Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(Following on from yesterday's party food thread) to be irritated by this?

116 replies

KTeePee · 07/03/2007 12:14

Our school discos are on soon and one mother has put a note at the botom of the ticket order form expressing concern that we are selling sweets at this event even though it is during Lent.....

I know it is a church school but I'm a bit about it - surely if she doesn't want her darlings to partake she can just send them without any pocket money?

OP posts:
Elasticwoman · 09/03/2007 21:05

Is that Catechism current, Twinset? When was it published?

twinsetandpearls · 09/03/2007 21:02

taken from the penny catechism

  1. What are the Friday forms of Penance?

On Fridays other than Solemnities we are to abstain from meat or some other food, drink or amusement or undertake one of the other works of penance stipulated by the Bishops' Conference. (Abstinence is binding from the age of 14).

twinsetandpearls · 09/03/2007 20:53

I think and I may be wrong that the ban on eating meat on friday was lifted and instead we are encouraged to give something up and donate the money that we would have spent to the poor.

crunchie · 09/03/2007 20:13

all I can say is that my kids have been told to say
'oh no, we are jewish, we don't give up ANYTHING for lent' VVloudly if they get asked

I am trying to get hem to convert ther little frinds by telling them jewish holidays are all about food and chocolate and at Chanukkah they get 8 days of pressents

Elasticwoman · 09/03/2007 19:47

Are you SURE meat was ok'd for Good Friday in Vatican II? I seem to remember that in the 60s meat was allowed on ordinary Fridays (a new development then as most adults could remember the no-meat Fridays of previous years) but Good Friday was still a fasting day. You didn't have to eat fish, just had to abstain from meat.

I'm sure there is an interesting debate to be had about the difference between belief, superstition and even tradition. But you certainly gave Madamez what for, Aitch.

stleger · 09/03/2007 10:00

Cork is the home of the famous Connie dodger, named after a strict bishop. It was some kind of glorified bread with cake overtones (I am thinking toasted teacake), which was bready enough to satisfy some complex rule. I sometimes feel the spirit of Lent has been lacking for quite a while.

AitchYouBerk · 09/03/2007 09:17

the infamous and distinctly marvellous Great White Arse, of course...

madamez · 08/03/2007 21:56

Aitch, just satisfy my curiosity and then I'll depart from this thread... what on earth is a GWA????

gobshite · 08/03/2007 12:13

Crisps are only OK if you're Irish, StLeger, eaten solemnly in memory of the famine dead.

We had complicated rules as kids, all self-imposed, whereby sweets were out, but biscuits were OK, with much debate about what a kit-kat was ....

stleger · 08/03/2007 11:28

My inlaws only eat fish on Good Friday and whine non stop. I'm vegetarian as well as Protestant and would like to slap them. FIL will happily eat fish at other times, Friday or not. We do have a fresh fish van selling in our town on Friday, so it seems to be still done here (Cork), as a tradition at least.

amidaiwish · 08/03/2007 10:46

what you can eat meat on Good Friday?
since when?
wait til i tell my mum

twinsetandpearls · 08/03/2007 10:08

There is no church law that says,

thou shalt not eat sweets over Lent but crisps are OK!

It is a personal choice whatyou give up if anything, most priests now tend to focus on doing something positive TBH. As I ahve said repeatedly on this thread the giving up sweets is a very small part of lent that other people are focussing on as they are choosing to see religious people as making their children's lives grim.

twinsetandpearls · 08/03/2007 10:06

You can eat a suasgae on good friday and could ever since vatican II which is almost half a century ago!

Many catholics choose to keep Fridays for fish just out of tradition, as we do here. It is on no way a hardship but a tradition thatwe enjoy, makes Fridays special.

stleger · 08/03/2007 10:01

I can't see why the school doesn't sell crisps instead? Or indeed why you 'can' eat crisps in Lent but not sweets. Or fish on Good Friday but not a sausage which contains very little meat. But I'm not Catholic, only Irish.

twinsetandpearls · 08/03/2007 09:52

madamez as I said we do emphasize the positive much mroe than the giving up sweets - which as dd only has sweets on a Friday anyway is hardly making her live a life of misery.

I think it is because you want to see me as making my child's life a misery that you arefocussing on the no sweets bit.

AitchTwoOh · 08/03/2007 01:21

in my head she's the owner of the GWA, pann. it's just something about the name...

themanfromiPannema · 08/03/2007 01:08

ditto aitch.

madamez simply wishes to make a name for herslf, one that is already well-established.

AitchTwoOh · 08/03/2007 01:03

by the way madamez, i do think your use of the word superstition is pretty rude. and i think you knew that when you wrote it.

AitchTwoOh · 08/03/2007 01:01

sorry, my keyboard is all wonky... you'll have to decipher that last post.

AitchTwoOh · 08/03/2007 01:00

well, as i way if you are off sweets with all your pals there is a perverse sort of a pleasure in it. (nothign to do with religion, io, everything to do with being the biggest sook with teh teacher etc etc). the things i most remember doing were things like your usual chores but without whinging about it , going to mass with the whole family before school, getting homework completed before teatime etc etc. bear in mind that this was thirty years ago.

i'm kind of surprised that people still go in for it, but then i'm also surprised that children eat sweeties at school (they're pretty much banned by popular parental consent from my local school) so what do i know?

madamez · 07/03/2007 23:43

I don't see why anyone would inflict this crap on children in the first place, but can you not, if you must make them pay attention to superstituon, emphasise the positive and get them to make resolutions to do nice things such as helping round the house, raising money for charities, etc? Rather than enforcing some sort of irrational misery time on them, which is going to be difficult for them to understand and simply make them resentful ("well dear, we're having no fun today and hitting ourselves with sticks because of other people's sins" - but mummy, you said it's not fair to blame other people for my mistakes, why should I suffer for theirs?), why not just encourage them to enjoy life?

AitchTwoOh · 07/03/2007 22:40

okay, so you and i aren't going to agree. i think that you shouldn't set children up to fail, and during lent they will be faced with sweeties at the school tuck shop etc so if that's too hard for them then another abstinence should be chosen. if it's not too hard, and if the school has (weirdly, imo) decided to hold a disco during lent then one or more children cannot expect the festivities to be made less pleasant in order not to tempt them. i was five once, i loved sweeties and yet i didn't find it too difficult. lord knows i probably slipped off the wagon a couple of times, but if i was the type of child who would be heartbroken over such a thing then i think it would be irresponsible of my parents to encourage me to do it in the first place.

twinsetandpearls · 07/03/2007 22:00

But I would be suprised if it only affects one child.

AitchTwoOh · 07/03/2007 21:59

i do agree with you about the timing, but i think that one child simply doesn't have the right to dictate how an entire school disco is run. especially as the tuck money presumably is part of the fundraising. (which is just another reason why the timing is )

twinsetandpearls · 07/03/2007 21:55

But to be honest my dd would probably give in to tempatation as she is little and loves sweets and that is why we are supporting her rather than trying to trip her up.

Swipe left for the next trending thread