Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

in expecting my bil to punish his child for her distructive and violent behaviour?

62 replies

williamsmummy · 05/03/2007 22:39

one of my nieces was in my care for the afternoon. She is develpmentally delayed and is 10 yrs old, and will go to a special school in september.
I am fully aware of this and have worked with children who are often much younger in there head than years.
However, it seems that there are no boundries in this family. I respect and agree that any form of corperal punishment is not a way forward. However that seems to be an excuse not to have any rules.

Well apart from the children having complete control of daddy.

This 10 yr old child , was rough and voilent with a 3 yr old guest, waiting until i left the room to do this. shoving and throwing things at this child.

Smacked my 8 yr old daughter because she didnt want to play her game, with her.

tried to slap my other nephew around the face, but being quick of foot she missed.

Then to cap it all, she spilt 1/2 litre bottle of bleach all over my bathroom floor, staining my bath mats, and being walked across my landing.

She lied about it to our faces, until I pointed out that she was the only child with bleach stains on her clothes.
We did check her for any harm to her hands, but she was very careful not to spill any of it on her skin.

The other neice 9yrs sulked all day because my daughter didnt want to play her games. At least she was quiet.

My BIL decided that as a punishment he would take the children home early, but that was what the children wanted to do anyway.
I didnt have the guts to mention the violent behaviour , as we did try some years ago, and he wouldnt accept that our son prevoked his daughter, ( and implication that he deserved it)

A couple of hours later BIL rang hubby and said he had a little chat with daughter , who had told him that it was only a small amount of bleach, so no harm done.

This man sees his children through rose coloured glasses. They have no respect for many adults , there father ( who she does smack as well) or any children that come in her way.

My children have started to ask that we do not invite these children in our home.

recently, they have broken a double glazed window, lost some parts of my sons toys , and where caught putting glasses of blackcurrent squash on full heat in my microwave. ( but that story is for another moan!!)

I want my hubby to say something , but he is right in saying that he will never listen to us. so I am at a loss at what to do.

We have been pressured in to going to his home on mothers day, the whole family will be there, but I am sick of my children being smacked by these children. I have told hubby that one incidence of violence or controling behaviour and I will pack up my children and leave.

I never let my children bully other children, why should i let them be builied, but a child who may have learning difficulties, but is aware of what she is doing and needs rules and boundries.

end of rant.

thank you.

OP posts:
ThisFrogIsGonnaWhoopYouAss · 06/03/2007 15:03

I can't understand why you are exempting your SIL from any blame in this - although to be honest the thought of any adults being left in charge of 10 (or 11) children when they quite clearly don't care beggars belief.

ElenyaTuesday · 06/03/2007 14:52

In fairness to Williamsmummy, I have bleach on the windowsill in my downstairs loo. My kids are 10 and 7 - when they were toddlers the bleach was put away but now they are old enough to understand not to touch it and they don't. Do other people really still lock stuff away when their kids are that big? I appreciate that the child mentioned in the OP was SN and that's a different situation.

BigCookLittleCook · 06/03/2007 13:54

I would not leave bleach in reach of any ten year old, SN or not. It could kill a child if they drink it. Even if she had to stand on the loo seat or a chair to reach it (just a guess), it is "within reach". You need to lock these things away. I know you said your house is "no longer geared up for pre-school children" as your youngest child is 8, but surely you dont want your 8-year old, or other three kids, to be able to get hold of bleach, especially in a bathroom where they can probably lock themselves in.

Alan · 06/03/2007 13:34

williamsmummy thank god you are not my daughters aunt because it doesnt sound like you looked after her at all, infact she sounds like she was neglected

juuule · 06/03/2007 10:35

In your own house do it your way. Let the adults know your expectations. If they don't or won't agree then they must go home with their children. Decide for yourself what allowances you will make. You need to decide what you can live with. When you are in control of your own home and what you can cope with you can then decide what you have left to help your bil and sil with their situations otherwise things get too chaotic (and from what you've said, dangerous) as you have found.
When visiting you can decide what you consider to be appropriate behaviour for your own children. You might make suggestions about other people's children but you can't impose your way onto other people. Your way might seem to strict/slack for other people's comfort zones. You don't know what they have to deal with day to day. You can't force them to be you. What you can do is remove yourself and your children if you are too uncomfortable with a situation.
As it's your bil and sil I would make several attempts at discussions about expected behaviour on all sides. As long as people don't fall out over it, communication can be eye-opening and very helpful to all concerned. An insight into the difficulties that other people have can make a difference to how we view situations.

williamsmummy · 06/03/2007 10:13

my bil has two , sil has four and i have four.

as for punishment, i think that removeing child from situation and having time out would be a simple first step. With clear, simple, explanation.

warning that if bad behaviour happens X will happen ( e.g favourite toy removed for a previously set time), and again time out. and so on.

give suggested ways to overcome shareing / playing difficulties, with calm explanation.
while observing play.

This is something that would apply to all children and not just single out one child.

other points taken on by other parents and children, understanding of cousins problems, flagging up problems ASAP so that can be delt with swifty before problem escalates.

BIL to point out and GUIDE us on how he wants this to be delt with before it happens.
As its clear that dump and run out the door ( with my hubby) is not working for me or the children!!!

OP posts:
KristinaM · 06/03/2007 10:00

sounds a bit chaotic to me! does your niece coep well with chaos? Some children ( nt or sn) prefer a quieter more structured environment. Maybe she woudl do better with fewer children as well. Are the ten children just yours and your BILs?

coppertop · 06/03/2007 09:57

As others have said, just because your niece is rouhly at the level of a 7yr-old does not mean that she is able to act like an NT 7yr-old. It's not that simple.

Being able to tell you what poisons are doesn't mean that your niece has the maturity to control her impulses or compulsions around them. Again it's just not that simple.

I am still genuinely interested in hearing what you would consider to be a suitable punishment for your niece.

williamsmummy · 06/03/2007 09:44

microwave thingy, two adults in the house btw, most of the day with me , makes three adults, when I left for doc appointment had ten children, when at docs, ended up with 11 as neighbour came in to play.
6 outside, on heelys , others indoors playing babies etc. snacks and drink left out. brief instruction for heelie children to go in at certain time as getting dark. ( older child 15 watching)

found BIL and SIL on sofa had no Idea how many (or who)children where in house, left kids alone with microwave, and Upstairs window broken because while i was gone one was hanging out of window.

I was in the house for ten mins checking on the children and starting to cook tea before they even noticed I was there.

i feel very grateful that I didnt find a child on my front lawn from falling from window and didnt have to deal with broken glass , cuts and burns.

So I suppose when I think about it, bleach incident very minor in comparison!!

OP posts:
williamsmummy · 06/03/2007 09:35

jimjams 2 I think you are right, but that means that its getting impossible for me to look after this child.
Having this 3yr old around was a spur of the moment desision. It wont happen again.

much of the comments everyone has said my hubby has said. I am taking them on board. perhaps its because they are family that i am not seeing this as clearly as I would a child I have care of outside the home.

As for the children picking up bad vibes, well, they are always keen to play over here, when they have an idea of what we are going to do.

I cant approach my bil as its clear he doesnt approve of our parenting methods. When we have broached the subject in the past, with one of our sons, he replied that she must have been prevoked. That was the end of that!

There is so much of her behaviour that I ignore and accept, as norm for her, I dont give a monkeys about my bath mat, I dont live in a show home by any means. I do want them to be happy, but I want my children to be as well.

as for the comment about her being young in her head, well , emotionally and educationally she is not ten yrs old.
how do i phrase this?

There are peaks and troughs in this, but her general understanding is good.
She explained quite clearly what poison was, and identified some around the home.

Again, lesson learned and all dangerous stuff will have to be removed and hidden when she comes to the house.

And plan to follow her from room to room.

It would for instance be a doddle to look after the girls if I didnt have my children with them.
But that is not an option. For them they want to play with my daughter, its part of the day.
But planning activites, and lining up other choices is enough when babysitting.
which is in effect what I do. everyone is right I only have them for a day, and dont have enough contact with them to make a difference to their lives.

OP posts:
batters · 06/03/2007 09:17

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

dejags · 06/03/2007 09:16

Well 11 kids to one carer, is just a recipe for disaster.

That's not the fault of the children though.

I am getting frustrated - Williamsmummy, you only seem to be looking for negatives in this situation.

williamsmummy · 06/03/2007 09:13

I will just add that the microwave thingy was in my home, but father was there are the time, I had to dash out for a doc appointment and he and my sil offered to look after all the children ( 11 of them at the time)
i came home to find children putting my cheap asda glasses filled with blackcurrent on full heat in microwave. on their own with daddys ok.

I found that incredible, and had nightmares about skin grafts and burns!

OP posts:
Jimjams2 · 06/03/2007 09:12

Please stop saying "in her head she is...." as the mother of a child with learning diffficulties I find it offensive. Not sure why, but it doesn't seem very respectful.

ALL the behaviour you describe- the pushing over of a 3 year old, getting bleach everywhere the destructiveness etc is NORMAL for a a child with significant special needs. Your niece requires SUPERVISION.

I have 3 children, my eldest has SN my other 2 do not. I would NEVER leave my 2 year old alone with one of my friend's children with SN. Not for a minute because I have seen them try and push toddlers over etc. It goes with the territory.

This sums it up

"As for not observing child , its not that often that you need to observe a child of ten in the toilet who has been toilet trained since she was 3.( Even if in her head she is around 6-7yrs)"

That's because most children of 10 do not have learning difficulties. It doesn't matter what you would usually do-- you have to provide supervision. DS1 is 7 with severe learning difficulties- he requires more supervision than my 2 year old. That's just the way it is.

dejags · 06/03/2007 09:10

Sorry but I think you are being terribly hard on this guy.

I am total stickler for rules. I love em.

However, I would not be disciplining my kids if I was unaware there was a problem. You never told your BIL about the hitting (besides the one time, in passing). He cannot be expected to sort out a problem that he isn't aware of.

It sounds as if you BIL is doing his best. It's your choice to have them around or not - and if not having them around is causing so much discord then you need to talk to your BIL in a proper setting with the right emphasis.

Kids can sense when they aren't liked or welcome and it makes them even more difficult when they do pick up bad vibes IME.

2shoes · 06/03/2007 09:08

i find it surprising that you don't seem to realise a child with sn is not going to act the same as an nt child. OK you say in her head she is so and so but that is not the end of it. you can't just then say oh that makes her 7 and she should act like that. I think you will find it is much more complicated than that.
Your poor BIL sounds like he is out of his depth. can you not broach the subject in an chatty friendly way.

williamsmummy · 06/03/2007 09:04

thank you for your points, I have taken them on board.
I must explain that the 3yr old was not my child, but a guest,popping over for a short visit, to join us icing a cake. Mother of 3yr old joined us after 1/2hr. child was with us for about 1hr.

As for not observing child , its not that often that you need to observe a child of ten in the toilet who has been toilet trained since she was 3.( Even if in her head she is around 6-7yrs)

as my youngest child is 8 my home is no longer geared up for pre-school children.
the 3 yr old was escorted to the bathroom for this reason.

I do love my neices, but do not approve of their behaviour. They are spoilt , which I see as a form of neglet. Rules and bounderies are reasurring for children, as well as showing them you love them.
They have complete control over there activity choices, for instance they ring up a friend to come over and play, then inform their father . He complies every time, for many situations.
It must be frighting for two young girls to have that control over their own lives.
If socially they have everything there own way, how to they learn to share? to form relationships with people other than 'you do was i want , I want to play this game' ? ( a phrase I hear freqently) which is something that needs to be learnt. So that they can form decent relationships when older.

As a single father I am well aware that he is on his own. Which is another reason why violent behavour must stop.
He would be heartbroken if my children said in front of him that they dont want their cousins to play because they are being hit.
We need to have the children here to give him a breathing space.
I think an agreed method of disapline for all their careers / family would help.
However this is an extremly difficult area to go forward with.

When my neices are in my care there are structed activites in place, or outings.
Cooking is something they all enjoy , which we did.
But after planned activties are finshed, they should at there ages be able to play games happily with little adult intervention.
I am to assume that I am wrong here?
Perhaps I should ask for another adult to be at home with me when i care for my neices? So that I can follow her and give full time one to one??

