Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy my housing association home now and not wait for right to buy

214 replies

Fulani1989 · 17/06/2017 09:20

I have lived in a housing association home for 6 years. Refurbished houses sell for roughly 130,000. Average semi detached houses in the area sell for over £200,000 as it's not a bad area but my house is on a medium sized (100 houses) council estate which brings down the value.

There's absolutely no way I want to live in this area any longer than I have to. It's okay for now as it's 12 miles from my job.

I have the right to acquire. I requested to know how much the housing association would be willing to sell me the house for. They said it was worth £90,000 and with discount of £9,000 that's £81,000. The reality is that my house is a worth around 110,000-130,000 but HA's tend to under value.

My house is a Council house it was just transferred to a HA 9 years ago. The right to buy is supposed to be extended to HA properties but I've been waiting over a year now and there doesn't seem to be ANY development. I'm starting to believe it's never going to happen.

With the RTB instead I would get a 36% discount and would only pay £57,600! Well, well worth waiting for. I'd be willing to wait a few years to get the discount as the discount gets bigger with each year I'm a tenant.

BUT I don't know if it will ever even happen and I don't want to live in this area indefinitely.

My parents and friends said wait for the Right to buy. But I'm sick of waiting.

Buying my housing association home is my only chance of buying a house. It's the only mortgage any lender is willing to give me because of a less than stellar credit rating from a few years of unemployment.

AIBU to just buy my house now? And just forget the chance of a much better discount?

OP posts:
TheDogAteMyGoatskinVellum · 17/06/2017 21:11

However there would clearly be people who need housing more than you as your circumstances have changed.

We don't know whether any of them are in her area though, do we? It's quite possible that she's talking about somewhere with no shortage of SH, so while there are clearly people in the country on waiting lists earning less than that, if none of them are prepared to live there then it becomes irrelevant.

The issue of charging more was mooted a couple of years ago, but dropped. Not surprising really. I can't imagine how they thought they were going to monitor it, and it would have led to ghettoisation and people deliberately keeping their income under the threshold. It's one of those things that sounds nice on paper.

pinkspeckle · 17/06/2017 21:08

Chickpea, I would be happy to pay a bit more! I know I'm really lucky to have my home and a secure tenancy and would pay more for the privilege. I currently pay £450 a month. But private rented where I am is around £600-750 per month which I could not afford at all!

Chickpea212 · 17/06/2017 20:57

Pink - For someone in your circumstances I don't think it's fair to kick you out. However there would clearly be people who need housing more than you as your circumstances have changed. I think you should have to contribute more as earnings go up.

Chickpea212 · 17/06/2017 20:53

I don't think RTB is wrong in principle but it clearly needs reform, houses must be replaced, can't be rented, if earning over a certain threshold pay more, etc.

I think the entitlement that the OP has shown plus daily fail articles, etc are why the austerity cuts have been accepted by the majority of the public. Unfortunately they target the most vulnerable as opposed to the minority who are on the take.

pinkspeckle · 17/06/2017 20:39

Look I agree with PP that OP's attitude probably isn't the best.

However, I also live in HA property and earn £32k per year. I've lived in my house for 9 years, it's mine and DD's home. Why should I have to move because I earn more than when I got it?

I couldn't afford to live in private rented nor would I be able to get a mortgage. So what is the answer?

I have no intention of leaving my home and would probably buy it and live in it for years. Does that make a difference?

Are people jumping on OP because she just clearly wants to get it as cheap as possible and get maximum profit from it?

TheDogAteMyGoatskinVellum · 17/06/2017 19:54

You're pissing in the wind trying to get a non south-east centric discussion of SH on here OP. Doesn't matter how often you point out to people that there are plenty of areas in the UK where there's no shortage of SH and barely even a waiting list, you'll still get a load of badly informed comments about taking a home from someone who needs it, tower blocks et al.

There have been dozens of threads over the years where people have been educated about the fact that quite often, being working is an advantage when applying for SH, and every HA in the country lists their criteria online, but you'll still get pearl clutching because someone who isn't in abject poverty has a HA home. Even if nobody else wants it. Because our national discourse on the subject is framed around London.

You didn't help yourself with the 9k line, mind. That was asking for trouble.

I'd buy now. The RTB for HA tenants was a Cameron govt pledge, and they blatantly put it in as something to give way on when they went into coalition. It wasn't in the most recent Tory manifesto.

Nightshirt · 17/06/2017 18:47

In practical terms the OP is sensible to take the opportunity presented to her. A more sympathetic attitude for those fortunate than herself wouldn't go amiss though, and I think it's the tone of the posts that is grating more than her situation.

