Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

is it normal to think of dumping your child with a stranger before preschool?

35 replies

BarefootDancer · 21/02/2007 11:53

Took my friend's ds (AKA 'Tom') 4y to preschool this morning. Waiting in the lobby for the 10 minutes before preschool opens, a woman turns up with her dd. I don't know them as I dont go there often and was only doing a favour for my friend. Tom doesn't give any sign of knowing them either.
The woman says to her dd, but clearly in my hearing 'you can wait with Tom's mummy (meaning me) coz I have to go to work'....
I say 'I'm not Tom's mummy, I'm a friend...'
She does not carry on the conversation (she must have realised I was not looking helpful..). If she had asked me directly to look after her child, I would have refused, as I don't know her or the child at all.
Weird, or do people normally do this kind of thing? What I find most weird is that she was telling her dd to wait with me instead of introducing herself and asking me.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
crustonbread · 08/09/2022 14:39

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Pixel · 22/02/2007 13:41

I took ds to the cash and carry with me only to find that they'd changed the rules and no longer allowed pushchairs in. There was no way I could carry ds and move the huge trolley and he was fast asleep so the receptionist offered to have him behind the desk with her. It genuinely never occurred to me that there could be anything wrong with that. I didn't know her but I recognised her as having worked there for ages. Really, what was she going to do? She was working and the place is awash with cctv,you can see yourself on the monitor as you go in the door. I was just really grateful that I didn't have to drive all the way home again (1/2 hr) without any supplies. Ds even obligingly slept until I got back.

I agree that you do have to trust some people, (and I'm the sort of person who until very recently always took the children in with me to pay for petrol or buy a newspaper, even though they would only have been outside in a locked car and dd is almost 11). Obviously I want my children to be careful about putting themselves into dangerous situations but I would hate them to have the idea that everyone is a potential kidnapper or raving loony.

NotQuiteCockney · 22/02/2007 13:32

When I go clothes shopping (for me) with DS1 (5) I just bring books for him to read, and he sits in the corner of the shop, with my coat and bags, and reads. I wouldn't do this in a giant shop, as he might need the loo or something and not be able to find me, but it's fine in normal-sized stores.

prettybird · 22/02/2007 13:27

Good to kow Hoolgirl - but as ds is now 6, I think he's be a bit much of a handful!

But I'll echo NQC's comments.

I know that when my mum was new in this country, with a 3 year old (me) and a 1 year old (db), it was through random strangers helping her out that she made friends.

A stranger is only someone you don't know yet!

NotQuiteCockney · 22/02/2007 13:13

I let random people mind my kids all the time. I don't go in for stranger danger at all.

That being said, I don't thrust my kids at random people without the random people's consent!

hoolagirl · 22/02/2007 13:02

Prettybird, the changing room assistants in Topshop in Arygle Street are good for watching the kids whilst you try on various outfits .
Agree that this woman was a bit out of order, maybe she was desperate?

prettybird · 22/02/2007 12:38

Have to admit that like Shonaspurtle, althugh I think she should have asked you, I could imagine doing the same thing - and have done similar things to Shona. Maybe it's a Glasgow thing!

When ds was 11 months, we were in Skiathos and the nice Italian family (who we'd met on the beach the day before and who had been encahted by ds) offered to look after ds (who was sleeping in his sun tent) to allow dh and I to go for a swim, We jumped at the chance!

When he was 13 months old, we were in South Africa (Skiathos was a trial run and had been "free" with some holiday vouchers I had got as a bonus from work) and ds was playing up one lunch time. The restaurant staff whisked him away and was a given a tour of the kitchen and the outside gardens (a lot of the time out of sight) before lording it over everyone on the bar, being fed crisps , while we were able to enjoy our lunch.

I can remember being left in the primary school playground when I was very wee, while my mum went on to catch the train into Uni. it was normal for kids to be left in the playground in the 60s.

I think it is sad that we are now automatically distrustful of people with regard to kids (and other things!) - and I make a conscious effrot not to be.

Themis · 21/02/2007 20:43

I think the pre school should have a word with the mother or remind all parenst that they are responsible for their children on the preises until they are handed over to a member of staff.

This women obviously had no idea who parents were as she assumed you were the mother. Poor kid !

If she had asked directly I would have refused as well.. you could be leaving yourself wide open for problems.

Very strange actions. The child will think it is Ok to go with strangers when all the time as parents we are trying to enforce that it is wrong and prevent it.

FloatingInSpace · 21/02/2007 20:29

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

tribpot · 21/02/2007 20:24

My mum left ds with the shop assistant in a charity shop recently whilst she tried something on. I was a tad aghast when she told me, but she pointed out (a) she could hear ds the whole time and (b) the assistant had a broken leg and thus couldn't have run off with ds even if she'd wanted to! I probably wouldn't have done that, but I definitely wouldn't have left ds with someone who was with a child I vaguely knew ... no way.

FrannyandZooey · 21/02/2007 20:22

When I worked as a nanny people used to try to leave their kids with me all the ruddy time

I could have been anyone but apparently the fact someone else is willing to pay you to look after their children inspires great confidence

FrannyandZooey · 21/02/2007 20:21

Blimey, I've just remembered - when ds was little, I had to leave him with the receptionist at the doctor's several times while I had an appointment

can't remember why??? maybe I was having my stitches checked, I had loads of problems with them

anyway one time I came back and he was in his pram crying out in the hallway with loads of strangers standing around, right next to the front door

"oh sorry" she said "he was making a bit of noise and it was very busy"

WideWebWitch · 21/02/2007 20:18

Not normal imo. Agree that a baby with eg Mothercare employee is ok while you go for your purse but pre schooler with complete stranger in lobby is odd and not on imo.

sunnysideup · 21/02/2007 20:16

Totally agree with Comeoveneer.

And yes this woman's action in attempting to leave her child with you WAS seriously odd. Really odd.

I would certainly let the staff know that she tried to do this. Her set of priorities are odd if getting to work 5 mins sooner is more important than settling her son into pre-school, or at the very least ensuring that he is left in the hands of someone who is not a total stranger to the mother and child!

Of course I see the emergency scenario bit; but leaving my child with shop staff while I went to get my purse; that would give me nightmares forever. What's the hassle in taking the child with you to get the purse that outweighs their safety?

ComeOVeneer · 21/02/2007 20:04

Chipmonkey, as a dentist I agree that professionally it is easier to do your job if there isn't a screaming child there, but I am still very careful aboutwho I hand my children over to.

chipmonkey · 21/02/2007 13:12

I'd have done what shona did, tbh. Also, as an optometrist, it is far easier to carry out an eye exam with the baby out with the receptionist than trying to do it with mum and I both getting distracted by screams.

hertsnessex · 21/02/2007 13:03

When i take ds1 and ds2 swimming if ds1 needs a wee, then i ask mrs xxx with her kids to watch ds2, there are cameras, toilets you can see door from pool and its a members only club, so pretty secure. its easier than getting them both out of the pool, waiting for ds2 etc etc.....

but agree no where is 'safe' but you have to trust sometimes

cx

ComeOVeneer · 21/02/2007 12:58

I guess I am ovely cautious then. However a few years ago a friend of mine had here child abducted by a employee in Boots (fortunately they were caught by the security in the shopping centre a coiple of yards outside the shop). Apparently (it was discovered) this woman had given birth to a stillborn child many years before, and obviously had problems. So I'm afraid I don't trust anyone I don't know pretty well.

BarefootDancer · 21/02/2007 12:50

Thinking about it, yes I would have looked after the child, no problem, had I known the mum or child at all.
As I was there dropping off a friend's son I did not know many people there and would have felt uncomfortable about it. Not because I think she was taking a risk with her child (it was obvious I was just dropping off a child too), but that I would then be responsible for this unknown child who might have become upset at her mum leaving her with someone she didn't know at all.
The way she just mentioned it to the girl rather than me was odd and rude, and obviously made me avoid offering help at all.

I have left my own dc with various strangers - depends on what the situation is whether you think it a risk. It is a responsibility for the person you leave them with though.

OP posts:
GrumpyOldHorsewoman · 21/02/2007 12:37

Yes, it's one thing when the parent isn't going far and will be back (i.e emergency scenario) but to leave the child at the school gates and head off for however many hours, just assuming that she went inside OK and without asking the adult she wanted to leave her with is irresponsible. Lest we forget, this is a pre-school age child, not a 9 or 10 year-old who can take some responsibility for themselves for 10 minutes

sunnyjim · 21/02/2007 12:32

It is a bit outside the norm. I'd do it if I knew the mum in a heartbeat. However I have asked compelte strangers to watch DS in emergancies - ie DS ball rolls into the road out of the playground - turn and say to the nice mum and dad with a toddler the same age who has been 'playing' along side DS and say 'very sorry but would you mind keeping an eye on my lad for five minutes while I go rescue his ball safely'
Best friend also had to do it when out with her 7yr old and 2 yr old and heavily preggers with number 3 'can you possibly watch my kids I'm afraid I have to go throw up' (in a kiddies playzone)

I would ask directly

mummy2aaron · 21/02/2007 12:30

Lol at Jimjams, I know that feeling well.

MrsGoranVisnjic · 21/02/2007 12:30

woman was rude though

Bozza · 21/02/2007 12:29

Her first post, that is.

MrsGoranVisnjic · 21/02/2007 12:29

I'd leave my kids with anyone who'd have them

Swipe left for the next trending thread