On their own these children are delightlful and fun, but for there own good they must learn to behave in a more socially acceptable manner.

In the past my children have behavied badly on these family occasions and they have had some conseqence as a result. its difficult for them to see bad behaviour in others go without comment.
But they do understand that for these girls different rules apply.
But as they grow older and stronger, ( the teenage years are around the corner) how do we stop this?

thank you for your comments.

OP posts:
monkeymonkeymoomoo · 06/03/2007 08:12

Yes you are being unreasonable... your tone is appalling and unsympathetic 'this child', 'these children', 'at least she was quiet' etc etc.

wannaBeWhateverIWannaBe · 06/03/2007 07:36

Saying you have worked with children with special needs is a bit like saying you?ve babysat for someone so know all about babies. In short, you don?t have a clue.

I agree that having other peoples? children being destructive in your home can be frustrating, but if you knew this girl has development delay why were you not supervising her more closely? And if you don?t tell your bil what happened how can you possibly expect him to deal with it? He?s not psychic is he?

As for the bleach, the fact the girl got hold of it is your fault not hers. Does your 3 year old also have unsupervised access to bleach?

IMO the best way forward for you is to tell your bil you don?t think you can look after his children in future. That would probably be the best for you and for his children.

FillyjonkDOEStellherkidsoff · 06/03/2007 06:23

I'm sorry, I agree with the other posters

I also kind of think these kids are a part of your family and they should be supported by you. And that your BIL has a much trickier job than you.

And you can't have been properly supervising really.

dejags · 06/03/2007 05:52

Sounds to me like a lot more supervision and structure was needed for this number of children (with varied ages and needs).

I think the fact that your BIL sees his kids through rose coloured glasses is wonderful. If you didn't tell him about the violence, I am not quite sure how he was expected to act on it. He clearly did take it up with his daughter and even called you to tell you that he had.

If you have such an issue with his kids hitting yours you need to do three things:

  1. tell your BIL about the hitting (not something mentioned in passing, but actually sit down and talk to him).
  2. take it up directly with your nieces when you see it happening - something along the lines of "I don't accept that sort of behaviour, please do not hit XXX"
  3. don't have your nieces around again - I agree with the poster that you don't seem to like them much - kids pick up on this sort of thing.

HTH

BassMama · 06/03/2007 00:38

I dont understand why you think you BIL's children are so bad when you atated that the 9yo sulked when she didn't get her own way? Typical 9yo behaviour and not at all destructive or violent?

Violence can be a problem in SN children, depending obviously on what her condition is. This only means they should be watched MORE not less.

They are clearly quite playful little girls, possibly slightly mischevious, but putting juice in the microwave and losing parts of toys are not exactly bad things for children to do!

I think you should maybe try to remember that SN children need more supervision, and shouldn't be left alone, actually, SN or not, where there is access to bleach.

Maybe you could politely ask your BIL not to leave his children at your house when there are other children around, if you feel you cannot cope?

I am sure you can appreciate how hard it must be for your BIL and SIL to care for their SN child, especially with a younger child to look after too, and I am sure the choices thay have made regarding the childs discipline are correct, informed and appropriate.

KristinaM · 06/03/2007 00:14

I think your niece needs much more supervision that you are currently providing. You are aware that she has "developmental delays" but you are leaving her where she has access to bleach and hot liquids. You left her alone with a 3 year old? You are not providing sufficient care for her IMHO

miffedandmoody · 06/03/2007 00:03

Being a mother of a child with SN I find your post to be very ignorant and unsympathetic.

This is your niece and you sound totally detached from this.

As coppertop said working with a child with SN and actually being the parent of a child with SN day to day is totally different.

The description of your day with your niece sounds like a typical day with my son who has SN agruing with his litle sister and getting into mischief.

You say"your children have started to ask that we do not invite these children in our home"

"These children "

How lucky you are to have such well behaved children.

coppertop · 05/03/2007 23:17

If she had bleach on her clothes then I would say it was pure luck that none of it soaked through to her skin and not a case of her being "very careful not to spill it on her skin".

Swipe left for the next trending thread