Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

wanting to overrule dd1's preferred decor for her bedroom?

34 replies

melpomene · 24/02/2007 07:55

DD1 is 3.9. She needs a new carpet for her bedroom. Her current carpet is blue. The walls in her bedroom and the blind are yellow.

We've been looking at carpet samples and dd1 says she'd prefer a lilac carpet. I'm not keen on that, and I'd prefer to stick to blue because:

  • I think lilac carpet would clash hideously with the yellow walls. We'd either have to put up with the clash or redecorate the whole room (time and expense).
  • It would not be as good for the resale value of the house, because many people wouldn't want a lilac carpet in a boy's bedroom.
  • Blue makes it feel more unified with the rest of the house (All the rest of our upstairs carpets is blue.)
-Blue is more 'neutral' and flexible when it comes to adapting the decor of the room at a later date.

On the other hand, dh thinks we should respect dd1's preference. It is her bedroom, and he thinks we should respect her autonomy.

So, am I being mean? Should I grit my teeth and accept the clash of lilac carpet with yellow walls? Would it be reasonable to compromise and go for the blue carpet, but buy dd1 a purple pony picture for her wall?

(off for breakfast now, but will check back later)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thcc · 09/04/2023 23:25

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Previously banned poster.

crunchie · 24/02/2007 16:53

Well I let DD2 decorate her room at 5, OK I 'let' her choose purple as that is what I had already decided!!

Howevr she did choose curtains adn light fittings (she went fot the sparkly chandelier option!!)

SS1 was 2 when she got her room decorated and we did pink stripes, I have promised her a new room at 10 (sh eis now coming up 8) and she is already coming up with plans and ideas

We are planning a bed a little like this

detoxdiva · 24/02/2007 12:09

lovelymoo - LOVE that! Will remember that one for when dd gets a bit older - tee hee!!!

lovelymoo · 24/02/2007 11:52

I Let my three year old choose the deco in her room but i gave her two options i had already picked. She got to pick her room without realising that i was still controlling what she picked IYSWIM. Why don't you let her choose the rug for her room she needs to be able to make her own choices too its her room

nearlythree · 24/02/2007 11:08

I must admit I agree with Cece. Ideally you want to avoid any coloured carpets if you want to sell. Ours are neutral with a weave that hides any stains.

Twiglett · 24/02/2007 10:40

ooo a riled Daddy .. how lovely

welcome

If you want to consult your 3 year old on home decor then that's great .. and you're right .. if you ask her what she wants and she answers with a strong opinion she should have it because you opened the conversation

... thank the lord she asked for a lilac carpet and not one with poo-poo on it .. oh yes forgot momentarily she's a 3 year old girl not a 6 year old boy

BandofMothers · 24/02/2007 10:05

Good.
She wont care about the carpet as long as she gets her beautiful rug!!!!!

rosylonginglily · 24/02/2007 10:02

gorgeous!

melpomene · 24/02/2007 09:58

Okay, we have a solution everyone is happy with. I suggested to dd1 having blue carpet plus a rug and showed her pictures of 3 rugs. She chose this butterfly rug . Phew!

Thanks to everyone who suggested getting a rug.

OP posts:
Saturn74 · 24/02/2007 09:38

There's nothing wrong with letting children have a say in matters that are important to them, but when the child is very young it is probably wise to give them a choice of two or three things rather than free rein - particularly if they are likely to choose something impractical, or a colour you really dislike.
Negotiation and flexibility are also important skills to learn as a member of a family - not everybody can have what they want all the time.
I think the rug idea is excellent.

melpomene · 24/02/2007 09:32

Wickedwaterwitch, we didn't tell her she could choose. But she looked at the carpet samples and said she wanted the lilac one.

OP posts:
BandofMothers · 24/02/2007 09:31

LOL Rosy. DD1 (3) pretty much has dh where she wants him.
I personally like lilac. (Dh would be rolling his eyes at that understatement.)
I'm sure your dd would be happy with a rug. Have you asked her yet?

cece · 24/02/2007 09:29

I don't want to be rude but regarding the resale. We had blue carpets in our house when we moved in - they were gone within a fortnight. Couldn't stand them.

So I htink my point is go with what you like as you have to live with it. Whatever you hoocsome people will like and some won't when it comes to resale.

rosylonginglily · 24/02/2007 09:28

my dh is pure soft putty in the hands of our dd age4 which is of course as it should be Though I won't be allowing either of them to paint the living room black

WideWebWitch · 24/02/2007 09:24

inabsentia, I don't think it's patronising to let her choose something small. She's 3! The OP didn't say you'd asked her and told her she could choose though, it just said she'd stated her preference, which was lilac.

LowFatMilkshake · 24/02/2007 09:23

In support of NearlyThree, pink and yellow go really well together. DD(3.5) has a yellow room with pink and lilac accents - with a sort of Disney Princess theme (lampshade, bedding, pictures etc), although nothing we can't change as she actually prefers Mickey and Donald.

Granted her carpet is neutral beige, but we got the carpet a few months before she was born and it's in both DC's rooms. Our room is .....lilac !

Just wondered, regarding your comment on re-sale, are you planning to sell anytime soon? Guessing not else you would'nt be getting her new carpet?

nearlythree · 24/02/2007 09:16

Lilac and yellow go lovely together - think primroses and crocuses. Add a little pale gree and you have a colour scheme like spring - just right for a three and a bit yr old.

I'm with InAbsentia. If you've asked dd what she would like, you go with it.

melpomene · 24/02/2007 09:09

Thanks for the suggestions, everyone. There seems to be a clear consensus - I think the rug idea is a good one. As you can tell from the post above, I showed the thread to dh.

OP posts:
InAbsentia · 24/02/2007 09:01

Posted by Twiglett:

your DH needs a talking to

that would be me then

are you mad?

possibly

its your house

rubbish. it's OUR home. and it's HER room.

take her to the shop and let her choose an ornament or toy or something

a great way to patronise the people you (claim to) love!

fact is, we asked DD what she thought. to ignore the reply because we don't like it is positively insulting.

BandofMothers · 24/02/2007 08:51

That's a good idea and makes it feel homey to them.
I have a big Charlie and Lola picture of stickers and a giant Fifi pic with stickers and drawing that we did together.
She loves that she can look at it everyday.

rosylonginglily · 24/02/2007 08:42

She can be involved without it costing the earth, let her paint a big picture herself and stick it in a clip frame for her wall!

BandofMothers · 24/02/2007 08:42

I got dd1 a pink hopscotch rug, which she loves. Argos for 15, but i got mine from the market for a tenner.
Bit harsh Twiglett, but understandable as 3/4 yr old tastes can be bloody awful and you'd end up with a roomful of stuff that clashes.
A rug can be moved at least.

Twiglett · 24/02/2007 08:36

I must be incredibly mean / tight-fisted / cruel (delete as appropriate) as I can't help feeling that I wouldn't even let her choose a rug .. small toy / small ornament .. under a fiver

Miaou · 24/02/2007 08:32

No, I think the blue carpet/lilac rug would be a great compromise. The dds have been talking about redecorating their bedroom (it's a vile manky magnolia atm) and though we are happy for them to come up with suggestions, dh and I will certainly have the final say.

WideWebWitch · 24/02/2007 08:26

I also agree that she's too young to have final decision making power on carpets!