Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

..in thinking this isn't a fair method of discipline?

155 replies

yorkshirelass79 · 02/03/2007 13:32

Message withdrawn

OP posts:
Booboobedoo · 02/03/2007 15:37

Thanks EmmyLou.

I certainly don't encourage the other children to bully or 'grass up' the talkers. If it happens too often I just open the backstage door so that I can spot the culprits, but they need to learn to do it for themselves.

But the talkers do feel ashamed when the other children are exasperated that their rehearsal is interupted. They're all there because they love their drama, and all of them want to work really. It's just that some of them (when with their peer-group) are congenitally incapable of keeping quiet for more than two minutes.

I'm in quite a priveleged position, as I teach one small group at a time, and I supervise their break-time. No bullying here, ta.

Greensleeves, you may not agree with my methods, but I am emphatically not a lazy teacher. I'm a bloody good one as it goes, and I also happen to like and respect children. Unfortunately not something one can say of all teachers.

pointydog · 02/03/2007 15:33

Must admit, that's pretty essential in drama. Agree with boo on that one.

flutterbee · 02/03/2007 15:33

Well when I was at school we had the exact same reward/punishment scheme and it worked brilliantly.

Can someone please tell me how they would have solved the situation if they didn't use this method.

EmmyLouArris · 02/03/2007 15:30

I was just about to post that I completely see your point Booboobedoo. I think that your method promotes a way for the children to take resposibility on a group level and helps them to work together.

Booboobedoo · 02/03/2007 15:26

Interesting viewpoint, and one that I completely disagree with.

Greensleeves · 02/03/2007 15:23

"I tell them that I know it is unfair on the quiet ones, but that the talkers give me no choice."

I don't think I want my children to be "taught" that sort of value system, thanks.

Not to mention the fact that it's an outright whopper. Of course you have other choices. It's just lazy and unfair, and you know it, and so do the children.

Booboobedoo · 02/03/2007 15:21

I run a drama class, and without this method teaching would be impossible. They have to learn not to talk backstage, and it's a Herculean feat to get them to stop.

I tell them at the beginning of a rehearsal that if I hear anyone talking backstage the reharsal will be stopped and I will come back and find out why. If no good reason is given to me, everyone will be pulled out onto the stage and made to sit with their eyes shut in silence for five minutes.

I tell them that I know it is unfair on the quiet ones, but that the talkers give me no choice.

Any children who are worried about it either talk to me about it, or their parents do. Invariably the ones who worry are the ones who behave well, and I'm always able to reassure them and praise their behaviour.

I've found this method very successful when combined with a warning and praise for good behaviour. the children I teach are very happy. I know this, as if they weren't they'd leave! (I have a lot of competitors).

I rarely have to use this method with classes under 12 anyway.

Greensleeves · 02/03/2007 15:14

Soupy, I meant to point out a similarity in the sense of the teacher deliberately promoting discord among the children in order to use them as a disciplinary tool against one another. Prison officers exploit emnity among the inmates by turning it to their own ends.

Although having read it through it's not a great analogy at all, is it

pointydog · 02/03/2007 15:10

I think it's crap but it is reasonably common

EmmyLouArris · 02/03/2007 14:15

In my child's school, a certain type of points are awarded for good work or good behaviour. For poor work or poor behaviour these points are not removed but another type of points are given. The sum totals of these 2 things are recorded on the child's school report as well as house lists.

yorkshirelass79 · 02/03/2007 14:09

Message withdrawn

OP posts:
Caligula · 02/03/2007 14:08

If Ofsted don't like it, how comes schools do it?

robbosmum · 02/03/2007 14:00

When i was at school eons ago , i admit, the bad children were always bad,,, as a good (hmm) child i would never confront another childs' bad behaviour anyway, they were far too scary!

SoupDragon · 02/03/2007 13:56

IMO only a valid punishemtn if there's been lots of warnings and it's a last resort BTW.

SoupDragon · 02/03/2007 13:55

I think they say it's something to do with "collectve responibility". It hink DS1's class has been collectively punished for something before.

I'm not quite sure how it equates to permitting a bullying prison inmate... It's kind of the opposite in my mind - the inmates pulling together against the misbehaver.

OrmIrian · 02/03/2007 13:51

Sounds like our school - we have houses in juniors and whole-class punishments. But never removal of points from an entire house. Sounds a bit drastic. IME the whole class punishments only tend to be used by the stricter teachers and generally only in the first half-term until boundaries are established.

lockets · 02/03/2007 13:50

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

ScummyMummy · 02/03/2007 13:49

Bad teaching, imo. But if a one off thing probably a salutory lesson in life not being very fair sometimes.

Also i think these sorts of systems are often very bad for naturally well behaved children, especially if they have a bit of a perfectionistic streak or a fear of losing adult approval. They get endless streams of stars for years on end and may feel that the prosepct of losing one would constitute the crumbling of their world. If your dd is a bit like this it'll be good for her to lose a few house points now and then and realise it's not the end of the world, imo. Every child should have the opportunity to (safely) dare to be naughty and screw the consequences sometimes imo but some children get very stuck in the good role.

Greensleeves · 02/03/2007 13:47

It is lazy, as well.

yorkshirelass79 · 02/03/2007 13:46

Message withdrawn

OP posts:
Hulababy · 02/03/2007 13:45

I don't agree with whole class punishments and they are strongly disapproved of under OFSTED and LEAs, etc.

Greensleeves · 02/03/2007 13:44

That's what I meant yorkshirelass. It's a form of institutionalised bullying. It's rotten practice IMO.

kslatts · 02/03/2007 13:42

My dd's school has a similar system, but I don't think the teacher has taken points off the whole group if only a few are messing about. It does seem unfair your dd should lose a house poiunt even though she wasn't misbehaving.

yorkshirelass79 · 02/03/2007 13:42

Message withdrawn

OP posts:
Greensleeves · 02/03/2007 13:40

I think the teacher should do her own job rather than getting the other children to do it for her.

Swipe left for the next trending thread