Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

in expecting my bil to punish his child for her distructive and violent behaviour?

62 replies

williamsmummy · 05/03/2007 22:39

one of my nieces was in my care for the afternoon. She is develpmentally delayed and is 10 yrs old, and will go to a special school in september.
I am fully aware of this and have worked with children who are often much younger in there head than years.
However, it seems that there are no boundries in this family. I respect and agree that any form of corperal punishment is not a way forward. However that seems to be an excuse not to have any rules.

Well apart from the children having complete control of daddy.

This 10 yr old child , was rough and voilent with a 3 yr old guest, waiting until i left the room to do this. shoving and throwing things at this child.

Smacked my 8 yr old daughter because she didnt want to play her game, with her.

tried to slap my other nephew around the face, but being quick of foot she missed.

Then to cap it all, she spilt 1/2 litre bottle of bleach all over my bathroom floor, staining my bath mats, and being walked across my landing.

She lied about it to our faces, until I pointed out that she was the only child with bleach stains on her clothes.
We did check her for any harm to her hands, but she was very careful not to spill any of it on her skin.

The other neice 9yrs sulked all day because my daughter didnt want to play her games. At least she was quiet.

My BIL decided that as a punishment he would take the children home early, but that was what the children wanted to do anyway.
I didnt have the guts to mention the violent behaviour , as we did try some years ago, and he wouldnt accept that our son prevoked his daughter, ( and implication that he deserved it)

A couple of hours later BIL rang hubby and said he had a little chat with daughter , who had told him that it was only a small amount of bleach, so no harm done.

This man sees his children through rose coloured glasses. They have no respect for many adults , there father ( who she does smack as well) or any children that come in her way.

My children have started to ask that we do not invite these children in our home.

recently, they have broken a double glazed window, lost some parts of my sons toys , and where caught putting glasses of blackcurrent squash on full heat in my microwave. ( but that story is for another moan!!)

I want my hubby to say something , but he is right in saying that he will never listen to us. so I am at a loss at what to do.

We have been pressured in to going to his home on mothers day, the whole family will be there, but I am sick of my children being smacked by these children. I have told hubby that one incidence of violence or controling behaviour and I will pack up my children and leave.

I never let my children bully other children, why should i let them be builied, but a child who may have learning difficulties, but is aware of what she is doing and needs rules and boundries.

end of rant.

thank you.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ilovesooty · 09/04/2023 23:30

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Previously banned poster.

Go away. Reported.

Thcc · 09/04/2023 23:29

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Previously banned poster.

Pixel · 07/03/2007 11:48

Well I'm torn on the 'not blaming everything on SN'. My sister thinks I'm not strict enough with ds because I appear to be letting him get away with a lot of things, but like Jimjams I have to ignore certain behaviours otherwise he just does them more. Also he doesn't always understand that he is being 'naughty' or just downright annoying!

On the other hand, he is almost 7 and does have a sense of humour. He will often do things that he knows he shouldn't to see if he can get away with it. He clearly finds himself very amusing in these situations and I have to stop myself from laughing and look very strict. I'm sure that like any other child he is perfectly capable of being a pain just for the sake of it. If someone was looking after him I would expect them to be able to tell him "no" and then remove him from the situation, not just ignore him on the grounds that he 'can't help it'. How else will he ever learn? Of course, I would also expect them to be supervising him!

Jimjams2 · 06/03/2007 19:03

But if they hit they would understand why they shouldn't. DS1 (7 SLD) pinches me around the neck, ds3 (aged 2 but NT) copies him- I deal with both incidents differently- I have to. In fact I don't tell ds1 off- he doesn't understand being told off, but likes the funy voices and responses people use when they tell him off- so telling him off means he does it again. And again. And again. He's doing it for interaction anyway- so I ignore him -completely, and turn away from him- that way he doesn't get reinforced for it. DS3 has better language development than ds1, and a better understanding of rules and what being told off means, so I do tell him off.

Agree with socci- learning difficulties are not separate from the child. Children with learning difficulties are not "like a 2 year old". DS1's language expression measures at below 12 months- his understanding is above 12 months but below 2. Yet he can pick out a trapezium and a hexagon, and if you tested him on an ability t match cars with people having seen them for 10 minutes a year previously he would score better than any adult. You can't say he's "like a 2 year old" or whatever because he charts all over the place.

