Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Keeping child in at lunchtime for failure to complete work

166 replies

Elizabeth1970 · 25/03/2017 08:04

Is this reasonable that my child's school have decided to keep her inside at lunchtime if she has not completed her work, she is in yr 1.
She struggles with writing so takes a long time even at home with no distractions ( only child ) to complete a writing task so I feel it's very unfair she is banned from going out after lunch, instead being sent back to class to continue the writing task.
Break times are unaffected so she has 15 minutes at 10am and another 15 at 2pm but this is all most days now.

OP posts:
YouTheCat · 25/03/2017 15:59

Granny, I know plenty of people who don't have a lunch break in order to keep on top of their work.

If the OP's child didn't get a reasonable amount of work done, and there are no additional needs, then she needs to learn to stop messing about and chatting. Low level disruption is the bane of teachers' lives.

I very occasionally keep disruptive year 1s in at break if they mess about in my phonics class. It does not happen often.

MaisyPops · 25/03/2017 15:42

grannytomine
I know. Thats why i said its a bit young for me as a punnishment (because they may totally miss the point e.g. rush work so it looks more to go for play) but if its that the teacher wants to go through it to help them out so ita support rather than a punnishment i can see it being ok. One lunch isnt the end of the world (and i cant imagine it being easy for a ks1 teacher to set a class off so theu can give 1-1 support in class).

grannytomine · 25/03/2017 15:36

MaisyPops but she .5 or 6, you will be teaching 11 or 12 to 18? It is a big difference. Some 5 year olds aren't as mature as others.

Trifleorburst, and yet someone said, When she gets older, she cant just leave her work because its lunch time so which is it? Do adults get kept in at lunchtime to finish their work (never happened anywhere I worked) or is it one rule for 5 year olds and another for adults?

MaisyPops · 25/03/2017 14:45

Elizabeth1970
Shes had her lunch and went back to class then its fair do.
Personally i think 5 is a bit young for her to understand it as a punishment (e.g. sit there in sikence and do it) but if the teacher needed to give a little bit of extra support to get it done then id probably be ok with it.

MaisyPops · 25/03/2017 14:41

grannytomine
It depends.
Say i have a child with extra needs and we're doing a really tricky topic, theyve worked well but dont get through everything then theres no way on this earth id be keeping them in. Thats not fair.
Or, a student has worked well but just fallen a bit under what id normally expect, id ask them subtly if i need to recap anything and theyd go for lunch.
Or a student has struggled with a task but theyve used all the strategies to move forward then theyd not get kept back

But say i set an extended writing task that i know is within the ability of the kids and someone stares out the window instead, yes theyre being kept in.
Or if someone has been talking instead of working then yes theyre being kept in.
Or if theyre simply coasting along and then 10 mins before the end rush some substabdard work, theyll redo it.
Or, theyve been lazy and think saying "i dont get it" just before the end will excuse poor attitude to learning, theyre back at lunch

Im secondary though (Im ready for the 'but what if they didnt understand?' chorus. Teenagers can be absolute pros at trying to get out of things based on their mood, subject, weather etc. One student has recently started not writing the date/title because "i didnt know what was the date/title". Its on the same board where it always is- and has been for the 3 years theyve had me!)

Trifleorbust · 25/03/2017 14:40

grannytomine:

I am not a child. I don't wear uniform or put hand up before I speak either Hmm Different rules.

Saying that, it depends why this is happening, whether it is fair or not.

Elizabeth1970 · 25/03/2017 14:37

So sorry I didn't mean they didn't feed her, she went back to class after eating instead of out to play

OP posts:
grannytomine · 25/03/2017 14:20

To teachers saying this is right, if you don't get through everything you intended to do in a lesson do you get kept in? Or you know do you accept that some days you can achieve more than others?

armpitz · 25/03/2017 14:14

YANBU

I started a thread about this the other day. I just don't feel detentions are particularly effective, but because they are the only tool teachers have they get overused.

At five, though Shock how awful!

MaisyPops · 25/03/2017 14:11

So the office have said that they can categorically say it was 100% all of lunch and that the child was denied a chance to eat their food?

Only ask because office staff in my school are always busy and simply would not have time to supervise and keep an eye on a classroom. Or did they say 'yeah DC was in at lunch with the teacher'. Just saying they are very different things.

I have yet to meet a teacher who has kept a child all lunch and/or refused to allow them to eat.
Ive had/heard many a complaint, of varying 'you cant do this' levels, claiming it has happened though (despite all evidence that the child was out and about for more than half of lunch).
other common one is 'you made my child miss his bus and i had to collect them blah blah blah. No i spoke to them after the lesson and the busses leave 10 minutes after the final bell so students can collect things from their locker/speak to staff. If theyve dawdled then its really not my problem.

harleysmammy · 25/03/2017 13:37

They are not allowed to keep them the whole lunch time. Its illegal to keep them from eating, they have to allow 10 minutes of a half hour lunch and 15 minutes of a 45 minute lunch. Im a teacher in year 2. If she didnt complete her work then yes she should have to complete it but if she struggles, she should be getting help. When she gets older, she cant just leave her work because its lunch time.

Elizabeth1970 · 25/03/2017 13:34

It was 100% the whole break, I did phone and the school office confirmed this, they must have seen the teacher with her or something

OP posts:
Trifleorbust · 25/03/2017 13:18

Only had parents evening a fortnight ago and nothing mentioned regarding needing extra support or anything so I would be surprised if that's the reason behind it
More likely that she just takes longer than others to complete a writing task therefore had to stay in
Even if she were just chatting away to a friend and that's what delayed her I wouldn't be happy that a 5 year old loses her entire lunch break because of it!

But she has to learn not to do this when she meant to be working. She won't be 5 for long .

TheRealPooTroll · 25/03/2017 11:28

If she's chatting then I see no issue with her having to stay in and do it at break time. Basically she is being offered the choice to do her work at work time or playtime and she's choosing playtime. If the teacher allowed her to chat instead she'd never learn anything.
One of my dc struggles with writing an the teacher will sometimes gives him a more manageable amount of writing to do than the rest of the class. If he was choosing to mess around though she'd have my full support to keep him in to finish off. I doubt any teacher would penalise a child who was working hard and trying their best - even if their progress was slow.

MaisyPops · 25/03/2017 11:18

ShowMePotatoSalad
I also wondered this. Weve had complaints (although secondary) from parents saying their DC hasnt had any lunch because theyve apparently lost all their lunch break.
The reality is they were kept back 10mins and decided to chill with friends rather than get lunch.

ShowMePotatoSalad · 25/03/2017 10:51

I highly doubt your daughter lost her entire lunch break. Have you phoned the school to ask what has happened?

ShoeEatingMonster · 25/03/2017 10:48

I'm a teacher. I fully support making children complete work at break/lunch IF they haven't worked their hardest or been messing around. Obviously if the child simply hasn't completed as much as everyone else because of their ability they shouldn't be kept in. If they haven't completed as much as they are able to for whatever reason then yes they should make up the time.

Teachers do know their pupils you know. We know what they can and can't do and what to expect of them.

Elizabeth1970 · 25/03/2017 10:43

Only had parents evening a fortnight ago and nothing mentioned regarding needing extra support or anything so I would be surprised if that's the reason behind it
More likely that she just takes longer than others to complete a writing task therefore had to stay in
Even if she were just chatting away to a friend and that's what delayed her I wouldn't be happy that a 5 year old loses her entire lunch break because of it!
We do lots of writing and her formation is very good, but it takes her longer than her peers

OP posts:
MrsTwix · 25/03/2017 10:35

The teacher might be trying to help them. Ask the teacher.

harshbuttrue1980 · 25/03/2017 10:09

As some others have said, it depends. Child trying their best but struggling? No, they shouldn't be given a punishment. Child pissing about (and, yes, it does happen even in Y1!)? Yes, fine to punish them.

grannytomine · 25/03/2017 09:58

So a 5 or 6 year old? No I don't think it is reasonable. I think it is a great way to turn them off learning if it's all about punishment and missing out on playtime. If it's a one off or even twice then fair enough but if the child still isn't finishing their work then that strategy isn't working.

sherazade · 25/03/2017 09:51

As a teacher , I don't think it's acceptable for any primary school child of any age to be kept in for any length of time during break or lunch, regardless of how many breaks they've had or will have later . Children in this country already have very limited free play play outside and fresh air, which actually does wonders for their brains .

MarsInScorpio · 25/03/2017 09:47

The amount of mandatory work/writing set in Years 1 and 2 is IME geared towards the slower dc. Those more advanced at maths/quicker at writing then get asked to expand or do additional work if they finish early.

Yes and no. Tasks are adapted or differentiated to meet every child's needs. It isn't necessarily a base task + extension work. In our current Year 1 cohort, there's a boy who'll bash out 3 A4 pages of cursive writing in the same time another child will write 4 sentences which only a teacher or parent who knows them could decipher (she doesn't have SEN). This kind of range isn't unusual. Setting a single task to meet both their needs would be pointless. Teachers may look at a single objective or task but right from the outset, different children will be asked to do different things.

There isn't really any such thing as mandatory work unless it's for assessment and these are rare.

PeridotPeridot · 25/03/2017 09:16

Depends on the reasons she struggles. If it's genuinely because of aptitude and she's trying her hardest but just a bit slower...or if there are SEN...then I would be unhappy.

However ds2 is in Year 2 so similarly aged and has been kept in a couple of times. But he has no SEN and is perfectly able to keep up and only doesn't finish if he's messed around or chatted too much...the twice he's been kept in it's been both him and the same two other boys as they've all chatted together and not focused. That's fair enough, they know the consequences.

The amount of mandatory work/writing set in Years 1 and 2 is IME geared towards the slower dc. Those more advanced at maths/quicker at writing then get asked to expand or do additional work if they finish early.

Babymamamama · 25/03/2017 09:14

I wonder are the school offering extra help? In a positive sense. Have a chat with them to clarify? Do you do any writing with your child at home?

Swipe left for the next trending thread