Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

not to let my 6.5 year old go on a school trip which involves an overnight stay?

112 replies

laughingduck · 20/03/2007 11:23

Title says it all really. dh and I don't want him to go on the trip as he has never stayed away from home without one of us before. He is in a mixed YR1/YR2 class and the trip is a last minute cancellation that the school have got and so details have yet to be finalised. Are we just totally out of touch - is it the norm for infant school aged children to go on this kind of trip? Most people we have asked so far have said they wouldn't either but I thought I'd get the opinion of MN too (plus can't resist starting a thread in this topic ).

OP posts:
Jennylee · 21/03/2007 13:02

frogs I would say...

...
...

NO

and it is no because he would not enjoy it but is up to me isn't it, my son would need dry nights and is a bit deaf at the moment so these are the main reasons, and other peoples different/careless way of looking after children which sometimes i see in my son's peer group. won't be changing my mind untill he is older

Marina · 21/03/2007 12:19

Frogs, because I know the parents who'd be in charge of the sleepover, I'd ring them and discuss it, not least to check they were aware of the invitation being issued...
It's a different issue to a school trip to a non family-setting venue overnight though, at aged six. I feel ds has matured hugely from how he was in Yr 2. I would not have let him sleep out anywhere at that age - but it's a hypothetical question for our family as he never asked. He is asking now and I see that as a sign he is ready.

lucy5 · 21/03/2007 12:15

My gut instinct would be no but if my dd really wanted to go and all her friends were then I would let her, although I would hate every minute of it.

admylin · 21/03/2007 12:10

Also agree, if the child wants to go and it is going to be safe then it is better to let them go. I just heard from a friend who's dd won't go on sleep overs and she's nearly 9 years old and my niece has quite happily been going on sleep overs since she was 5, so it does depend on the child.

sunnysideup · 21/03/2007 12:09

I went on a school trip for a week when I was 7 or 8, and I had a lovely time...however I just don't know how i'd feel about ds going at 7!! He's five this year, and I can't imagine at the moment that I would be happy for him to go away for a week at 7 years old.....but as I say I had a fantastic time myself so I don't know what I'm basing this on! Bizarre.

I remember it being a really special time where I got to know my friends and teachers in a more profound way, we felt we were looking after eachother (us kids) and we saw the nurturing, family side of the teachers which was lovely. So I have to say that if ds was offered a trip away at primary school age, I would have to consider it, I couldn't say no straight off.

clumsymum · 21/03/2007 12:06

"I think it's totally unnecessary."

But what HARM will it do?

Blimey, eating an ice cream is "totally unnecessary", but it's fun, it's a change, it's an experience you don't have every day.

If a 6 year old comes home from school and says "there's a sleep-over, can I go" and you give an outright NO (despite the fact that it's an organised, risk-assessed, safe activity) then how are you making the child feel? How do you look in their eyes?

I think just saying NO on the basis of a particular age is also "totally unnecessary".

I can also see that it may be right for one child of 6, and maybe not for another (even siblings in the same family. I was much more adventurous at 6 than my sister had been).

But an outright "NO WAY" just seems small minded and over-protective to me.

frogs · 21/03/2007 12:03

So all you people who say 'No' to trips and sleepovers, how would you react if your 7yo says, "X has invited me to stay the night on Saturday, please can I go?"

admylin · 21/03/2007 12:01

I think if your ds wants to go I would say let him. My dd is expected to go on a 5 day trip with school aged 7 but she doesn't want to so I'm not pushing her. If the school would offer a one night trip I would try to convince her to go and enjoy it.

If your ds has never slept away from home before, this could be great fun for him to be away for the first time with all his pals. If he doesn't go on this trip, maybe the next trip will be for 3 or 4 nights then it will be even harder for him if he's never done it before. That has been my worry with dd, she isn't going on this trip for 5 nights but if the teacher offers a shorter one I hope she will go. The good thing is you can be sure there will be enough staff going along to ensure their safety - I'd have to send my dd with 2 adults and 25 children (Germany)

juuule · 21/03/2007 11:50

"My son is 7. He needs me and his father, he needs to know he is loved, he needs to be cared for. But he also needs to discover life and the world for himself, in a safe way. This will help him to be a confident, happy, rounded individual."

I absolutely agree with that. But I don't see the necessity for staying away from home overnight.

"How old is old enough? What happens if you say "no you won't like being away from us" one time too many, so by the time you are ready for them to go, they are too scared to try it?"

Oh, believe me when they are ready for it they let you know. However, there are some who are just home-birds most of the time.

As I said before, not sleeping out at night before secondary school age does not appear to have affected my older children (19,17,15,14) in any adverse way. I don't think it would have had any benefits for them to do so. I think it's totally unnecessary. However if it's what you and other parents believe is right for your children then fine. I just can't see the point and for me primary school age is too young.

clumsymum · 21/03/2007 11:04

Yes juuule

"its some parents who cant cope with their children being away.........."

I DO honestly believe that.
And reading a couple of the comments on here, I think there are some parents who are AFRAID of their children developing independence, afraid of seeing that their children can be seperated from them for more than 12 hours without falling to pieces.