Socci · 06/03/2007 18:52

Message withdrawn

kimi · 06/03/2007 18:51

If OPs children hit back i bet they would be told off.

kimi · 06/03/2007 18:49

Yes JJ2 DS1 can entertain himself, in fact he has a better social life then me or he has his nose in a book, (has the reading age of 15 so I am always having to check books are suitable).
The point I was trying to make is SN or not children need boundaries and OPs BIL needs to accept that if he is leaving his child in someone else's care and she brakes things then at least he could offer to replace them.
Ok the little girl is 10 but behaves much younger, does that mean you would not tell a 3 year old off?

Socci · 06/03/2007 18:42

Message withdrawn

misdee · 06/03/2007 18:19

you see i am torn. on one hand i think its great that you have looked after your neices to give BIL a well deserved rest, but the bleach thing worries me.

is there any way you can look after your neices but also enlist the help of some other grown ups when you have al lthese children over? so yout BIL gets some rest from caring, but you can also feel secure knowing that you have extra people helping?

kittywaitsfornumber6 · 06/03/2007 18:16

Williamsmummy poor you it sounds like an absolute nightmare for you and your children. I think you are not being unreasonable.
I think though that you should seriously consider not doing this sort of child care either. If the girl has such needs that she is being excused this behaviour because of her needs then her father should not be leaving her for such long periods. It is not fair on anyone.
It sounds as if your bil has no regard for you and your family. Perhaps if he should ask you in the future to look after her you should say that you don't feel that you can cope and cannot provide her with the care and supervision she obiously needs she needs.

Chocolate1000 · 06/03/2007 18:04

How can you punish a child with SN anyway if they have developmental issues? Surely they won't understand what they're being punished for so it won't have any deterrent effect?

I agree with the other posters, 11 children is too many - IMHO I would insist that one of their parents stayed with them to help supervise. Children generally tend to start bullying when they're at a loss to know what to do but this may not apply to a SN child (I don't have one so I can't comment).

At the end of the day, you're the adult. If you don't want your nieces around your house, then don't have them but do offer your BIL some sympathy for heaven's sake. It sounds like he needs support more than you do.

Alan · 06/03/2007 17:59

my daughter has a global delay and if I punished her an hour, or even 10 minutes after the event she would have NO idea what she was being punished for. That is why her BIL didnt do it

I dont think it is acceptable for 1 person to look after 11 children, 1 who has significant needs anyway fwiw

Jimjams2 · 06/03/2007 17:52

Been thinking about how to explain this- kimi- presumably as your son is bright there are things he can do with his free time off his own bat- eg play a computer game/read a book/play with lego/play on gameboy etc. This may not be true of a child with learning difficulties. DS1 for example can do nothing alone. Not even watch TV - except for a very limited period. He can't read, he can't play on game boy, he doesn't understand how to play with trains for example, he can't draw..... So unsupervised he fiddles with doors, raids the fridge, climbs on high places and looks for someone to pinch to get an interesting reaction to liven up the day. ie because of his learning diffculties he needs that constant supervision and guidance 1:1.

This girl may not have such severe learning difficulties, but she will have the same sort of problems regarding entertaining herself, and having language to express problems etc.

Jimjams2 · 06/03/2007 17:39

yes but the behaviour/understanding of a child with learning difficulties is different from the behaviour of a child the same age without learning difficulties. That's why so many courses for parents of children with learning difficulties are on challenging behaviours- it goes with the territory and is difficult to deal with- which is why parents need lots of help. Poor social skills is a different ball game from learning difficulties. Having tourette's is different form having learning difficulties. One reason ds1 will get into mischief if unsupervised is because he doesn't have the skills to entertain himself at all- hence walls get drawn on, or bottles of washing up liquid get emptied throughout the entire house. With someone engaging him that doesn't happen. He never blames his behaviour on learning difficulties as he doesn't know he has any!

The clinical psych came to visit me to help with ds1's challenging behaviours. In front of her he climbed on top of the freezer, pinched me, and generally gave a good display of his problem behaviours at the time. She said there was no point coming to see me again as I was using the correct responses, she would leave me her phone number so I could use her to bounce ideas off, and that unfortunately the things we were dealing with were part of the territory- we could sort some of them, but they would come back, and/or be replaced by something else (as I already knew). Challenging behaviours are responded too appropriately most of the time as we've had training in dealing with them, but it doesn't make them go away.It's just a case of making sure they[re not escalated by an inappropriate response (like shouting in ds1's case- shout at him and you've got that behaviour to deal with for months as he desperately tries to get you to shout again).

