Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect my rich brother to buy me a decent birthday gift?

57 replies

Sheila · 08/03/2007 10:03

OK - he may not be rich exactly, but he earns a lot of money, his wife also works full time, they live in a massive house, have an au-pair, annual skiing hols etc etc, and what I got from him today on my birthday was a cheap as chips bracelet that probably cost no more than £10.00 (if that) and is already starting to make my wrist go green.

In fact the card is in his wife's handwriting so I suspect that she was roped in to buy the gift and send it, and she's not my biggest fan.

I know I shouldn't care, but I do. I don't have a DP/DH so family presents are more important, and I feel so let down and sad about my life.

OP posts:
Sheila · 08/03/2007 12:54

I think another factor is the history of my relationship with my brother. We were very close as children and teenagers but now I hardly see him. Most of the time I accept this (with a lot of sadness) but birthdays bring it home. I also feel very let down about the fact he makes no effort to see ds, felt very bitter about his complete lack of support when I broke up with XP and had to find house, job on my own with a 2yo ds...etc etc.

So I guess it's a lot more complicated than one birthday present!

As for the money thing - I've been accused of being materialistic but I think it's just basically mean when someone has a lot of money not to spend some of that on their family. I don't have much now but when I did have money I always spent as much as I could afford on those I loved, including DB and his kids. My mum, 79 and living on a pension, spent far more than DB did. I know it doesn't always follow but it's hard not to feel that the amount of money spent = the amount of love felt.

OP posts:
Gobbledigook · 08/03/2007 12:18

Hmmm. I wouldn't be bothered. I don't make a big deal of birthdays and never have. We are much better off than my ILs but we probably spend less on them than they do on us. It's their choice, just as it's mine. I'm not bothered if I get nothing - I don't expect anything. I buy whatever I want for myself anyway.

Earlybird · 08/03/2007 12:15

Happy birthday Sheila!

My family don't have any idea what to get me for birthdays/Christmas, so I have started to make suggestions. It makes everyone happier all the way 'round. For Christmas they pooled money to get me a nice digital camera - my requested item - and I'm thrilled. Otherwise I have a running 'wish list' on Amazon, and they can order something from there which will be posted directly to me.

I'd love it if they could be on my 'wavelength' enough to choose something wonderful, but experience tells me it just doesn't work that way. Maybe give it a try next time so they're not stuck for an idea, and you're not disapointed with what they select...

inanidealworld · 08/03/2007 12:01

happy Birthday!

I know what you mean about the the thought that goes into a present. My ILs are a bit like that. In the past we always got them something we thought they would like (takes time and effort to think of something good and original) or asked what they would like (which they would get even if it was more than I would have ideally liked to spend) whereas we just got (it felt like) whatever else the rest of the family were also getting with no regard to individual tastes (e.g a carriage clock . Nowhere in my house would suit a carriage clock and it's just not us). Anyway after years of it, I have decided to do the same and they just get what they get. End of.
Have no expectations and you will not be disappointed

sunnysideup · 08/03/2007 11:10

thanks sheila.

Sheila · 08/03/2007 11:06

Thank you, thank you Sunnyside up! At last somebody understands! Hope your birthday is lovely whenever it is - you deserve it. xx

OP posts:
sunnysideup · 08/03/2007 11:00

Happy birthday Sheila.

I think you're right and obviously your birthday is making you miss the things that you kind of forget you want the rest of the time; it IS nice to have a DH who makes a fuss of you....so I understand where you're coming from.

Maybe you should do what my SIL does; circulates a list of things she wants round the family, then books a table at a restaurant for us all to go out to celebrate her birthday (which of course she would not dream of paying any towards, it's HER DAY after all)........[hmmm]

then there's my bro, who lives abroad for much of the time, forgets birthdays most years, except the time he sent a card saying "I hear that you've gone ahead and had your birthday without telling me. Please be more considerate next year".

Go on, book a meal for you and your bro and SIL and then resolutely do not get your purse out when it comes to paying up. They can afford it seriously though, have a lovely day with your ds and friends, and hopefully the presents from your bro will not seem so important.

Sheila · 08/03/2007 10:41

Hope your db comes through for you bubblerock, and if he doesn't that somebody else does XX

OP posts:
bubblerock · 08/03/2007 10:31

Happy birthday fellow pisceans! It's my birthday tomorrow and I will be very surprised if I even get a card from my brother.

hippmummy · 08/03/2007 10:29

I think if you feel the issue is that he hasn't put any thought into it then tell him how you feel. He would probably be quite upset to know that you feel birthdays are so significant he's let you down.

I remember being really gutted when my DH didn't remember my first Mothers Day. He just didn't see the relevance as DS1 was only a few months old so couldn't 'buy' mummy a present (Men!). After told him I felt let down because it was the gesture that mattered he never forgot again.

If the issue is the amount that he's spent I think you need to let it go and just be thankful that they remembered it was your birthday - we all know money's not everything.

And happy birthday

fireflyfairy2 · 08/03/2007 10:29

You have said he & his wife both work full time. You just have to read on here, how many people find time for nothing as they work full time...... so he may have remembered at the last minute.. I'd be greatful I think

Nockney · 08/03/2007 10:28

We are reasonably well off. But when it comes to shopping for DH's sister, it really is my job. And I don't know her taste that well. I do my best, and I think she was reasonably pleased last year (nice bracelet from a trip - silver etc), but I know she doesn't expect much from us and knows we are disorganised and rubbish.

amidaiwish · 08/03/2007 10:28

and it's not because he doesn't care for them, he is just totally maxed with work and can't remember what day of the week it is, never mind that it is x or y's birthday next week! he does usually phone them on their birthday though... card usually follows!

amidaiwish · 08/03/2007 10:27

my dh is relatively "rich" compared to his siblings.
most of them always buy decent/thoughtful pressies. dh is useless and i refuse to end up buying lots of pressies for his family (well except his mum) as i have a big enough family of my own to remember.

anyway, they have cottoned on and just say to him "oh, some cash would be great so i can buy something special for me"... he is thrilled - just bungs some £ in a card.

a bit materialistic/unthoughtful imo but seems to work well all round!

wannaBeWhateverIWannaBe · 08/03/2007 10:23

"the contrast between what he could afford to spend and what he actually does spend". What a materialistic view. Maybe if you learned to show some gratitude you'd realize that it's not actually the cost of the present but the thought that counts.

I had no card or present from my sister on my birthday, I had a card but no present from my mum, but so what, it's only a birthday and it really isn't that big a deal.

if you were my sister I probably wouldn't buy you anything at all.

Sheila · 08/03/2007 10:21

Thanks for birthday wishes. I'm going to leave work early and take DS out for cake, then out tonight for a drink with a couple of friends, so it could be worse.

My sympathies to those of you who get nothing at all from your siblings - I hope you have somebody who does take some trouble.

Happy birthday to you Twinset! What are you doing today?

OP posts:
wotzsaname · 08/03/2007 10:17

It is probably left for his wife to buy and organise. Men aren't the great at this stuff.

I have to buy my DHs mums and dads stuff, else they wouldn't get anything.

I normally buy my own Mothers Day flowers and homemade get cards from my DDs (which are the best kind).

If you don't get him anything for his Birthday he probably wouldn't even notice. Not because he has lots, but because, men aren't as sentimental over trinkets.

What did you expect (£££) for them to spend on you? Not the same as a DH/DP would spend on you.

Hope you have a nice Birthday. Cheer up.

brimfull · 08/03/2007 10:17

happy birthday sheila-you sound really down.
Why not go and treat yourself today,meet up with a friend and do something nice.

Sheila · 08/03/2007 10:14

I guess what bugs me about it is the complete lack of thought on his behalf, the contrast between what he could afford to spend and what he actually does spend (why are those with the most money often the most mean, incidentally?), and (the bit that isn't his fault) that no-one else is making a fuss of me either. I'm sure it wouldn't bother me half as much if I had a DP/DH who was showering me with gifts.

I guess birthdays are a bit like Xmas - they show up the holes in your life.

OP posts:
nathaliea · 08/03/2007 10:13

it depends. did your brother buy a present for 10 pounds that had a meaning? because that should lift your spirits more than the worth of the gift would.

hippmummy · 08/03/2007 10:13

I think you are expecting too much - especially from a man tbh! I know he's your brother, and you buy him presents, but women do generally tend to think things like birthdays are more important than men do.
My DH is useless and if I didn't remember birthdays for his family members they would get nothing!
At least you got something, even if it was via your SIL.

ScottishThistle · 08/03/2007 10:13

Happy Birthday!

If it makes you feel any better, my Brother didn't even give me a card last year & I always buy him lovely gifts...Men, get used to it!

fireflyfairy2 · 08/03/2007 10:12

Only one of my bro's ever buy to me for my b'day & that is because I buy to him, as our b'day is in the same month. Last yr I bought him an expensive aftershave, he bought me a £4.50 CD holder & some perfume. The cost never came into it for me really, I know his fave aftershave, he knows my fave perfume.... that's all there was to it

Happy Birthday

tissy · 08/03/2007 10:11

Yes you are being unreasonable. My siblings and I don't buy each other birthday presents; we have enough on our plates trying to remember the birthdays of all our children, let alone their parents as well.

As they both work full-time, you're lucky to get a card, let alone a present, and I would consider a £10 bracelet generous, not cheap as chips.

twinsetandpearls · 08/03/2007 10:11

It is my birthday today and no presents from my sisters.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.