Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

..in thinking this isn't a fair method of discipline?

155 replies

yorkshirelass79 · 02/03/2007 13:32

Message withdrawn

OP posts:
dejags · 02/03/2007 13:38

How very Hogwarts.

Seems strange, a note to the Head might be in order? Personally, at the age of 9 I'd leave the school to their own forms of discipline though.

sykes · 02/03/2007 13:37

My dd's school does this and they all lost a point once in her class because of bad behaviour at lunch. Has only happened once in three years and she does love getting points for either academic work/sports/being kind/helpful etc. If it happened a lot - taking points away it wouldn't be very fair but, generally, the children seem quite happy with it. My younger dd at the same school now too.

Iklboo · 02/03/2007 13:37

Think the teacher should have givin a warning first "if you don't be good I will take a house point from EVERYBODY" - after taking them from just the noisy children (if they haven't calmed down)

clairemow · 02/03/2007 13:36

doesn't sound fair, but sometimes as a teacher it's difficult if the children messing about aren't easily identifiable and there's a general mess about going on. Sometimes keeping the whole class in or whatever can work by peer pressure - your DD is cross so next time the ones who are usually good and were cross might put pressure on the others to behave better.

I wouldn't advocate this as a regular method of discipline though, as it isn't fair fundamentally.

Greensleeves · 02/03/2007 13:35

I don't approve of this either, but sadly it is quite common. I believe the thinking behind it is that the other children will be angry with the naughty ones who caused the punishment, thus putting more pressure on them to behave. A bit like prison officers turning a blind eye to the "daddy" bullying other inmates, in exchange for a degree of control over whom he terrorizes and when.