Exactly my view

Lostbeyondwords · 17/06/2017 18:16

OP just go for the rta discount, live in it for a few years then sell. For most councils/HAs if you sell within a certain time, usually 10years (which it sounds like you will), the council or HA you bought it from has to get first refusal on it and most times buy it back anyway to build stock up again. That's what my LA do at least.

RTB and RTA are not being used properly by LA's as they were intended, but that is not OP's fault or anyone else's.

For those saying OP should rent private because she "can afford it", when pay to stay is rolled out (if still going ahead) in london at least, it will only be put on households with 40k or over income. Not 27k, because although that might be the average, it's not enough to rent private in a manner most people would like to live in. Ie, not desperately living hand to mouth each month and without having hb.

trufflecake · 17/06/2017 17:43

RTB is just wrong. So wrong. It makes me sick.

The council's never make enough to build anouther house in its place. They'd have to sell 2 or often even 6+ just to cover the costs of building one new home. There is no sense to it whatsoever.

You should be ashamed of your decision. Yes you have worked hard to turn your life around, but so have many. No one deserves that kind of monetary bonus. Longterm tenancies yes, tens of thousands just to move away and have a new life at the taxpayers expense? Or perhaps worse, to rent out to people on housing benefit costing the council thousands per year. No way. NO WAY.

If £9000 is so easy for you to save, then you should be thankful for that and your below market rent and save enough money to use as a deposit. You could have that in less than a couple of years if it is so easy for you.

This selfishness has to stop

RunYouJuiceBitch · 17/06/2017 17:40

FFS, I'm fermenting in a big heap of sour grapes here and freely admit it.

How come I don't get a HA house I can buy at a reduced cost? I earned less than £33k last year. Confused

I was forced to use my hard-earned house deposit savings to continue paying my private rental two years ago when I had to take long-term sick leave - SSP didn't come close to covering it. Trying to build it back up again (I also have a Help To Buy ISA now) but it's pretty disheartening.

In practical terms the OP is sensible to take the opportunity presented to her. A more sympathetic attitude for those fortunate than herself wouldn't go amiss though, and I think it's the tone of the posts that is grating more than her situation.

(...goes back into box, grumbles bitterly, reminds self that a negative attitude will become a self-fulfilling prophecy...)

heyduggeeallday · 17/06/2017 17:28

In my area as soon as a council home becomes vacant it seems to go straight up for auction!! It's crazy as we are short. I'm living in a 3 bed council flat, I would have to wait 3 years for a house

dotandstripe · 17/06/2017 17:08

This is an interesting thread because the Tories have proposed making council tenancies time limited and everyone seems to be against that. Well this is an example of why it's a good idea.

In regards to the OPs question, what are you going to do if you buy it and then either can't sell it or can't get another mortgage? If you don't want to live there long term it seems like a risky idea to buy. Only buy somewhere you're prepared to live for the next 10 years or more. If interest rates go up or the market changes, it might be a struggle to sell at all.

Motherbear26 · 17/06/2017 16:56

While I don't necessarily agree with RTB or purchasing social housing, I certainly can't blame anyone for making the most of any advantages they are offered in life. I can't fault the OP at all for putting her future and that of her child before the principles of others. She didn't create the system we are all complaining about and none of that is her responsibility.

We moan that people live on benefits and don't want to better themselves. The OP is actively working to secure her future and that of her child. I completely understand why anyone would be loath to let go of a safe home and move into privately rented accommodation where she has no security or stability whatsoever. Some people may believe that it is unfair but as I tell my children, life is unfair so it's up to us to make the best of it. Buy the house and good luck with it all.

notknownatthisaddress · 17/06/2017 16:45

A lot of bitter, jealous people on this thread. Pay no attention OP. Do what's best for you. Makes me laugh when people say 'you ARE ON £33k, WHY are you renting social housing. Fuck off and live in private let!' Yeah right, like THEY would! They would cling on to that tenancy for dear life, no WAY would they give it up.

For a start, £33K is a good salary but it's not excessive. Many couples have close to that or more. And the OP clearly didn't have that salary when she was offered the tenancy. And she may be in a position when she isn't on that money some time in the future. Good for her for looking after hers and her son's welfare and future.

Yeah it's not great that people buy their social housing homes and reduce the housing stock, and the HA's and councils should build one for every one they sell, but the opportunity is THERE and you would have to be dippy to not take the opportunity. As for the person who said 'I rented a council house but didn't buy it because I am a better person than that and I know people need the homes...so I bought on the private market.' Bully for you! Hmm

Millions of people have taken the RTB offer because they could and because the government made it possible. Stop making out that anyone who does it, is a money grabbing selfish cunt!

