Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Keeping child in at lunchtime for failure to complete work

166 replies

Elizabeth1970 · 25/03/2017 08:04

Is this reasonable that my child's school have decided to keep her inside at lunchtime if she has not completed her work, she is in yr 1.
She struggles with writing so takes a long time even at home with no distractions ( only child ) to complete a writing task so I feel it's very unfair she is banned from going out after lunch, instead being sent back to class to continue the writing task.
Break times are unaffected so she has 15 minutes at 10am and another 15 at 2pm but this is all most days now.

OP posts:
Trifleorbust · 26/03/2017 14:05

Parents can make an informed choice as to whether to send their child to school.

They can indeed. Home education is a completely reasonable choice. But it being the best thing for one child doesn't make the it the best thing for every child up to the age of 8.

As a secondary school teacher I start teaching children a core subject at age 11. For many of them, home life is a chaotic mess, involving constant X box/DS, variable bedtimes, little outdoor activity, no books, no educational trips, no stimulating conversation.

The thought of those children being at home rather than school for an additional three years before someone begins to teach them to hold a reasonable conversation, let alone read or write, is frightening.

sailorcherries · 26/03/2017 13:59

Parents can make an informed choice as to whether to send their child to school. Him being too young is not the school's fault at all.

Also there is a vast difference between children having fun and learning, purposeful play, and children outside tanking themselves up on sweets, sugary juices and crisps. Never have I ever excluded a from purposeful play activities.

grannytomine · 26/03/2017 13:52

I can't quote vast amounts of research but I can say that one of my children was not ready for school at 4, he was bright and as I said before has a first from a great uni and is doing really well with his masters but at 4 he was very young for his age. Starting school at 8 was great for him. One of his nephew's, my DGC, is very like him, his parents made the decision to send him to school at 4 as they thought it would help him and he needed the extra time. Like his uncle he "woke up" at 8 and has done fantastically in the last year and has moved up 4 tables at school, from bottom table to 2nd table. Unfortunately the previous 4 years have damaged his confidence and his self esteem. We are getting there with him but you know what, he started in school at 8 in pretty much the same position as my son academically but my son had 8 fun years and was confident and ready to learn. DGS was convinced he was stupid, very prone to crying if he couldn't get something straight away. I might not have taught hundreds or thousands, I might not be a trained teacher but I have seen both in two very similar children and I know which one I prefer. I hope my grandson fully recovers from the damage school has done him.

Increasinglymiddleaged · 26/03/2017 13:30

But seriously, where did someone say 'I am a wonderful teacher' and this led to compromising someone's mental health?

It's the smug attitude of 'well I wouldn't let them'. I can't remember if it was you or not but it came through in bounds in a couple of posts.

Rosieposy4 · 26/03/2017 13:18

Popcakes thank you for telling me how to conduct research and account for extrinsic factors.
Why assume I don't know that? prior to being a teacher i was a university lecturer in a scientific discipline and have nearly 50 published papers to my name.
Actually i am aware of extrinsic factors, and very much so about my students mental health, partly because we are very keen on getting that right where i work, and also because oddly enough i read the medical ( and sen) notes for every one of the 340 kids i teach every week and am well aware of those under the care of the GP, or CAMHS, or seeing our school counsellor. It would be negligent of me not to be.
I agree with another poster who said that a lot of educational research is poorly done, that includes lots of the published work from universities. All the more reason for practitioners in the field to carry out their own work.

armpitz · 26/03/2017 13:15

BINGO tes veterans

But seriously, where did someone say 'I am a wonderful teacher' and this led to compromising someone's mental health?

Increasinglymiddleaged · 26/03/2017 13:14

Come on then reference it. Then people can decide on its validity for themselves.

Increasinglymiddleaged · 26/03/2017 13:14

Seriously, we can't disagree with each other as it might upset Mrs Special Snowflake teacher and compromise her mental health?

