Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Keeping child in at lunchtime for failure to complete work

166 replies

Elizabeth1970 · 25/03/2017 08:04

Is this reasonable that my child's school have decided to keep her inside at lunchtime if she has not completed her work, she is in yr 1.
She struggles with writing so takes a long time even at home with no distractions ( only child ) to complete a writing task so I feel it's very unfair she is banned from going out after lunch, instead being sent back to class to continue the writing task.
Break times are unaffected so she has 15 minutes at 10am and another 15 at 2pm but this is all most days now.

OP posts:
Elizabeth1970 · 26/03/2017 11:13

Sorry, was a busy day yesterday and didn't have time to reply
I will clarify if she was just chatting but I think it's unlikely as the others on her table currently ( they get moved around per term ) are all boys and she doesn't tend to join in with their talk as doesn't know what they are taking about, superheroes etc!
She's a quiet child and does take longer to write so this is why I jumped to this conclusion.
My husband picks up and if she had been messing around I think the teacher would have let him know, but she didn't.
The social reasons meant we started her at 4, I worried how she would settle into a class that had been together for 3 years.
I think my worries were justified seeing and hearing some of the nonsense just over the short period of reception and year 1 with certain children being excluded from groups and so o.

OP posts:
harshbuttrue1980 · 26/03/2017 10:43

Why are people comparing this situation to someone at work - "if you don't finish your work would you be kept in at lunchtime??". If I started pissing around at work, I'd be sacked. If a child pisses around, they don't get "sacked", but they get asked to stay in to complete the work they didn't do while chatting. What's so hard to understand??

Trifleorbust · 26/03/2017 10:18

grannytomine:

Maybe. Maybe not. I'm a teacher too and I think not, to be honest. Most students would struggle, starting at 7, to catch up to where students are who start at 4 by GCSE. Again, in my opinion.

MyWhatICallNameChange · 26/03/2017 09:39

This is one of the main reasons I took my son out of school. I'd been asking for help for him since year 1. He was diagnosed with ADHD (inattentive type) and ASD in year 3, which obviously the school knew.

This means he had concentration problems and also had trouble handwriting (very slow, very messy, found it painful doing it for a length of time)

Their answer was to keep him in to finish work at break and lunch. This meaning he didn't get a chance to run around meaning his concentration was worse in the afternoon meaning I'd get moaned at that he hadn't done any work at all all day and he'd have to do it at home. No. He won't.

I HE now, he does his handwriting practice everyday and has so much running around time that it means his concentration is so much better when he does have to sit and work. Amazing, who'd have thought running around and exercise could be good for kids?

grannytomine · 26/03/2017 09:26

His teacher didn't agree with you. She felt years were wasted. Just think if school started say three years later so basically keystage 1. You could then have classes of half the size in years 3, 4 and 5. So standard state school with classes of maximum 15 kids to 1 teacher plus whatever TA support there would be. How much progress would kids make? Or even if you said 4, 5 and 6 year olds shouldn't be in a classroom for 6 hrs a day so they did half days, 15 did mornings and 15 did afternoons. I bet they would all do better.

Trifleorbust · 26/03/2017 09:14

grannytomine:

Not everyone has children who are able enough to not fall seriously behind given such a laissez faire approach to education.

grannytomine · 26/03/2017 09:07

I didn't send my kids to school till they were 7 or 8, I won't say I home schooled as it wouldn't be true. I let them play and do what they wanted and as an example one of mine started school at 8 and was assessed by the teacher who said she was ahead of the class in reading, writing and arithmetic. She was also on grade 4 music, very good at IT. All because it was what she wanted to do. At the other extreme I had one start school pretty much where they are in reception, he could read a bit, could write his name and was OK with numbers. I was honest with his teacher and she was brilliant. Probably an advantage that she had just moved to Keystage 2 after always teaching reception/year 1.

By the end of that year he was on top table for everything. At the end of the year I took her a gift to thank her for all she had done and she said I had made her feel her whole career had been a waste of time. I was shocked and said I thought she was a wonderful teacher and she said yes but I've spent years trying to get 4, 5 and 6 year olds to do things they aren't ready to do and if we just left it till they are ready look what they can achieve. So my son achieved 5 years work in 1 years. He had 8 years being a kid and enjoying himself and no he never got kept in at playtime.

He currently has a 1st from a great university and is working on his masters. Not too bad for a boy who was 4 years behind his peers.

If she is too slow to get "enough" writing done then she isn't ready yet. Let her develop at her own pace, forcing her won't achieve anything.

Trifleorbust · 26/03/2017 08:14

OP hasn't been back. I do think it is a fair question whether she was chatting.