BigCookLittleCook · 06/03/2007 17:33

OK maybe I am wrong about bleach and older children. I only have DS, who is just a year, so have no experience of how responsible older children can be. I just know that if any child, my own or someone else's, managed to drink bleach in my house under my care I would never forgive myself. DH is crap at putting the cupboard locks back on and I am forever telling him off...

kimi · 06/03/2007 17:24

JJ2 my son has tourettes and the social skills of a dead mackerel.
And sometimes he will do something just because he is a 10 year old and they all play up sometimes but try's to blame it on the tourettes. Sometime he does not take others feelings in to account or see their point of view, that he can not help, but if he does something wrong he gets punished, he (like all children)need to know what is right or wrong and what the boundries are

Jimjams2 · 06/03/2007 17:17

kimi- your son doesn't have learning difficulties though does he? Emptying things (luckily for us its always been washing up liquid rather than bleach), hitting other children and adults just goes with the territory of learning difficulties. Of course it should be dealt with, but it is not safe to assume that a child with learning difficulties should understand not to do it, or as CT said earlier, be able to control their impulses. The only way to prevent that sort of behaviour- or deal with hitting in a timely fashion is to supervise.

WM- if you can't cope with seeing them then don't. There are plenty of people that I would never visit with ds1 (and therefore don't visit!) because I know they couldn't cope with it. There are very few people that I would leave looking after him (other than paid, trained helpers, my Mum, and my in laws for short periods or with help from DH).

kimi · 06/03/2007 17:08

I would refuse to look after the children again, and not invite them to your home at all.
I have a 10 year old with SN and he is a lovely child, but like all children he can go to little sh*t mode, he gets punished.
I hate parents who use SN as an excuse for EVERYTHING.

sunnysideup · 06/03/2007 16:52

williamsmummy, I think you need to take control here - what you're describing sounds a very chaotic household, with all these kids around and out on the streets, and your BIL and SIL neglecting to supervise adequately.

Don't leave kids in their care in future.
Don't ever have them all round at once; if you have lots of kids already, and a neighbour comes to play, say no.

You can't care for all these kids safely, and you do have the power to take control.

Saturn74 · 06/03/2007 16:04

I think you should stop looking after your nieces at your house.
I find it very concerning that your BIL believes his children are being looked after in a caring and understanding way, but from your posts it would appear that you have very negative feelings towards these children.
These negative feelings will doubtlessly have an impact on how you treat these children, and how you behave towards them.
It also appears that you know that your neice has developmental delays, but make no allowances for them.
The bleach incident could have caused serious injury. You should be relieved that the only casualties were your bathroom mats, TBH.
It doesn't seem fair for any of the children - yours or your BIL's - for this child care arrangement to continue.

Alan · 06/03/2007 15:44

how do you know I have no idea what real neglect is? massive assumption there love

williamsmummy · 06/03/2007 15:37

My Sil has similar problems with our nieces when they visit her home. But we are aware that any gentle chat over the children with BIL will be taken as knocking his parenting skills.
He doenst give himself credit for the good stuff he has done, and takes to heart any thing we say. we think the best way forward is as I have previously posted.
But this will have to be checked out with BIL first, as he is not comfortable with this ,as he feels his children should never be made unhappy in any form. which is understandable.

As for leaving the children with uncaring adults, well, they were looking after their OWN children in the house.
I spent the whole day looking after them , except when I went to the docs.

As for neglect Alan, I have seen first hand what neglect really is, and you have no idea what that is.

I also have a child with different special needs, that needs protecting, however I havent mentioned that aspect of our lives, as I wanted a opinon on these children.

OP posts:
Bozza · 06/03/2007 15:31

As I understand it her SIL is not married to her BIL - they are presumably both her DH's siblings. The mother of the 10yo who is the BIL's DD is not on the scene. the 10 children are all cousins.

Bozza · 06/03/2007 15:30

I have bleach in a kitchen cupboard without a lock on. My DCs are 6 and 2.

tearinghairout · 06/03/2007 15:23

Williamsmummy - just wanted to say that you have my sympathy. Sounds like a big headache. I have nothing to suggest, excpet try to limit numbers - ten children sounds too many at once if one has 'challenges'.

Certainly, communication is the key, with child and BIL. Also need to patiently explain to DH why certain plastic cups can't go in the microwave. I don't know why women can learn these things & men can't. Mine still puts non-dishwasher stuff in the dw, despite me explaining what can & can't go in.