Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to object to neighbour marching into our garden? PARKING THREAD ALERT!

112 replies

CookieTramp · 03/06/2017 08:39

We moved into a new house last October, in a little tucked-away square, and our nearest neighbour is very close to our house, and adjacent. She seemed a finicky old soul but harmless. I started putting her bins out and putting them back for her, because she is close to 80. Brought her a cupcake when I was baking, that kind of thing.

However, when we had our driveway done, everything changed. I gave her a copy of the plans upfront, as the land gets cut a strange way, and it was to be paved where it was all grassed before - hers merging with ours. I told her the dates and to let us know if her land registry plans were different to ours.

She wasn't happy about it being done, although her plans agreed with ours. 'it was always fine as it was', etc. She also asked us to pay for gravel on her little section, which I just dodged as it seemed utterly unreasonable. I just politely repeated, each time she had a moan, that we wanted to do it, and it would mean one fewer car on the road outside. We had space for one car but by paving it it can take two, so visitors can park on our drive instead of on the road. But when the work started, there were problems throughout. Her daughter always parks directly in front of our drive when she picks her mum up, but one time when I parked on the road because I couldn't park on our drive while it was being done, there were ructions. Her daughter said she could not get onto her mum's driveway, but... she never does park on the driveway. She just pulls up outside our house. So yes, my car blocked that, on this particular day, but they never actually do that, if you see what I mean. Her daughter was really unpleasant, but I let it go. Then one time her daughter was on her way, and she knocked and asked our workmen to move their truck, so that her daughter could get on the driveway (which, as I said, she never does). He told her politely that when she arrived, he would move it, and what car should he look out for. She slammed the door that time. Also, when I spoke to her to try and smooth it out, she said she was annoyed the work was taking longer than she thought it would. That seemed very unreasonable too, as it is our works. I just said yes, we weren't happy it had gone on a bit too. Since that conversation, she completely stopped saying hello to us or our boys.

Then two days ago we got some garden work done. I had put a note through to let her know which days the high hedge between our houses (our hedge) was being trimmed, and if any foliage dropped into her garden, to let us know and we would come and remove it. My mum was here while it was done, as we were away for the week - and she knocked on the old lady's door to reiterate that if anything fell in her garden, she/we would remove it immediately. The old lady was quite rude and said no, her son would do it.

Later, she knocked and said her cleaner was on the way, and could our workmen move their truck (it was parked across our driveway, not on our driveway, being pretty big). Her cleaner would not be able to get her car onto her driveway. My mum, having had enough of the trouble last time and not wanting to hop to her tune straightaway, said 'Yes, I will ask them when they come down from their ladders.' The old lady said, no, could she ask them now. My mum said no. The old lady said she would ask them herself, and my mum said no, they were our workmen and she would ask them. Then my mum went into the house. The old lady opened our side gate, and went into our garden, and asked them to move their car! After this, she had a gardener arrive, and made a barbed comment to my mum about him removing stuff that had fallen into her garden - despite me having offered in our note and my mum having offered that very morning. I am also worried she will bill us for it, but that is a side issue.

Let me stress, there is no shortage of parking around the square outside our house, only a metre or two away. Her daughter blocks us in all the time, when picking her mum up, and I have never made an issue of it. When workmen are here, it is clearly a temporary thing, and we have never said they would not move their trucks, just not straightaway while the men are working.

DH says I should let it go, but she has been so unpleasant all the way through, and it really bugs me that she walked right into our garden like that.

AIBU? What would you do?

OP posts:
Ceto · 03/06/2017 12:22

OP, you've admitted that it's only for 5-10 minutes. You know exactly whose car it is and if you are so desperate to access your drive in that time, you know where the driver is to ask her to move the car

But the point is that OP hasn't objected to this, despite the fact that those 5-10 minute obstructions must add up to a hell of a lot of time and there must be occasions when it is a bloody nuisance. Yet despite OP's tolerance of this, the neighbour feels entitled to kick up a fuss just because occasionally it's mildly inconvenient to get on to her drive.

Waltermittythesequel · 03/06/2017 12:18

Your mother was rude, petty, and wrong.

You don't own the bloody workmen!

Neighbour had someone coming and she wanted access to her own drive.

Your mum should have kept her beak out. She has escalated it.

FrancisCrawford · 03/06/2017 12:14

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

apostropheuse · 03/06/2017 12:10

I think it's possible that your neighbour just doesn't like being left with that small patch of grass. When her lawn and your lawn were joined together it would give the illusion of her having a bigger garden. She's been left with a pretty ugly little triangle of grass. You're legally entitled to do that of course.

Ceto · 03/06/2017 12:03

Picking up an elderly person (5-10 mins) is NOT anything like having contractors blocking access, however slightly, for HOURS at a time

But they aren't blocking access. Their presence on OP's land simply makes access slightly more inconvenient.

FrancisCrawford · 03/06/2017 11:57

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Greenkit · 03/06/2017 11:52

I get you OP

You have been kind and considerate to the neighbour, ignored her daughter blocking YOUR drive.

It seems she got the hump because you wanted up date and add a parking space to your property and wouldn't pay for gravel for hers.

She has then deliberately, go the huff about your builders, NOT blocking her drive just to be a pail.

Perhaps she is jealous, I would ignore from now on

Lostwithinthehills · 03/06/2017 11:41

Am I being unreasonable to object to my 80 year old neighbour entering my garden to politely ask that my workman move his massive truck because it was obstructing access to her drive? My neighbour initially politely asked my mum to ask the workman to the truck but my mum refused.

I think that sums up your AIBU and my answer to that question is yes.

keeplooking · 03/06/2017 11:36

she is close to 80.

she's not going to be your neighbour for long. Sit back and let nature do its thing.

Nice.

TheMaddHugger · 03/06/2017 11:32

Sweetie OP Thanks for the extra info. I would be happy to live next to you.

((((((((((Hugs)))))))

CookieTramp · 03/06/2017 11:31

"everything else is padding".. well, yes. it would have been a bit meaningless in isolation. I have said upfront that that is the bit that is the issue, by entitling the thread that, and by saying so directly.

OP posts:
HotelEuphoria · 03/06/2017 11:30

Sounds to me that she wasn;t happy about you making your drive bigger, older people can be a bit odd about change, I know my dad is and is obsessive about next doors garden and how they don't cut their hedges or grass etc ...BUT, it all seems a bit tit for tat now.

Be the bigger person don't have your builders block her drive, don't let her daughter block yours and let her put her own bins out.

WinBigly · 03/06/2017 11:30

I wouldn't have put paving around the bush to the left of the picture, it looks ugly and makes the neighbour's patch of grass look bizarre

I think you're as bad as each other to be honest. Your mum could easily have asked the gardeners to move their vehicle there and then (e.g. "when you've finished up the ladder, can you move your van") rather than saying she'd ask them later. That was dismissive and is what caused the neighbour to enter your garden in the first place.

These stupid little neighbour disputes escalate to ridiculous proportions - court cases, physical assault etc. There's no winners in these situations.

Lostwithinthehills · 03/06/2017 11:29

Later, she knocked and said her cleaner was on the way, and could our workmen move their truck (it was parked across our driveway, not on our driveway, being pretty big). Her cleaner would not be able to get her car onto her driveway. My mum, having had enough of the trouble last time and not wanting to hop to her tune straightaway, said 'Yes, I will ask them when they come down from their ladders.' The old lady said, no, could she ask them now. My mum said no. The old lady said she would ask them herself, and my mum said no, they were our workmen and she would ask them. Then my mum went into the house. The old lady opened our side gate, and went into our garden, and asked them to move their car!

So this is the bit you are angry about, everything else is padding.

As you haven't said otherwise I assume that your neighbour asked politely for your workman's truck to be moved but your mum refused to ask the workman. I don't blame your neighbour for asking your workmen herself, what were her other options for getting the obstruction in front of her drive removed?

bigmack · 03/06/2017 11:23

I don't think that you've been a bad neighbour, but you don't seem to recognise how upsetting this situation may be for your elderly neighbour. She probably feels very vulnerable.

