Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

..in thinking this isn't a fair method of discipline?

155 replies

yorkshirelass79 · 02/03/2007 13:32

Message withdrawn

OP posts:
harpsichordcarrier · 02/03/2007 20:23

why's that kitty?

kittywaitsfornumber6 · 02/03/2007 20:23

Harpsi, sorry but that's a pretty poor analogy

codswallop · 02/03/2007 19:58

yes

Greensleeves · 02/03/2007 19:28

They wouldn't believe you Pann - she's perfick, remember?

Pann · 02/03/2007 19:20

Easy. It was me driving, but teenage daughter takes the rap.

Greensleeves · 02/03/2007 19:06

Hallelujah. Common sense.

harpsichordcarrier · 02/03/2007 19:04

OK how about this for an example:
your family car is caught speeding.
the police can't tell if it was you driving, dh, or your teenage daughter
so you all get a £80 fine and 6 points on your licence
well, you know life isn't fair
nd only those who have been traffic police can comment

Booboobedoo · 02/03/2007 18:50

Ta!

'Spect I'll be on here whinging about it dragging out for a few days.

pointydog · 02/03/2007 18:48

aw booboo! ALl the best when it happens

Booboobedoo · 02/03/2007 18:47

CAM - My baby's due tomorrow, so I'm hoping for a baby werewolf.

I'll be worried if he comes out all hairy.

themildmanneredjanitor · 02/03/2007 18:46

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

LazyLine · 02/03/2007 18:45

I remember being at school and being subjected to the "if someone doesn't own up, the whole class will get detention" trick and it certainly didn't make anyone behave.

LaidbackinEngland · 02/03/2007 18:23

I think it is an 'OK' way of dealing with things ...if used very sparingly.

I can think of other examples in adult life where other people in a team might let the side down - despite the strong performance of others. Also in team sports - if the person in goal lets a goal in - the whole team have to expereince the loss .... it's a lesson in being a little bit out of control

fruitful · 02/03/2007 17:54

To the OP - are the children in your dd's class equally divided between the 4 houses? Because if so, you might point out to your dd that taking 1 point off each child makes no difference at all to which house wins at the end of term.

[cravenly avoiding the whole debate ]

iCAM · 02/03/2007 17:54

I'm upset, Greeny, you didn't notice me further down the thread when I posted earlier

You're not on the ball

pointydog · 02/03/2007 17:53

oh yes

I got it bad

iCAM · 02/03/2007 17:51

Is the hair growing on the palms of your hands pointy

Greensleeves · 02/03/2007 17:51

Hello again CAM, fancy meeting you here

pointydog · 02/03/2007 17:47

awooooooOOOOOO

itsafullmOOn · 02/03/2007 17:43

Booboobedoo, remember its a full mOOn, some people turn into werewolves,

or is it that they just can't stand being disagreed with

Greensleeves · 02/03/2007 17:29

Well put soapbox. Children do usually have a strong natural sense of justice (it can be very annoying)

Soapbox · 02/03/2007 17:28

I started a thread on a similar topic earlier this week - I don't like whole class punishments, they are ineffective and unjust.

I think it is fine to have a bit of rough with the smooth in school life - afterall we all put up with that in our adult lives. However, I think it is vitally important that whatever form of behaviour management is used, children should not be held responsible for the poor behavioural choices of others.

Children do have a natural instinct for fairness and justice - I find it sad that this instinct is so easily tossed aside becase a teacher is unable to control one or two children in their class.

Judy1234 · 02/03/2007 17:17

I think telling your child the school is always right is a fairly good principle, that you supoort the authority of the school for the greater good even if on that one occasion little Johnny was unfairly treated. Obviously within reason.

LaDiDaDi · 02/03/2007 17:00

I don't think it's very fair but I don't think it's a big deal if it happens very rarely. If it happens on a regular basis then it's worth questioning with the school as I certainly think that the well behaved children are likely to become demotivated.

kookaburra · 02/03/2007 16:55

HAven't read the whole thread (yeah, I'm lazy too...) but I think you are not unreasonable, and that this 'method' stinks.
At my DC school they have 'golden time' ie free play that they can lose as a class or individually and it incenses me when all lose because of a few recidivists. DH almost used this on our brood the other day becuase he could not determine which child was the culprit - each swore it was the otehr. i persuaded him not to do it, as the innoocent party had no control over the the other and it blatantly unfair. (Actually slight aside - it is what the government is doing to us 'good landlords' who always return deposits to tenants - making us all suffer draconian rules becasue of the baddies.)
I do tell the children that teachers are human and make mistakes - like their parents - when they are angry. If I do something unjust when I am angry I apologise and withdraw the punishment - wish teachers would do that.
BTW - I also tell them that they are bloody lucky that life is unfair, if it was fair, we would all be living in Africa and walking five miles a day to collect unsafe drinking water. That ususally shuts up the 'unfair' whine.