Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think charity shops refusal to reduce is sometimes unreasonable.

246 replies

roseforarose · 26/01/2017 09:08

I realise that some charity shops aren't allowed to but i think some shops must lose quite a bit of business by their outright refusal to accept a "knock down", usually saying "we aren't allowed, it's a set price" sort of thing.

I wonder if that's always true, because recently i asked if they'd take a bit less on some walking boots which i thought were a bit dear, got told "no we can't" then i noticed the brand new price underneath theirs and it was only about £2 less brand new. When i pointed it out she said "well if that's the case I will reduce them for you" . So she did have the power to reduce after all.
So when they say they can't reduce, maybe in a lot of shops they can if they want to?

OP posts:
WhiskyChick · 26/01/2017 10:17

I worked and was paid in charity for years. The people that haggled 9 out of 10 times were the people who had plenty of cash. I didn't mind that. It did make a lot of volunteers uncomfortable. Where you think pricing is excessive then you will find these shops don't sell enough and will close, if they don't then they have the pricing right. Most of the large charities will have a pricing structure.

Take an example of a book. Oftenwise a shop will sell these at around a third of the new price which will depend on condition. However some books will also rise in value, for example first editions or out of print. These would never be priced with that structure and would likely be priced more than new.

Clothing is different. The charities receive huge stocks of cheap stuff, the vast majority will never make the rails. The stuff that does should be priced accordingly however you'll often find head offices set a minimum pricing to prevent people taking the piss.

At the end of the day the shop has a duty to maximise its profits as this is what goes to the charity at the end of the day. They have no responsibility to provide anyone with bargains. Don't forget these shops often have the same overheads as high street chains, and no the stock (or at least the majority) isn't free. There are collection costs etc.

Invictus74 · 26/01/2017 10:16

I just would't have the neck to ask them to reduce something in a charity shop :(

glitterazi · 26/01/2017 10:16

It's a charity shop! How tight have you got to be to haggle??

This! I can be tight sometimes lol, but good grief - even I'm making a [shocked] face at the thought of people arguing over prices in charity shops!
Would you do that in Next or Marks and Sparks? I'm guessing not, so why is it fair game in charity ones? Do you not see them as proper shops or something?! Confused
You just pay the price, and if it's too expensive (which some of them are) or you can't afford it, then you walk away!

Frouby · 26/01/2017 10:14

We have a charity shop across the road. Ds (3) loves it. However some of the things we have bought have been overpriced. £1.99 for a dinosaur that was only £1 from wilkoa for instance.

But I find it balances out. I paid £3.99 for an almost brand new scooter for him. £2.99 for a john rocha coat and the same for a next coat. Both immaculate. Both probably £40+ to buy new.

Some of the toys they have out would be better of in the bin though.

BarbarianMum · 26/01/2017 10:14

Actually a lot are closing because clothing is so cheap now. It's hard to make emds meet selling £3 shirts for 80p

roseforarose · 26/01/2017 10:12

It's a charity shop! How tight have you got to be to haggle??
Try not to mistake tightness for being a mug. There's a difference.

OP posts:
roseforarose · 26/01/2017 10:10

In answer to your original question: it's incredibly crass and rude to haggle in a charity shop. "Lots" of people doing it doesn;t make it any less so.
I don't agree with you at all, if a charity shop is clearly overcharging (as they're often prone to do) it's absolutely acceptable to point it out and offer less. They'd be soon out of business if they were that unreasonable not to accept. That's probably why so many are shutting down, they're pricing themselves out of business.

OP posts:
OverTheGardenGate · 26/01/2017 10:09

Most of them are unpaid. They mostly have one paid manager and
maybe a paid assistant manager. The rest of us do it for nothing.

The unpaid staff are not allowed to make reductions.
Otherwise we might be tempted to reduce things for our friends.

they aren't always unpaid, my friend gets paid in her present job. She only wanted to rectify because i'd pointed it out to her

PinguForPresident · 26/01/2017 10:09

OP: can you give us an example of these charity shops that aren't actually charity shops? The ones you claim don't actually donate to charity?

Onthecouchagain · 26/01/2017 10:06

It's a charity shop! How tight have you got to be to haggle??

BarbarianMum · 26/01/2017 10:05

Most shops will have a paid manager to oversee things and make sure everythings done correctly, legally etc (deal with all the shit, basically) but the actual people sorting, pricing, selling etc are volunteers

lalalalyra · 26/01/2017 10:05

Some charity shop pricing is a joke. The BHF shop locally has books that are years old, and properly tatty and they're surprised that people don't want to pay £6/7/8 for them. Someone did a name and shame on Facebook recently because they priced a book that had £7.99 on the back for £8 - no-one is going to pay a penny more for a second hand copy of a book!