NoSquirrels · 03/06/2017 11:22

Well, if that's your only issue then just ignore it - your mum should have asked them to move straight away, knowing it was a sore point in neighbourly relations. Digging her heels in really wasn't helpful.

She an 80-ish year old bothered about parking and access. She's not going to be in your garden all the time for nefarious purposes.

Let it go, and try to move on gracefully.

CookieTramp · 03/06/2017 11:18

Just as additional information, we didn't even draw the driveway line according to the land registry plans. It looked very brutal to her, so we brought it forward by a foot or so, ceding our land. I think we have tried very hard to be neighbourly, and I have to say I feel quite crushed by people saying we have been bad neighbours :-(. The issue I have issue with isn't the blocking in by her daughter (it was added as extra info), but only her opening our gate and going into our garden. I have let everything else go - the barbed comments, the aggressive daughter, the blocking in.

OP posts:
bigmack · 03/06/2017 11:16

You've obstructed her driveway over a period of time and she has found this upsetting. She was perfectly entitled to ask the workmen to move their van.

CookieTramp · 03/06/2017 11:13

Scholes, I have never made a fuss about her daughter blocking me in. I have never blocked her in. I have never made a fuss about anything, and I have put her bins out, and I have watched over her house (let her know when someone was doing something odd with her front door), and I have brought her cakes.

Not sure why you wouldn't want to live next door to me!

OP posts:
LyingWitchInTheWardrobe2726 · 03/06/2017 11:13

OP, perhaps 'insular' was the wrong word, I didn't realise that you talk to your other neighbours also. What I meant is that you've gone from the occasional cupcake to a 'defensive stance', which I totally understand but it's very awkward.

I have to say I winced a bit when you said you took cupcakes to your neighbour and put the bins out because it's SO awkward now. I've been in your position before myself (with a shared access) that became so awkward that I just moved.

From your photo (very helpful), I see what you mean about the driveway and yes, it's quite petty to complain about being blocked in but, your neighbour's (and her daughter's) hackles are up now so any, tiny little thing is going to set them off.

I said about making sure that your boys never encroach because that is the last thing that you want. Kids playing wouldn't think anything of a ball going in somebody's garden as being something dire but in a neighbour 'dispute', everything is sensitised. That's all that I meant by that.

Is there any way of speaking to neighbour and just drawing a line under this and starting fresh as polite neighbours?

Scholes34 · 03/06/2017 11:09

Meant to say, HappyJanuary is talking a lot of sense. I'd have HappyJanuary live next to me!

Scholes34 · 03/06/2017 11:07

Well this is just so petty. Of course the OP is under no obligation to grave the neighbour's drive, however small, but given the disruption works on the OP's house causes to the neighbours it would have been such a small and generous thing to have done. As for all the arguments about who's blocking who in, when the neighbour's daughter blocks your drive, OP, you've admitted that it's only for 5-10 minutes. You know exactly whose car it is and if you are so desperate to access your drive in that time, you know where the driver is to ask her to move the car. And builders are notorious for their need to park their vehicle as close as possible to where their working - a few feet can make a big difference to them! Yes, it's legal where they're parking, but for the sake of maintaining (or in your case trying to re-establish) good relations with your neighbour, ask them to be a little more considerate. If relations between you and your neighbour have broken down, your behaviour since the arrival of the builders has done a lot to bring that about. However just you might feel in your stance and behaviour, you've got to live there, so good luck to you. Pleased I'm not your neighbour.

PurpleMinionMummy · 03/06/2017 11:07

Making access difficult isn't on either. Yabu and making excuses for it.

Lostwithinthehills · 03/06/2017 11:05

To be fair to your neighbour a month was a long time for her to put up with your workmen outside her house and it may have influenced how she feels about anything else you do that impinges on her. I expect she has expressed her unhappiness to her daughter who probably now feels defensive on her elderly mother's behalf.

CookieTramp · 03/06/2017 11:04

Oh and Lyin, when her daughter picks her up, blocking us in actually means further for her mum to walk. If she parked on the actual driveway, that would be the closest place for her mother.

OP posts: