Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to use a baby sleep consultant?

34 replies

MumsyH · 07/03/2017 20:29

13 month dd's sleep has gone from bad to worse. Nowhere near self settling, slept through once a month ago and ever since has been waking screaming in the middle of the night for up to 3 hours.
I'm at the end of my tether. Husband does nights and I work so often on my own then have to face the day on no sleep..
I've tried sleep training to an extent but cant cope with cio and she will not even slightly entertain anything else as just goes mental.

I feel like getting a consultants help would mean I've failed really. Everyone else seems to manage fine and I guess we must have done something wrong somewhere..

Has anyone gone down this route and was it a)worth the expense and b) was it at all successful? (same question I guess really)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Gjanduja · 19/01/2023 16:02

Can i ask who you used?

AbigailPriest · 19/03/2017 20:09

Hire a sleep trainer! My 5m old was sleeping in less than 48 hours, all on her own. No dummy, no feeding to sleep just in her bed all on her own.
I highly recommend Great Expectations Maternity, it's all in home support and they have a 100% success rate. They are based near Bury St Edmunds but travel.

Whatsername17 · 08/03/2017 08:40

People shouldn't judge, period. There is nothing wrong with parents needing sleep. It's not like your baby sleeps 6 hours through the night and you want 10. Ignore any judgement.

Writerwannabe83 · 08/03/2017 07:48

mumsy - I found the basic package quite sufficient but that's because me and DH had hit the point where things HAD to change and our resolve was strong. We knew we'd stick to her plans with absolute conviction so we didn't feel like we needed regular support and guidance. She discussed various methods of sleep training, ones which have very quick effect (controlled crying) and the more gentler ones that can take weeks and I imagine that people taking the slower approach would need more than just the basic package as they'd probably need regular follow-ups and evaluations etc.

Because we started to see improvements within a few days (and complete success within a week) the basic package was fine for us. From what I recall though she did send me an email about 10 days after our initial phone call just to check that everything had gone to plan and I imagine if I'd said we were still struggling she'd have offered us more support but it wasn't needed as DS was fixed by that point.

People who criticise those who use sleep consultants seem to think parents are only doing it for themselves (I.e we are shattered) but they seem to forget that sleep is so, so important for a child's development and sleep training is beneficial for the child too. By the end of the week of training my DS was getting about 4 hours more sleep every 24 hour period than he'd previously been having which is really significant. He was such a happier baby for it and me and DH became much happier people too.

StrawberryMummy90 · 08/03/2017 05:23

Mumsy drop her an email and she'll get in touch and talk you through the packages to see which is best suited to your baby

Chocwocdoodah · 07/03/2017 23:37

You are not a failure at all. Sleep management is bloody hard work and I think HVs should be trained in all the different methods so they can offer better advice than just "CIO".

What I would say is, a)as PPs have mentioned, you need to look at your baby's whole day. Day time naps have a massive effect on NT sleep. An overtired baby will sleep really badly at night, for example. B) sleep training does not automatically mean CIO - there are so many different methods.

Personally I loved the Baby Whisperer. Her methods are, as she says, "middle of the road" - not too tough, not too soft and I genuinely believe her pick up/put down method not only taught my DD to self settle but taught her to feel confident that mummy was always there to help and comfort her but independent enough to settle herself, if that makes sense. And I really saw that effect ripple throughout her behaviour in the early years. I know some parents swear by it but I think some forms of CIO can cause clinginess and fear of abandonment. Most sleep training inevitably involves tears but there's a big difference between staying throughout the crying and walking away. I did try CIO as recommended by my HV and it was horrific. Cried herself hysterically to sleep and for a long time after, she screamed whenever I left her at any time of day.

My issue with DD was that weirdly she slept well once asleep but getting her settled was a bloody nightmare of hrs of rocking for every nap and bedtime. 3 days of PUPD and she was self settling. It was a bloody life-changing miracle.

Anyway, your sanity and sleep are so important so do what works for you and good luck.

MumsyH · 07/03/2017 23:21

I think ill just go for it! Feel ready to try anything to be honest.
Nicola Watson looks pretty good. Which package would you recommend?

OP posts:
CluelessMummy · 07/03/2017 23:16

I have started using one as of yesterday and just having a goal to work towards is a huge relief (even though obviously it's had no effect yet!) Yes other people manage without, but they are not you and not living your life. If you have reached the end of your rope then of course YANBU.

Raaaaaah · 07/03/2017 23:09

We have used a sleep consultant for our 3rd DC. The others were nowhere near as rubbish at sleeping. It has vastly improved her sleep. We were on our knees. I have had a couple of slightly arsey comments from friends but honestly I could not give a hoot. We didn't leave her for more than 3 minutes and that was only twice. It all felt very gentle and she needed sleep as much as we did.

Derlei · 07/03/2017 23:03

Thanks Writer and Strawberry - really useful info!!
Might need it one day Wine

nextchapterplease · 07/03/2017 22:58

If you can afford it just do it !
We used Ann Caird.
Honestly we both wished we had just done it sooner.
As PP have said the exhaustion meant we weren't really able to follow through on good intentions but our daily chats with Ann kept us sane and focussed .. it was such a relief
Good luck

verite · 07/03/2017 22:20

I tried millpond and it didn't work for our DS. But I know others had success with them so I think it was more that we had a particularly stubborn child!

Writerwannabe83 · 07/03/2017 22:04

Grin @ £90 a week.

