Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Keeping child in at lunchtime for failure to complete work

166 replies

Elizabeth1970 · 25/03/2017 08:04

Is this reasonable that my child's school have decided to keep her inside at lunchtime if she has not completed her work, she is in yr 1.
She struggles with writing so takes a long time even at home with no distractions ( only child ) to complete a writing task so I feel it's very unfair she is banned from going out after lunch, instead being sent back to class to continue the writing task.
Break times are unaffected so she has 15 minutes at 10am and another 15 at 2pm but this is all most days now.

OP posts:
Increasinglymiddleaged · 25/03/2017 09:07

As with all of these threads you need to speak to the teacher rather than posting about it on MN.

If it had been my DD in Y1 I wouldn't have had an issue with it, I'd have assumed she wasn't concentrating/ messing around when she was meant to be working. But if you think she's being punished for struggling at writing then that obviously isn't fair. But you won't find out which it is by posting about it on here.

Trifleorbust · 25/03/2017 08:49

The teacher will not want to keep a well- behaved child back as a punishment. Therefore, it stands to reason that this is either meant supportively, or your child is poorly behaved, or the teacher is under pressure from elsewhere.

Thoughts?

MummyMuppet2x2 · 25/03/2017 08:45

This is one of my pet peeves.
My two have occasionally been kept in during their lunch/break since at least Y1. Most of their teachers have been absolutely lovely regarding everything else, so I've never mentioned it, but seriously, Y1 detention - for not completing work!? It's one thing if they've been messing about, but if they've tried their best they should not be missing breaktime.

tireddotcom72 · 25/03/2017 08:43

I have taught Year 1 for a long time. If I child hadn't finished their work because they were messing about, talking or refusing to work ( it happens) I would make them come back at lunchtime finish their work and then go out to play usually they finish the work very quickly when they know it's playtime they are missing out on. Generally after a couple of times if that they learn it's much better to get the work done during lesson time not their time. I had one repeat offender spoke to his mum and she was happy to take the work home and make him finish it there. Speak to the teacher if she is being kept in repeatedly but by this point in year 1 the expectations of work are getting higher as they need to be ready for year 2 and sats.

muckypup73 · 25/03/2017 08:31

I know a few sen children that lose their lunchtimes because they have not completed their work.

ShitIForgotToUntick · 25/03/2017 08:29

I think that's unacceptable at that age. Our school do this from P4 but they're usually kept in at breaktime instead of lunchtime. They offer a lunchtime homework club as well. But tbh it happens so infrequently i can't get worked up about it, think DS has been kept in twice all term, he also has issues with slower writing as he finds cursive writing tricky being left handed, particularly as all their work sheets are designed for right handed people Hmm. I've always said i don't mind them being kept in if they've been mucking around and failed to complete their work. OTOH if it's due to poor time management then I'd have an issue with it. In your situation OP I'd be speaking to the teacher as i think 5 is far too young for this sort of thing.

SuburbanRhonda · 25/03/2017 08:28

There's not enough information here to know whether the teacher was right or not.

Why not go in and talk to him/her and then you can discuss whether your child needs extra support in class.

Good luck with asking for 1:1 though Smile

Postagestamppat · 25/03/2017 08:27

Has your daughter told you this or the teacher? It sounds to me like it probably happened once or twice and she has exaggerated it. I can understand the teacher doing it if she was not working as she should have been during lesson. It is a tactic I have used many times. If time is not being used constructively in the lesson and there is a very clear expectation that a certain bit of work should be done, then any student that has not done that work will be kept in until it is done (although in all fairness I teach secondary and not year 1!). That sounds like the most reasonable explanation. Also, who is your daughter sitting with in class? Would that affect her concentration? You have to speak to the teacher to get to the root of it.

MaisyPops · 25/03/2017 08:27

Bit much in y1 but maybe it was so the teacher can give a bit if extra help.

By the time they get to us at y7+ yeah, dont get the work done, catch it up in your own time e.g. break lunch or home.

WateryTart · 25/03/2017 08:25

I used to give up my lunchtime to help children struggling with their work and to make sure I heard all the children read.

Maybe that's what's happening, not a punishment but extra support.

BewtySkoolDropowt · 25/03/2017 08:25

I think it's entirety reasonable to offer a child additional support during lunchtimes to work on tasks that are as important as writing.

Bear in mind that the teacher will be giving up their lunchtimes to help her too.

MickeyRooney · 25/03/2017 08:24

How much of the work has she completed by the end of class?

RhubarbGin · 25/03/2017 08:23

Depends on the circumstances. My ds2 is now y4 and has fine motor issues and all the difficulties mentioned above by Mars, plus a stubborn steak a mile wide. He gets kept in with my entire support when he flatly refuses to put pen to paper. However when he's tried his best despite all his difficulties but hasn't managed to complete much if anything then he's allowed out, which is as it should be.

GraceGrape · 25/03/2017 08:22

Are you sure they keep her for the whole lunch time, not just a few minutes?

MarsInScorpio · 25/03/2017 08:19

Are you sure it isn't deliberate?

What do you mean by 'struggles'? Attention, motor, letter formation, structure, attitude...

If the teacher feels she could and should do better but isn't because she's decided to underperform then this could be fair. 1-2-1 help can be very valuable. Have you discussed this with the school? What did they say?

PopCakes · 25/03/2017 08:12

YANBU I wouldn't accept this at all. There's a lot of evidence that our kids don't get enough play time and time outside as it is there is absolutely no way I'd allow her to be punished with lack of play time because she isn't a quick writer. It negatively affects concentration, behaviour and mental health to deprive kids of playtime. That aside it's ridiculous and unfair to punish her for something that isn't deliberate.