Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

..in thinking this isn't a fair method of discipline?

155 replies

yorkshirelass79 · 02/03/2007 13:32

Message withdrawn

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
thecranberiezzzz · 02/09/2023 23:13

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

CAM · 04/03/2007 18:03

That's what happens when the govt sets targets

Caligula · 04/03/2007 14:59

I'm never quite sure what OFSTED's role is. They appear to have carte blanche to criticise negatively without any responsiblity to set positive guidelines.

I'm always amazed when I hear about teachers using behaviour techniques which are obviously rubbish and which a cursory reading of any parenting manual would indicate was a no-no. I would've thought they'd learn positive behaviour-management techniques as part of their training, but if some of the teachers I've come across are anything to go by (to say nothing of the mumsnet horror stories), that's not the case. When you think that it's such an important part of teaching, it's extraordinary that more emphasis isn't put on it.

As for the circumstance of being able to fail a teacher because one pupil is doing badly - good grief. They seem to use exactly the same management techniques which if parents or teachers used to manage behaviour/ education, they'd heavily criticise (and rightly so). Talk about focusing on the negative.

Blandmum · 04/03/2007 11:36

OFSTED, in their infinate wisdom, don't say anything caligual. they say 'Don't do thos' but seldom, if ever give you another way of dealing with the problem.

They say 'Don't exclude' as it disadbvatages the excluded child, but don't tell you how you can deal with the child, and the disadvantage that will give to the rest of the class if they continue to dosrupt.

At the moment a lesson will be deamed to be 'unsatisfactory' by ofstead if even 1 chaild does not make progress in the lesson.

So, if you have a class of 26 kid, 25 of them work and do very well, but the 26 isn't working because he has an argument with his girlfriend. or if parent have just split up, or he has a hair up his arse for the day because he is just being a teenager, the teacher is deamed to hhave failed.

Utter arse. I'd love to put the inspector in front of the same class and say 'Show me how to do it then'

newlifenewname · 04/03/2007 10:19

To me the collective responsibility issue would be diminished in terms of its negative impact on 'innocents' if it were not bound up with the undermining of a positive reward system.

Collective punishment/consequence? - maybe. Collective undermining of haard work and achievement? - no way!

Caligula · 04/03/2007 09:46

So what do OFSTED suggest in the face of time constraints re finding out who is individually to blame?

Whoever said about the police rounding people up etc., this does actually happen in real life - especially when it comes to football matches, demos etc.

People tend not to be charged with stuff or fined on the spot, but they do get marched off to the cells for the ngiht if they happened to be in the wrong place at the wrong time.

The police always issue an apology afterwards though, and mostly people accept that mistakes happen. I think the issue is acknowlegement - that we all know in a crowd situation, you can't always be fair to everyone. But you acknowledge that you've been unfair, because of logistics.

newlifenewname · 04/03/2007 09:41

House points are like star charts aren't they? I'm not a fan of star charts but if a reward based system is used I believe that it should be an incentive focused approach rather than reward/punishment focused.

So, the child is rewarded for 'good' behaviour/success. The reward system does not morph into a punishment system via the removal of points/stars.

Removal of points undermines achievement. If a star or point has been earned then it should not be removed.

Of course a good reward based system should be backed up by positive behaviour management/discipline structures. The reward is reinforcement of positive behaviour - and should not be used to punish imo.

Blandmum · 04/03/2007 09:31

I try not to do it.

Why do teachers do it, probably despiration. If you have stood in front of a class for days or week, tried all the things you can think off an nothing has worked, then you may be desparate enough to try it.

Doesn't make it right, but teachers are human.

There are also times when 5 kids messing round can make it to dangerous for the erst of the class to do an activity....I have cancelled practicals for this reason. Not often, but I have done it because he safety of the kids is my prime concern. More often I stop specific students, but soetimes if there are lots of them mucking about, you simply don't have the time to stop each mirscreant individually.

And I'll bet that if I do this, some parent, somehwere will think that I am 'picking on' their kid. That theor kid has got a ban name, and I'm over reacting.

There are times when nothing we do is right. There you go.

Caligula · 04/03/2007 09:04

God personal insults are boring arent' they.

Collective responsibility is specifically forbidden in the adult world isn't it? Particularly in relation to war crimes etc.

No-one has answered my question: if OFSTED are so anti it, why do schools do it so often?

CAMy · 02/03/2007 22:31

Thank you

Pann · 02/03/2007 22:29
kittywaitsfornumber6 · 02/03/2007 22:29

Ooh, I see all the while that I've been feeding myself you have been having a jolly time. That's nice . We need some more smilies.

CAMy · 02/03/2007 22:27

She started it

Soapbox · 02/03/2007 22:24

Now now children. play nicely or I will get MNHQ to ban everyone who has posted on this thread!

A bit of peer pressure will teach you how to behave

CAMy · 02/03/2007 22:16

Thank you

Pann · 02/03/2007 22:11
VeniVidiVickiQV · 02/03/2007 21:49

More slanging matches?????

I missed it.

And i was right in the mood for one too.

Greensleeves · 02/03/2007 21:46

Thank you

harpsichordcarrier · 02/03/2007 21:45

oh yes you are certainly belligerent
but in a good way

Greensleeves · 02/03/2007 21:43

LOL, if she had picked just about any other insult nobody would have disagreed

"Greeny's not boring, she's a belligerent nutjob"

Is that what they call a Pyrrhic victory?

JustJAMtart · 02/03/2007 21:43

no not JARM, nor a tart

harpsichordcarrier · 02/03/2007 21:42

(is that you JARM? why are you a tart?? IYSWIM...)

JustJAMtart · 02/03/2007 21:41

lol at no biscuits

lockets · 02/03/2007 21:40

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

harpsichordcarrier · 02/03/2007 21:40

yes, and if their behaviour continues there will be no more custard creams!
let them eat arrowroot

Swipe left for the next trending thread