Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

party bags at school

41 replies

maisym · 02/03/2007 22:27

Today was cleaning teeth and healthy eating day at pre school & my dd3 had to take in a wash bag with toothbrush & paste plus a healthy snack.

She comes home with a sweet filled party bag (half gone) as there was a birthday in the class. The parents had made party bags for all in the class and they'd been handed out to the children.

It was also healthy day at school & my dd3 had taken some yogurt in - but instead no one had anything healthy just choc cake for the birthday. Her yogurt had to go in the bin as it had been in the warmth all day.

I just hate it that little kids are given bags filled with sweets & parents not asked - even more so that is was healthy eating day - ahhhh!!!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ificouldturnbacktimee · 09/11/2022 20:07

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

gingermonkey · 03/03/2007 16:51

At christmas at my DD's school, loads of the kids brought in presents for everyone. Now, I do the teacher and if she mentions a special friend I'll give her a fiver to choose something, but the whole class????!!!! One of the girls had even made crackers to put sweets in. I can't be arsed with all that! If it ever comes to a time where my daughter needs to buy the friendship of other kids with fancy presents or to boost her popularity that way she'll be sat down and told that they are not the kind of friends you want! Obviously it's mostly for the parents benefit but it is all very unecessary, isn't it?

whiffywarthog · 03/03/2007 16:20

my dd isn't old enough for school, so i'm out of my depth here.

but my opinion - this is getting totally out of hand! ok, so there's competition as to who sends home the best party bags. and now that's not good enough - you've got to inundate the whole class at school too??? come on! a cake? fine. but a bag of sweets for each dc? totally ott imho.

maisym · 03/03/2007 15:45

emmylou - not sure on the set up for the party - think the parents will do some experiments to amaze the kids.

Am interested to find out.

thanks for all your replies.

OP posts:
ellceeell · 03/03/2007 11:26

maisym - the parents want to send in whole party bags and / or cake - it makes's up for not inviting the whole class to parties apparantly.

Fonk · 03/03/2007 11:10

would be unimpressed and peed off, tbh

I have always stated anyway that ds is not to be given stuff like this. the colourings/sugar send him loopy and most of these sweets have gelatine, and so are not vegetarian.

don't really get how boiled cow hoof with a bit of coal tar extract and aded aspartame could be seen as a treat.

fortunately he is now at a poncey nursey where such foods are not given out.

Budababe · 03/03/2007 11:10

We bring in a cake on birthdays - my DS usually doesn't eat it as "it had jam Mummy" in a world-weary disgusted tone.

Had yummy choc cake yesterday tho for his friend's b-day - I know as his Mum is a friend of mine and made extra! Very yummy in fact.

I don't have a problem with it. They have the cake at second snack time which is in the afternoon. Having had a school-provided healthy snack and lunch already. I wouldn't be happy with sweets but my DS prob wouldn't like them anyway. Do agree that party bags is completely OTT.

Went to a party this week and the bag consisted of a little notebook, pencil and rubber and Kinder Hippo biscuit. DS ate biscuit and had actually used other stuff all week.

(He has now decided to collect Party Bags!!! Just the actual bags I think! He also wants to collect Pez containers - told him he is a bit late to make his fortune on that one!)

newlifenewname · 03/03/2007 11:10

Yep! If your birthday was going to be in hols(mine usually falls in feb half term) you get your cake moment the week before break up.

I must say it seemed quite magical back then...

EmmyLou · 03/03/2007 11:08

What's a science party? Is it held in your home???

maisym · 03/03/2007 11:05

loved all things bright & beautiful & morning has broken.

what a splendid idea - bet everyone loved it when it was their turn. Did kids with birthdays in the hols get a chance as well?

OP posts:
newlifenewname · 03/03/2007 11:02

At my primary school some 20 odd years ago they used to have a battered old 'fake cake' which would be wheeled out in assembly complete with candle for all the birthday children of that week to come up, blow out the candle together and be sung Happy Birthday by the whole school.

Better than All Things Bright and Beautiful as I recall...(is that the title of that one??)

maisym · 03/03/2007 11:01

good idea emmy - hope they all have lots of fun.

my dd will be going to a science party in a few weeks - they'll do some experiments - goodness knows what will be in the part bags!!!

OP posts:
EmmyLou · 03/03/2007 10:54

Top tip for older girls: DD2's party is next weekend - half a dozen 7 and 8 year old girls, at home with a lovely pottery painting lady who helps them paint a bowl each - this then goes off with said lady to be glazed and a few days later bowl presented to each child - party activity AND party bag in one!

Yeah, OK, I might sneak a chocolate bar in too...

Whole class idea is frantic anxiety madness.

maisym · 03/03/2007 10:48

agree mb & emmy - it's a bit like hallowean that's now a huge sweet fest.

Must say I've never sent in party bags - mainly as it's such a hassle - all the class plus the kids who come for the party. Also my bags for the party ,have a maze, a slice of cake & a lolly (probably disappointing for the kids)

OP posts:
maisym · 03/03/2007 10:44

agree on the carrot cake - it is as rich & sugar loaded but it's just different to the huge choc cakes that are always brought in.

In fact there's a kid in the class who's allergic to milk products & is left out from cake. When it was my turn I checked with his mum & the teacher & brought in a cake everyone could enjoy. I didn't make it but got it from the supermarket as his mum was worried.

OP posts:
EmmyLou · 03/03/2007 10:43

This really bugs me at our school too. Don't know when this 'tradition' began. I know it's a bit nanny-ish of me but my heart sinks (OK, not very low) when they come out of school clutching a little bag of haribo or something because it was someone's birthday or a child has returned from holiday.

Once they get to secondary school, parental control of this sort of thing goes out of the window anyway but until then....(cue manic control freak cackle etc)

I think it does send mixed messages. I'd have no problem with a slice of cake - more befitting of a birthday and celebratory. But cheapo sweets? Its a bit of a non-gesture really.

Blandmum · 03/03/2007 10:43

at the risk of being branded a real sour puss and grumpy face over this , why send anything in?

Isn't this all part of the relntless over inflating of birthdays that we seem to be doing atm.

When I were a nipper, back in the Dark Ages, you wnet to a party in someones house, ran round, played pass the parcel and came home with a bit of birthday cake in a napkin, and thought that you had died and gone to heaven.

then came the party bag, then came parties at play zone, and entertainers. Now I read that people are sending stuff into school, I assume as well as the party, more party bags etc etc.

Am I alone in thinking that this is all rather OTT? where will it all end?

I don't think anyone should send anthing into school on the day, be it sweets of home ground wheatmeal fibre bars! Don't kids already have enough, and to be blunt, don't we all have better things to do with our time than to shop for more junk?

Disgusted Martianbishop

newlifenewname · 03/03/2007 10:36

I get what you are saying but... (and this bit is a general comment not directed towards you - you just made me think of it)...

What is it with the virtuosity of carrot cake? Cake is cake! obv. it is healthier if made of carrot and not choc but fgs! this gets to be almost, ummm....pious. Spelt pie-ous.

I'm off for a plastic hob nob from the homecorner...

maisym · 03/03/2007 10:32

can see both sides (thanks to mumsnetters for this)

what gets me was that it was healthy eating day & it was all stopped to have cake & sweets. Everything in moderation is fine - could have been a carrot cake (just as rich as choc) but at least different to the choc, sweet junk handed out to the little kids.

OP posts:
newlifenewname · 03/03/2007 10:32

I love blueberries but have you noticed the price difference between that and a slice of battenburg? A good example of healthy as the unaffordable choice.

Jammie dodgers, bar of choc, vile lollies, all cheaper than a small tub of blueberries.

Very, very wrong....

Blandmum · 03/03/2007 10:28

I don't think it is a good idea to hand out party bags in school. If you must then they should be given out at the very end of the day.

The last thing kids need in school time is loads of sugar and E numbers.

No-one does this at my kids school.

Party bags are given out at the end of the party.

Ali5 · 03/03/2007 10:25

We had this dilemma at our school. We figured with 30 children in the class you're looking on average at sweets/choc things being handed out almost every week. As part of our Healthy Eating theme we asked parents what they thought and many said they'd be relieved not to have send stuff in on their child's birthday! We took the step of saying if parents wanted to send a token in for their child's class it should be healthy (or not food at all) but we would always make a fuss of the child anyway on their special day. Think your school is being a bit hypocritical and giving out mixed messages! Might be worth having a word with some other parents and see what they thought and then having a quiet word in the teacher's ear.

DimpledThighs · 03/03/2007 10:22

well I don't send anything in for birthdays but if you want to what can you send it that is healthy to share out? Blueberries?

newlifenewname · 03/03/2007 10:19

When my children had birthdays in France their French school tradition was to bring bought cake in to share at break time.

It was never an 'issue' here. I really detest the British healthy eating nannying... The French seem to have a little of what they fancy and afaik have less of an obesity problem. They also received school meals that could realistically pass as good food.. No fuss, no over stipulation, no problem.

maisym · 03/03/2007 10:14

ellce - do you mean they want to give sweets & cake or that they want it stopped completely?

OP posts: