Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(Following on from yesterday's party food thread) to be irritated by this?

116 replies

KTeePee · 07/03/2007 12:14

Our school discos are on soon and one mother has put a note at the botom of the ticket order form expressing concern that we are selling sweets at this event even though it is during Lent.....

I know it is a church school but I'm a bit about it - surely if she doesn't want her darlings to partake she can just send them without any pocket money?

OP posts:
twinsetandpearls · 07/03/2007 20:02

for my five yearold giving up sweets is a sacrifice she undertands.I team up make a sacrifice with prayers at night and trying to do something positive as well.

ChippyMinton · 07/03/2007 20:02

In the first week of Lent I was busy pushing sweeties and fruit shoots at a church/school family social. Agree with aitch about personal denial/choice of what to give up The sales fund the socials BTW, so no sweeties=no funds.

twinsetandpearls · 07/03/2007 20:00

I think if it is a church school she is within her rights to complain, I would do the same TBH although I am certain we would not have a disco during lent and there certainly owuld not be sweets at it.

AitchTwoOh · 07/03/2007 19:57

is that to the OP or me, dimpled?

DimpledThighs · 07/03/2007 19:40

FFS!

AitchTwoOh · 07/03/2007 19:33

helenhismadwife, it's definitely not a question of disresepcting her religious convictions, just that by insisting there are no sweets at the disco it rather misses the point of facing the personal challenge of her children denying themselves sweeties. other children at that disco may have given up cbeebies, may have promised to set the table every night, to do their homework before dinner or are going to mass every morning for lent - they deserve a good blow-out on sweeties if that's what they want. there are plenty of things a child could do to observe lent, ditching sweeties is merely the least imaginative of them.

mummydoc · 07/03/2007 16:28

my dd1 asked if she could give up her little sister for lent ....i think she hs missed hte point really, wonder if hte children in the op would like to give up their mother...

Anchovy · 07/03/2007 16:16

upbrings = upbringing, obv.

Anchovy · 07/03/2007 16:15

I had an uber-strict Catholic upbrings. Deffo no sweets during Lent and then a nice big blow out on Easter Day .

Think it laid the foundations for the concept of binge drinking actually, but there you go.

FWIW, she is doctrinally wrong, because what you are doing is mortifying your own flesh - it is supposed to be very personal and introspective. If someone is offering sweets to you, for example, (or honey or locusts or standing you on the pinnacle of the mountain and showing you the whole world, just as random examples) then you are doing well by specifically turning them down. I would therefore say you are offering little Bernadette and Aloysius a very good test of their resolve.

kslatts · 07/03/2007 16:01

I hate the way people critise the efforts of the PTA but are not prepared to give up any of their time to help organise events.

helenhismadwife · 07/03/2007 15:58

I think you are being a bit hard on her to be honest, she is obviously has a strong religious belief and sends her children to a church school hoping that they are going to be mixing with like minded children and families,and to gain a good understanding of their faith and you are all taking the mickey out of her belief but sending your child to a church school.

Children cant really give up much else during lent can they? so maybe she has a point, my willpower is not great so I wouldnt expect a childs to be good

Before you all jump on me Im not religious but I do have a strong respect for other peoples faiths and beliefs

yeahinaminute · 07/03/2007 15:53

Lent is 40 day's and nights including Sunday's and ends on Palm Sunday which is when Holy Week starts !!

My Lenten alcoholic fasting however is being extended to Easter Sunday as I am buggered if I'm staying on the waggon while I'm in Paris next week !!

chipmonkey · 07/03/2007 15:39

We always had a reprieve on Paddy's day.

EmilyDavidson · 07/03/2007 15:08

She has a very shaky understanding of Lent if she thinks it should mean that she has the right to deprive, not only her own, but other peoples children of sweets.

Perhaps next year she should give up being a controlling misery guts

gobshite · 07/03/2007 14:55

My DP was very brave during his hormonal teenage years, when he dared to date a girl called Concepta ...

AitchTwoOh · 07/03/2007 14:13

i've just realised how to pronounce your name, st leger... had been thinking it was some weird german sounding name for a while.

stleger · 07/03/2007 14:10

I heard a lovely story a couple of years ago about a family in the 1960s who were given a big Toblerone from an airport. It sat on top of a cupboard all through Lent - on Easter morning it was empty as the mum had eaten it! I'm fairly sure her need was great....

Lovecat · 07/03/2007 13:56

We went down the stleger route - we were allowed to buy sweets or have them bought for us (our mum's bribe for being good in church, which I'm ashamed to say I'm using on my toddler atm) during Lent, but they were then stashed away in a big biscuit tin until Easter Sunday - oh God yes, the multicoloured vomit thereafter...

On the names front, at our school we had a Benedict, a Malachai and twin girls called Mary and Josephine....

potoroo · 07/03/2007 13:25

Actually, not only did we have to give up sweets, but as an added bonus we would have to donate the money we would have spent on sweets to charity.

KTeePee · 07/03/2007 13:21

stressteddy, if you count it up, Lent actually lasts for more than 40 days, it is only 40 excluding the Sundays I think.

Very good point Miaou, may use it if I have to actually speak to the woman (mental note to self, do not get into conversation with her or will say things I will regret later...)

OP posts:
stressteddy · 07/03/2007 13:17

Great point Miaou. Although I have it on good authority that some people think they can still indulge in whatever they have given up for lent on each Sunday in lent. I always thought that lent was the whole 40 days? Maybe the disco could be on a Sunday

KTeePee · 07/03/2007 13:15

Pussinwellies, you got one of the names right - she does only have two children so I would have a small bet that they don't quite follow the Vatican line on everything

OP posts:
Miaou · 07/03/2007 13:15

Isn't the whole point of giving something up for Lent (if that's what lights your candle) that you resist temptation? If there are no sweets there then what is there to resist?

AitchTwoOh · 07/03/2007 13:12

aloysius. sounds like they've got a wee bit of a jesuit thing going on.

PussinWellies · 07/03/2007 13:05

Ooh, ooh, what are they called?? Best ones we know are Ignatius, Benedict and Augustine -- we were laying bets on what the fourth one would be (Dominic? Clare? StJohn?)