Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to object to neighbour marching into our garden? PARKING THREAD ALERT!

112 replies

CookieTramp · 03/06/2017 08:39

We moved into a new house last October, in a little tucked-away square, and our nearest neighbour is very close to our house, and adjacent. She seemed a finicky old soul but harmless. I started putting her bins out and putting them back for her, because she is close to 80. Brought her a cupcake when I was baking, that kind of thing.

However, when we had our driveway done, everything changed. I gave her a copy of the plans upfront, as the land gets cut a strange way, and it was to be paved where it was all grassed before - hers merging with ours. I told her the dates and to let us know if her land registry plans were different to ours.

She wasn't happy about it being done, although her plans agreed with ours. 'it was always fine as it was', etc. She also asked us to pay for gravel on her little section, which I just dodged as it seemed utterly unreasonable. I just politely repeated, each time she had a moan, that we wanted to do it, and it would mean one fewer car on the road outside. We had space for one car but by paving it it can take two, so visitors can park on our drive instead of on the road. But when the work started, there were problems throughout. Her daughter always parks directly in front of our drive when she picks her mum up, but one time when I parked on the road because I couldn't park on our drive while it was being done, there were ructions. Her daughter said she could not get onto her mum's driveway, but... she never does park on the driveway. She just pulls up outside our house. So yes, my car blocked that, on this particular day, but they never actually do that, if you see what I mean. Her daughter was really unpleasant, but I let it go. Then one time her daughter was on her way, and she knocked and asked our workmen to move their truck, so that her daughter could get on the driveway (which, as I said, she never does). He told her politely that when she arrived, he would move it, and what car should he look out for. She slammed the door that time. Also, when I spoke to her to try and smooth it out, she said she was annoyed the work was taking longer than she thought it would. That seemed very unreasonable too, as it is our works. I just said yes, we weren't happy it had gone on a bit too. Since that conversation, she completely stopped saying hello to us or our boys.

Then two days ago we got some garden work done. I had put a note through to let her know which days the high hedge between our houses (our hedge) was being trimmed, and if any foliage dropped into her garden, to let us know and we would come and remove it. My mum was here while it was done, as we were away for the week - and she knocked on the old lady's door to reiterate that if anything fell in her garden, she/we would remove it immediately. The old lady was quite rude and said no, her son would do it.

Later, she knocked and said her cleaner was on the way, and could our workmen move their truck (it was parked across our driveway, not on our driveway, being pretty big). Her cleaner would not be able to get her car onto her driveway. My mum, having had enough of the trouble last time and not wanting to hop to her tune straightaway, said 'Yes, I will ask them when they come down from their ladders.' The old lady said, no, could she ask them now. My mum said no. The old lady said she would ask them herself, and my mum said no, they were our workmen and she would ask them. Then my mum went into the house. The old lady opened our side gate, and went into our garden, and asked them to move their car! After this, she had a gardener arrive, and made a barbed comment to my mum about him removing stuff that had fallen into her garden - despite me having offered in our note and my mum having offered that very morning. I am also worried she will bill us for it, but that is a side issue.

Let me stress, there is no shortage of parking around the square outside our house, only a metre or two away. Her daughter blocks us in all the time, when picking her mum up, and I have never made an issue of it. When workmen are here, it is clearly a temporary thing, and we have never said they would not move their trucks, just not straightaway while the men are working.

DH says I should let it go, but she has been so unpleasant all the way through, and it really bugs me that she walked right into our garden like that.

AIBU? What would you do?

OP posts:
CookieTramp · 03/06/2017 10:59

oh and our boys never go onto her land. I have made sure of that. So I am not sure where the 'boys encroaching' stuff comes in either.

OP posts:
CookieTramp · 03/06/2017 10:58

Lyinwitchinthewardrobe - insular? How have we been insular? We chat to all the neighbours, and have done multiple little things to help our elderly neighbour out. I don't understand what you mean.

OP posts:
CookieTramp · 03/06/2017 10:56

OK, it is clear how to post a pic from my laptop, rather than my phone. Here is the pic of my house, with her house to the left. I took it from the green square out front, where people can freely park around.

As you can see, if you park in front of our house, you could still drive around onto her driveway. And I stress, the only people ever to have done so are workmen who are carrying stuff to and fro, so they position the back of the truck facing our neighbour's house, making the distance the shortest.

Also, the driveway work went on for a month, and the gardening work only for a day and a half.

AIBU to object to neighbour marching into our garden?  PARKING THREAD ALERT!
OP posts:
LyingWitchInTheWardrobe2726 · 03/06/2017 10:52

OP, be careful because what you are saying is the same thing just isn't. Picking up an elderly person (5-10 mins) is NOT anything like having contractors blocking access, however slightly, for HOURS at a time.

To be honest, you and your mum seem to have picked up the gauntlet here and the response to your neighbour saying that the builders were 'up a ladder and you'd speak to them when they got down' was ridiculous.

I have an elderly neighbour and some of the things that she worries about are of no or little concern to me but, because she's elderly, I accept that small concessions will smooth our way - and it is actually reciprocal. She never forgets when we do something for her and appreciates it.

Best train your boys very well to ensure that neither of them encroach on your neighbour at any time either... or you could find that your other neighbours will start taking sides and it won't be yours. She has the time to speak to them whereas you seem to enjoy being insular. Your choice but just remember that it was.

I think it's referred to as 'having your arse in your hands'?

gleam · 03/06/2017 10:44

So annoying, it's bloidy!

gleam · 03/06/2017 10:44

Don't block the driveway, it's bloidy annoying.

CookieTramp · 03/06/2017 10:44

Gosh, so many responses to read through. Thank you. It is really bothering me so having other perspectives will really help.

Just to clarify, when workmen park in front of our drive, it doesn't block her driveway exactly, but makes it more difficult to get onto her driveway. They have to drive round the truck out front and edge in, but it has never been actually blocked. She calls it blocked, but it actually isn't. Workmen have only parked in front of our driveway instead of on the square because they are carrying paving slabs/rocks/foliage to and fro, so they get as close as they can to our side gate. Her daughter does actually block us in when she collects her mum. It is usually only for 5-10 minutes, and it wouldn't bother me except that they have made such a hoo-hah about when trucks have parked where it is more difficult for them to get onto a driveway (that they never drive onto anyway).

I can understand the confusion about how it all fits together. A diagram would be good, but not sure how to attach a pic. I will try and figure it out.

As to the poster who asked when she marched into our garden, it is in the original post.

Will plough through all the responses when my toddler pipes down, at leisure. Thank you.

OP posts:
BewareOfDragons · 03/06/2017 10:42

Your workmen should not be blocking her drive whether she uses it or not as it upsets her. End of.

Ditto for her daughter: she should not be blocking your drive (soon to be drives), and you should point out the hypocrisy in her complaint.

But you should also ensure your workmen stop blocking her in.

For everything else, YANBU. She is. It is your drive, your property, your garden hedge. You have a right to make improvements to and maintain your property whether she likes them or not. You offered to clear up any foliage droppings.

Belmo · 03/06/2017 10:42

She sounds like a total pain, but you/your visitors should never be blocking her driveway whether she uses it or not. And your mum was rude. So you're both U, I reckon - I'd just ignore, and hope the work is finished soon.

whatsthecomingoverthehill · 03/06/2017 10:41

I think there's a bit of a difference between someone blocking a drive for a few minutes when dropping someone off and a builders van being parked there all day.

Sugarpiehoneyeye · 03/06/2017 10:38

Elderly people often find change difficult, also she probably has plenty of time on her hands, to continually mull this over.
I'd try and let it go, the job should be nearing completion, and just hope she returns to her normal self. I imagine she is annoying her daughter with her constant witterings.
However, I hear you, it must be awkward.
Forget the cupcakes and bin shuffling.

Ceto · 03/06/2017 10:36

I don't entirely follow how something parked across your driveway blocks hers? We NEED that diagram. But yes, it the workmen were blocking access then they needed to move, no matter how inconvenient it might have been.

And, of course, by the same token if her daughter blocks your driveway then she needs to move without delay every time she is asked to do so.

pipsqueak25 · 03/06/2017 10:33

where is op ? there are lots of posters asking valid questions.

TheSmallClangerWhistlesAgain · 03/06/2017 10:33

Your workmen should not be blocking anyone's drive. They do need to stop doing that.

Equally, if her daughter is blocking yours and you need to get out, you should ask her politely but firmly to move.

We have nightmare whiney neighbours now. They have been having work done on their house and their favoured passive-aggressive tactic is getting workmen to interfere with our access. It is Not On.

We do not put their bins out, offer them stuff from the garden or kitchen, or even speak to them unless strictly necessary.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe2726 · 03/06/2017 10:31

I agree with HappyJanuary. OP, your elderly neighbour's unreasonableness started off quite mildly and it's grown because you've allowed your workmen to encroach on space that they needn't have.

It's not always about who's right and who's wrong but more about a 'way through' that doesn't impact either too badly. Yes the works are temporary but this is your neighbour and she is not temporary.

You can still get what you want and need without outright making enemies and bear in mind that if things do escalate, the time and attention you will necessarily have to spend on taking it through proper channels will be disproportionate to any mild consideration you would/could give now.

Is it really worth it? Or could you take an objective look at what it is you're doing and what it is your neighbour is upset about? You've already refused what you don't want to do and that's fair enough but for the smaller stuff... what will it actually cost you to make your contractors more considerate of your neighbours?

Think about it before it really gets out of hand because you will ultimately lose and be posting about it here constantly. Not.Worth.It.

shesabrick · 03/06/2017 10:30

In some ways she is being deliberately awkward so all you can do is make sure you are never in the wrong - do not ever block her drive or allow workmen to, its irrelevant if she uses it or not, and don't take her cakes or whatever but continue with saying hello and big fake smiles every time you see her. Engaging with the nonsense will not help in this situation.

My grandmother was rather like her. She lasted until 95 in her own house, I bet her neighbours thought they'd be rid of her much sooner too.

FrancisCrawford · 03/06/2017 10:27

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

PurpleMinionMummy · 03/06/2017 10:26

So Ylyou/your visitors keep blocking access to her drive and you wonder why she's annoyed? Whether she uses it or not is irrelevant, it doesn't mean you can block it.

If her dd regularly blocked yours to the point you had to ask her to move you both sound as bad as each other. If her dd literally stopped there a min whilst her mum went out to the car I don't see the issue as presumably she was in the car and could move straight away if you needed to come out.

Judashascomeintosomemoney · 03/06/2017 10:25

I'm confused. So the workman ARE blocking her drive? And you're saying they'll move it when you say so not when she asks? If I've got that right then YABU.

llangennith · 03/06/2017 10:24

Let it go. Things will calm down and get back on an even keel once your extensive building works are finished.
I expect everybody will be relieved.

diddl · 03/06/2017 10:18

I need a diagram also!

If your drive encroaches onto hers somehow, why would you expect her to pay anything if you wanted the work doing?

Was her drive blocked by the truck?

How long does the daughter block your drive when she pick up & does it usually affect you?

HappyJanuary · 03/06/2017 10:17

Some elderly people have a lot of time to worry about things that busier people wouldn't worry about.

My grandma is a similar age. She considers it a busy day if she needs to go to the butchers. She stresses if a routine bill arrives. She frets about Christmas from august onwards.

She's not batty or cantankerous, she's set in her ways and doesn't like change. Many of us will be the same, although we don't think so now.

As far as I can see, she doesn't like her drive blocked. She doesn't want you to move the vehicle when her daughter or cleaners arrive, she wants it kept clear at all times.

This is easily remedied by asking visitors not to block her drive, especially as there is ample parking a few metres away.

It wouldn't bother me that she came into the garden, and your mum was a bit rude telling her she'd ask the workmen to move later.

lalalalyra · 03/06/2017 10:16

You're annoyed because she "marched" into your garden to tell your tradesperson to move their vehicle, which was blocking her drive?

Your Mum was rude. If someone doing work for you blocks a neighbours drive then they are perfectly entitled to ask them to move now. Doesn't matter what they do or don't use the drive for.

Take her daughters parking up with her and stop letting people block your neighbours drive.

hmcAsWas · 03/06/2017 10:08

Oh and I think I would have a word with her daughter about not blocking your drive!

AnnieAnoniMouse · 03/06/2017 10:07

LadyLapsang

Well consider it from her point of view, new neighbours move in. Yes. Into THEIR house, not hers.

gravel the drive against her wishes. Gravel THEIR driveway.

Then they are parking 2 cars instead of 1 on THEIR drive.

so perhaps extra noise on THEIR drive

Do you see the pattern?

blocking access to her own home on more than one occasion for her and her visitors. Blocking access she never uses. Deep sigh.

The neighbour is being difficult because she liked it how her neighbours driveway/garden was better. That's totally unreasonable. I like the neighbours opposite garden how it was before they moved in & I liked their windows better before (they've had mock Tudor pvc windows put in a '70's terraced house, looks ridiculous IMO) but it's THEIR house. I can raise an eyebrow at the ugliness of it, but it's not my place to say anything, as it wasn't my place to say anything whilst they had a skip on their driveway & they were parking on the road making access to my driveway very difficult. It's life.

She's stupidly cut off her nose to spite her face. She had neighbours doing nice things for her & looking out for her. People she could trust & ask for help. Now she's created all this animosity over the OP gravelling HER OWN driveway. She's been very stupid.

Swipe left for the next trending thread