My son is 7. He needs me and his father, he needs to know he is loved, he needs to be cared for. But he also needs to discover life and the world for himself, in a safe way. This will help him to be a confident, happy, rounded individual. I believe it will help him to develop self-reliance, which I think is a VERY important thing. I think it will also help him to relate with his peers and other adults better, when we are not always there to do it for him.
When the idea of the Beavers sleep-over first came up, he was a little unsure. I gave him the choice, but encouraged him to go. He LOVED it, and feels so proud of himself. He would have been quite upset I think if he had decided not to go, then everyone else went and he missed it.

Yes they do have "the rest of their lives to go on sleep-overs", but you have to let them start sometime. How old is old enough? What happens if you say "no you won't like being away from us" one time too many, so by the time you are ready for them to go, they are too scared to try it?

I really do worry about todays children being over-protected. Losing that sense of adventure, the joy you feel when you were a bit scared, but did something anyway and it turned out well.

Remember the phrase "if you love them set them free"? well that can apply, even at 6 years old, if you let them go on a one night, safe supervised sleep-over.

juuule · 21/03/2007 10:22

Children will become independent in their own time whether they stay out overnight at a young age or not. So I would say that staying away from home at 6 doesn't encourage independence either and in some cases may harm a child's confidence. I just don't understand the rush to seperate children from their parents.

"its some parents who cant cope with their children being away.........."
Do you really believe that?

q7 · 21/03/2007 08:53

I would have let mine go. They love that kind of thing. Plus, a night away from the children makes me realise I love them after all!

helenhismadwife · 21/03/2007 08:48

umm that isnt really a a sensible comparison at all, letting them walk in front of traffic is not going to encourage there independence where as going away from home without their parents does.

Children develop at different rates, some 6 year old will be fine with being away from home, some wont. By the sound of it though its not the children who cant cope with being away from their parents its some parents who cant cope with their children being away..........

juuule · 20/03/2007 22:12

We can't always let children do things they are happy to do though, can we? They might be quite happy to walk in front of oncoming traffic but I don't think I'd be happy to let my children do that. An extreme example, I know, but you get the gist.

helenhismadwife · 20/03/2007 21:44

I dont suppose it does

As I said it helpful to be guided by the childs feelings not just the parents, I was happy to let my children do things like this because they were happy to do it

Jennylee · 20/03/2007 21:33

finish even

Jennylee · 20/03/2007 21:32

it won't finsh them off to 'miss out' once in a while

helenhismadwife · 20/03/2007 16:19

I would also look at it from the other side, that if all your ds friends went and he didnt he could well feel left out.

I think it should depend on how the child feels about it as much as how the parents feel, its true about them having plenty of time to do stuff in the future but its also about doing things now with their friends and doing stuff children do and not missing out on fun stuff.

laughingduck · 20/03/2007 16:14

Right, well back from school run and it seems a few mums have the same concerns as me. I agree with a lot of what has been posted here too. I think dh and I will perhaps not send him. I say perhaps as it appears that the teacher may have given out the letter to the Y1's in error so all my worrying may have been in vain. Thanks to all who have posted though, it has been helpful and if he isn't going this time it will have given me some food for thought for next year .

OP posts:
Jennylee · 20/03/2007 16:11

I understnad the 'why not?' but if a parent would rather they didn't it is up to them and I would worry as my ds is high maintainance has things that mean he would need extra taking care of and so why bother putting myself through the worry and my son the prospect of any situation arsing that he might not know how to handle yet, when he is older that would be fine but it is up to the parent, and children are all different some would love to go away from home overnight but some would find it horrifying. Is fine if you children want to go and you are happy for them to but it a parents choice.

a person wanted to take my ds for me to a caravan holiday with her nephew but i did not like the idea as sometimes their nephew has been out in the dark riding a bike in the street when quite small, things like that, or they might let them do things they are not allowed to do, I let her take ds once and they did not get a drink all day and even went to the pub with the woman and ran about while the woman had a drink with a friend and so things like that when they are young I cannot be bothered with

flatmouse · 20/03/2007 15:59

If child wants to go - why not? Where is the harm?

Mind you on trip DS is going on they are v concerned about bunk beds and we need to sign to say OK for top bunk.

I signed with "DS would PREFER to be in top bunk"

Jennylee · 20/03/2007 15:57

Also I agree with your post juule, but then I think we have a few things in common

Jennylee · 20/03/2007 15:56

I meant overnight , obviously he goes to see friends and plays out etc and goes places to play with other kids , just not overnight

juuule · 20/03/2007 15:52

"he has his whole life when he is older to stay with friends and go away places"
Absolutely, Jennylee.

makealist · 20/03/2007 15:49

The current rules of The Scout Association state that the Beaver Scouts can only spend one night away from home. (24 hours including travelling time to and fro venue)

I am a Beaver scout leader and beavers are expected to attend at least one sleepover before they swim up to cubs (aged 8)

I would have no problem letting my child go, but from experience of a beaver leader (parent used us as baby sitting service and went out on the pi** and didn't answer/hear phone)I would make sure I was contactable if they needed to get hold of me.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.