Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that its wrong to exclude a toddler from toddler group

85 replies

twobabies · 19/03/2007 15:04

I go to a toddler group on Fridays and last week there was an incident with one of the toddlers I think shes just under two. She had been playing and another child took the toy she had been playing with and she tapped him on the arm. Another child then came and tried to take it and she hit him too. I have never seen this child hit before and she is quite a popular member of the group. The mum of this girl got up told her daughter off and made her cuddle both other children she then apoligised to the other mums and took her child away to a quite part of the room. When she came back to join us the leader of the group came over to her and in front of about 4 other mums told her that there was a "behaviour policy" in the group that if a child hit more than twice they would be asked to leave.... The mum seemed quite embarrased and I was quite embarrased for her. She had done everything she could after the incident and the leader acknowledged that these things do happen but that it was to "stop bad feeling between parents". She then went on to add that "this was only the second time that she had had to tell a mother this and that the first one had started crying, left the group and never came back! This mum then quietly left 10mins later. So do you think I am being unreasonable in thinking that this is a ridiculous policy for a toddler group to have? or is this quite common? I would love to know what you would have done had this been you as the mum seemed quite embarrased and then left. By the way this is my first post so hi to all as well!!!

OP posts:
fortyplus · 19/03/2007 21:52

kama - funnily enough my two have never hit anyone apart from each other!

fortyplus · 19/03/2007 21:51

But what's wrong with asking the child to leave one session - then return? How will they learn otherwise? No one wants their child hit but the kids who hit are often the offspring of the most needy mothers.

kama · 19/03/2007 21:50

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

FrannyandZooey · 19/03/2007 21:49

TSAP it is the pits

I have been threatened in the street because of enforcing this policy in the worst case I ever dealt with

and this very month a mother left in tears because I had to mention this policy to her

I handled it really craply on that occasion, obviously, and feel fkn dreadful about it, but I HAVE NO TRAINING on this and yet I have to ensure the safety of other children in the group, I have to

fortyplus · 19/03/2007 21:46

I used to run a M&T group and we had an 'unofficial' rule that if your child hit another you should leave that session - hopefully so that the child got the message that this behaviour led to undesirable consequences ie no more play. But of course mum & child would be welcome at the next session - everyone seemed to think it was a good compromise - protected children from being on the receiving end of violence but allowed the hitter to come back and learn to socialise.

twinsetandpearls · 19/03/2007 21:46

I would feel awful asking a family to leave if I was not able to offer them support.

FrannyandZooey · 19/03/2007 21:42

I think that is the problem tsap, most groups do not have the facility to offer support outside of the group

so they are given this blanket policy to deal with all behaviour problems and then have no way of improving things for the family in between sessions

I DO support the use of this policy where necessary but it is hard for all concerned

It is standard though, all toddler groups who are members of the PSLA, or have been visited by their parent toddler officer (should be most if not all) will havbe been advised to do this as best practice

twinsetandpearls · 19/03/2007 21:41

It is very hard, I do feel for the woman running this group as it is hard balancing the needs of one child and the safety of the rest of the group.

twinsetandpearls · 19/03/2007 21:40

Before using the behaviour policy we do try to supportthe parents ion discipiling their children within the group and I offer all the advice and support I can and usually we can solve the problem before a family is asked to temporarily leave the group.

twinsetandpearls · 19/03/2007 21:38

I run a mother and toddler group whihc mnay children with behaviour issues attend, I have a discipline policy which I have had to use twice in four years. I am not aware of a more traditional group having such a policy, it is nevassary for my groups due to the nature of the children and families attending.

On both occasions the child concerned was biting, punching slapping several times in one sessiona nd this had been happening for a number of weeks. I had to ask the mothers not to bring their children but this was done quietly and discreetly and I ensured that the organistion I work for provided support for the family until they were able to return to my group.

FrannyandZooey · 19/03/2007 21:34

Yes I agree the behaviour policy should ideally be known to those attending

they should have a welcome pack in which this is spelt out (to be fair, they may have done this - parents don't always read or recall all the information they have been given)

Caligula I can relate to what you are saying

However this IS normal policy and will not have just been invented by the leader of this group. A woman who is, in all likelihood, a volunteer, doing this job in her own time, for no pay, and having to follow the guidelines that she has been given, with no training to help her enforce these rules. She may also have her own child at the group and will have had very little time to think this over - she probably felt she needed to act quite quickly here. It is a very nasty situation for everyone, IMO.

Traycee · 19/03/2007 21:30

Hmm wonder how the policy would fare under scrutiny of the DDA. Children with learning difficulties often hit/bite etc more than their normally developing peers.

VioletBaudelaire · 19/03/2007 21:28

"the leader of the group came over to her and in front of about 4 other mums told her that there was a "behaviour policy" in the group that if a child hit more than twice they would be asked to leave...."
This was not a professional way to handle the issue.
And the issue had already been dealt with amongst the group.
The leader has now stirred up a situation that had been resolved, and made everyone very uncomfortable.
Those attending the group should already be aware of the rules and regulations anyway.

Caligula · 19/03/2007 21:27

Oh it's insane

It's not a usual occurrence in this instance. I can see with a constantly badly behaving child it would be an issue, but with a child who is having an off day, it's just mad. Two instances isn't a usual occurence either.

And there has never been a recorded instance in English law of a case like this being given house-room. This is not America and we don't need bonkers policies like this.

It totally disempowers grown adults from using their common-sense, negotiation skills, diplomacy and common humanity.

FrannyandZooey · 19/03/2007 21:21

The leader is just following what she has been instructed to do by her parent and toddler officer. I feel sorry for her. She gets the blame if children are getting hurt, she gets the blame if she tries to sort it out.

Am I right in thinking that she did not actually ask the parent to remove the child? She just said that if the child hit more than twice she would be asked to leave, but the mother left after a while anyway, is that correct?

FrannyandZooey · 19/03/2007 21:18

Ok have now read thread. Phew!

This really is the policy advised by the PreSchool Learning Alliance. If you have experienced prolonged episodes of hitting, biting or kicking in your toddler group you will know why. Repeated incidents like this can divide a group and lead to the children feeling unsafe at the group. The group leaders also have a responsibility to the attendees to ensure their safety, and could in theory be sued if a child was injured by another child, if this was a usual occurence and no action was taken.

PanicPants · 19/03/2007 21:15

Ds would be out on his ear as well - he's 19months and is really going through a hitting phase at the moment.

Poor poor woman, I came home and cried tonight after the cm mentioned ds' hitting when I picked him up - I can only imagine how she felt in front of all those people.

FrannyandZooey · 19/03/2007 21:14

Haven't read all thread, but this is a common policy for toddler groups as recommended by the Pre school learning alliance. When they say the child is asked to leave, they mean FOR THAT SESSION.

I run toddler groups and have had to enforce this rule and there is good reason for it IMO. Whether it has been correctly applied in this case I am not sure. I would have counted the two hits as one incident if it was me. Also I am not sure I would have counted the "tap" at all.

Surfermum · 19/03/2007 21:13

Oh that poor lady. I would be finding out where she lived so I could go round and make sure she was OK. It's not policy at our toddler group. Sounds most strange to me.

And bless you Caligula for getting all worked up about it .

RosaLuxembourg · 19/03/2007 21:12

I suggest that you print this thread out and (anonymously!) pin it to the toddler group noticeboard.
I also suggest that if you see the mother in question around you make a point of telling her how out of order you think the leader's behaviour was (and that all your MN friends think so too!)

helenhismadwife · 19/03/2007 21:07

well I wouldnt worry to much with a bloody stupid twatty rule like that the toddler group will be non existent within a few weeks.

hoolagirl · 19/03/2007 19:20

OMG the poor woman, I for one would be out on my ear with my DS, he loves taking swipes at anyone who trys to take his toys off him !

mummytosteven · 19/03/2007 19:15

. with a FFS for good measure. These things happen with toddlers, how dreadful undermining for the mother.

Smithagain · 19/03/2007 19:04

I run a toddler group and it had never crossed my mind that I should have any kind of behaviour policy. The toddlers are there with their mums/grannies/carers. My job is to provide activities and refreshments in a safe environment - NOT to discipline them.

I guess if there was a kid who was completely out of control and the mum didn't give a damn, I might say something. But it would have to be pretty extreme.

Hugs to the mum. I hope she finds somewhere nicer to play with her DD.

Troutpout · 19/03/2007 16:55

omg!
Can't believe this... it is so so ridiculous
I would be boiling mad if i saw this at a group i went to.
I would go back...and i'd make a song and dance about it too.
That poor woman who left crying.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread