Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be asked to ring in work each day when you are off sick..

161 replies

curlysmum · 28/02/2007 14:53

I have been off work for almost two weeks with this sickness bug then it developed into flu and I am off this week my second week. In my first week I rang I think 3 times to state I was ill then finally saw the doctor last Friday who took one look at me and said you need to rest and I 'm signing you off for 1 more week.
I rang my boss on Monday to tell him this put the Certificate in the post and now today he calls me at home , sounding a bit on the sarcastic side 'how are you' etc I explained all of it again he says , 'so when will you be back ' I told him next Monday and he sounded not impressed so I told him well I have sent in my Doctors certificate etc, he says well I still want you to call in each day WTF! am I a child or a 38 year old women, my dd father said I shd ring the Human Resources lady and give her a piece of my mind. By the way this is a very big American City Company who treat most women like idiots anyway, any view on this??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thcc · 09/04/2023 23:31

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Previously banned poster.

DominiConnor · 02/03/2007 22:07

I've seen this from the management side of things a couple of times. It's messy. Some managers don't want to be involved, others think the employee is malingering, and everyone tries to compensate for their lack of accurate knowledge of employment law by using golf and/or soccer analogies.
Confusion implies wekaness, but as we all know that weak people are more dangerous. They stick to stupid paths regardless of things they see along the way, then suddenly flip to another for a trivial reason.
That's why HR people are often seen as so nasty. They are trying to put a corporate face on a mess, and they are getting grief from more senior people who confuse obeying employment laws and rational staff management with weakness, but who aren't prepared to do the dirty work themselves.

MadamePlatypus · 02/03/2007 21:44

I think your boss sounds as though he doesn't have enough to do. If I had notified my boss that I was going to be off sick until day X, he would be a bit bemused,and possibly rather annoyed, if I still kept phoning him every day to say, "Hi, its me, just to say, I'm still ill, cough, cough".

nightowl · 02/03/2007 20:23

whadda you mean cod? was that to me? or were you being sarcastic. (never sure with you!)

DonnyLass · 02/03/2007 20:15

ps

male/female

scottish/seastern (seems we have a new country in the british isles)

part/full time

cleaner/MD

whatever ... it is about trust and respect

or the lack of

DonnyLass · 02/03/2007 20:11

responding to the op

whole thing screams f distrust to me

and/or he is projecting what he does when wfh hence doesnt trust/believe you are ill

he sounds pathetic and threatened ...

knobhead

adding to your stress will only create more problems

you should treat employees as you would your best customers for they are your most valuable resource

register his innappropriate behaviour calmly and clearly with hr and get back to doing a good job ... let him cock up for himself

he will

codswallop · 02/03/2007 19:57

yes

nightowl · 02/03/2007 19:40

working with five children must be hard yes, especially when you have a housekeeper, nanny and a cleaner.

Judy1234 · 02/03/2007 19:24

VVV, that's true. When people say how did I manage working and with 5 children I've often said the children are teh reason you have to work hard as they're so expensive to keep. If I didn't have any I could mess around and not work very hard at all.

VeniVidiVickiQV · 02/03/2007 11:44

Xenia, if an employee is messing an employer around, the employer is well within his/her rights to take them 'down the route'.

You speak like it is the majority of part-time working mothers that do this. It really isnt the case at all.

In fact, in my experience of HR work, interviewing and recruiting staff, and managing them - I found that working parents - full OR part-time - who had bills and rent/mortgage to pay were far less likely to muck their employer around, because they had so much more to lose than just their job. The women - particularly part time also knew that they felt they had to work That Bit Harder to be noticed and taken seriously for promotion prospects.

There were 2 working mothers who mucked the company around somewhat IIRC, and at least 20 who were young folk, living with their parents.

Worst of all were Managers, who felt that they had earned their right to fiddle expenses, mileage, "working from home", private work, days off sick, simply because they were managers, adn they knew they had a very dedicated team beneath them vying for their position.

yellowrose · 02/03/2007 09:17

Ah, don't worry DC, I did realise you were different people - although at one point I thought you may be brother and sister, or worse still married to each other - lol

Your post is very reasonable though DC, for a change !?! Yes, HR has lots of little spies, be very careful if you want to keep your job, I think I said that too to curly much further down. Good advice

Judy1234 · 02/03/2007 09:03

Good points.

I need to get some work done now but thought this which I was just sent....might be of amusing relevant on this thread. They can send out spies with videos to video if you're properly sick or not.

"A former police officer filmed mowing his lawn while on a disability allowance cannot claim that the filming broke the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act (RIPA), according to the Investigatory Powers Tribunal.The former policeman wanted the Tribunal to rule against the police force under RIPA, but the Tribunal has found that it has no jurisdiction to do so because the filming of him did not constitute the kind of surveillance that RIPA governs.

The former sergeant retired in August 2001 from the police having made a claim dating from 1998 for an injury he said he sustained to his back after tripping on a carpet in a police station while on duty. He was awarded £100,000 in 2002.

He was also awarded an enhanced pension due to the injuries on the basis that his disability was estimated at 53%. He said that the injuries would affect his ability to earn income as a driver.

In August 2002 the police instructed a firm of private detectives to observe the former sergeant to see if he was doing anything that was inconsistent with his claimed injuries. Nine minutes of video footage showed the man mowing the lawn and in his car.

RIPA governs the surveillance of people by public bodies to ensure that it is lawful and that relevant warrants and permissions are obtained.

"Cases of unauthorised covert surveillance by a public authority of its employees would appear at first sight to be the kind of case that would fall within the jurisdiction of the Tribunal," said the Tribunal's ruling. "The main purpose of RIPA is to ensure that the relevant investigatory powers of public authorities, such as interception of communications and various forms of covert surveillance, are used lawfully and compatibly with [Human Rights] Convention rights.""

DominiConnor · 02/03/2007 08:52

Oh dear, Xenia and I are different people.
I would however (contrary to my image), offer some constructive advice.

My work means dealing with a lot of HRs, and their perspective is that they are protecting the firm from the staff. You should assume that any measure taken by HR is for the (perceived) benefit of th firm, not the staff.
It's an adversarial situation, and you should take precautions for the next phase....

Keep a log of the calls you make to HR. Who you spoke to and what you said. They may be using this process as the first part of getting rid of you.
Do call them every day.
You need to be seen to be reasonable, which in this context sadly, does not mean what most of us would think. If you are not so ill that you cannot use a phone, then it's not reasonable to make you call, but that's not the description I read hear.
You need to have "reasonableness" on your side if this gets nasty.
Do not share anything with HR that you do not want taken down and used in evidence against you. Express the desire to get back to work as soon as possible.
A small consolation is that the HR probably doesn't want to hear from you any more than you want to ring. Do you want some sick woman interrupting your work and talking about how ill she is every morning ?

Judy1234 · 02/03/2007 08:33

Most people work things out like Eddas. Many employers find part time workers just what they need. I need part time cleaning and part time nannying. Depends on the job. What employers don't like is people who are unreliable and I think there's a big problem with a lot of people wanting flexible working after maternity leave and many jobs not easily fitting into that pattern yet the woman has an expection she can have it and the employer can't or 4 days the job might just about squeeze to but she wants 3. In practice most people do sort it out.

The advantage of part time is you can keep your hand in and also if you find housework etc a bit boring at times you get relief from that tedium.

yellowrose · 02/03/2007 08:16

Eddas - Lola Ferrari - lol -
I only have a size 38 DD bust, so never as good as Lola !

Ladies, PLEASE, I really don't think Xenia is interested in any of our views.

I think she has come to this website because she has a set agenda. People like this NEVER change their minds on any thing.

Personally I am getting very bored with threads that she kicks off. I would much rather talk about Eurotrash

Xenia reminds me of DominiConner on other threads. I think she is the female alter ego of DC !

Eddas · 02/03/2007 08:09

I see your point scummy and on my part wasn't trying to make Xenia not a woman any more

Pann, do you have a large one too as normally my holes are huge Maybe you have something to avoid them in the future for me, or maybe i should refrain from posting?!?!

Xenia, i actually agree that working part time in my job makes it very hard. I find that there isn't enough time to do anything properly. The trouble is that we could not afford our house without my wage(which isn't too bad considering i'm part time) So i cannot be a full time mum. Am about to have another child(4 weeks to go) and am seriously considering whether to go and get a simpler job after ML this time. Also we are toying with the idea of me being full time and dh working part time.

Judy1234 · 02/03/2007 07:58

Perhaps working parents whose career prospects have been damaged by all the working parents who mess around, often aren't there, ill all the time or their children are, want to ask for impossible hours etc should bring a class legal action against those other parents. It is there the damage has been caused by those other parents, not by the employers.

Judy1234 · 02/03/2007 07:56

But it's completely unfair on their employers and very unfair on other mothers who do take work seriously i9f those mothers who turn up when they choose fitting it around their family, little Johnny has flu and granny or a neighbour couldn't possibly mind him so let's have yet another day off work and upset the employer, the clients, the co-workers. If you can't stand the heat, get out of the kitchen and enjoy your 24/7 with the child but don't expect to mess employers around in the process and think they'll then not prefer women and men who don't.

I have always thought full time parenthood was a better deal for parents than part time working. Part time working means your husband expects you do everything at home, your pay is pathetic and you lose promotion and you don't do anything well. It also as we now see means parents who are committed to work get tarred with the same brush.

VeniVidiVickiQV · 02/03/2007 00:36

phucku

Dontknowmyarsefrommyelbow · 02/03/2007 00:33

Yep thats right I said chill the f*ck out! Urm - just wondering what you're contribution to this discussion has been? I was only trying to lighten the air a little bit as I always find it disappointing when us women fight with women over being women! There is no right or wrong on this one. Do you thing there are groups of blokes getting all pissy with each other about their lifestyle choices on some 'DadsNet' website? Stick together sisters!!

phucku · 02/03/2007 00:21

"my initial observation is that it's great that everyone shares stuff etc but some of you need to chill the f*ck out! "

is it? is it really? Good for you. Thank you for sharing that with us all.

I await your next stage of observation breathlessly.......

ScummyMummy · 02/03/2007 00:17

Eddas- you were not the only one I was referring to, I promise. It was the general theme. And you are right, you made some great points lower down, imo. I just think it's pretty low when threads descend, without too much extrapolation, into telling someone that their views are such that they somehow are not, cannot, be a 'real' woman, whatever that may be. I want to see Xenia pushed to explain and justify her (imo) bizarre ideas on social justice. I don't want to see her expelled from the so-called sisterhood on the (spurious and unproven) grounds that she is not beautiful, nurturing or feminine enough to belong there.

Dontknowmyarsefrommyelbow · 02/03/2007 00:12

I am new to this mn thing and have only had breif scans over some of these discussions - my initial observation is that it's great that everyone shares stuff etc but some of you need to chill the f*ck out!

VeniVidiVickiQV · 01/03/2007 23:56

Mines a genuine question scummy - she speaks like she doesnt consider herself a woman in the terms that she describes women.

Its very distinct.

Pann · 01/03/2007 23:53

got this small JCB here if you want to borrow it. I've used it loads of times..