Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Keeping child in at lunchtime for failure to complete work

166 replies

Elizabeth1970 · 25/03/2017 08:04

Is this reasonable that my child's school have decided to keep her inside at lunchtime if she has not completed her work, she is in yr 1.
She struggles with writing so takes a long time even at home with no distractions ( only child ) to complete a writing task so I feel it's very unfair she is banned from going out after lunch, instead being sent back to class to continue the writing task.
Break times are unaffected so she has 15 minutes at 10am and another 15 at 2pm but this is all most days now.

OP posts:
PopCakes · 26/03/2017 12:17

Rosieposy4 You don't have the statistics to conduct any significant research or to account for external factors which you won't be aware of. You also won't be aware of the impact of your teaching on the students mental health for example because you are not privy to that information. Lots of teachers I know read research papers and incorporate firmly established results into the way they teach.

This isn't a criticism of teachers - a teacher is going to be much more capable than anyone else of actually enacting good practise. It's all very well to know e.g. to use positive behaviour management techniques but to actually do it successfully needs experience and skill.

My issue is with someone coming along saying "i'm a teacher I know this works" when what they're saying is directly contradicted by a huge wealth of evidence.

armpitz · 26/03/2017 12:14

Gawp AT you and shrug, that should read!

armpitz · 26/03/2017 12:13

Increasingly

If they are messing about in the lesson usually I'd approach them about the work rather than behaviour (assuming it's 'low level' stuff!) So for instance 'how are you getting on with your story, Jack?' rather than 'Jack, stop giggling and whispering to Phoebe.' Gets them less defensive. Sometimes. Wink

If they sort of gawp and you and shrug that's kid code for 'I don't know WTF to do' so I might say something like 'do you want an idea to start it?' or 'do you want me to explain it to you again?' or 'do you want to have a quick look at Phoebe's to see what the table should look like?'

If they are still not cooperating it might be appropriate to get them to step outside and calm down (this one works for gigglers as they soon realise there is nothing funny outside the classroom.)

Bribery can work. We have three levels of rewards. I often say 'I tell you what, if you manage to finish that I'll give you a (first reward)' Lots of kids love showing their work off so you can offer to tell Mr or Mrs X how WELL they did (!) or even ring parents to let them know that Jack was very sensible and settled down.

If someone's being persistently disruptive you need to remove them.

If someone's persistently not working then theres a real problem and it needs flagging.

If someone's having a giddy and silly day then it's not going to be improved by making them lose the time allocated TO be giddy and silly!

Increasinglymiddleaged · 26/03/2017 12:06

OK Sheraze and armpits.

You are a teacher and you notice a child in your class messing about rather be than working. What would you do about it? I'm sure all the teachers on MN will be waiting the enlightenment on how this situation can be solved without there being consequences.

Rosieposy4 · 26/03/2017 12:06

Pop cakes
Secondary teachers don't necessarily teach kids for just a year. I have some kids i have had in my groups for years on end, top set y9, followed by triple science, followed by A level biology, thinking of several in one of my y13 classes. So you can indeed see trends.
In addition to which many teachers do research themselves into various aspects of pedagogy, we certainly do in my school.

PopCakes · 26/03/2017 12:03

armpitz It is considered a right under EU law. You can insist upon it for your child. I don't know if Trifle really is a teacher but she consistently posts deliberately argumentative posts that are basically the polar opposite of current good practise in the classroom and her views are completely contradicted by most educational research.

armpitz · 26/03/2017 12:03

I think Trifle might be on maternity leave to be fair there! She mentioned a young baby in another post! (Sorry if I've confused you with someone else Trifle!)

But when teaching anyone - animal or human - something, if they aren't cooperating, forcing them to sit down until they do just isn't going to work.

sherazade · 26/03/2017 12:02

I fully agree with armpits. Breaks should be a right for children regardless of whether they have done the work fully or not .

PopCakes · 26/03/2017 12:01

sorry should be the right to recreation.

PopCakes · 26/03/2017 12:01

Trifleorbust you may think you have more insight than a parent but you don't have more insight than people who conduct educational research. You would be ignorant to imagine you do. You have no idea about the long term consequence of your teaching on students mental health or long term educational outcome because you have not conducted any long term study. You also don't know the impact your teaching has on their immediate mental health.

As I've said before if you are a teacher (who spends most of her day posting on mumsnet) you have neglected to keep up to date on educational research or EU law which guarantees children the right to education.

sherazade · 26/03/2017 11:59

Sailorcherries - surely if a child had spent a full hour talking that would be noticed during the lesson and stopped there and then ? How are children spending full lessons not doing any work for teachers not to notice ?

PopCakes · 26/03/2017 11:57

people who have taught hundreds or even thousands of children have more insight into what will or won't help more if those children to learn, than non-educators

Absolutely not clear at all. Teachers have no insight into the long term impacts of their teaching - they are going to develop an experience for what works in the shop term. They teach children for a year.

That's why we don't simply let teachers get on with it we conduct research and that governs (or should govern) what teachers are trained to do.

armpitz · 26/03/2017 11:57

I don't know that it is Trifle

I'm honestly a bit taken aback at how many people think depriving such a young child of time to play, socialise with her peers and renew her concentration levels, is in any way conducive to learning.

When children get older it's possible not working is an act of defiance and that's different but it's also easy to confuse defiance with lack of understanding.

I do think we need to move away from lost breaks and lunch times as a punishment. I think these should be considered a right.

CecilyP · 26/03/2017 11:56

No, trifle, I don't agree it is obvious, as the post I highlighted was a follow on from your post:

Maybe. Maybe not. I'm a teacher too and I think not, to be honest. Most students would struggle, starting at 7, to catch up to where students are who start at 4 by GCSE. Again, in my opinion.

For you to have more insight than most, you would have to have taught a significant number of children who started at 7 and been able to compare with children who started at 4. That seems an unlikely position for a secondary teacher to be in.

grannytomine · 26/03/2017 11:56

Trifleorbust, but not all teachers agree with you so it doesn't mean you are right just because you are a teacher.

Trifleorbust · 26/03/2017 11:46

armpitz:

That's okay.

Trifleorbust · 26/03/2017 11:45

CecilyP:

I think that's too obvious for debate, to be honest. Education is a contentious business and hardly anyone agrees with anyone else on everything (two teachers in an otherwise empty room will argue over something!), but I think it's obvious that people who have taught hundreds or even thousands of children have more insight into what will or won't help more if those children to learn, than non-educators. Forgive me but I think that's clear.

sailorcherries · 26/03/2017 11:38

I teach and I have kept children in before, not every day but it has happened. They are 7 and 8.

I always differentiate the workload between different groups, based on ability, and then I further differentiate my own expectations of what each child is expected to achieve in the group. They may be in the same group and have the same task but I don't expect wee Timmy to do the same as Tommy.

I only keep a child in when they really have not worked during the lesson. For example sitting for over an hour and not even completing 1/4 of the assigned task because they prefer to talk.
I'd never keep a child in who had been struggling to complete a task or if the task/concept was brand new to the group/child. However, if I know they can do it and have chosen not to then that is a different matter.

My rule has always been that it will only happen at break time, as lunch time is one hour later, or at golden time. They can eat their snack while working and as soon as they are finished they are free to go outside/join in golden time for the duration. Never have I returned to class to see a child still working away, they've generally completed the task to the expected standard in 5 or 10 minutes, letting me know they were just messing around in class time.

I could never send jotters/books home for the work to be completed as I need to use them the next day and I look over every single piece of work each night to monitor progress and check for any difficulties (so normally about 75 different marked tasks - 25 literacy, 25 maths and 25 topic/science/rme etc).

I don't like keeping them in and have only done it a handful of times although those who have been kept in are generally spurred on more towards break time as they know the consequences.

armpitz · 26/03/2017 11:38

I'm a teacher and I disagree with you Trifle

CecilyP · 26/03/2017 11:30

Fair enough. I hope you don't mind if, given that I do this for a living and have taught hundreds of children, I continue to think I have more insight into this than you. No offence.

As a secondary teacher, teaching children almost all of whom started school in reception, some high achieving, some not, how do you have any more insight than anyone else?

Trifleorbust · 26/03/2017 11:21

grannytomine:

I'm not anti home education at all, actually.

grannytomine · 26/03/2017 11:20

Trifleor bust, no offence everyone entitled to their own opinion. However, several teachers I know don't agree with you. When we went to home ed groups for social activities I was always struck by how many of the kids had a parent who was a teacher, one family I knew had a dad who was Head of an outstanding local school.

Generally I find the people who understand home ed have experienced both systems, the people who are anti generally only have experience of school. Not 100% of course but my experience.

grannytomine · 26/03/2017 11:17

Elizabeth, I worried about how mine would fit in at 7 or 8 but it varied as much as most things in life. One had a really hard time, the one who went in top of the class put a few noses out of joint and led to bullying, one was very popular, everyone vying to be friends with the new boy and show him round. I'm not sure if it would have been any different if they started at 4, as some of it was just down to their personalities and the particular class involved

. The one who fitted in well, popular new boy, is still good friends with those classmates nearly 20 years later and they are all off on a boys trip at Easter.

Trifleorbust · 26/03/2017 11:15

grannytomine:

Fair enough. I hope you don't mind if, given that I do this for a living and have taught hundreds of children, I continue to think I have more insight into this than you. No offence.

grannytomine · 26/03/2017 11:13

Trifleorbust, mine all did well, all went to uni, all got firsts. 3 have post grad qualifications and the youngest is doing his masters now. My husband is from a country where children don't start school until they are 7 so it was normal for him and he persuaded me to give it a try. One of the things that persuaded me to give it a try was knowing several children who had arrived her after school starting age who didn't even speak English and by 18 were out performing English kids who started school at 4.

You might think not but maybe you are wrong, maybe I was lucky. I think it would take a big study to prove either of us right.

Swipe left for the next trending thread