Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

..in thinking this isn't a fair method of discipline?

155 replies

yorkshirelass79 · 02/03/2007 13:32

Message withdrawn

OP posts:
pointydog · 02/03/2007 16:54

I think, generally speaking, it is unfair practice. I don't do it in the classroom.

However, BooBoo gave one example of when the sum behaviour of teh whole group takes precedence over the behaviour of individuals. They're putting on a play, the teacher cannot be with them if she is front of stage assessing and if children choose to go to drama group I think it's A Good Thing that they learn the self-discipline of staying quiet when they have to.

kittywaitsfornumber6 · 02/03/2007 16:49

No, Bocco it doesn't. It DOES mean that you aren't in a postion of understanding when it comes to classroom dynamics and discipline. There are things that you might want to improve, think taht you can improve etc etc. but the theory and the practice are two very different beasts.

Booboobedoo · 02/03/2007 16:49

La la Greensleeves.

'Virtually everyone else' being the 20 or people who've posted on this thread, and 'defending to the hilt' being the reasonable poins I've made with no personal attack against your stance.

I shall reiterate once more: I think I've outlined a circumstance in which the method can be reasonably used. I think taking away 'points' that the children have earned is a bit rough.

I think communication with the children is the most important thing. We have group discussions in class about group etiquette and why certain rules are a good idea. Everyone gets a chance to comment, and I encourage the children to air grievances.

kittywaitsfornumber6 · 02/03/2007 16:46

Ooh no Greeny, not me .
However, there has to be a certain amount of 'c'est la vie' when it comes to schooling, especially beyond primary level. As it happens I have never agreed or done the withdrawl of any reward or point given, both as a teacher and with my own kids. I believe that once it has been earned it should be kept. You can not give out more as a punishment but you should not take away what has been given.

Boco · 02/03/2007 16:43

It's a bit lazy, and i can't imagine incredibly worthwhile as it just pisses off the good kids and makes them less inclined to try hard, and the naughty kids aren't often that bothered about merit points anyway - especially when they're all being punished equally.

What's with the argument that only people who have actually taught children of that age can really judge? Does that mean all non teachers should butt right out of their childrens education and not question anything, even if they think its crap practice? anyone with a child is qualified to judge how effective, fair, useful, damaging, rubbish, brilliant the way their child is treated. They might not be able to change it, but if its particularly rubbish they have the job of undoing and counteracting it at home.

Greensleeves · 02/03/2007 16:43

I agree with Xenia too about teaching the children that teachers are human and can mak mistakes.

It would be easier to promote this idea though if teachers were able to admit themselves that they make bad decisions sometimes, rather than defending to the hilt what virtually everyone else recognises as unfair and shoddy practice.

LittleSarah · 02/03/2007 16:40

It wouldn't bother me hugely, although it is unfair.

I remember being at school and some of the class playing up during a game of rounders and the whole class had to go upstairs and write out the alphabet over and over.

Especially frustrating for me and a couple of others who hadn't even played and had been delivering messages to teachers!

Booboobedoo · 02/03/2007 16:40

Depends how often it's happening BBS. I'm just hypothesising. (See my earlier posts for my own example).

Judy1234 · 02/03/2007 16:40

It's really important parents do. Also part of going to school is learning about the fallibility of adults, the taking the blame for things you didn't do, having a teacher you don't like and they don't like you occasionally etc. They have two teachers no one likes at the moment. I try to suggest that's good for them or to try to think of something nice to say to that teacher - you've a nice dress on today or something. My children then think I'm mad.

beckybrastraps · 02/03/2007 16:37

Hmm. If it happened that fleetingly then is it really worth that level of punishment?

Booboobedoo · 02/03/2007 16:36

Xenia: teaching the children that teachers are human?

(Not because it's you saying it btw - just nice to hear).

Judy1234 · 02/03/2007 16:34

I don't remember exactly at my children's school. They tend to get or not get them rather than having them taken away but I think they have some kind of demerit system and if you get enough of those you lose a house point and sometimes (rarely) they are applied to everyone which children know isn't fair. I just tell them life is like that. Or I suggest they be sympathetic to the teacher who might have had a row with her husband or be in a mood as we all are from time to time.

Booboobedoo · 02/03/2007 16:34

JustJAM: did this include when the children were through necessity out of the teachers sight? Even in sedentary lessons teachers have to look away sometimes, you know.

I wouldn't take away well-behaved children's points/stickers either: I think it's unfair.

I just wanted to put across a scenario where IMO/E it's a good practical device. Much better than risking punishing the wrong child.

lockets · 02/03/2007 16:32

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

beckybrastraps · 02/03/2007 16:29

At my ds's school, points awarded are never retracted. It is a big thing there.

As a teacher I have only very rarely punished a whole class, and that would only be keeping back for a short time. It is not something I like to do at all.

JustJAMtart · 02/03/2007 16:29

When I was school it was the teachers that had a lack of control that penalised the whole class, the teachers that had it nailed needed only discipline the people that were misbehaving.
As has been said it was an attempt for the masses to intimidate the few into behaving.

lockets · 02/03/2007 16:26

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

Greensleeves · 02/03/2007 16:13

So I trust when your children reach secondary age kitty, you'll be keeping your mouth firmly shut when it comes to shoddy and bad practice from their teachers?

Somehow I can't quite see that

kittywaitsfornumber6 · 02/03/2007 16:07

Yeah and I used to teach primary too [grin.] Actually skills needed in that job have stood me in very good stead over the last 8 years

Booboobedoo · 02/03/2007 16:05

kitty. I knew the mother of (nearly) six kids would understand.

kittywaitsfornumber6 · 02/03/2007 16:03

I think only those who have actually taught children of that age can be in a position to make a FAIR judgment. Sometimes as a teacher you have to do things that aren't ideal. So, it might not be fair? So what? That's life, kids have to learn to deal with that sort of stuff. For heaven's sake

Booboobedoo · 02/03/2007 15:43

Greensleeves: it's just a bit of healthy self-respect. I've seen MB refer to herself in a similar manner without anyone being snide enough to question her.

And I've had plenty say it, thanks.

Booboobedoo · 02/03/2007 15:41

Also, in reply to the OP, maybe it'd be an idea to let the teacher know how your DD is feeling if she's really upset.

I always value feedback from parents as long as it's constructive, as it helps you to get to know each child better.

(I'm sure yours could be constructive: I've just had my share of screaming loonies in my time: "WHY HASN'T LITTLE CELIA GOT THE LEAD?" etc. ).

Greensleeves · 02/03/2007 15:41

We'll disagree on this then Boobedo. Whether or not you are a "bloody good" teacher or not I have no idea. I would have thought that was for others to say.

However the practice being discussed on this thread is, IMO lazy and unfair and inherently wrong, and I would be annoyed if any of my child's teachers deployed it.

It's always amusing how a thread like this turns, as soon as one person posts who disagrees with the main consensus - all the dissenters melt away all of a sudden

KathyMCMLXXII · 02/03/2007 15:40

Interesting discussion.
I think maybe there's a difference between using this method if the sanction has immediate consequences, than if the effects are delayed. I thought the example given by the OP did sound vindictive and probably not very effective (because the badly behaved children won't care about the housepoints), but what Booboobedoo describes sounds quite reasonable IMO - perhaps it is also more likely to work because none of the kids will want the rehearsal to be over.