Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to NOT want my name on dh's card to HIS mum

81 replies

kickassangel · 08/03/2007 10:47

signing cards this morning, he just put all our names on it - he says it's just a card from our household to his mum. i say it's from him to his mother. my mum wouldn't want his name on a mothers day card to her. who is being reasonable - come & judge oh court of mn

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Lanawashington · 02/08/2022 09:18

@xxAbbieC why are you digging up all these old in laws threads from 2007!?

kickassangel · 09/03/2007 15:25

twinkie, i think you should slide on over to arts & crafts & ask someone to make you a card!

OP posts:
twelveyeargap · 09/03/2007 15:16

We tend to just send flowers/ card to our own mums - probably becuase that's how we did it before we lived together. No other reason. I wouldn't object to having my name on DH's mums card though, because I like her.

I object strongly when DH forgets to add me to her birthday present card/ present.

Twinkie1 · 09/03/2007 15:10

Yes

We put the wholefamily on card to DHs mum - me DH DD and DS.

Luckily I only have to send one because no one has invented a card made of dog shit to send to stepmonster yet!!

BirdyArms · 09/03/2007 15:07

I just put my own name on the card to my mum but as I have to buy and write the card for dh's mum put all of our names on her card.

ShinyHappyPeopleHoldinghands · 09/03/2007 15:03

yes

nh101 · 09/03/2007 15:02

I don't put Dh's name on birthday or mother's day cards to my mum cos I always choose one with a really nice message that really means something and those sentiments don't come from DH, they only come from me. All my three sisters put their Dh's names on though. And DH puts mine on cards to his mum and it doesn't bother me.

LazyLine · 09/03/2007 14:33

For me, I send a mothers day card to my mother and would not dream of signing someone elses. Mothers day for me is not about saying "congrats on being a mother", it's about saying "thank you for being MY mother".

Now, if there was someone that I was very close to and had treated me like a daughter and the bond was there such as a MIL who had gone out of her way when my mother hadn't then I would deffo sign a card.

frenchconnection · 09/03/2007 14:11

Think you're right, she's HIS mum and not yours,and vice versa!
i wouldnt put dh's name on my mum's mothers day card due to the small fact that SHE AINT HIS MOTHER!

kickassangel · 09/03/2007 10:46

i didn't even see it as anything to do with how close we were - that's a whole other story - just that i honestly thought it was meant to be to your mum, a kind of reminder of how they were your mummy when you were little, how they have brought you up & helped you on your way through life. it's a reminder of that close bond which (hopefully) you have with your mother.
now i realise that for some people it's more of a family thing, how you all work together. that's fine, i just never ever thought that anyone did that. in our family we tend to treat blood relatives as closer than in laws, but thaqt is partly because there are so many of us that we can't afford cards/presents for the 'late comers'. we're not nasty to them, but my mum would be a bit quizzical about dh signing a mother's day card to her. on all other cards, they would be sent as a family.
incidently, dh sends a card to his gran on mothers day because she did help to bring him up, so it seems appropriate, but i never sent one to mine. i think the kickass household shall just allow each other to sign cards as they see fit, and i now understand the different points of view around this subject.

OP posts:
noonar · 09/03/2007 10:16

as hulababy's posts reflects. some relationships are closer than others.

noonar · 09/03/2007 10:15

kickass, no one can tell you that you are being unreasonable, or odd, imo, as its such a personal thing that depends on your particular relationship with your mil.

mymama, maybe you feel really close and chummy with your mil, but maybe kickass doesnt. she's not 'wierd' just cos this doesnt feel right! every family is different.

Hulababy · 09/03/2007 10:02

I don't call MIL mum and FIL dad though. TBH I tend no to use any name, lol! First names souded too familiar when younger, Mr & Mrs toof ormal; so now I guess I am so used to avoiding any names!

Hulababy · 09/03/2007 10:01

As we were both so young though, I spent a lot of time at his house and he at mine, and in uni life, being chauffered around my parents, under their care I guess. I call his grandad my grandad. PILs always says I am like a daughter to them, esp as they have only sons I guess. I have always been treated as very much of the family, and they are really important to me. To me, they are very much my family, so it makes sense to me.

But as ever, everyone has their own ways of doing things. Guess main thing is to make sure you and your DH agrees on what to do and go from there.

compo · 09/03/2007 09:58

I never put dh's name on my mother's card. I see it as thanking her for yesrs and years of things, things that predate dh.
I don't call mil 'mum' either, I know she would love it but I only have one mum, end of.
If my ds/dd call their inlaws mum and dad i'll be gutted tbh

edam · 09/03/2007 09:57

Aw hula, childhood sweethearts. I met dh when I was 19 and he was still living at home but it still wouldn't occur to me to put my name on his mother's day card.

ipanemagirl · 09/03/2007 09:56

my dh and ds sign a card for my mother in law and I send one to my mother which my ds signs!
It's a personal thing isn't it? But hell, my mil is a mother to me in a million ways so I should probably sign hers in 10 foot letters!!! I give her a gift though.
I suppose it's nice to mark the uniqueness of being a mummy - that's how I've always seen it.

mymama · 09/03/2007 09:55

Both names here. Actually find it a bit weird that you would not want to be thought of as a family on a card.

Hulababy · 09/03/2007 09:54

To me Mother's Day is about mother figures/roles - not just necessarily about the one person who gave birth to you. Of course I adore my own mum most, but DH's mum plays a big and important role in my life too. So to me she is a mother like figure in my life. Dh and I did meet when 16 and still at school, so maybe that is why.

edam · 09/03/2007 09:53

Forgot to ask last night. I think he signs from ds too and gets him to scribble, which makes sense. Don't mind if he does, just strikes me as odd. If I signed from dh, it wouldn't be as special as me thinking of my own mother, IYKWIM.

noonar · 09/03/2007 09:51

deceptive

noonar · 09/03/2007 09:50

kickass, i'm totally with you on this one . i have my own mum to send an m's day card to. strikes me as odd to sign it from you too, tbh......but am sure your dh did it out of habit (most other cards are signed by all, arent they?) rather than being secretive or decptive! (so dont be mad at him.)

i dont think your'e overreacting at all, but your reaction does rather suggest a bit of 'history' with your mil. join the club...

kickassangel · 09/03/2007 09:40

edam - i suggest you check! I have been blissfully unaware of this until the other morning, and we've been married for 15 years!

OP posts:
Hulababy · 08/03/2007 21:11

Our Mother's day cards are signed for us all (me, Dh and DD). We have great relationships with our parents and each other's parents, so the sentiments are there, regardless of whose mum it actually is.

AngharadGoldenhand · 08/03/2007 21:09

Dh and I write our own cards for our own mothers and we're both happy with it.

So, from this household, no, you're not being unreasonable.