Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To buy my housing association home now and not wait for right to buy

214 replies

Fulani1989 · 17/06/2017 09:20

I have lived in a housing association home for 6 years. Refurbished houses sell for roughly 130,000. Average semi detached houses in the area sell for over £200,000 as it's not a bad area but my house is on a medium sized (100 houses) council estate which brings down the value.

There's absolutely no way I want to live in this area any longer than I have to. It's okay for now as it's 12 miles from my job.

I have the right to acquire. I requested to know how much the housing association would be willing to sell me the house for. They said it was worth £90,000 and with discount of £9,000 that's £81,000. The reality is that my house is a worth around 110,000-130,000 but HA's tend to under value.

My house is a Council house it was just transferred to a HA 9 years ago. The right to buy is supposed to be extended to HA properties but I've been waiting over a year now and there doesn't seem to be ANY development. I'm starting to believe it's never going to happen.

With the RTB instead I would get a 36% discount and would only pay £57,600! Well, well worth waiting for. I'd be willing to wait a few years to get the discount as the discount gets bigger with each year I'm a tenant.

BUT I don't know if it will ever even happen and I don't want to live in this area indefinitely.

My parents and friends said wait for the Right to buy. But I'm sick of waiting.

Buying my housing association home is my only chance of buying a house. It's the only mortgage any lender is willing to give me because of a less than stellar credit rating from a few years of unemployment.

AIBU to just buy my house now? And just forget the chance of a much better discount?

OP posts:
gamerchick · 19/06/2017 10:40

But there will still be some people who are reading our posts who won't believe them because yanno London.... Grin

x2boys · 19/06/2017 10:37

same here gamerchick theres some flats across from me and sever single men l;ive in them also i was able to turn down a couple of houses we didnt think were suitable and still we got our house within a few months!

CallingPeopleACuntOnFb · 19/06/2017 10:19

Do it now

As it might not be possible if a different government get in

gamerchick · 19/06/2017 10:15

Yep I'm up north as well and they even give council places to single men here Shock

x2boys · 19/06/2017 10:11

you cant gamerchick whenever theres a thread like this it always goes the same way i live in the northwest no where near london but people cant accept its not the same everywhere.

x2boys · 19/06/2017 10:09

i wonder if we live in the same town FP my housing associoation two bed house is probably worth no more then £70,000 i dont think i will buy my house unless things change drastically and i could buy outright plus i have had amortgage and its not all that, however i dont begrudge the OP for buying her house.

gamerchick · 19/06/2017 10:08

Honestly, this goes back to the point I and others have made: the discussion of SH on MN is too Londoncentric. You cannot apply the metric for the south east to other areas of the country where the housing situation and in particular the SH situation bears no resemblance to it

Yep, it's ruddy weird. It would be nice to keep that bloody city out of one of these threads when the OP doesn't live anywhere near the place.

FP239 · 19/06/2017 09:35

All the people having a go at the OP. just leave them be for gods sake. There is no shortage of council houses in my town either and I have the right to buy my house just as my ex husband has the right to buy his flat. His is worth £66k on the open market and if he bought it tomorrow he would pay £22k. Mine is worth £80k and should I buy it it would be £50k. I will one day buy mine and i will not feel guilty at all......my town has built over 200 energy efficient green council/HA properties in the last 2 years ( more than they have sold on) so I refuse to feel guilty for exercising a right that came with my lease/ contract. Plus I love my house, its bloody awesome and my home.

If you are angry about this, write to your MP and the PM.

TheDogAteMyGoatskinVellum · 19/06/2017 09:14

It's instructive that you say city, there. Because whichever city you're talking about, and I have a sneaking suspicion it begins with L and ends in N, it's not the one OP lives in.

Honestly, this goes back to the point I and others have made: the discussion of SH on MN is too Londoncentric. You cannot apply the metric for the south east to other areas of the country where the housing situation and in particular the SH situation bears no resemblance to it.

stopfuckingshoutingatme · 19/06/2017 07:16

I think she should buy the flat
But to post at this moment in time with what's going on was misguided and showed a lack of her sensitivity

We are so many of us part of this system

People who buy ex LA
People who buy Victorian houses in up and
Coming neighbourhoods
People who invest in second property to Boos their pensions and income

There is no malice in it - but the end of the road means we have a city that poor people cannot afford to live in

Sigh

Mumoftwoyoungkids · 18/06/2017 10:18

practical terms the OP is sensible to take the opportunity presented to her. A more sympathetic attitude for those fortunate than herself wouldn't go amiss though, and I think it's the tone of the posts that is grating more than her situation.

This.

However, as an answer to her original question, personally I would buy the house now. Interest rates are very low right now so once it is bought then every payment you make will be knocking off the capital.

Also - you have no guarantee that you will ever get the RTB so you could be waiting years and still not get it.

Also - if the house is really worth c£130k then sooner or later the council will realise this and then that will be the start price so the bigger discount will just get you back to where you started from.

Finally - the political situation is very very strange at the moment. Six months from now we could have a very very right wing prime minister, a very very left wing prime minister or somewhere in the middle. Once you have your house then you are immune to this.

x2boys · 18/06/2017 09:39

Seriously why can people accept we dont all live in london i live in a HA house the only criteria for applying for a house in my town is that you have the right to live in the country and have local connections there are no massive waiting lists and i got my house within a few months most people on my estate work.

TheDogAteMyGoatskinVellum · 18/06/2017 09:27

It should be if you earn x amount you have to pay market value in rent or move out.

Even if the alternative is leaving the property empty?

I also want to hear about how people advocating forced move out/rent increases when a certain income level is reached plan to prevent ghettoization? Bear in mind that a lot of SH is in estates, not mixed developments. And that there's nothing more likely to increase social problems in an area than by making sure the people living there are all below a certain income.

IfNot · 18/06/2017 09:23

I find it hilarious how much vitriol is being poured on a working single mother who wants to buy her housing association house, as if she is the very cause of the world's evils.
As someone pointed out up thread, middle class people routinely seem to inherit property worth hundreds of thousands of pounds. I know people whose grandparents died and left them tens of thousands, and they acted like it was their due.
But a woman goes from income support to bringing in a reasonable income ( not amazing- 33k for a household isn't a fortune) and wants to shore up her position she is the reason for the housing crisis.
Let's get a few things clear;
Right to buy in itself is no bad thing. In my area many of the larger older estates are much improved by having a mix of peogle. Without rtb MANY people would never had the option of owning a home. ( no granny's inheritance you see) resulting in many people being stuck where theyou don't want to be. Social mobility is a GOOD thing.
The problem was that the money should have been ploughed back into housing. That's the governments fault not OPS.
Also, please can we get over this idea ( that I only see on MN) that "social" housing is for the destitute. It may have come to that, but council housing was always intended for ordinary working people who maybe couldn't access credit/ mortgages.
In my area it's garden to get a HA tenancy if you are not working. Social housing get is nothe, as many seem to think, a favour bestowed by the benevolent state as an alternative to the workhouse Hmm
It's just cheaper rent with secure tenancies. Like we should all be campaigning for.
As OP says, her rent is not massively lower that private ( and here in the wilds of the rest of the country that isn't London this is often the case).
She is lucky but she doesn't have to be grateful, ashamed or move out of her "social" house because she has done what we are supposed to do- get a good job, be self sufficient and not be a drain on the state! It's bloody hard to get to the point of bringing in a reasonable income as a lone parent. A high proportion of children from single parent families are in serious poverty.
I also find it amusing when council tenants get a pasting on MN for being so lucky. Look, it's great to have a secure tenancy, it is, and I wish everyone who needed to could buy cheaper houses, but OP has already said her estate isn't great. I know for a fact that half the enraged splutterers on here would be scared to walk through some of the council estates they are supposedly desperate to live on, and they certainly wouldn't want to bring up their dc on one..
But. This is where we have come to, eh?
It's a bizarre upside down world where people are hurling rotten tomatoes at single parents on council estates because they have a chance at security and millions of us don't.
Campaign for better rent conditions. More housing to be built. Go after developers who get away with the minimum number of affordable housing.
There's no dignity in this game.

londonrach · 18/06/2017 09:17

Op post has just shown everything thats wrong with right to buy and council houses. Isnt there an mp somewhere in one. It should be if you earn x amount you have to pay market value in rent or move out. Maybe revalue housing every 5 years depending on need. Cant see it ever coming in but pretty shocked at op post. Is it really true that you get that much discount. We were caught in the rent trap for 10 years

TheDogAteMyGoatskinVellum · 18/06/2017 09:14

Although I've just recalled we were talking about another poster and not OP... so my first paragraph should be amended to read possible rather than certain. One cannot assume that she is in an area where there's insufficient SH.

TheDogAteMyGoatskinVellum · 18/06/2017 09:11

I just think it's very unfair that plenty of people who earn 30k have no choice but to pay excessive private rentals. They have to afford it.

And that's a perfectly valid point chickpea, it's just that clearly none of those people are willing and able to take SH in OPs area. Or they'd have done it already, and there'd be more than a two month waiting list. So the issue for those people is a lack of suitable SH for them, where they live, not what someone does in an area where supply broadly matches demand.

Re discounts notknown, the rules do actually specify that people are supposed to pay it back on a sliding scale if they don't stay in the property for a certain amount of time afterwards. I think the issue is policing it. HAs and councils quite understandably don't necessarily have spare staff for checking Land Registry, electoral rolls etc.

And if you sell within a certain period of time, the council/HA are actually specified in the rules as getting first refusal on the property. Not sure how this works in practice.

Dewey595 · 18/06/2017 00:29

I do feel RTB is so wrong. On 33k you're taking the mick OP. And £9k is nothing? Hmm

notknownatthisaddress · 18/06/2017 00:19

Maybe the answer for right to buy is to let the tenant have the house with the discount, on the condition that they live in it and don't sell. If they do sell within say 5 years, they have to pay back the entire discount. And if they sell within 5 and 10 years, they have to pay back two thirds of the discount. I mean, if they like their house so much that they want it forever, they wouldn't want to sell would they?

Making people pay back the discount if they sell should hopefully eliminate the opportunities for people to buy their house, sell at a huge profit, and then a private landlord obtaining it. Maybe they should be made to sell it back to the council?

stopfuckingshoutingatme · 17/06/2017 23:51

Your timing sucks OP

Mean buy the house fuck yes

But given what's going down in the world and in large cities .... consider yourself lucky

5OBalesofHay · 17/06/2017 23:51

Grab what you can off everyone else then. Fuck the rest of them eh OP

SuperBeagle · 17/06/2017 23:49

Fruitbat If May resigns, someone else from the Conservatives will take over. Labour didn't come close to winning the election, so a couple of months is vastly unlikely to change anything.

Fruitbat1980 · 17/06/2017 23:47

Parking my views on RTB. Much as it pains me in next 3 months May resign and we'll have another GE and labour will probably scrape in. Corbyn and his cronies will almost immediately can the RTB scheme. So do it now, or risk it no longer being an option.

Floggingmolly · 17/06/2017 22:41

Are you sure you're allowed to buy the house and then rent it out?? What a farce Hmm. I don't know how you qualify for a housing association property, but surely buying to put it straight on the letting market precludes you from actually "needing" (in the real sense) social housing at all?
There really needs to be stricter regulation on these things, when there aren't enough to go round in the first place. Shocking.

Chickpea212 · 17/06/2017 22:34

I just think it's very unfair that plenty of people who earn 30k have no choice but to pay excessive private rentals. They have to afford it.

Personally I think reform is a nice idea as opposed to getting rid of RTB completely which is wear I think it's going.

Also to the OP who thinks 9k is nothing, I'm what you would call comfortable (SE) & I think that's a lot. It's more than 1/3 of your salary!