As I said, many people on this thread sound bitter and jealous!

DixieFlatline · 17/06/2017 16:31

People on here are determined to have SH linked to benefits and can't believe that everywhere isn't like the south where SH is hard to come by.

I think the main point is that RTB depletes it. It's all very well laughing about how it's not hard to come by in some areas - it bloody well will be, everywhere, if this continues.

Izzabellasasperella · 17/06/2017 15:53

I believe RTB should be abolished asap. It massively impacts on social housing stock. It also causes a lot of ill feeling between people, the ones that can't afford to buy their council/ha house, the private renters and the buyers who have to pay much more for a similar spec house. Just look at some people on this thread.
I think we need to start looking at houses as homes rather than money making machines.

bungle99 · 17/06/2017 15:43

OP,
I def. think you should apply for it now instead of waiting. If this is your only chance of house buying and not sure if RTB is going to happen then go for it. Good luck 💐

tattychicken · 17/06/2017 14:48

Buy it now, it could be years before the RTB is extended to HA tenants. With the current spotlight on housing, I don't think it's something Tresemme will want push through, and if Labour get in at some point I would expect them to scrap the RTB.

SquidgeyMidgey · 17/06/2017 14:26

I love how the left twist rtb into a non-profiteering Tory 'game' when it's for their own benefit. Where are the lofty principles these days?

user1467798821 · 17/06/2017 14:06

I live in social housing in South East London, I am unable to work due to ill health, claim no benefits and we survive on my DH wage of £30k a year. Our essential bills come to £1000 a month, so that doesn't leave us a lot left over for food etc. Our LA have introduced a new rent policy that if you earn over £40k a year for every £1 you earn over £40k you pay an extra 50p in rent.
Why on earth should the OP give up a secure tenancy to rent privately, which is not only more expensive but unsecured. She could end up being homeless on a regular basis should a landlord want to sell, or reclaim their property.
My DD and her P rent privately, they are both teachers and cannot afford to save for a deposit and pay rent and live etc, they would give their eye teeth for an LA property and then assume their RTB.

My DS and his DW were in a private rented property with some top ups in terms of WTC, the landlord wanted his property back and so they were homeless with 2 small children in a hostel, they are now in a brand new build from a HA.
I think the issue is that when Thatcher introduced the RTB she prohibited the monies from that being used to build more stock, in fact very few councils build, most of the new housing in my area is owned by HA, whose rents are higher and they maintain strict controls of the way you live your life ( one HA has a rule that you can't hang washing outside on a Sunday!)
There aren't many of us, who given the opportunity wouldn't buy a home for a really cheap price. Rent is dead money, a mortgage is an investment.
If the purchase price of these properties were invested into building more stock, there would not be the housing crisis that there now is.
Don't hate the player, hate the game

Stopnamechanging · 17/06/2017 13:56

Over a third are let out again by right to buy owners turned landlord. That's FOI request so I think that the true figure will be higher than that.

www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/buytolet/article-3197529/Two-five-Right-Buy-flats-sold-1980-hands-private-landlords-FOI-request-shows.html

ShakingAndShocked · 17/06/2017 13:51

Posted in fury but will ask MN to delete my post as just realised it's pretty outing for someone else.

Fucking fuming at what I've seen on here though, fuming. The entitlement, the 'I'm alright Jack', the BS to assuage postion, it's fucking disgusting IMHO. Sooner RTB abolished the better so chancers like OP can no longer turn a personal profit on a state owned property.

ShakingAndShocked · 17/06/2017 13:48

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

gamerchick · 17/06/2017 13:45

It's not in a nice area anyway. There's no shortage of social housing around here

You're wasting your time OP. People on here are determined to have SH linked to benefits and can't believe that everywhere isn't like the south where SH is hard to come by.

Then on other threads you get horrific private rent is and yet on these threads this should be your goal if you earn a good wage. You couldn't make it up man Grin

Stopnamechanging · 17/06/2017 13:31

I think that's what has riled me about the op, she keeps saying what a good idea RTB is.
It's really not, it's fundamentally wrong and unfair.

However if you are lucky enough to get the opportunity, most people would do it.

Because humans are fundamentally selfish and it's the lack of acknowledgment of that.

I am doing something selfish, my dd2 has a disability and has been badly failed by the state school system where we live.

So she goes to a private school, which is unfair on others in her position who can't, I am putting her above my principles.

It all needs reforming and lifelong tenancies are being stopped now, I feel most sorry for those in private rented paying extortionate rents, moving every year and never being able to buy their own home.

Swipe left for the next trending thread