Wow you sound nice, I hope you don't teach my children.

Trifleorbust · 26/03/2017 13:13

PopCakes:

I would prefer not to engage with you as I think you have been deliberately rude. That is my last response to your posts.

PopCakes · 26/03/2017 13:13

I'd be interested to read the research that says being kept in for 10 minutes every so often harms mental health.

This is a wealth of evidence that the current lack of recreation time is damaging their mental health let alone reducing it any further!

Increasinglymiddleaged · 26/03/2017 13:13

Popcakes

As far as I can see you have cited no research at all in your responses.

To assume that the answers to all of life's problems can be found in an academic book/ research is breathtakingly naive.

Trifleorbust · 26/03/2017 13:12

Increasinglymiddleaged:

There is a 'right to recreation' but it doesn't specify that children should never lose any specific instance of recreation.

There is also a right to education. I would argue that includes your teachhera doing what they can do to make sure you don't spend your lessons pissing about. Hmm

PopCakes · 26/03/2017 13:11

My point is keeping children in at playtime has been illustrated to be negative in the long term this has been firmly established, it is also a right under EU law. That is the salient point.

armpitz · 26/03/2017 13:10

Where has someone done that on this thread?

Seriously, we can't disagree with each other as it might upset Mrs Special Snowflake teacher and compromise her mental health?

PopCakes · 26/03/2017 13:10

How hilariously rude.

Which bit of my post did you consider rude or hilarious? Obviously you will admit that a few years teaching experience with a few hundred children at most doesn't mean your anecdotal experience with no long term knowledge of how your teaching affected them or any source of comparison against an alternative method of teaching gives you any authority to comment compared to those who have conducted large scale studies of educational outcomes in which they are able to account for external factors and compare hundreds of thousands of students. This I would consider to obvious to debate (as you put it). You sound incredibly dismissive of people who disagree with you because "you're a teacher". Which is silly because plenty of other teachers disagree with you and in fact educational research disagrees with you. It's concerning that if you are a teacher you're happy to ignore all of this research in preference for what you feel works in the short term. I would hope neither my doctor nor my child's teacher takes this approach.

Increasinglymiddleaged · 26/03/2017 13:07

For a start , I wouldn't just let them mess about routinely for lessons on end and then get them to catch up in break.

Well for me the key here is 'routinely'. But I am Hmm re the right for a whole break and lunchtime every single day. I would agree losing break time 2/3 times a week is indicative of a bigger problem.

I'd be interested to read the research that says being kept in for 10 minutes every so often harms mental health.

I am also quite interested that teachers who claim to care about mental health are seemingly less concerned about the mental health of their colleagues by possibly making them feel shit about their own classroom problems (and everyone has them) by promoting what a wonderful teacher they are.

And teachers have pretty much the worst mental health of any profession, there is lots of research that shows that.

Trifleorbust · 26/03/2017 12:41

armpitz:

Thanks. Feeding her and enjoying a lovely Mother's Day as we speak. Back to work in a couple of weeks. Grin

Trifleorbust · 26/03/2017 12:38

I'm not going to engage multiple posters over this. I can see when people are determined to be rude and aggressive. I do think teachers, as the front line in education, have more insight than non-teachers. Naturally those non-teachers who hold particularly...ahem...strong views aren't going to agree when I say this. That's life.

kesstrel · 26/03/2017 12:38

Regarding all this talk of educational research and evidence: actually, there are really not very many practices in education that actually have sufficient good quality research to back them up as being strongly evidence-based. This is partly because it is very difficult to design high quality studies in classrooms, due to there being so many variables, and also due to the expense.

sailorcherries · 26/03/2017 12:35

Also I don't shout at them, belittle their work or make a big deal out of them talking. I go and sit with them, discuss the work and engage with them. I let them know they are on the right track or spend time going over tasks again to make sure they understand. I then remind them they have 'x amount of time until break' and that I'll be back to see how they're doing in 'x amount of time'.

Sometimes no amount of teacher support, encouragement, praise or moved seats will stop a particular child chatting at that particular time.

Trifleorbust · 26/03/2017 12:32

PopCakes:

How hilariously rude. Blush

sailorcherries · 26/03/2017 12:31

sherazade thank you for assuming I do bugger all but watch them chat for a full hour.

In my hour and a half/hour and 45 minute literacy lesson which is to include reading, a reading activity and spelling or phonics I have 5 different spelling groups and 6 different reading groups, plus an eal learner and children with support needs. I also teach a multi-composite class with 3 different stages and 3 different sets of outcomes to achieve.
I spend roughly 10 minutes with each group but cannot see each group each day, leaving me with little time to circulate but I do while groups are coming to/leaving the teaching area and, for obvious reasons, certain children need more support than others. I have no classroom support due to budget cuts.

If I see a child chatting I do go over to them, ask about the work and try to work with them for a few minutes. However, with so many different groups and needs I cannot do this too often as I then cannot teach.

This isn't a common occurance nor would I 'routinely let them mess around for lessons on end' and normally it is high achieving children who can't be bothered to write at that time and would rather discuss their weekend/what they're doing after school/Fifa 17 (speaking to them they know what they are doing and can participate in discussions about the task) but when it does happen it as addressed to the best of my ability while still trying to teach such a vast range of groups and abilities. I cannot spend time constantly correcting low level behaviour to the detriment of every other child. The ones who have been kept in know why, can understand and do finish the work withon 5 or 10 minutes which indicates they were just messing around.

Unfortunately that is the reality of many teachers these days.

PopCakes · 26/03/2017 12:29

sherazade You sound amazing - I hope my DC always have teachers like you (so far so lucky for us!)

armpitz · 26/03/2017 12:23

I should add as well that I haven't always had this philosophy Blush

I was a right twat once and I thought if you shouted at them, they behaved, that if you punished them and made them miserable , they wouldn't want to be miserable and punished so would behave and that it was tough luck if they had ADHD/ASD, The Real World would not make allowances for them (yeah, I really was a twat Grin) so why should I?

It was a quote that changed my mind on my training course (luckily before I met any real children.) It simply said 'behaviour is the language of the child.' For some reason it struck a chord with me. I've worked with animals for a long time and I realised my horse isn't being 'naughty' when she refuses to go in her horse box, she is telling me she's afraid. I don't yell at her and try to drag her in. I stand with her and I see what she's seeing and I let her know she is safe. Why so different to children? I don't scream at my dog or horse. I don't punish them but I do praise and reward them. Sometimes for their safety and mine I might need to remove them from a situation.

If a child isn't doing her work, she's telling you something. If your only answer is 'you WILL do it' then you're not listening to her question. And if you do listen to it, you might find she's telling you something very important.

sherazade · 26/03/2017 12:18

I am a primary school teacher. I've worked in the public and private sector.

For a start , I wouldn't just let them mess about routinely for lessons on end and then get them to catch up in break.

There are many, many different possibilities as to why the child is messing about .
It could be they don't understand the work
The work is not pitched at their level - too easy or too hard
It could be that they are not interested in it
There could be factors affecting concentration like: tiredness, hunger
It could be a one off
It could be recurring
It could a behavioural issue , it could be cognitive
Every child and situation is different and would be addressed accordingly .
For children who mess about for no apparent reason , you engage with them and refocus them . You don't just watch them chat for a full hour and then keep them in. You try to address what the problem is and then go from there . You might find that the child needs to change group or place , or needs different work, or needs a five minute explanation which you would try to do in lesson time , or needs further support from other staff , or needs a practical activity, or has a different learning style that is not been catered to, or needs an abacus or a dictionary or whatever . I can't tell you in one post what I'd do as it depends on the child and the problem . A good teacher is fluid and dynamic . There's no one size fits all am afraid .