Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

in thinking that instead of going into rehab some of these .................

38 replies

2shoes · 07/03/2007 09:09

"celebs" could try spending time with their dc's.
I mean if Britany spent some time with hers. I bet they would get her feeling better in no time. Same with Jade,
Or is that too easy?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheNightTroll · 07/09/2023 00:14

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

zippitippitoes · 08/03/2007 09:38

no one can look on and decide whether someone has any kind of mental health problems

I'm astonished that people can say of anyone let alone someone they don't know they are not depressed

Lovecat · 08/03/2007 09:21

I agree completely, BM, but in the case of Ms. Goody, I don't believe she is depressed. Desperately trying to claw back whatever remains of her pathetic 'career', yes. Depressed? Not a bit.

As I posted earlier, I feel deeply sorry for Britney Spears and hope she can find the help she seems to be needing.

BassMama · 08/03/2007 01:58

I am actually almost reduced to tears reading that people think things like this about other people, celebrity or not.

When you are depressed, it is very easy to become addicted to drugs and alcohol. This then fuels your depression, so you take more drugs or drink more to feel better.. and it is a horrible, vicious circle.

To say that spending time with your children is some kind of 'cure' for depression is horrid.
To suggest that not wanting to spend time with your shildren when you are in the pit of depression is disgusting, totally ignorant and very very upsetting.
The reality is, that when in this situation, you do not want to do anything. You do not want to spend time with yourself.

To say that severely depressed people should spend time with their children rather than go to rehab is a totally unaducated thing to suggest.

Rehab is a end-of-the-line decision for any person - celebrity or not, and can totally change peoples lives.

Surely it is better that a mother takes 2 or 3 montsh out of their life to go to rehab and get well, rather than years and years with her children around, continuing to be depressed?

nightowl · 07/03/2007 17:17

its hard enough to drag yourself out of depression..and thats when the world arent talking about you and putting you down. celebs like britney dont stand a chance really.

duchesse · 07/03/2007 17:01

Anybody who has suffered post natal depression and even people who haven't will recognise the signs in Britney Spears. Spending time with her children will not improve that.

I try to ignore the other person mentioned as much as possible, so have no comment to make about her.

MrsSpoon · 07/03/2007 16:58

I read somewhere that Robbie's latest breakdown is over an ex-girlfriend who did a 'kiss and tell' interview and revealed some private stuff about him that proved he was 'screwed up', apparently he twitches in his sleep, no wonder after 36 espressos, surprised he can sleep!

zippitippitoes · 07/03/2007 16:53

is this a major difference between men and women then?

if women can snog and not be gay why can't men?

nightowl · 07/03/2007 16:52

dont know about jade but i actually feel sorry for britney.

her husband was an absolute shit to her.

everyone begged her to leave him for years.

she eventually did, she fell apart and now the vultures rip her to shreds.

he wants custody and funnily enough there are no stories about him at present.

people have short memories.

raz30 · 07/03/2007 16:51

no way, blokes do not snog each other unless they are gay

zippitippitoes · 07/03/2007 16:29

according to mn it is common for women friends to snog each pother does the same not apply to blokes?

does it matter? except to his bank balance?

raz30 · 07/03/2007 16:19

i saw him snogging another bloke in a club about 10 years ago

wannaBeWhateverIWannaBe · 07/03/2007 16:15

robby hasn't come out so it's only speculation and opinion that says he's gay.

he might be, he might not be, but what does it really matter anyway.

zippitippitoes · 07/03/2007 16:12

if a celeb is not in the news they aren't making money so regard all this magazine drivel as their job and the perspective changes

Tortington · 07/03/2007 16:11

you cant possible tell how much time a celeb spends with their children and compare their lifestyle to ours.
i dont see my kids every day from 8 am to 5.30 - 6 om - sometimes if i have an evening meeting i dont see them at all that day.

i bet britney sees her kids a damn sight more than that - with ebbs and flows of promoting.

