Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

..for getting offended at my in-laws referring to my son as 'heavy' yesterday?

58 replies

americantrish · 19/03/2007 14:52

..because his cousin (who is 3) is only like between 26 and 28lbs.. and ds is 2 3/4 and is 32lbs. (ds is 3"3', a good 2 inches taller than his cousin.) no one made a peep about ds's weight until his cousin came around to dh's mum's and then it was like 'oh calvin, i didnt realise how HEAVY you were' or 'ohh! you're a heavy boy!'

(by the 3rd, HEAVY comment, i finally remarked he is a good height/weight for his age and the HV has NO concerns as he's recently been height/weight checked.)

(that shut them up.)

i was about to burst beneath my skin!!!

OP posts:
americantrish · 19/03/2007 17:03

tubinmybub> imo, at this age, heavy and fat arent the same, but as ds gets older, they will become one and the same. (as no doubt i was called the heavy child over my sister) and yes, whenever anyone says how active he is, i say, yes well i know he is healthy!!

exbury> ds ALWAYS got the 'what a BIG baby' comment when he was a baby. drove me mad. i finally starting telling people when they commented (yes, even strangers.) that i ate miracle grow when i was pg. and it WORKED.
yes, dh calls ds heavy too but not as much now.

tinkerbellhadpiles> i WOULD flip beyond words if ANYONE ever called ds 'fatso' that IS SO uncalled for. im so sorry....

sigh...at least i can vent here about it, because i cant say anything to dh about it!

OP posts:
steinermum · 19/03/2007 16:59

Many grandparents seem unable to avoid making public comparisons between their grandchildren, even though it's a right wind-up. My mum does it all the time about every aspect of her six grandchildren and if I ever put up a spirited defence of mine I'm accused of being touchy or unable to take a joke...Exquisite torture IME

tinkerbellhadpiles · 19/03/2007 16:58

I get very offended when my MiL calls my 22 week old DD 'fatso'. She's tall and yes she's heavy but I was in a size 10 at 10 a half stone so I reckon we are just built of rocks.

Esp. as MiL could do with missing a few meals herself.

exbury · 19/03/2007 16:55

AmericanTrish - glad it's not just me then . DD is only 5 months, but after MIL had commented for the umpteenth time on Saturday about what a big, heavy girl she was (and she did not mean big as in grown up) I had had enough. DH insists she means as in "big, healthy baby" but that wasn't what I was hearing

Biglips · 19/03/2007 16:52

my DD who is 2.5 yrs old (born oct 04) last weighed before Xmas - 36lb!!...she had always been a heavy girl but she is solid and tall..just over 3 foot tall. My HV said that her weight is spot on for her height

i find it funny when people expected my dd not to be heavy as i cant help but ask my friends/relatives to "pick her up"

tubismybub · 19/03/2007 16:49

I don't think heavy and fat are necessarily the same thing really. DS is only 21 months and also 28lbs and even other children who look the same build as him are far lighter in comparison. I think it's quite a positive thing that he's such a sturdy chap!

As for the hyperactive comments I get them all the time I just say "yes he certainly loves life he's got a great spirit" people either agree or shut up.

americantrish · 19/03/2007 16:45

thanks troutpout!

(your name reminds of a pub not too far from us called the tickled trout!)

OP posts:
Troutpout · 19/03/2007 16:39

he looks absolutely perfect
lovely boy

americantrish · 19/03/2007 16:38

hi miaou yeah thats another thing that is often pointed out about ds, how he's "hyperactive" "doesnt sit still like his cousin/other toddlers".

i dont think they really understand how much it bothers/hurts me. next time, i will make sure i mention it, tactfully.

thanks..xx

OP posts:
Miaou · 19/03/2007 16:29

trish, my parents (particularly my mum) can be insensitive when making comparisons - though I have to say they are usually in favour of ds and "critical" of my nephew! They say things like, "oooh, isn't ds lovely and calm, not like dn" . I blimmin well hope they don't say it in my db's hearing! We (my mum and I) are going down with ds to stay with db after Easter and I can already hear the comparisons ... argh

Weight is such a sensitive subject - regardless of whether the speaker knew how hurt you were by such comments as a child, it's just not appropriate to comment on a child's weight (and particularly not your ds, who is just "normal"!). I do feel for you

americantrish · 19/03/2007 16:06

awwwwwwww thank you, bigcook!!

OP posts:
BigCookLittleCook · 19/03/2007 16:01

Trish have now also looked at your pics. DS is goooooorgeous. Does not look fat at all anyway. Just very handsome.

americantrish · 19/03/2007 15:53

madmarchhare> its been mentioned to them before when things like this have been said about ds. i try not to worry about it, but easier said....
thank you

OP posts:
madmarchhare · 19/03/2007 15:52

If they are aware then yes, its a bit insensitive, but really though, you shouldnt worry about it.

By the way, your ds looks gorgeous on your pictures.

americantrish · 19/03/2007 15:52

awww squonk! your ds' are lovely!!

OP posts:
americantrish · 19/03/2007 15:50

thanks for your compliments, 2happy and squonk

it was a mothers day reunion, pomegranatessparkle! dh's family lives 2.5 hours away in leicester area.

words like 'heavy' might as well be fat at the end of the day. and i was called fat as a child (a young child, as far back as i can remember, which is probably around age 5) - and that has affected me to this day. i WONT let that happen to my son. and next time its mentioned, i will stand up for it a bit better. i didnt want to make an issue on mothers day and certainly if the comments on him being HEAVY continue, i will have to keep making the point to STOP them.

OP posts:
americantrish · 19/03/2007 15:47

madmarchhare> dh's family already knows i'm sensitive about weight comments. it's come up before. and after 3 remarks, i feel a bit justified to have gotten upset! (even though i hide my emotion on my face.)

OP posts:
fryalot · 19/03/2007 15:36

Thank you 2happy. I wouldn't mind so much if anybody ever said anything else about him, iyswim. It's like it is the thing that defines him and in actual fact, it isn't. I can totally see where americantrish is coming from - it feels like a comparison and your ds is coming out wanting, even though it probably is not meant that way.

Fwiw, Americantrish, I think your little boy is gorgeous and he has a very cheeky smile

pomegranatesparkle · 19/03/2007 15:34

lol, was this another mother's day reunion? Bet there were insensitive comments aboundingyesterday. Apparently gorgeous dd (10 months old with perfect eyesight as far as one can tell) has inherited her great grandfather's weak right eye? (according to mil) Based on what evidence? and it's surprising that I'm still bfeeding!

2Happy · 19/03/2007 15:27

I've got to say Sqounk (in a slightly deranged fan kind of way) I think your ds has a gorgeous smile, and in fact looks beautiful in every way. So does yours, AmericanTrish. But I also have to say Squonk's ds looks very similar to my ds1, and I myself call him chunky and heavy. He is. He's a big big boy. But one look at his father and you can see why (bears a remarkable resemblance to Martin Johnson who was captain of England rugby team). It doesn't irritate me at all when people say he's big, they're just stating the obvious, but I can see that it does irritate dh - I think because he had all those comments when he was growing up (and even now, people still remark on his build - it's a bit like people telling pg women how big they are!). Because of this, whether the comments irritate or not, I think they should be discouraged because I don't want my dses growing up with the same self-consciousness.

madmarchhare · 19/03/2007 15:20

My ds could be your dss cousin. ILs are always on about how different all the boys in our family are.

I couldnt really give a toss about what they say or think. I certainly dont think for a minute they are critisising any of them, just taking an healthy interest.

Its the mindless sort of baby/children chit chat people have. I think people are too sensitive about things like this at times.

beckybrastraps · 19/03/2007 15:15

Mine are both heavy. Much heavier than other children their age. And taller too. And yes, people comment on it. So I do I.

BigCookLittleCook · 19/03/2007 15:14

Ah Squonk was just thinking of you and Nemo when I saw this thread.

I comfort myself with the fact that if DS gets gastroenteritis or goes off his food for a few days he is not going to waste away.

TBH I usually get in there first and say "he's heavy" before handing DS over to anyone.

americantrish · 19/03/2007 15:14

it wasnt a compliment. not by a long shot. the comment wasnt made by dh's mum (who raised 5 children as a single mum.) they were made by a childless relative. :I (dh was out of the room for most of them, so he didnt hear them.)

OP posts:
fryalot · 19/03/2007 15:11

We had a thread about this a few days ago, which prompted me to put some photos of ds on my profile. Everyone always comments on him being fat, chunky, heavy - whatever. It really pisses me off, they never say what a gorgeous smile he's got, or what brilliant blue eyes.

Although, I do think that shonaspurtle's got a point, to our parents' generation, the heavier, the better.... it may have been meant as a compliment!

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread