Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be asked to ring in work each day when you are off sick..

161 replies

curlysmum · 28/02/2007 14:53

I have been off work for almost two weeks with this sickness bug then it developed into flu and I am off this week my second week. In my first week I rang I think 3 times to state I was ill then finally saw the doctor last Friday who took one look at me and said you need to rest and I 'm signing you off for 1 more week.
I rang my boss on Monday to tell him this put the Certificate in the post and now today he calls me at home , sounding a bit on the sarcastic side 'how are you' etc I explained all of it again he says , 'so when will you be back ' I told him next Monday and he sounded not impressed so I told him well I have sent in my Doctors certificate etc, he says well I still want you to call in each day WTF! am I a child or a 38 year old women, my dd father said I shd ring the Human Resources lady and give her a piece of my mind. By the way this is a very big American City Company who treat most women like idiots anyway, any view on this??

OP posts:
beckybrastraps · 01/03/2007 14:59

Ah, so it's conservatives who are hard-working

expatinscotland · 01/03/2007 14:59

'Surely you can accept there is a huge political difference between Scotland and the rest of the UK. '

Oh, most definitely. And not just political differences, thankfully.

Oh, yes, some of the favourite people in my life come from Scotland, too .

Judy1234 · 01/03/2007 14:56

Giving women too many maternity rights damages them in terms of career and in negotiations with husbands who then make sexist assumptions about who stays home. If I advocate equal parental rights I am doing you lot huge favours, or rather, your daughters and grand daughters.

As for Scotland... what can one say? Some of my favourite men are from Scotland so I'd never do it down but how many times has it had a conservative majority - ever? Surely you can accept there is a huge political difference between Scotland and the rest of the UK. In fact more people live in the SE than Scotland. Perhaps we should have our own Parliament like the Scots in that case.

citylover · 01/03/2007 14:44

Maybe Xenia (whose posts are really very entertaining) is really Ruth Lea ex Head of the Institute of Director and now head of the Institute for Policy Studies!!

Does anyone know of her? Very right wing believes having children is no more than a lifestyle choice, very anti any equality measures because of the burden to employers blah blah!!

I say this slightly tongue in cheek of cours
but she (ruth lea) argues that

' that "the 'work-life balance' agenda for further employee rights and regulations is damaging the workplace and will damage it further", and Healthcare in the UK: the need for reform (IoD, 2000), which argued for the removal of the NHS from health provision'

And so on

and just this week we have a report from the Govt saying that mothers with young children are the most discriminated against group both in and out of the workplace.

There you are rant over!!

TnOg · 01/03/2007 14:22

I've just nearly chocked on my lunch reading this thread, unbelievable, stereotyping going on in some quarter's.

expatinscotland · 01/03/2007 14:16

'and mostly Labour supporters/ left wing in Scotland kind of thing? '

Howling with laughter! Xenia, that is the funniest thing I've read all day - and the doorman left a copy of The Sun lying around.

You just don't get it.

And you never will.

So no point wasting time even responding to you most of the time.

Purpleparrot · 01/03/2007 14:00

Some eomployers are just prats. I was signed off work for a total of 3 months after an ectopic pregnancy. I was in a lot of pain afterwards and could not sit upright or stand for any length of time plus of course I was a mess emotionally. I then had suspected heart problems and was having ECG's to check things out, medication to prevent a heart attack just in case etc etc and I get going into work every week with my sick line and every week my boss got more and more grumpy about it... "don't know how we are going to cope" grumble grumble and eventually he said just because you have a sick line from the doctor, it doesn't mean you can't come back to work anyway! Eh? i'm sorry but my the end of the leave I was bored out of my mind just wandering to the school to pick up my ds and would have liked to have done something more but if my doctor is concerned about my health and thinks I should not be at work then I owe it to myself and my ds to listen and take up that advise! I stuck it out a bit longer with that company - who were never the same after they were taken over - and I am now with a great one!

Cloudhopper · 01/03/2007 13:51

God Xenia that is an outrageous thing to say - you have certainly lit the blue touchpaper now.

What a totally ludicrous and bigoted thing to say. I'm thoroughly ashamed to reside in the South East after your bizarre comment.

Dear God woman, if you must insult people, do it in your own name, not mine as a Londoner.

sunnysideup · 01/03/2007 13:51

Xenia you should spend less time on here berating others who 'malinger' or don't live in the correct postcode for a 'work ethic' and DO SOME WORK. How much time have you lost from work this year on this chat room?

yellowrose · 01/03/2007 13:49

Anne Widdocombe - lol - but she says she has 5 kids and nanny and they all excerise all day and eat healthy food !

Sounds like Anne W with 5 adopted kids and on Weight Watchers !!

We love you really, Xenia, you make us laugh like DC makes me laugh on other threads !

Lovecat · 01/03/2007 13:44

Xenia, you are Anne Widdecombe and I claim my £10!

Are you for real?

Hard-working mentality of the South-East? I work for an international financial organisation and I've never seen so many people take sickies (or should that be hangoveries) as when I first moved down here from the NorthWest! In fact, sickness was extremely rare at home because people were terrified of losing their jobs... but then I suppose that's your ideal scenario?

I'd like to believe you're taking the michael or are just on a windup (esp. with that last comment), but I'm scared your posts are actually serious.

To the OP - your boss is an eejit. If you're signed off, you're signed off. How did you get on with your HR department?

HappyDaddy · 01/03/2007 13:43

Xenia, malingerers still have the power to call everyday, you know.

You do make me laugh.

yellowrose · 01/03/2007 13:41

That is just South East snobbery. There is no such thing as the South East work ethic. It is totally dillusional, like quite a lot of what Xenia says

littlemissbossy · 01/03/2007 13:40

I don't Xenia is lazy or blinkered - IMO she knows exactly what's she doing.
And I wouldn't be at all surprised if she was claiming to be someone she isn't. Remember Judge Flounce anyone??
Not that I'm saying she is JF, just someone like that poster.

Marina · 01/03/2007 13:36

Xenia, you do make me larf.
It is absolutely possible to be

  1. hard-working and very committed to your job
  2. active in your trade union
  3. work in the despicable public sector
  4. and stay highly motivated to providing a quality service even though you are not paid a fortune to do so

It is entirely coincidental I live in the SE, I think.

Really, generalisations like some of yours on this thread are the product of a lazy and blinkered mindset! Hardly what you'd expect an intelligent well-educated person to come out with...

littlemissbossy · 01/03/2007 13:32

"South East working hard mentality"
PUR-LEASE, don't make me laugh!
if you're so bloody hard working Xenia, how come you spend so much time on here??!!

yellowrose · 01/03/2007 13:27

Yes, work from home or become self-employed if you can. The only way for people like me who have seen the light !

yellowrose · 01/03/2007 13:24

Xenia - do you work for some extreme Right Wing think tank or something ? Sorry, but you do sound like you spout things out according to some Ring Wing agenda, rather actually THINK about what you are saying.

Judy1234 · 01/03/2007 13:18

Difference between South East working hard mentality and mostly Labour supporters/ left wing in Scotland kind of thing? Not sure. Just very different views anyway.

What most good workers would look for is whether in fact they get better sooner. Doctors are notorious for writing sick notes to keep th e patient happy. There is much written about it and they often just find it easier to sign - it's a huge problem for the nation. Not of course saying that in this case but sometimes people signed off sick for a week find they are up to work by the Wed next week and good loyal employees who feel that change would be hot footing it back into the office earlier in the week than otherwise indicated. That's all. Of course someone may well be bed ridden and very infectious etc and that's a different thing.

Yes, obviously only work from home if that's lawful etc.

yellowrose · 01/03/2007 13:18

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

expatinscotland · 01/03/2007 13:01

'Offer to do someting from home, be the best employee you can - therein lies the path to things going well'

This is oftentimes a violation of the company's insurance policy.

She has a NOTE. The note has a date on it when she will be coming back to work.

Would you expect someone in hospital to ring every day?

I cannot believe some of the posts on here, I really can't.

BibiThree · 01/03/2007 12:52

I see your point about unnecessary conflict, but if he's the awkward type anyway, she can't win being polite or not. Sometimes it's good to let off a bit of steam.

I don't understand what he wants her to say every day ..."um, yes, the Drs note still says I'm sick, like yesterday and for the rest of the week"

  • seems a bit pointless.

What did you decided to do CURLYSMUM>?

Marina · 01/03/2007 12:50

I work in the public sector and manage a small team.
I personally agree with Xenia's take on this - if off for more than a couple of days and coherent, I am happy to ring in every day to update the situation, and stay in touch with my team in a helpful fashion (eg answering queries, progressing projects by e-mail etc).
If a team member is off and not yet past the cut-off for certification, I would in fact ring to check they were OK if I did not hear from them in maybe 48 hours. I would make no reference to work/queries etc if I did though.
If a certificate was issued, I'd not be so worried to check on them for its duration.
There is a big difference between concerned courtesy and hassling people though. Your boss is bullying you curlysmum.
Love that joke Scummy.

littlemissbossy · 01/03/2007 12:39

yes thank you Xenia, I think I could have actually worked that one out myself

Rhubarb · 01/03/2007 12:36

Xenia I humbly apologise more than scummy for taking the piss. You know I love you more than she ever could!