TheColonelAdoresPuffins · 26/03/2017 06:46

It's too young.

She struggles with writing so takes a long time even at home with no distractions

The above indicates that it is beyond her control and not due to messing around. You could double check that with the teacher.

tethersend · 25/03/2017 22:07

Taking away playtime from a 5 year old makes as much sense as taking away maths. Playtime is when they learn.

If a child is regularly struggling to complete a task during the allotted time, the task is set at the wrong level and needs to be differentiated.

TheRealPooTroll · 25/03/2017 21:59

And presumably the time the child would be spending sitting with a Ta that sherazade describes would be when the other children were accessing the continuous provision. So they would be missing out on that.

TheRealPooTroll · 25/03/2017 21:56

In the schools I've worked in I've never known a child be kept in more than twice. And kids were only kept in if they were messing around during work time. Strangely enough once children know that doing the work at playtime isn't an empty threat they find themselves able to do it at work time.
If you give them a choice of messing around or working then it's unsurprising that some will choose to mess around.

AlexanderHamilton · 25/03/2017 21:52

Sherazade you sound like a great teacher.

AlexanderHamilton · 25/03/2017 21:51

In which case poo the better option at that age would be for the work not to be completed, or you risk an endless cycle of being kept in increasing the poor concentration & the likelihood is that the child will be totally put off learning.

TheRealPooTroll · 25/03/2017 21:50

That's a very wholesome view you have of a 5yos home life. Their parent may well find the most appropriate time amongst playing, sport and dance or when their child isn't on their ipad or they might not get them to do it at all.

sherazade · 25/03/2017 21:38

Taking away from play time has a knock on effect and leads to poorer concentration and performance and just leads to an endless loop of work not being finished and staying in . I know I'm the in minority though because in the school I worked at it was normal to keep the kids in. I never kept the kids in. If a child was consistently not completing work I'd make sure I kept on top of them during the lesson and would anticipate this. If it still persisted it would mean either a greater level of support or further differentiation or make time to sit quietly with the TA during other times.

AlexanderHamilton · 25/03/2017 21:30

The difference is that it could be completed at the weekend maybe when the child was alert & rested & not under a time pressure.

In a school day taking away a 15/20 minute playtime means the child has no chance to let off steam & recharge for the next session of learning.

The parent could judge the best time for their child, for some that might be first thing in the morning, before breakfast, or maybe afte school after being given an hour to play in the garden etc etc etc.

Or at the weekend when it's just a short period of catching up in an otherwise day full of playing/sport/dance

TheRealPooTroll · 25/03/2017 21:26

So you'd make the parent take away the child's play time rather than doing it yourself. How is that better?

AlexanderHamilton · 25/03/2017 21:07

Children have very short attention spans & as they develop at different rates many are simply not able to focus on a single task for the same amount of time as others are. The thing is to try & slowly build this skill up.

AlexanderHamilton · 25/03/2017 21:06

The OP never said her dd was chatting.

In the case of simply chatting I would expect the teacher to gently remind the child to stay on task & if it persisted for the work to be sent home ( being sympathetic to any asd/adhd style traits of losing train of thought or constantly going onto another subject )

TheRealPooTroll · 25/03/2017 20:50

So presuming the teacher is differentiating and they have a manageable amount if work and still waste time chatting. Do they just not do any work?

TheRealPooTroll · 25/03/2017 20:48

Given less work if they are chatting?
My son has asd and dyspraxia and is given less work. I still expect him to do what he's capable of without fannying around. And if he did choose to fanny around then he'd have to do the work at another time. In reception that would be during child led play in the classroom or break/lunch time.

AlexanderHamilton · 25/03/2017 20:43

They should be given less work. For example slow professors can do every other maths question & fast workers/those with more concentration given extension tasks.

It's not rocket science, teachers should be able to differentiate. (Dh is a teacher & I have worked in extra curricular education)

TheRealPooTroll · 25/03/2017 20:38

So when do they do the work they've missed then? If it's sent home they will be missing out on recreation time at home doing it.

PopCakes · 25/03/2017 20:27

Astoria7974

I'm also depressed by your post - mainly due to it's ignorance and lack of empathy. There is literally no advantage in starting formal education early; it's detrimental to long term academic progress. Although you can get away with it with some kids and score a short term advantage over their peers many children are not neurologically ready to start reading and writing before 5 and though you can force them somewhat it can have very negative effects long term.

There are proven long term negative impacts on academic performance and mental health in children due to lack of free play and time outside. There should be no reason to deprive a child of their free time. If a child has wilfully misbehaved (and some children simply cannot concentrate as long as others so I would not include lack of concentration in this) there should be consequences but missing recreation shouldn't be one of them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread