Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

.. to think council should pursue CURRENT tenant for c-tax and not drag me to court??

95 replies

Backt0Black · 02/02/2017 12:50

Hoping someone on here can help? I'm getting nowhere with common sense with the council.

In Nov after a long running dispute with the landlord over various legal issues (I'll omit to keep this short, but happy to explain) I left a tenancy 7 months early (was 2.5 yr). I immediately informed council (both properties in same billing area) to pay final bill on old property and to take on bill at new property.

Landlord had re-marketed the property the month previously - hence my need to move quickly. During my move (back and forth with van) landlord entered the property with a band of his workmen and stole around £2000 worth of possessions (not that it matters but I'm heavily pregnant and this was a bit terrifying and can't believe the council are supporting this 'landlord') then returned to change the locks later in the week. So - effectively no access from Nov. (I was happy to hand existing keys to landlord in exchange for a receipt of return as he is quite dodgy)

Out of spite landlord has said to council I should retain the council tax liability until end of tenancy (June!)... despite the fact he has re-let the property to new tenants.

I appealed and wrote to council explaining the changed locks and new tenant and they STILL are holding me liable until June. Despite new tenant and the fact that I am happily paying them on a new property. They and are pushing ahead with court action ... I cant just pay... it's a huge bill - £280 a month on a high band! (will be on SMP soon!)

They have said my only recourse is to write another letter. I dont know what else I can say that there is another tenant in the property and that the landlord changing the locks was implied surrender?

They will no longer discuss verbally and feel like I am doomed to end up in court, never been through anything like this.

Any legal eagles with advice.... anyone been through similar and have takes of success.... or warning?

OP posts:
roseshippy · 02/02/2017 18:15

"the judgement I quoted is relevant "

you didn't quote a judgement though.

which one are you talking about?

specialsubject · 02/02/2017 18:12

roseshippy the judgement I quoted is relevant when the property is empty (as noted I had problems, fortunately minor, on the other side). As you know, a landlord can only end a tenancy by going to court or accepting a deed of surrender. The problem here is that the tenancy was for a longer fixed term and neither happened. The tenant wanted to (and did) leave and the landlord's 'loss' is ended by installing a new tenant.

As I said, the property is not empty so if the council had a peanut of common sense the liability is for the new tenant. The idea of the local MP is a good one if he/she isn't a safe-seat-time-server. Mayor? Head of council? Local paper?

I also think the OP was illegally evicted. The update shows more issues but none are relevant to the council tax and the council won't care because thinking about it creates work. If they are like mine, they accept any declaration of end of liability without checking.

Backt0Black · 02/02/2017 17:52

Hi All I'm back!

Firstly THANK YOU for the replies. I have to confess I ended up crying tears of frustration after the call to the recovery team. They would not enter into discussion on why they would not purse the new tenant for c-tax and just kept repeating 'you will be liable for court costs, we will secure an order' it just seemed common sense was not valid.

I feel better even knowing someone (you guys) have actually heard and understood the issue rather than just quoting process (regardless of actual rights / wrongs) at me like recovery have. Some points I've spotted with outstanding questions....

  • can I prove I have moved. I rang them to advise of the move and they have been very happily billing for my new home since the move date. Unsurprisingly. I also have completion dates from my solicitor.
  • are both properties same 'county / borough' ..yes, both Durham.
  • why have I not sued for the £2000 stolen property.... landlord is a villain, went bedroom to bedroom with a van full of his workmen taking possessions, he has had various brushes with the lay,and has even had a couple of cannabis farms in his various let properties . I just wanted him out of my life and to draw a line under it, I do not want him exacting any more revenge at my new address or any further contact.

Did I choose to end the tenancy or the landlord. Well - this is all related the the breakdown of the tenancy, again happy to explain, but did want to try and keep short...but if you're up for a tangled web........ read on Smile. .........

We found out AFTER signing tenancy what sort of guy the landlord really was (see above). We paid him in full on time for 18 months ... it then became apparent that he wouldnt deliver on some stables he promised to build part of the tenancy (in writing) on the land that came with the house, I was fed up of my horses shivering despite the fact we'd contributed towards materials. .. so we reduced the rent we paid. He DID then apply for planning permission using my name! stating fraudulently we had a TEN year lease (nope 2.5 yr) he also signed my name! ... which was granted. Neighbours are up in arms as feel he will use this to craftily build another house (he was in court / the papers for attempting same 4 years ago) ... anyway, stables were never built, what he did do instead is start making huge winding access roads clearly for a house.... my horses don't drive!), ripping out field fencing without prior notice leaving our horses to roam onto the A-roads.... this happened easily 7-8 times. We asked several times that he please not just send workmen to remove fences... It continued... we rarely had a day without workmen so had no privacy. After another release of the horses and large vet bill (and the worry that he still wouldn't stop and it was a matter of time before a serious road accident was caused and we were left to explain why the horses were on an A roads and maybe through some poor drivers windscreen)so we then progress to flatly withhold rent each time I had to collect horses from the road.

All of the above re horses, planning permission, no stables, fencing being ripped away isnt really valid re c-tax. But it was asked.... so there you go. God it reads like a bad episode of Eastenders.

OP posts:
Pumpkintopf · 02/02/2017 16:19

If local councillor can't/won't help speak to your MP.

YogaDrone · 02/02/2017 16:02

You have to have gone through the Council's own complaints procedure before the Ombudsman will accept the case MrsMoastyToasty, but certainly raise an official complaint if you get no joy from a meeting with the team manager.

The reason I recommend speaking to the CT Manager is because s/he is most likely to have the best understanding of the law. Usually the way a Council complaint is dealt with is to give the complaint to another department to investigate. This person have even less grasp of the law than the person/people OP has already dealt with.

ivykaty44 · 02/02/2017 15:41

Don't tell/ talk to a government body. Email so you have a paper trail that can verify what you have shown, given sorted with them.

MrsMoastyToasty · 02/02/2017 15:27

If you get no joy with the council then tell them you are taking the matter to the Local Government Ombudsman.

ivykaty44 · 02/02/2017 15:22

For those saying make an appointment with CAB, have any of you ever tried to get an appointment?

It's easier to find ticking horse shit

Seriously op will be 101, cab area seriously underfunded and the waiting list is massive

ivykaty44 · 02/02/2017 15:18

Where did he remarket the property? Was it in a newspaper?

YogaDrone · 02/02/2017 15:01

Personally I would take this to my local councillor first. After all, this is a council matter.

CAB might be useful if they have someone there well versed in rating law. Otherwise the hierarchy of occupation, which is laid down in the LGFA 1992, is your friend here OP. The actual section extract is below. It's the Local Government Finance Act 1992, Section 6:

Local Government Finance Act 1992 Section 6
(1) The person who is liable to pay council tax in respect of any chargeable dwelling and any day is the person who falls within the first paragraph of subjection (2) below to apply, taking paragraph (a) of that subsection first, paragraph (b) next, and so on.

(2) A person falls within this subsection in relation to any chargeable dwelling and any day, if on that day –

(a) he is a resident of the dwelling and has a freehold interest in the whole or any part of it;

(b) he is such a resident and has a leasehold interest in the whole or any part of the dwelling which is not inferior to another such interest held by another such resident;

(c) he is both such a resident and a statutory or secure tenant of the whole or any part of the dwelling;

(d) he is such a resident and has a contractual licence to occupy the whole or any part of the dwelling’

(e) he is such a resident; or

(f) he is the owner of the dwelling [where unoccupied]

puguin86 · 02/02/2017 14:53

Hi this happened to me.

I moved out of a flat - told the council paid final bill

A year later new house 300 miles away Got a letter saying I owed liverpool City council 1500 for the last years council tax.
Rang the council someone had rung the council and told themi was still there. I said I'd supplied them with evidence of end of tenancy - they didn't giv a shit because the mysterious caller had told them that is decided to renew rather than leave. I called my old landlord who wouldn't help.

Bailiffs threatened me so I wrote a letter before action to both the debt recovery and the city council (sent it to the head of legal and the chief executive emails ) detailing all of evidence of me moving out and a claim for harassment. Got a letter back straight away saying they had got it wrong. Plus they owed me money because i had over paid when I was there

Could you do something similar?

LouKout · 02/02/2017 14:48

I agree you should make an appointment at CAB

YogaDrone · 02/02/2017 14:46

ooops, poor mistake there, sorry. Should read:
"it would still be arguable that it is NOT the OP's bill as she has no ability to occupy the property "

gillybeanz · 02/02/2017 14:45

They told me you can only be registered as living at one property for council tax.
You shouldn't have to pay twice.
i'd either get a solicitor, your MP involved, and definitely CAB.

YogaDrone · 02/02/2017 14:44

I agree with the other posters - get your ducks in a row OP and take your occupancy dates, any emails/correspondence, any utility or other bills which show your new address and anything you may have (removals or van rental perhaps) to show that you no longer live at the property they are trying to charge you for.

rosehippy is totally correct. Unoccupying tenants are liable providing there is no other occupier.

I guess the new tenants could claim that the property is not their sole/main residence, particularly if they don't have an official tenancy agreement but I think it would still be arguable that it is the OP's bill as she has no ability to occupy the property as the landlord has changed the locks. Although OP says that the landlord re-marketed the property so this seems unlikely.

The elements of occupation are:

  1. actual (nope!)
  2. excusive (double nope!)
  3. beneficial (nope)
  4. not too transient a period (doesn't really apply)

The only thing the council have here is the tenancy agreement and I think you can refute that with the landlords correspondence and the re-marketing of the property.

Also, the council should have property inspectors on staff. I imagine they would have them to inspect new builds for completion dates and checking on uninhabitable properties. They need to get one of them round to the property and ascertain who lives there and actually do some investigation. At the moment they are taking the path of least resistance which is the OP and her tenancy agreement until June.

I hope your appointment went well OP. Perhaps your scary midwife could go to the Council on your behalf?! Smile

MirandaWest · 02/02/2017 14:38

So do the council not have anyone down other than you to pay council tax there?

I have paid council tax for two houses whilst renting despite only living in one of them but was as I moved into this house while there was still a month left on old contract. Was a pain as had to then pay full rate instead of single person discount rate as I didn't live there anymore Hmm.

Did you leave early because the landlord made you leave or was it your choice?

aginghippy · 02/02/2017 14:33

Speak to your local councillor. You can find information about who they are and when they have surgeries on the council web site.

This will be more effective than trying to escalate with council officers IME.

rjay123 · 02/02/2017 14:09

Potentially, the landlord has illegally evicted you from the property. I would 100% speak to Shelter regarding this matter.

Illegal eviction is a criminal offence.

m.england.shelter.org.uk/get_advice/eviction/harassment_and_illegal_eviction_by_landlord/illegal_eviction

roseshippy · 02/02/2017 14:00

"Tenants are liable to the end of the tenancy , not the vacating date . This has just been proven in a judgement."

This is wrong.

Which judgment are you talking about? If it is Leeds CC v Broadley it is not relevant to his case

The legislation is here:

www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1992/14/section/6

The order of priority goes down to "owner". Owner comes behind any kind of 'resident'. 'Owner' means someone with a 'material interest'. This typically includes a contracted tenant .

Therefore if the property is EMPTY, the 'owner', i.e. the tenant, is likely to be liable for council tax.

However as soon as someone else moves in, they, as the resident, usurp any liability for the mere 'owner'.

Isitjustmeorisiteveryoneelse · 02/02/2017 13:48

Though not the same circumstances as you, I had something similar a few years ago when a CT bill suddenly turned up for a flat I'd lived in years before. I explained that I'd not lived there for nearly ten years but the councils attitude (not the same council I was living under at the time) was, tough prove it, or we'll take you to court. I think I was just the least dodgy person to have lived there and it was easier for the LL to give my name to the council for chasing the debt rather than any other of the subsequent tenants. All it took was a letter from my bank to the council concerned to confirm I had not lived there for ten years and they dropped it straight away.

urbansprawl · 02/02/2017 13:43

Seconding YogaDrone: in the absence of a document proving that you are no longer the tenant (such as a termination agreement), the council's being lazy and trying to use your 2.5 year lease as 'proof' you're in situ.

It would help to demonstrate that you're no longer living there if you can provide the council with some evidence that you now live in a new property, e.g. your correspondence (emails or letters) with landlord telling him when you'd move out, redacted bank statement/utility bill showing your name on the the new address with the relevant date(s), details of your new council tax account on your new home etc. Line up all the documents and send them to the council by email and signed-for post with a letter explaining the situation in very clear terms. Use bullet points if it helps to get your point across, but make it really easy to read and understand.

I wouldn't mention the landlord theft issue to the council as it isn't relevant to your council tax position, but I'd be tempted to follow up with the police. I think it might well be a criminal issue, although I'm a bit fuzzy on crim law.

Sorry you have to go through such a hassle. Council tax depts can be such a nightmare! And best of luck with your MW appointment!

Whathaveilost · 02/02/2017 13:40

A few years ago I was in a similar position and I phoned my MP and spoke to his secretary who took down all the details. At the beginning of the following week I got a letter in a posh envelope from my MP saying that everything was sorted with the council and I didn't have to do anything else.
I was amazed and the prompt reply and a successful result.

Could that be an option?

user892 · 02/02/2017 13:38

If the property was marketed and re-let, might there be a paper trail to prove this? e.g. letting agent or Rightmove screenshot? If you search under 'let agreed' filter the page usually mentions the date the listing was added. Could add weight to your case with the council.

Arsewipe. Rogue landlords are utterly criminal.

specialsubject · 02/02/2017 13:37

Tenants are liable to the end of the tenancy , not the vacating date . This has just been proven in a judgement. I've been on the other end of this, when a tenant leaves before the bailff but the property is still not available to the landlord until the bailiff date which ends the tenancy.

Changing locks does not end a tenancy - tenant protection. I can see how you have been caught out by this, legislation intended to protect you has backfired. A landlord does not have to accept a deed of surrender.

But (before mn starts screaming) with a new tenancy in place yours should be deemed ended by common sense. Escalate with the council to find.someone who will actually take the situation in rather than just ticking boxes and minimising work.

roseshippy · 02/02/2017 13:34

Have you sued for the £2k? If not, why not?

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.

Swipe left for the next trending thread