It was £90 for the email contact and the phone call Consultation.

The general gist was that if I felt I wasn't getting anywhere with the service provider in the basic package then I could always go up to the next level package and just pay the difference.

The issues I had though were the relatively common ones: would only sleep if breast fed to sleep, no naps in the day, unable to self settle and waking about 4 times a night. They were all simple things that could be changed with new routines and sleep training and so it wasn't anything that required face to face contact really because it's easy enough to discuss over the phone. We implemented her strategies the following day and within a week all our problems were solved.

Steviea88 · 07/03/2017 21:49

Oh that's not bad then. I'm going to have a look!
Thank you.

I'll have a look into both, I think the millpond was quite a bit more expensive

StrawberryMummy90 · 07/03/2017 21:43

stevie wouldn't of gone near her if it was £90 a week Grin lol can't remember exactly how much it was but around £200 for the 6 week package which seemed dear at the time but the results were worth triple that amount! Lol was definitely the best money we spent.

www.childsleepsolutions.co.uk/about-us/

That's her website if you want to have a look. I looked in to millpond as well at first but I chose Nicola and am so glad I did!

Whatsername17 · 07/03/2017 21:37

With dd1 we did a form of controlled crying. We settled her, kissed her and left the room, waited 1 minute before returning and settling her again. We never left her crying, and always returned when she cried (after 1 minute). No talking, just shhhhh and tummy rubs. It took two hours the first night, by the end of the week it took 5 minutes. The key is consistency. Once you start you have to persevere.

Steviea88 · 07/03/2017 21:36

Sorry to jump on and ask lots of questions. But was it £90 a week for her or was your package £90 for the 6 weeks.
I didn't really think a phone consultation could work but it seems it has for quite a few of you and my friend too. I think she used millpond sleep clinic has anyone heard or dealt with them?

StrawberryMummy90 · 07/03/2017 21:29

Child sleep solutions do different packages I don't think face to face is an option although can't remember. I purchased a 6 week package that involved a thorough phone consultation, Nicola then explained in detail all the different training methods going from gentle to CC, once you choose which one you want to implement she writes up a detailed plan for your child's day/night including when to feed, nap, wake from nap, go to bed, wake in morning etc. She also sends a step by step guide to your training method of choice and is there for 6 weeks whenever you need her day or night with any questions/worries or if it's not working you can review what you're doing and change things around a bit etc.

She also gave general advice about bedroom setting, lighting etc.

I feel so bad when I read how mothers are on their knees with exhaustion, I've been there and it's awful. Thankfully majority of the time it is completely fixable with dedication and consistency!

Writerwannabe83 · 07/03/2017 21:24

derlei - yes, £90 was that basic package.

It started off with her emailing me a really detailed questionnaire asking about all the problems I had with DS, what methods we had tried to address them, what types of parenting styles myself and DH had, asking about the very specific details of DS's daily routines and then she asked for a week long history of his exact sleeping patterns. I emailed her all the information that she asked for which she used to devise a plan as such and then a few days later she phoned me and the entire Consultation was done over the phone and lasted about 2.5 hours. We discussed all the different sleep training methods, what method we felt was best and then she created a very detailed step by step plan as to how to deal with all our problems.

She changed his entire daily routine, I.e what times I should feed him and put him down for naps etc and she completely changed his bedtime routine and went through all the theory behind the changes in relation to good sleeping behaviours. She gave me a set instructions on how to address his night wakings and me and DH did absolutely everything we were told and the results were phenomenal.

Steviea88 · 07/03/2017 21:24

14 months not 24

Steviea88 · 07/03/2017 21:22

YADNBU I am looking into doing the same. Dd2 is 24 months and has never slept through it is so so draining. She goes to bed at 7pm fidgety and moans till about 10.30 then is up till 1 back down waking every 40 mins moaning then up to start the day at 5am. It gradually catches up with you and I walk around like a zombie most days.

I spoke to a friend yesterday who has used a sleep therapist for her 17 month old who does is all over the phone and she said after 2 weeks he now sleeps through but still starts his day at 4am so that is what they are trying to work on now. He was a terrible terrible sleeper but this woman costs a lot of money and I can't really see how someone giving advice over the phone who has never met your child can help. But it isn't controlled crying.

Is child sleep solutions over the phone or do they visit the home does anyone know? I'm fed up of my bags and would happily give a kidney away for a full 6 hour sleep.

StrawberryMummy90 · 07/03/2017 21:21

I'm pregnant with DC2 and planning on doing exactly the same! Haha

Writerwannabe83 · 07/03/2017 21:18

Writer....she's amazing isn't she!

She was amazing!!!!!!
Our phonecall Consultation was about 2.5 hours long as she was so thorough. I will never, ever forget how much she saved me and I will be forever grateful to her.

My DH was really reluctant at first but he soon agreed that it was the best £90 we'd ever spent Grin

I'm currently pregnant with DC2 and plan to start implementing her routines and strategies from a few months old to prevent my life becoming the sleep related hell that it was with my DS (he's almost three now).

Derlei · 07/03/2017 21:15

"@Writer" - sorry to hijack but is that the basic package you went for? Does she give advice over the phone and offer support/advice while you implement the rules, as opposed to face to face?

CeCeBloomer · 07/03/2017 21:10

Don't feel a failure! Everyone I know has used one and I found that dd seemed to magically improve everytime I was about to call one