Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Misleading salary - pro rata

89 replies

bagpackbagpack · 24/02/2017 21:35

Doesn't even remotely effect me, but as a contractor I see this all the time as I am jobs boards a lot sourcing my next line if work.

However AIBU to think job adverts for part time roles should just state the actual pay a person will get, not however much pro rata?

It's so misleading, and doesn't make it easy to compare salaries, as pro rata could meet anything! The whole recruitment market is so under regulated in my opinion (I was recently asked by a recruiter what my childcare arrangement was and if I plan on having anymore children, like it's any their business, I am applying for a job that I feel I am capable of, my childcare or child rearing status has no impact)

Probably about 3 AIBUs here!

OP posts:
roundaboutthetown · 24/02/2017 22:41

YANBU. School support staff job adverts are particularly aggravating, as they are often term time only and part-time during those school terms. They almost never specify what full-time hours would be (in schools, this normally seems to be somewhere around 37-40 hours), nor how many weeks per year you would be counted as working - school terms are generally 39 weeks, but do you add on paid holiday time and if so, how much paid holiday? Therefore, without stating both the annual salary and the pro rata amount, it is incredibly difficult/impossible to work out what the actual pay is going to be, because they don't give enough info to work it out.

reup · 24/02/2017 22:38

I used to work freelance and we all compared rates - realised 2 of us were being ripped off so we managed to negotiate the same rate.

ElizabethG81 · 24/02/2017 22:38

WhisperedLoudest I think that's pretty disgraceful to be honest.

I'd never apply for a job that wasn't transparent about the salary. "Competitive" or "Attractive" to me = minimum wage or just above.

reup · 24/02/2017 22:36

Whispered loudest

What happens if the 2 employees ever compare salaries? What a horrible system

Bluntness100 · 24/02/2017 22:28

Is your issue then not you don't know how many hours they want or classify as part time? The salary is fairly easy maths if you know the hours.

PyongyangKipperbang · 24/02/2017 22:27

I agree that without the full time hours to use as a basis for calculations, it could mean anything.

As has been said part time pro rata for a 35 hour FT job is totally different to a 45 hour job.

CotswoldStrife · 24/02/2017 22:26

It can be confusing, but if the job isn't hourly paid then it's hard to get a feel for the salary without the full-time equivalent. I do think for some jobs it would be handy to quote the full-time rate and then the possible part-time equivalent (eg half time would be £10K).

I used to work in HR and have seen employers get it wrong as well.

jamdonut · 24/02/2017 22:25

YANBU
Teaching Assistant jobs are usually shown pro rata.Thats because the "full-time" salary looks impressive ( particularly in my area). The reality is a lot different.

WhisperedLoudest · 24/02/2017 22:24

"Competitive" is a means of not having to nail your colours to the mast and end up paying inflated salaries unnecessarily.

For example I've just recruited two employees and one is being paid 50% more for essentially the same job. We asked what they expected, provided an uplift and they were both satisfied.

If I'd advertised the salary at the lower rate the other candidate might never have applied. If I'd advertised at the higher rate I'd be paying well over what the first candidate was delighted with.

bagpackbagpack · 24/02/2017 22:21

graphista and dodo thank you for better articulating this for me, as I say it's NOT a big a problem I face, but I Look at jobs boards a lot and feel a bit uneasy about it...

OP posts:
Cel982 · 24/02/2017 22:17

The problem, then, isn't the use of 'pro rata', but the fact that the ads don't state how may hours the role involves. Which in some cases at least may be because it's negotiable.

Redactio · 24/02/2017 22:16

I think that "competitive" is a way of preventing existing employees knowing the salary that they are willing to pay.

bagpackbagpack · 24/02/2017 22:14

Obviously the advert wouldn't state pro rata twice, I give up with my iPad and slow internet connection tonight... there is even a lag on me typing. Game of frisbee with my iPad any one?

OP posts:
youarenotkiddingme · 24/02/2017 22:13

It's actually extremely useful. As I've discovered lately.

For example I work a TT only job therefore it 46 weeks a year including holidays and 30 hours a week.

I've be looking at similar jobs but for a different civil service. I've noticed that for a job with more responsibility, 37 hours a week and 52 weeks of the year it's only about 3k a year more.

So basically still a shit paid job role despite the level of work and responsibility. It's actually opens my eyes to the issues so many have with low income. General wages in the UK are shit!

LucklessMonster · 24/02/2017 22:13

pro rata could mean anything! Like I said in my op.

No, it doesn't. How do you not understand this?

dodobookends · 24/02/2017 22:12

I know what you mean OP.

Say there are two jobs you are comparing: they both say 20 hours pro rata and one is 25k whereas the other is 26k, the one for 26k looks better.

Except in the adverts they don't tell you that full-time hours for the first one = 35 hours a week, and the other = 40 hours.

Stating the actual hourly rate would make it much more straightforward to compare them.

Graphista · 24/02/2017 22:11

Yanbu

When I've been job hunting I find this SUCH a pita! Imo ALL job ads should show

How many hours in a standard week in the role
Pay per hour
Whether they pay sick pay
Overtime pay per hour

Because:

If it says pro-rata and doesn't say how many hours that's based on how the hell you meant to calculate the actual pay? Even if the ad says full time there's nothing in uk law to say what full time hours are! It's 'generally accepted' as being more than 35 up to 48 hours per week - that's quite a variation over a year!

Eg £30k pa for 35hr weeks = £16.48ph

£30k pa for 48hr weeks = £12.02ph

How many hours you work can massively affect tax credits, income tax, national insurance, childcare arrangements, benefits, does it fit in with another job/study

If all ads display pay per hour as standard that means there's an easy basic comparison for everyone to see. Makes scanning of job ads and calculating future potential income much easier, also bloody useful for online calculators eg mortgage, loans, tax credits, tax, benefits as they could standardise for this too.

Sick pay - basic info - most of us need time off sick at some point, potential employees need to know if they'll still be on full pay or on ssp as not everyone can afford to risk just Ssp.

Overtime pay per hour - if it's a job that expects employees to work overtime again this is basic info future employees need to know. Sadly it's still the case that salaried employees (especially in retail) often work considerable amounts of overtime unpaid.

bagpackbagpack · 24/02/2017 22:08

The thing is an admin role could pay between £15 and 20k where I live, full time. Why complicate things and say "Part time admin pro rata £20k pro rata"

What is part time? Is it 10 hours? 20 hours? Minimum wage?

Why not just say "10 hours per week job, X amount if money"

pro rata could mean anything! Like I said in my op.

OP posts:
BoomBoomsCousin · 24/02/2017 22:05

I can see, with so many people being under employed, that it makes it difficult to see if it's a wage you could live on. But I think it's probably the best way of showing what the role is considered to be worth.

BlueFolly · 24/02/2017 22:05

What I don't like is when an advert doesn't state a salary, and just describes it as 'competitive'. I tend cynically to think that it probably isn't

If a job has a high salary and it is stated in the job advert you get a lot more men than women applying. If a job has a high salary and the advert doesn't specify what it is you are far more likely to get women applying. That was what I was told once by a recruiter.

WankersHacksandThieves · 24/02/2017 22:03

If it isn't saying what the full time hours are then it is misleading as you don't know if it's 20 hours from 35 or 37.5 or 40 or whatever. As long as enough info is given then then it doesn't matter which way the state it though.

so, they could say it's 15 hours over two days from a 37.5 hour week at £35k pro rata.

or they could say it's 15 hours to be worked over 2 days at £14k.

in first example, if they don't say the normal hours then you could think it's 15 hours from 35 at £35k fte which gives £15k salary or over 40 hours which would only be £13,125. That would be potentially misleading.

so depends on what info is given to decide if it's unfair.

Gallavich · 24/02/2017 22:02

pro rata could meet anything

I don't get this either. Take full time salary, divide by full time hours, multiply by actual hours worked. That's what pro rata means unless I've got it completely wrong? It's very easy to work out.

flowery · 24/02/2017 22:01

"What I don't like is when an advert doesn't state a salary, and just describes it as 'competitive'. I tend cynically to think that it probably isn't."

Or £excellent/£attractive or similar. An ad is trying to attract candidates, therefore if the salary was indeed attractive they'd be clear about that, so I tend to agree with you.

indigox · 24/02/2017 22:01

YABU. Anyone mislead by this must be pretty stupid

WhisperedLoudest · 24/02/2017 22:00

It means exactly what it says Confused