We have a charity shop in town that has done away with pricing. They've got an offers/haggle system going. Apparently they are making way more money because people are starting higher than expected. They've also got a referral system going so that people (HV's/schools/even people like us with the playscheme) can refer folks who are in a bit of bother atm and then they are giving very favourable pricing to those people. It seems to be working really well, although the other charity shops in close proximity are kicking up a bit of a fuss about it.

pictish · 26/01/2017 10:03

What you find more in charity shops is an ASDA t-shirt for £3 when you can nip along the road to ASDA and buy a new one for £4.

roseforarose · 26/01/2017 10:03

iverthegardengate they aren't always unpaid, my friend gets paid in her present job. She only wanted to rectify because i'd pointed it out to her. But the thing was she'd earlier implied they weren't allowed to lower the price, but obviously they could if they wanted to.

OP posts:
PinguForPresident · 26/01/2017 09:59

Well i don't think the money is always for "charity" is it, i think a lot of them now are called charity shops but are actually business's making someone a lot of money...

Could you clarify what you mean by this, OP?

Charity shops raise money for charity. That's waht they do. If they are in faact money making businesses for someone other than charities, they are not allowed to call themselves charity shops. Are you perhaps mistaking shops for the "charity" bags that people put through the door, where a business colect unwated goods and give a small % to charity? Those are quite ethically iffy, but charity shops are exactly what it says on the tin.

In answer to your original question: it's incredibly crass and rude to haggle in a charity shop. "Lots" of people doing it doesn;t make it any less so.

roseforarose · 26/01/2017 09:59

pickled How would i know which ones actually donate to charity. Confused

OP posts:
BarbarianMum · 26/01/2017 09:58

Pretty easy to tell that by the sign over the door. If it says the Hospice Shop, or British Heart Foundation, or Imperial Cancer Research Fund, or Oxfam, or Red Cross etc etc it is for charity (and that charity isn't you). Wink

OverTheGardenGate · 26/01/2017 09:57

They'd clearly been overpriced hence the immediate offer of a reduction when i pointed it out to her

Well exactly. A mistake was made, but it was rectified immediately.
None of the unpaid volunteers in the shop would mind an obvious overestimate being pointed out.
It's people who haggle over what is already a bargain which irritates.

lovelyupnorth · 26/01/2017 09:56

It all depends how long stuff is on display. New stuff out I can understand. If it's been stood around for a few weeks then discount. at the end of the day they are there to raise money for the charity.

roseforarose · 26/01/2017 09:55

You actually haggle in a charity shop? hmm

I think that says a lot more about you than them refusing says about themto be honest.
How strange that that shocks you. I have a friend who's worked in various charity shops for years and she tells me it's quite the norm for people to sometimes make an offer for less than they're asking. But apart from that, where is it acceptable to "haggle" to you?

OP posts:
choccywoccywoowah · 26/01/2017 09:51

I didn't say the shop has to refund your money. Most of the charity shops I go in have the same refunds policy as a normal shop, so I don't see why there should be a shame in using it if something doesnt fit. I regularly volunteer for a charity so I am certainly not tight or cheeky.

PickledCauliflower · 26/01/2017 09:50

Are we talking about charity shops - or a business?
Your last post suggests that's it's not a proper charity shop?

PickledCauliflower · 26/01/2017 09:48

As it's for a charity (and they lots of overheads just running the shop), they charge what they hope they can get for their items. If you are not happy to pay such a price for a pair of boots, someone else may come along next week and be happy to pay that.
I used to work in a charity shop on Saturdays back in the 90s. They didn't take much money in at all. Sometimes they got a flurry of decent items to sell and then for ages - hardly anything.
I really don't think they are places to haggle or do deals.

OverTheGardenGate · 26/01/2017 09:47

I work in a charity shop, and we don't reduce the price if the item has only been out a couple of days. After a week or so we would.
Maybe the boots hadn't been out long, so a reduction was refused,
but after attention was drawn to the original price there was good reason to reduce them.
Loads of people try to haggle and it would just get silly if we kept knocking prices down to anybody who asked. What's the point of pricing things?
We do have a refund policy as well, and people often bring things back, mostly for genuine reasons (not fitting etc). Sometimes it's as little as 50p. I wouldn't bother, myself, but I figure they must really need the money.

roseforarose · 26/01/2017 09:47

Well i don't think the money is always for "charity" is it, i think a lot of them now are called charity shops but are actually business's making someone a lot of money....and no i wouldn't expect reductions in Next, or Gap or in supermarkets but charity shops aren't the same. Often they sell stuff that is clearly overpriced, in the case of the walking boots they were priced at just £2 below what the retailer had been selling them for and they were "used".

They'd clearly been overpriced hence the immediate offer of a reduction when i pointed it out to her. People go to charity shops to get a bargain, they won't go if the stuff on offer is practically the same price as new stuff surely.

OP posts: