Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to object to neighbour marching into our garden? PARKING THREAD ALERT!

112 replies

CookieTramp · 03/06/2017 08:39

We moved into a new house last October, in a little tucked-away square, and our nearest neighbour is very close to our house, and adjacent. She seemed a finicky old soul but harmless. I started putting her bins out and putting them back for her, because she is close to 80. Brought her a cupcake when I was baking, that kind of thing.

However, when we had our driveway done, everything changed. I gave her a copy of the plans upfront, as the land gets cut a strange way, and it was to be paved where it was all grassed before - hers merging with ours. I told her the dates and to let us know if her land registry plans were different to ours.

She wasn't happy about it being done, although her plans agreed with ours. 'it was always fine as it was', etc. She also asked us to pay for gravel on her little section, which I just dodged as it seemed utterly unreasonable. I just politely repeated, each time she had a moan, that we wanted to do it, and it would mean one fewer car on the road outside. We had space for one car but by paving it it can take two, so visitors can park on our drive instead of on the road. But when the work started, there were problems throughout. Her daughter always parks directly in front of our drive when she picks her mum up, but one time when I parked on the road because I couldn't park on our drive while it was being done, there were ructions. Her daughter said she could not get onto her mum's driveway, but... she never does park on the driveway. She just pulls up outside our house. So yes, my car blocked that, on this particular day, but they never actually do that, if you see what I mean. Her daughter was really unpleasant, but I let it go. Then one time her daughter was on her way, and she knocked and asked our workmen to move their truck, so that her daughter could get on the driveway (which, as I said, she never does). He told her politely that when she arrived, he would move it, and what car should he look out for. She slammed the door that time. Also, when I spoke to her to try and smooth it out, she said she was annoyed the work was taking longer than she thought it would. That seemed very unreasonable too, as it is our works. I just said yes, we weren't happy it had gone on a bit too. Since that conversation, she completely stopped saying hello to us or our boys.

Then two days ago we got some garden work done. I had put a note through to let her know which days the high hedge between our houses (our hedge) was being trimmed, and if any foliage dropped into her garden, to let us know and we would come and remove it. My mum was here while it was done, as we were away for the week - and she knocked on the old lady's door to reiterate that if anything fell in her garden, she/we would remove it immediately. The old lady was quite rude and said no, her son would do it.

Later, she knocked and said her cleaner was on the way, and could our workmen move their truck (it was parked across our driveway, not on our driveway, being pretty big). Her cleaner would not be able to get her car onto her driveway. My mum, having had enough of the trouble last time and not wanting to hop to her tune straightaway, said 'Yes, I will ask them when they come down from their ladders.' The old lady said, no, could she ask them now. My mum said no. The old lady said she would ask them herself, and my mum said no, they were our workmen and she would ask them. Then my mum went into the house. The old lady opened our side gate, and went into our garden, and asked them to move their car! After this, she had a gardener arrive, and made a barbed comment to my mum about him removing stuff that had fallen into her garden - despite me having offered in our note and my mum having offered that very morning. I am also worried she will bill us for it, but that is a side issue.

Let me stress, there is no shortage of parking around the square outside our house, only a metre or two away. Her daughter blocks us in all the time, when picking her mum up, and I have never made an issue of it. When workmen are here, it is clearly a temporary thing, and we have never said they would not move their trucks, just not straightaway while the men are working.

DH says I should let it go, but she has been so unpleasant all the way through, and it really bugs me that she walked right into our garden like that.

AIBU? What would you do?

OP posts:
hmcAsWas · 03/06/2017 10:06

I must say, it gives me the rage if someone blocks my drive...and I am normally quite reasonable. I find it arrogant and entitled - however if a neighbour came over and asked me first if it was okay to temporarily block my drive, and that they would immediately move the vehicle if I needed to go out - then I would be okay with that. I guess it is about being asked first rather than the other party just assuming that it is okay and me looking out to see my driveway blocked without any forewarning.

On the tall hedge issue she was being completely unreasonable.

wowfudge · 03/06/2017 10:05

Difficult to figure out what the set up is without a diagram, but it does seem to have got a bit tit for tat although you were right not to back down over the drive, etc. You shouldn't block her drive at all or you just lose the moral high ground. If you block her drive access you can't complain when her daughter blocks yours.

TheMaddHugger · 03/06/2017 10:04

Who's drive are they blocking ????

RoseTico · 03/06/2017 10:02

Are you still putting her bins out for her? She's very short sighted if she's acting this badly when you are doing her favours every week.

That said, if some of your workmen can park somewhere very near that leaves her never-used drive free, then maybe that's the best course to take?

NoSquirrels · 03/06/2017 10:01

Oh no doubt it is all petty & irritating stuff, but your mum did rather inflame the situation by not offering to speak to the gardeners straightaway, so the "marching into your garden" thing whilst being a bit off I can understand. Both as bad as each other in that scenario.

You should have paid for the gravel. It was a small gesture in the scheme of things, presumably not at all expensive compared to what the driveway cost. I think if you had you might not be having all this angst.

Never block the drive again, and do not allow anyone to do so - just explain to workmen that you're terribly sorry but your neighbour gets cross about it so please could they park further down.

My MIL can get a bee in her bonnet about things that other people do that are totally unnecessary "in her opinion" and it is vexing and wearing. But it's best to ignore and keep on the right side and not rise to provocation.

pictish · 03/06/2017 10:01

She has nudged things up a level by going into your garden as though she has the right. I can see why this has annoyed you so much. Don't rise to it. Flatly ignore. She is trying to become a factor...make her an irrelevance.

kaitlinktm · 03/06/2017 10:00

As PP have said, you could put a lock on your gate - but I realise this is impossible if you have workmen in doing stuff and they need constant access. But I would be inclined to put one on anyway to use when they have finished. If she has walked into your garden once and got what she wanted, she is likely to do it again when you are not expecting it.

I would also be inclined to put some sort of notice on it indicating that it is private, do not enter etc.

I would also from time to time (not every time - that would be unreasonable, at least to begin with) ask her daughter to move her car as you need to go out now. I say this because when people get selfish it might not even be on their radar that they block you in a lot more than your workmen block them in. Try not to block them in though if you can.

She might be 80, but that doesn't mean she can't be rude and taking the piss, and I say that as someone who has parents aged 84 and 88. They wouldn't dream of acting like this.

Ariawyn · 03/06/2017 10:00

Are the builders across your drive or her drive?

Are they actually blocking access to her drive?

Mummyoflittledragon · 03/06/2017 09:55

Your workmen should not park blocking her driveway. She sounds batty and doesn't like change. My ndn was exactly the same. And we also used to be on good terms with her and her husband. She couldn't see that our one storey extension was exactly the same as her having had her two storey extension 20 years ago. Her issue was that she didn't want to do anything to her house. The logic there escapes me.

Just continue to be kind and respectful. Escort her off the property if it happens again. My ndn, who created these problems died on the operating table earlier this year. I think she was less than 70. Yes, it took the issue away as her presence was very upsetting as she'd stand looking out of her upstairs window at us with a scowl and parked her car infront of her house so our workmen couldn't, zoomed past my dd and me like a maniac and we don't have pavements along the road etc etc. She also wouldn't allow the workmen on her land to build the extension wall so it looks really rough but could see nothing wrong with her workmen coming on my land to fix a leak. But I was still very upset that she'd died. Despite her unpleasantness toward us, I remembered a time, when she was nice to us. And of course her husband was heartbroken.

TestTubeTeen · 03/06/2017 09:54

She is being a pain, yes.

But my elderly parents have just had months of 'improvements' going on next door and the impact on them has been immense. The noise, the massive increase in dust, getting in the house, filthy windows, perceived lack of privacy with workman around. All legal, people are entitled to do it, but it does affect the quality of life for neighbours while work is going on.

inkydinky · 03/06/2017 09:54

Really you shouldn't be blocking her drive. She's clearly finding the disruption stressful. I have just fallen out with my neighbours over something similar. They have family staying and have been blocking my drive for months / preventing my visitors from parking in my spare space. Their view ( bit like yours) is that I don't usually use my spare space so it's okay. It ignores completely the fact that actually they don't know all of my guests movements and I could need that space at any time. I spent months knocking and politely asking them to move a few feet to allow access (which I really resented but wasn't prepared to fall out about so wa terrifically polite about it) and when I finally said, look, this isn't reasonable, can you stop. I got a mouthful and they've stopped talking to me as if I am in the wrong. Much as you assume your neighbour to be. My neighbours were previously nice to me too. Taking parcels in etc and lovely with my children but it didn't buy the right to block my drive!

LadyLapsang · 03/06/2017 09:52

Well consider it from her point of view, new neighbours move in and gravel the drive against her wishes and, moreover, don't offer to pay for gravel for her small bit (that would have been an inexpensive way of gaining some goodwill). Then they are parking 2 cars instead of 1 - so perhaps extra noise - on the drive and blocking access to her own home on more than one occasion for her and her visitors.

rightwhine · 03/06/2017 09:46

Well she's not going to have her bin taking in and out, service for any longer then, is she?
You should really also ask her daughter to move every time she blocks you in but tbh it would be better to just rise above it all, be civil and polite but not raise hostilities any more than they are.

Pouncival · 03/06/2017 09:45

let her do her own bins - she obviously doesn't appreciate small kindnesses - I like dartmoordoughnuts response

SofiaAmes · 03/06/2017 09:44

I thought diagrams were mandatory for parking threads.

pictish · 03/06/2017 09:43

I need a diagram as well. She sounds like a cantankerous pain in the arse. Maybe she doesn't like your driveway (personally I think it's always a shame to see greenery paved over...and if there's ample parking in the street like you say then I'd think it a travesty to do it) but that's tough. It's your house and your call. She is showing herself to be a very arrogant person. Avoid from now on, ignore where appropriate.

FittonTower · 03/06/2017 09:40

If there's loads of parking then the easiest solution seems to be that your various builders and stuff stop blocking her drive, or am I missing something?

Siwdmae · 03/06/2017 09:38

Don't block her drive, is very annoying. Stop being so bloody nice, she clearly doesn't want you to be friends.

FluffyWhiteTowels · 03/06/2017 09:38

I agree it sounds tedious for you. Some, and I stress some not all, elderly people get very anxious about change in any way and things looking different.

It's even more of a shame that her daughter appears to be joining in with heightening the tensions. You'd have thought she'd want to smooth things as you were being helpful before i.e. Bins and would have, I am sure, kept a neighbourly eye on her for safety especially in icy weather.

But hopefully tensions will calm down when the work has finished.

GlitteryFluff · 03/06/2017 09:31

Diagram is definitely needed!

TheFairyCaravan · 03/06/2017 09:29

If you don't want her annoying you stop annoying her. Tell your workmen to park 2m away.

Chloe84 · 03/06/2017 09:20

Are the workmen blocking her drive or yours? If the latter, is she just clutching straws for an argument? Can she actually access her drive?

I hope you've stopped taking her bin in and out.

BalloonSlayer · 03/06/2017 09:19

So when is she "marching into your garden" as your thread title states?

AlexaAmbidextra · 03/06/2017 09:17

Close to 80 and people are saying she won't be there for long? She could be there for another 15 years or more!

harderandharder2breathe · 03/06/2017 09:14

Your builders shouldn't be blocking her drive, regardless of if she uses it. People can get funny if they're blocked in as it takes away your options. I don't like people parking in my parking space (comes with my flat, not just somewhere i like to park) even though I don't have a car Blush It's never happened for more than a few hours at a time so I don't get worked up or write notes or anything... but I don't like it even though it doesn't affect me in the slightest

If you want to be awkward, then every time her daughter blocks you in, go and ask her to move. But tbh I would just ignore. Refuse to engage. Obviously refuse to pay if she tries to bill you for her gardener since you/your mum offered to remove anything that fell. Don't pander to her but also don't block her in or do anything to put you in the wrong. And ignore.