Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

telling my friend she comes across as rude in text messages

79 replies

RnBee · 22/02/2007 11:21

aarrgghh. just fallen out with my friend. She is having a dinner party on Sat and I texted her to offer to make a tiramisu for dessert (which she knows takes ages). At the moment I am so busy I don't know what to do with myself. DS2 is sick, I am moving in a few weeks and trying to renovate the new house. Plus have autsitic DS1 and a play opening in April that I have millions of lines to learn by the weekend.

However I am happy to help her by making dessert as she isn't really into cooking and she is making dinner for us and another couple.

Anyway her response to my offer was 'If you like. Can I borrow you rice cooker'

Tbh I was really taken aback. The least I expected was 'Thanks, that's really kind, I know how much you have on' or 'Thanks, but don't worry I have it sorted' or something.

I'm fed up of making nice suggestions like 'would you like to come round for dinner, I can pick you up' and getting 'ok' as a reply.

So I texted her back and said sometimes she can be rude in texts, even though I'm sure she doesnt mean to be. She is really upset and has cancelled the dinner party . She thinks I misinterpret. Maybe i do?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Freshmind001 · 10/11/2022 22:30

I can see where your coming from. However, some people are quite cut in their communication and it can come across quite rude but maybe that is not their intentions. You clearly have a lot going on, and if I was you I would try to be clear with your friend and say look I have XYZ happening, if you don't think I should make something the please let me know etc. so of course you also don't waste your time.

Kittykat9070 · 10/11/2022 22:30

@Scurryfunge12

it’s been 16 years since she posted, I think the apology is pointless now 😉

RobertaFirmino · 10/11/2022 22:21

So much of our communication is non-verbal. For example, I could tell someone to 'shut up' and they would know whether I meant this jokingly or seriously by my tone of voice, facial expressions and gestures. You don't get any of this with text messages (and that's why I feel like I have to end them all with 'x' so the recipient knows I'm not being rude).

It's quite possible you were overreacting or taking things the wrong way but in the absence of any 'clues', like a friendly tone of voice, I can understand why.

Peekachoochoo · 10/11/2022 22:19

If I were her I would have said, "That would be lovely, thank you."

If I were you and had received her message, I would have said, "On second thoughts, I'm not actually going to have time to make one, sorry". You could soften the blow by offering to pick something up at the supermarket but I wouldn't kill myself.

I'm afraid you can be too nice and people just don't appreciate it.

Scurryfunge12 · 10/11/2022 22:09

You’ve over reacted. Maybe she should have said thanks but at the same time there is nothing wrong with what she said. I’d apologise.

MichelleScarn · 10/11/2022 22:05

Yet another boring ZOMBIE ZOMBIE!!

ZombieSpammer · 10/11/2022 22:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

littlelapin · 23/02/2007 12:18

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

RnBee · 23/02/2007 12:15

just to clarify the original texts were in the evening, she had just sent me a long text discussing what she was going to wear for the dinner party so time wasn't really an issue.

lol fireflyfairy!

Yes all sorted now we have made up after realising how silly it was to argue over...a tiramisu. The party is back on

I offered to make it again, and the reply? 'YES PLEASE!'

OP posts:
fireflyfairy2 · 23/02/2007 11:41

Has it been sorted yet Rnbee???

I text my mum yesterday to say I would be over to pick her up, what time suited, & what would she like for dinner, she replied with " OK, anytime, anything"

chitchat07 · 22/02/2007 18:11

Um, can I ask why you offered to make desert if you are so busy anyway? You might think you are doing her a huge favour, but all it may be is that you are saving her from is buying a desert from the patisserie, so really, all you are saving her is a bit of money, and not the work.

Having said that.... (and I really have no idea if that was the case or not), texting is supposed to be brief, and even emails can be interpreted as rude. Basically people are crap in communicating nowadays. In person with the expression in the voice clearly heard makes a difference.

Oh, and maybe she was super busy at that point. Wouuld you have thought she was being rude if she hadn't responding for awhile??

snowleopard · 22/02/2007 17:59

I think "if you like" sounds a bit dismissive given that it was in reply to a generous offer. It's just as quick to text "yes please!" And cancelling it in a huff! - I think it's the friend who has issues here. i have to admit I wouldn't have texted back saying it sounded rude, but that's because I hate confrotation. I'd have just gradually cooled it a bit and not offered anything like that again.

FluffyMummy123 · 22/02/2007 17:40

Message withdrawn

FluffyMummy123 · 22/02/2007 17:40

Message withdrawn

Spidermama · 22/02/2007 17:39

And a rude poster at times too.

VeniVidiVickiQV · 22/02/2007 17:16

You are a rude emailer too

FluffyMummy123 · 22/02/2007 17:14

Message withdrawn

edam · 22/02/2007 17:13

Were you texting her while she was at work? Then you should have realised she might not have had much time to write a lengthy reply.

Spidermama · 22/02/2007 16:58

RnBee any time. I'll CAT you my number. I'm around tomorrow if you like. It would be great to see you while we're still neighbours!

VoluptuaGoodshag · 22/02/2007 13:31

Let the moral of this story be speak to each other in person or on phone right from the start and things might never have gotten out of hand.

If I was planning a dinner party surely people would assume I would only do so if I felt competent enough to cook all the courses. Whilst a nice offer to cook pudding perhaps she already had something in mind so was a bit narked that suddenly her whole plan was changed but she didn't want to hurt your feelings hence the "if you like".

If you'd spoken to her properly you'd have picked up on her tone if tiramisu was appropriate or perhaps she'd have been better placed to say whether it was or was not. I hate texting - it's only use is for quick meet you where and when stuff or I'm running late. I totally echo a previous comment that you can waste half an hour texting to and fro when a call would have been quicker and leaves you with a nice feeling of friendship.

To reply by text saying it was rude is a tad hypocitical.

But phone her as soon as you can and be apologetic and laugh about it. If she is still taking the hump then perhaps best if you drop this friend.

RnBee · 22/02/2007 13:25

Aw thanks Spidermama! Am really tempted to say 'if you like' hehe! Thanks thats really kind, would love too. Really need a break and chat

Thanks for the support, I'm glad I'm not the only one who thought it was rude. But it certainly is interesting how some people think it was a fine thing to say, and that others don't. We are all very different, I suppose.

NappiesGalore, that is exactly it. I said she comes across as rude, not that she is rude. I was actually trying to help.

DaveOHara, I think the exclamation mark makes all the difference.

Absolutely agree, Tinygang.

OP posts:
nogoes · 22/02/2007 13:21

I am constantly telling my friend that I would rather she used email or the telephone as a way of communication because I probably sound hundred times ruder than your friend in my text messages.

DaveOHara · 22/02/2007 13:21

but she hasn't actually done anything wrong (the firend) she's not betrayed you or purposely hurt you and you've (from her point of view) openly attacked her. Sometimes it's best to let things rude for the sake of a friendship. So what she's a bit tactless... is it worth losing a friend over? that's the question ultimately.

nogoes · 22/02/2007 13:20

My text messages are very short as I am always in a hurry. If you communicate by text you have to accept that is not a polite form of communication. I don't think she was rude at all. If you had been speaking to her face to face or even by email I would consider it rude.

Spidermama · 22/02/2007 13:18

I think 'if you like' could easily mean, 'don't feel you have to'.
It's the kind of thing I'd write because I'd want the person not to feel the had to make the tira. As we've all been saying, because it's in a text it comes across a bit abrupt and careless, but I wouldn't read it as such.