Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be asked to ring in work each day when you are off sick..

161 replies

curlysmum · 28/02/2007 14:53

I have been off work for almost two weeks with this sickness bug then it developed into flu and I am off this week my second week. In my first week I rang I think 3 times to state I was ill then finally saw the doctor last Friday who took one look at me and said you need to rest and I 'm signing you off for 1 more week.
I rang my boss on Monday to tell him this put the Certificate in the post and now today he calls me at home , sounding a bit on the sarcastic side 'how are you' etc I explained all of it again he says , 'so when will you be back ' I told him next Monday and he sounded not impressed so I told him well I have sent in my Doctors certificate etc, he says well I still want you to call in each day WTF! am I a child or a 38 year old women, my dd father said I shd ring the Human Resources lady and give her a piece of my mind. By the way this is a very big American City Company who treat most women like idiots anyway, any view on this??

OP posts:
DizzyBint · 01/03/2007 09:40

get a copy of your employer's absence policy and stick to it. simple really. if you don't like it take it up with your union, or put in a grievance.

i manage absence where i work and our policy is that if you're absent you have to call in every day. if you have a sick note you don't have to call in. a lot of employees still do call in though as a matter of courtesy. employees on long term sick, ie over a month, are assigned a case manager (possibly me) who will call them at home and may even arrange home visits depending on the situation. our employees are paid while they are off sick, so yes i do expect them to conform to our policies.

Rhubarb · 01/03/2007 09:39

Lay off Xenia. I get what she's saying.
When I was signed off ill it was no bother to phone in work and let them know how I was.

However harking back to the OP, I don't think it's the actual request she is objecting to but the way the request was made, i.e. sarcastically. Plus your boss or whoever should not be phoning you at home if you are ill.

It is not law to phone work every day, but as Xenia says it costs little to do this and works favourably with your boss as it shows you are keen to return and want to keep the office informed.

themildmanneredjanitor · 01/03/2007 09:34

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Pann · 01/03/2007 09:33

yes, X, I have been a T.U. rep. for many years, and now a manager, and am aware of 'managing' peoples absence rather than letting it all just slide.

yes people do malinger, but that is no justification to bully any individual - we just appear to have diferrent notions of what is acceptable.

Judy1234 · 01/03/2007 09:27

I didn't say calling in after the second week when you're signed off for a second week was necessary actually. But it's certainly good HR practice to stay in touch - see that link from the HSE etc below. If you don't get them to call in at all then the employer is failing in their duties both to other employees holding the fort and shareholders. Employers are not charities with huge cash piles to hand out on a whim.

themildmanneredjanitor · 01/03/2007 09:25

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Ceebee74 · 01/03/2007 09:24

Pann - I am a HR peep and have to say that I agreet that I think Xenia is wrong.

Asking people to ring in everyday, particularly if they have sent in a sick note saying they will be off for another week, is bordering on harassment so it is not good HR practice at all and I would certainly not advise any managers where I work to do this.

By all means, it is the responsibility of employees to keep their managers informed but this doesn't require a daily phone call.

In terms of covering whilst they are off, if they have sent in a sick note for a week, they are not going to come back earlier so you know you need to cover that week.

Judy1234 · 01/03/2007 09:22

Come on. Loads of people malinger and a regular call system makes them less likely to. It's common sense and nothing to do with bullying.

www.hse.gov.uk/msd/campaigns/pdf/managingabsence.pdf

Employers sometimes feel that asking absent employees for
information to help them return will appear intrusive. You
may feel equally uncomfortable about talking to an
employee whose performance, combined with frequent
short-term absence, is causing you concern. Listed below
are some dos and don?ts to help you deal with these
sensitive issues.
Do:
n create a climate of trust by agreeing methods,
frequency and reasons for keeping in contact;
n consider training for your managers on a sensitive
approach to help them get the most out of contact;
n consider the timing and form of contacts and who
should make them;
n be flexible, treat each case individually but on a fair and
consistent basis;
n if your employee is able to travel, suggest they come in
to see colleagues at lunch time or coffee breaks;
n keep a note of contacts made;
n welcome your employee back to work after absence;
n carry out return to work interviews;
n give your employees the opportunity to discuss their
health or other concerns that are affecting their
performance or attendance in private;
n remember that medication can have side effects on
things like physical stamina, mood, driving, machinery
operation and safety critical tasks.

Pitchounette · 01/03/2007 09:21

Message withdrawn

yellowrose · 01/03/2007 09:18

Actually I think most have very small dicks, but are TOLD they have big ones when they get promoted

yellowrose · 01/03/2007 09:17

Curly almost ALL City companies no matter what nationality employ big swinging dicks to be bosses !

I think it is extremely strange to call an employee at home when they are off sick. It is like they are checking up on you.

Having said that if you enjoy your job and wish to keep it, be very diplomatic when you go back to work. Tell your boss you have read the off sick policy and thought that you were doing everything by the book, which you clearly are. Don't make an issue of it because he may use it as a stick to beat you with every time you are sick.

I worked in the City for years. I know what slave drivers those people are. I wouldn't go back to the City environment if they paid me twice what I earned before. I found it soul destroying.

Pann · 01/03/2007 09:14

HR peeps anywhere??

Your position, X. is absurd, oppressive and unjustifiable in any sense of what is reasonable.

but that is IMVHO.

Judy1234 · 01/03/2007 08:39

I said employees should go out of their way to please employers. It's how people who do well operate. You can choose that path or not - it's up to the individual and usually felt in your pocket and career propsects. You can play the game or opt out of it. if an employer wants you to make one call a day when you've got time to post on mumsnet and haven't lost your voice why on earth not make it. Calling in every day is a very normal wise HR practice as any HR person on here will testify to. It really does help to make people realise they are needed back at work and in a sense it shows the employer cars so just make that call.

nightowl · 01/03/2007 00:01

when i was in hospital after having my first child my boss sent flowers by post and some work with my partner.

i feel this showed my commitment to the company, what do you think xenia?

Tinker · 01/03/2007 00:00

Can you just email him instead? "Still ill. curlysmum"

Pann · 28/02/2007 23:46

Xenia. This manager is bullying her. You can't please bullies by ringing in every day. IT merely emphasises his/her right to bully her.

expatinscotland · 28/02/2007 23:33

I agree, curly, this is the UK and if they're not willing to work w/i the parameters here they have no business being here.

Sorry, but that's just f*&^ing ridiculous.

And what's your point, Xenia? Of course the employee knows the hardship caused to others whilst she's ill.

She's got a doctor's certificate, she needs to stay home and recover and stressing about work isn't going to help her.

Some people actually put health before work, however much that comes as a shock to you.

VeniVidiVickiQV · 28/02/2007 18:01

Dont offer to work from home unless they have an existing flexible working policy.

curlysmum · 28/02/2007 17:54

I'll ask the HR lady , I do understand that the US has different ideas but I am in the UK and the part of the company I work is based is London and is a UK Ltd company and I do not really see the point in me having a nosense conversation with my boss we have a very poor communication anyway and most of the time when I'm at work he does not bother to even say hello , goodbye etc or speak to me at all , oh but now I'm off all of a sudden he wants to hear my voice every day, its a joke , he's just trying to make me feel worse I think.

OP posts:
Legacy · 28/02/2007 17:40

Bibi - why cause unnecessary conflict? After all, this is someone the OP has to work with all the time. I always find being uber-helpful about things like this actually embarrassed my boss in the end....

BibiThree · 28/02/2007 17:38

PS yes, he's a dick.

BibiThree · 28/02/2007 17:38

I'd not ring and speak to HR instead. If he rings you, tell him you're sick and don't wish to be bothered at home while deemed incapable of work by a medical professional.

Legacy · 28/02/2007 17:37

Think CurlysMum needs to ask for her own company's POLICY though, as many companies (US ones I might add!) have this as a policy.

I got dragged into some absence management issues in a former life, and I know this is done because it WILL discourage people who throw sickies without real reason, however best practice is for a manager to exercise judgement and tell someone who is genuinely ill that they needn't call in every day.

Frizbe · 28/02/2007 17:34

The company I used to work for had a call every day policy, its an american thing, its good policy to let your employees know you care about their welfare by speaking with them every day!! Mind you if we had a valid sick cert then it was only once a week.

Judy1234 · 28/02/2007 17:33

In the first week as someone said having people ring in personally every day is standard and very very wise. So many people I(not you) malinger and if they have to speak to someone at work every day it helps ensure they realise the problems their absence is causing the employer and makes it harder for them to lie about things. Also if you can afford the phone bill there's no reason you shouldn't ring in, is there? Nothing wrong with pleasing employers. Good tactic as an employee. May be there is some work you can offer to do from home too once you start to get more on the mend next week.

Swipe left for the next trending thread