IMO Jade went into rehab as some kind of whitewash for her behaviour in the BB house. hoping her sins with be forgiven.

Brittneyis clearly fucked up. she needs a reallity check and some new friends.

Lovecat · 07/03/2007 16:06

Plenty of gay men shag women in an attempt to prove to themselves that they're not like 'that'.

Means nothing. Sorry...

superloopy · 07/03/2007 16:05

Robbie can't be gay!!

My DH worked with a girl who shagged him!!

Bi maybe but not gay!!

superloopy · 07/03/2007 16:04

Poor Britney!! I think that she should just get her kids and come and stay with me for awhile.

She can get real, help with the cleaning, washing, cooking etc and play with the kids. I'm sure we could be great mates too.

She probably does have PND and a marriage break up hasn't helped, but getting back to basics and cutting out the 'Hollywood bullshit' would help.

She only has to call me...

helenhismadwife · 07/03/2007 14:59

its difficult for celebs though, I wouldnt want to be one, I saw a picture recently of the beckhams but it was one showing the amount of photographs trying to get pictures of them, I am sure that it is the same for other celebs as well, so perhaps the only place they can genuinely get any peace and quiet and not risk having their pictures or someone trying to take pictures or interview them is in rehab.

Pictures of them doing ordinary family things are not really newsworthy so we either dont see them or they are not taken there is no story in them. I think if someone followed me around all day they could probably get loads of pictures of me without my dd's seemingly doing odd stuff and I am with my daughters 95% of the time

ROBBIE cant be gayyyyyyyyyy

zippitippitoes · 07/03/2007 13:10

of course I don't know much about them because I don't read anything about them

just think they must proportionately suffer the same as other people..in fact more because certain personality traits common to those who seek celbrity are also common in certain kinds of illnesses what drives them to fame also drives them to need psychiatric help

ELF1981 · 07/03/2007 13:04

I think that certain people rub their hands in glee as celebs go off the tracks, wondering how they can turn it to their advantage / how far they can push it, rather than somebody sitting them down and talking to them.
Take Britney for eg. I bet there is somebody there suggesting that they can spin it in a particular way. I do hope she sorts herself out esp for her kids sake.
As for Jade - well. Not seeing her kids as her head was not in the right place - she agreed to go on the show, she said those words, she created the situation, and in my opinion, it is not a valid excuse not to see her kids. They went without her while she was on the show and she should have made a better effort.

zippitippitoes · 07/03/2007 12:55

rehab just sounds more jet set than psychiatric hospital it is the same thing really

these celebs do have mental health problems just like anyone else

I think robbie has manic depression

wannaBeWhateverIWannaBe · 07/03/2007 12:53

also a two week holiday isn't going to give them the real break they need is it? it'll only give the trashy mags something else to publish, only this time the kids will be part of it as well. at least by going into rehab these people are sparing their kids having to be photographed by the media as they chase the parents down in search of their next big story.

IMO the public have a greater part to play in all this than we perhaps would admit. if people didn't buy the trashy celeb mags, there wouldn't be a market for them, and the celebs wouldn't have the need to do one outragious thing after another to gain publicity.

wannaBeWhateverIWannaBe · 07/03/2007 12:50

it's so easy to judge though isn't it?

How many mothers work full time and don't see their kids say, from 8-6 monday to Friday, and yet they do consider that they spend enough time with them in between.

The magazines are going to print the celeb jetting off to this and that party and being seen in this and that club, but how big a part of their life is that really? The rest hardly makes good selling does it which is why we only get to see the "exciting" bits.

As for rehab, I think that the kind of lifestyle you lead if you're a celebrity means you are more likely to become involved with alcohol/drugs and are perhaps more likely to suffer from depression as it's not really a normal life is it.

stressteddy · 07/03/2007 12:43

An another thing...it's so easy to do all of this adopting abroad if you know they are going to be looked after by nannies back at home