Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To go to a private health club swimming pool, and whilst getting dressed a nine yr old boy walks in with his mother!!!

113 replies

bubblicious · 18/03/2007 18:06

What makes it even worse that he goes to the school where I work!

Just wondered as I have 3DDs so it has never been an issue for me, at what age is it reasonable for a child to get changed in the right changing room! (this swimming pool has separate changing rooms!

I have to say Im not a prude but there are only 2 changing cubicles!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hoppinggreen · 09/08/2022 12:44

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Johnnysgirl · 09/08/2022 12:41

juliaw · 22/03/2007 20:47

There was a boy assaulted at a pool near my parents in London when changing in mens area alone - also it was not that long ago a girl of similar age was assulted in a supermarket toilet while her parents waited for her outside - a man had gone in and loitered in there waiting for an unaccompanied child to go in. It does happen and as a parent of 3 boys I would say it would be at the discretion of the parents whether they felt comfortable letting their child change alone. Would you be happy letting a 9 year old girl change in an area separate to you where there may be men changing? Just because they are boys doesn't make them any safer at that age.

Oh, Jesus... ok, I change my mind.

AngieWool · 09/08/2022 12:41

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Johnnysgirl · 09/08/2022 12:40

franca70 · 18/03/2007 18:07

would it have been better for his mum to take him to the men's changing rooms?

She didn't need to take him anywhere. He can go in the men's.

Tundrawells · 09/08/2022 12:33

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

steinermum · 22/03/2007 21:42

No, I wouldn't let a nine year old girl change with strange naked men around because it would be horrendously embarrassing for her. It's my son who's telling me very clearly that it's embarrassing for him to be made to change in the women's, simply because he feels ready to go to the men's and does a great job - he's in and out in five minutes etc. Loads of dads and sons are in there at the same time. In my opinion, he is safe.

3easterbunniesandnomore · 22/03/2007 20:58

Am with Julia here....just because they are boys they still have a right to feel save, and it does kinda depend on the area and the child, I would think!

juliaw · 22/03/2007 20:47

There was a boy assaulted at a pool near my parents in London when changing in mens area alone - also it was not that long ago a girl of similar age was assulted in a supermarket toilet while her parents waited for her outside - a man had gone in and loitered in there waiting for an unaccompanied child to go in. It does happen and as a parent of 3 boys I would say it would be at the discretion of the parents whether they felt comfortable letting their child change alone. Would you be happy letting a 9 year old girl change in an area separate to you where there may be men changing? Just because they are boys doesn't make them any safer at that age.

steinermum · 21/03/2007 21:39

Well, My 7 year old's swimming lesson was today and I have been thinking a lot about this thread. I asked the pool what their policy was and they said 'from 8, boys are expected to go into the men's changing rooms'. I checked out the family room. You have to walk through the ladies and the showers are communal, so not a great deal of help. I had a chat with my son about various worst-case scenarios and he said 'I'd tell them no and come find you', 'I'd walk away' etc. I had also talked to DH about it, who said the changing area is completely open, any pervy bloke would be quickly hounded out by dads. So, the upshot is, my DS2, 7, is still going to go into the men's changing rooms.

spykid · 20/03/2007 14:02

ds1 is 8, and when I can he sytill comes in the ladies, loos too.

I worry about unsavoury people if he is on his own getting changed

PeachyClair · 20/03/2007 14:00

I suppose though Blu- tracing them is all very well, but if they've been attacked as DS1 was, its too late isn't it? I mean, fortunately it was a black eye / minor head injury- it could ahev been worse. So I can't ever risk it happening again- when they can't go into the womens chanaging, they will be able (hopefully) to go in pairs as they have each other (something I do with toilet trips now) but the younger ds isn't able for it yet.

Blu · 20/03/2007 13:47

I will loook this thread up when DS is 9 and see what i think then!

For now a few things occur to me. Several male friends have said things which indicate that by 9 young boys are (quite naturallly - nothing to do with perviness or any kind of inappropriateness) beginning to have a sexual response to adult women. One described hilariously his hours spent being made to wait at the side of his mother's yoga class and the lycra and open-legged poses etc etc - and i can remember my own brother being boggle-eyed on the naturaist beaches of North Norfolk that my parents used to drag us to, hippy and liberal-like as they were!
And I think at 8 or 9 I would let DS into a male changing room - given that this is a private health club, so all the people I there will be traceable by address etc, and there are usually photo id membership cards.

I knew at 7 what to do if anyone said or did anything inappropriate (my girls school was surrounded by a flasher-infeste park), so think DS would be able to understand the basics.

TeeCee · 20/03/2007 13:44

I'd much rather a 9 yr old boy be with his mum in the changing rooms than be alone in a room full of strang men, any of whom could have a thing for young boys.

Caligula · 20/03/2007 13:37

It's precisely because the only time naked bodies are shown to children, is in a soft-porn, sexualised environment (like the Sun for example - those two kids possibly had been exposed to that image of nakedness for years) that some seven year olds would behave like that (possibly also out of embarrassment and bravado).

The more normal nakedness is, the less shrieking and pointing there is to do.

steinermum · 20/03/2007 09:34

I agree with Tigermoth. It is not the fault of children that they are exposed to sexual imagery at an ever earlier age, no matter how much we try to shield them. 'Proto-perv' is well harsh.

bozza · 20/03/2007 09:15

My 2yo DD has been rather embarassing at times (not recently) staring at the over 50s ladies getting changed after their session which was before the parent and child. I used to aim for distraction. I would go for a quick hiss in the ear if 6yo DS tried the same thing.

tigermoth · 20/03/2007 00:09

I am really saddened to see the phrase 'proto-perv' applied to 7 or 8 year old boys. I am not saying they weren't being badly behaved in a 7 year old boy kind of way. The mother should have stopped it - I agree.

I agree lovecat that that children of any age might comment and stare at naked bodies -and sometimes it goes to far and becomes bad manners. But that phrse and what it means just leapt out at me

If those two giggling, pointing children had been girls, would you have said they were proto tarts, dykes, nymphos or whatever adult sexual connotation came to mind?

nally · 19/03/2007 23:59

i don't think you are being unreasonable. i know a 9 year old boy who draws boobs on every picture of a female he finds in magazines!!!

chipmonkey · 19/03/2007 23:54

Luckily dh now takes my older boys swimming. There's no cut-off age in our gym but nor are there private cubicles. I would feel very uncomfortable letting them into the mens changing rooms on their own even though they are now 8 and 10. I think, if someone were a paedophile, a gym changing room would be an ideal place to hang out.

bubblicious · 19/03/2007 23:25

Why is this such a awkward situation!!!!!!

OP posts:
steinermum · 19/03/2007 23:02

Lovecat - my 7 year old wouldn't point or leer (as he knows I'd be mad if he did), but he would DEFINITELY not be oblivious to the 'naked boobies' I think it would be uncomfortable for all concerned and that is why he is adamant about going to the mens' changing rooms. Having said that, I will have a fresh pep talk about stranger danger with both sons before swimming on Wednesday.

Lovecat · 19/03/2007 21:55

I've been in a pool changing room when someone came in with 2 boys, about 7 or 8, and the boys just stood there and LEERED at the semi-naked women (definitely leering, sniggering, commenting, pointing at boobs etc) and most of the women in there felt very aggrieved at the mother/carer, who didn't seem to feel there was anything untoward about her two proto-pervs' behaviour at all. So I'm not sure I agree that youngish children are too young to take notice of naked females!

Of course not all children are like this (please God!) and I do understand that if you're on your own with a male child it must be godawful to have to send them off into another changing room on their own, but I think there's definitely an argument for family changing rooms or, as another poster has mentioned, family 'areas' of changing rooms.

And I do agree with Caligula, if we weren't so hung up about our bodies in the UK then there wouldn't be all the pointing and giggling on the part of the children and there wouldn't be the awkwardness on the part of the grownups in the first place...

bubblicious · 19/03/2007 20:36

Wallace thanks for your comment it made me laugh- oh and by the way I dont have a size DDs for a bra fiting!!!!

I was just caught off guard what with seeing a child who does attend the school I work at, and know the boy well! it just got me thinking when was the cut off point for DC to accompany mothers into changingroom. sorry if it offends anyone!

OP posts:
staceym11 · 19/03/2007 18:03

PC thats horrible your poor little boy!

PeachyClair · 19/03/2007 17:51

Actually until DS was attacked he alwys went into toilets etc alone- as someone with AS the signs or toilet doors stating gender are strict rules for him. Now I am terrified if I have to let him go into a toilet alone.

I wouldn't suggest anyone risk it, personally.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.