Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

not to let my 6.5 year old go on a school trip which involves an overnight stay?

112 replies

laughingduck · 20/03/2007 11:23

Title says it all really. dh and I don't want him to go on the trip as he has never stayed away from home without one of us before. He is in a mixed YR1/YR2 class and the trip is a last minute cancellation that the school have got and so details have yet to be finalised. Are we just totally out of touch - is it the norm for infant school aged children to go on this kind of trip? Most people we have asked so far have said they wouldn't either but I thought I'd get the opinion of MN too (plus can't resist starting a thread in this topic ).

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Tundrawells · 09/08/2022 12:30

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Aloha · 21/03/2007 20:25

No, I wouldn't let ds go. He's five and I'm pretty sure he'd hate it even in a year's time. Plus if he's dry at night by then I'll be very surprised. Very unusual to have overnight stays at that age.

Jennylee · 21/03/2007 20:21

I never said anyone else was a bad Mum for letting their kids go overnight. that is not what I was saying at all, If I had a totally independant child who did not need extra help and I was sure , completely sure I could trust another family with my child he could go but not under the circumstances I stated earlier in my posts, so that will be when my ds is older,
Why are 'different' opinions automatically thought to mean 'bad opinions'

admylin · 21/03/2007 19:41

I also think supervision is the magic word! If I was offered a trip with plenty of capable staff and adequate information about the sleeping arrangements I would feel much better about sending my child away.
califrau, you brought back memories about the Waldtag, we had those every tuesday whatever the weather they would march off to the forest with the littlest ones in one of those wooden carts and build dens, get muddy and have a picnic! I didn't mind that so much as they had 2 teachers but when they went into town on the bus it was a worry because I knew the teacher did a fair bit of window shopping!

FrannyandZooey · 21/03/2007 17:36

I like the rite of passage thing very much Cali

and it's good that it was optional - I would not expect all children at this age to be ready to do this.

My own feeling on this is that if your child is not ready for such a level of separation from you then it would be a mistake to push them into it. And I would think it fair to trust a parent's judgement of whether the child is ready at this point.

Myself I would feel unhappy about it because I remember the very inadequate supervision we had on various school trips when I was at school. I think a properly supervised adventure away from home could be a magical thing and very boosting to the self-esteem of a young child who felt ready to try it.

clumsymum · 21/03/2007 17:27

Califrau,

I think on balance I prefer it Germany's way.

SSShakeTheChi · 21/03/2007 17:23

My dd's first sleep-over in kindergarten in Germany was when she was 3 and then she had one a year till she started school aged 6. She sleeps over at friend's houses occasionally, really not very often though. I think the first time she did that she was 4.

However, sending her away from town with her entire class at age 6.5 (her current age), I wouldn't contemplate yet though.

Califrau · 21/03/2007 17:17

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

clumsymum · 21/03/2007 17:11

Califrau,

Thanks for posting that, it really is so interesting. Interesting too that altho you thought your child wouldn't like it, he had such a wonderful time.

I am just so very concerned that we are creating a culture in the UK where our children are over protected, and that they miss out on things because of it.

And everyone got soooo hung up on my "small-minded" comment, that no-one has answered my question.

What harm do you think it will do your child to go to an organised sleep-over?

Califrau · 21/03/2007 16:47

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

clumsymum · 21/03/2007 16:40

You'll be very welcom Helen .

helenhismadwife · 21/03/2007 15:25

The general feeling and opinion seems to be that most would be guided by their children and if they were happy to go they would let them, but some seem to be saying that they would say no regardless of how the child felt which to me backs up what I said about it being some parents who cant cope.

We do know our children better than anyone, so hopefully would know if they could cope with staying away overnight. I let mine from quite young, they were happy to go and I would have happily collected them if they wanted to come home

Just off to ask my mum if I can stay overnight with frogs and clumsymum at the bad mothers bootcamp

kks · 21/03/2007 14:43

I think you should be guided by your child. If he is keen to go then let him go, he will probably be homesick for a little while but hes enjoying himself he will be fine.

juuule · 21/03/2007 14:29

"I think it is small-minded"

Your opinion which you are entitled to.

"to believe your child can't breath without you being present."

Sheeesh - it's all or nothing with you Clumsymum isn't it? You've managed to deduce that that's what parents believe just from evidence that they don't think its a good idea for their 6yo to go on residential school trips.

Marina · 21/03/2007 14:04

I don't think it's small minded to be sensitive to the needs of your own child, and to take account of the norm in education, which seems to be no sleep-over trips from school until aged seven plus.
I am sure that custom is there not just to please parents but to acknowledge that for a lot of children, sleeping away from familiar surroundings is unlikely to be a success before that age.
I trust my dcs' teachers, local Beavers leaders etc, and both have written policies that for the wellbeing of your average child, they don't do overnight trips before the age of 8. They've got lots of experience between them. I am happy to be guided by their instincts.

batters · 21/03/2007 14:03

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

frogs · 21/03/2007 14:00

OrmIrian, that is actually quite an accurate description of the teachers' behaviour during my dd1 Y6 school trip. Luckily the kids were a sensible bunch, and I trusted dd1 not to do anything daft.

clumsymum · 21/03/2007 13:58

But you are criticising me (not that I mindf, it's a free country.

And it isn't slinging insults, it is my honest-to-goodness opinion.
I think it is small-minded to believe your child can't breath without you being present.

Hard hat on, ready for the responses.

batters · 21/03/2007 13:56

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

OrmIrian · 21/03/2007 13:49

"They'd be sitting there in the evening drinking their wine whilst the kids ran wild".

Oh dear . Why would she think that?

sandyballs · 21/03/2007 13:47

This is quite timely as I've just been having a conversation with a colleague who has 3 children and her eldest is being allowed on an overnight school trip for the first time at 15 .

I tried to disguise my shock and asked her why he hadn't been away before, perhaps lack of opportunity. And she replied that she didn't trust the teachers, or schools and was convinced something would happen to him. "They'd be sitting there in the evening drinking their wine whilst the kids ran wild".

Astounding. My DDs are just 6 (year 1) and I wouldn't hesitate to let them go off for one night if they fancied it, wouldn't pressure them, but wouldn't clip their wings if they were keen.

clumsymum · 21/03/2007 13:30

you and me too frogs

frogs · 21/03/2007 13:27

Marina yes, obviously I would phone/talk to the parents to check that it was a real invitation and not the product of 7yo wishful thinking!

I just really don't get that people would say no if (a) the child really wanted to go and (b) you had enough confidence in the family to feel your child would be safe.

I had mad fun staying the night at friends houses from the age of about 5 upwards -- we lived deep in the country so friends were spread over a huge area, and the only way you got any kind of an out-of-school social life was staying the night.

And my dc seem to feel the same way ds has been invited several times since the age of about 6 to go along with various friends who were going to stay in the country for the weekend, and had fantastic fun crabbing, trampolining, going to the East of England Show, camping out on the beach, blahdiblah. Conversely we've taken dd1's friend to Devon with us several times starting from when they were in Y2 they went riding, swam in the sea, built dams, climbed trees etc. This particular friend rarely had the chance to get out of London otherwise, cos her parents were on low incomes. They had a blast yes, she missed her mum a bit of an evening, but we got over it by telling her that if she still wanted to go home in the morning, I'd call her family and organise for her to be picked up. Oddly enough, by morning she'd have better things to do.

I genuinely cannot see why you would want to deny a child the chance to have a fun time just because you can't be there to accompany them. Sure, some parents may not run their household in exactly the same way you would, but assuming they're not letting the kids watch 18-rated movies or drink alcopops, I really can't see the harm. On the contrary, I think it's quite healthy for the child to realise that there are other ways of doing things than they're used to in their own family. Nor can I imagine waking up in the middle of the night and missing them.

Clearly it's off to bad mother bootcamp for me, too.

clumsymum · 21/03/2007 13:11

Um Batters.

We were asked our opinion. We are all venting our opinions.

Thats why there is a healthy debate going on here.

batters · 21/03/2007 13:06

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread