I find) but I can't see that it should have any place in schools/educational trips.

handlemecarefully · 21/03/2007 11:19

At our school the children would probably be taken on a detour to Holland and Barrett to stock up on sunflower seeds. Our Headteacher would rather boil her own head than frequent McD's on a school trip.

On balance, I kind of like it that way

ScummyMummy · 21/03/2007 11:15

Your boys already fancy iron filings and rabbit sick, greeny? What advanced palates! Mine have still not graduated onto these delicacies.

handlemecarefully · 21/03/2007 11:13

Greeny you are incorrigible!

Nbg · 21/03/2007 11:12

They dont have to have muffins and burgers at breakfast.
McD's do porridge now and fruit bags and for her evening meal she could have the carrot batons instead of chips.

I'm presuming that you get that kind of menu at McDs there?

Greensleeves · 21/03/2007 11:12

I'm an "all thing in moderation" mum too. In fact I've just given ds2 a bowl of iron filings for elevensies, washed down with a mug of rabbit sick. A little of what you fancy does you good

handlemecarefully · 21/03/2007 11:10

I think it's a bit rubbish tbh (this speaking as an everything in moderation mum who does occasionally allow McD visits). I would let dd go but would write a letter to the Head expressing my disappointment. One visit to McD on a school trip is okay..ish but two is OTT.

Stigaloid · 21/03/2007 11:06

Can you not feed her first for breakfast and then drop her off for the rest of the day?

I'd be unhappy having McD's in my child's diet - it is so completely unhealthy and full of preservatives.

Either that or let it be a one off - encourage the mass eating of preservatives and sugar and sit back with the gleeful knowledge that the school will be dealing with a class full of hyperactive kids all day!

hehehehe!

robinpud · 21/03/2007 10:58

Thanks for that Greeny.. I am writing it down as we speak..

OP posts:
ghosty · 21/03/2007 10:53

Greeny for President ...
Brilliant Post ... I so wish I could write posts like that
"it's not his fault the teacher organising the trip is a slovenly lard-guzzling tosswank" PMSL

ghosty · 21/03/2007 10:51

Robinpud ... am out of date with my subs to MN so can't CAT ...
Email me on ghostyandmeg(at)xtra(dot)co(dot)nz ... would love to hear more

Scummy ... thanks for lovely message We have done EXACTLY what you describe ... DH found a nice suburb that is perfect for us as a family (similar type to where we live now) rather than the posh, salubrious suburbs where it is all about schools and achievement. Still nice school where the house is but not too far up it's own backside IYSWIM? Still, DH had a job telling them that DS really needs to stay in his correct year group (young for the year or not) ...

Greensleeves · 21/03/2007 10:50

If it was one of my boys I would let him go, because he would be gutted if I didn't, and it's not his fault the teacher organising the trip is a slovenly lard-guzzling tosswank. I would send him with a couple of pieces of fruit and a bottle of water though, and instructions NOT to eat burgers/nuggets because they are crawling with filth and laden with axle grease.

I would write a blistering letter to the school and demand 1) an explanation, and 2) a promise of more suitable arrangements next time.

robinpud · 21/03/2007 10:45

Ghosty.. do not be browbeaten .. would definitely want him in 2nd grade.. at least.
Cat me and I will fill you in on my EARly findings.. am in contact with a lot of other people just here for a year with kids so we talk a lot about schools.
Will be visiting Melbourne over Easter..
We so so so so loved NZ.. want to live in Wanaka..

OP posts:
Saturn74 · 21/03/2007 10:45

It's poor planning by the school.
But I think that it is unreasonable to not want her to go just for that reason.
I also think it might be awkward for her if you sent her with alternative food if everyone else is eating at McDonald's.
I wouldn't be thrilled, but I'd let the issue go, TBH.

ScummyMummy · 21/03/2007 10:44

How exciting Ghosty- I've always thought Melbourne looks like a fab city. If it was my boys I would go with where I thought they would be most comfortable socially rather than academically, fwiw. I think all things being equal that's more important. They are not super-bright though so I don't think i'd have to contend with a massive boredom factor unless they had a poor teacher.

Edmond · 21/03/2007 10:43

I think you should suggest the Little chef myself

ScummyMummy · 21/03/2007 10:40

I would not be impressed either. I think it's telling that you're not in the UK. I would be stunned if my children's school suggested this- all the state schools here are in total thrall to Jamie Oliver these days. To the extent that it's all a bit over the top sometimes imo. Then again if double trips to MaccyDs can be a routine part of a school trip in Oz perhaps we need to transport him over to you? Seriously, can you talk to the school?

ghosty · 21/03/2007 10:39

Not being rude if I don't reply though. Am off to bed. Will catch up with this in the morning.

ghosty · 21/03/2007 10:38

Oh, tell me how you find them different Robin ... am dying to know.
Am very apprehensive of DS starting new school.
To start with they are trying to persuade us to put him in Grade 1. He is in Year 3 in NZ and so should be going into Grade 2 in Aus. But they say that he will be young for the year (still in the right age group but one of the younger ones). He is bright and has had 2 full years of school ... bit of a dilemma ...

So a normal school trip to a museum. Why do they have to go to Macds?

robinpud · 21/03/2007 10:32

Sorry Ghosty.. not following things too closely.
hope all goes well and kids settle well.
I have found Australian public schools very different from my expectations..
Trip is to Science Museum in Canberra I think!

OP posts:
ghosty · 21/03/2007 10:27

Moving to Melbourne, not Sydney Robinpud April 11th

What is the school trip for?

Blu · 21/03/2007 10:27

I would let her go, but I would ask the school if the food could be re-thought, and let them know i thought it was a crap arrangement. In the greater scheme of things, I would be more worried about 3 to a seat and sitting on the floor of the bus.

robinpud · 21/03/2007 10:22

when are you moving to Sydney Ghosty.. it's different..

OP posts:
q7 · 21/03/2007 10:22

I think for a one-off long day out it won't do any harm. It's a long time since I went into a McD, but don't they do fruit/salads/healthy things now anyway?

Swipe left for the next trending thread