Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

dh looking for job in UK, I am devastated and don't want to leave, but he hasn't seen another job here....

60 replies

ernest · 21/02/2007 10:10

We moved away nearly 7 years ago to switzerland, 2 of my 3 boys were born here. I love it here. We have a fantastic quality of life. My eldest stared school in August, aged 7, and still only does 5 mornings and 2 afternoons. The rest of the time he's outside playing with his mates.

My middle son is in Kindergarten (5 mronigns & 1 afternoon).

The youngest will start Kindergarten in 1.5 years.

The eldest 2 are bi lingual, the youngest is learning fast.

I basically agreed with dh to move back, he's in a fairly specialisied field and much more opportunities in London than here. He's been looking for a new job for a while & not found anything here. So now he's looking in london.

I thought I was ok with it, but thinking about it, now seemingly an imminent reality I feel truly sick. Sorry, I know you all, or the vast majority live in UK and most of you happy, but I feel we'd loose so much

  • the kids would loose their bi- lingualism, ds3 would never even get it.
-they'd have to start school, and go the full day!!! They would hate to be away from me, and me them. My poor ds2 has never even been to school yet (he's 6.5) how on earth would he manage in a school where kids have bbeen going already for a couple of years?? My youngest is too young. He really is.
  • Even finding a school and getting a place at a decent one sounds unbelievably difficult.
-they'd loose their freedom, going out to play every afternoon. I constantly read on here parents saying even their 9 year old is not allowed out to play & other such stuff.
  • how on earth would we find a house, never mind be able to afford one?
  • I'd loose my lovely new home.
  • Our health service here is brilliant (if I phone doc a 7.55 am they ask if I want to bring him in straight away! I have never had to wait even a day for an appointment,)
The conjestion in london, the madness, the traffic.
  • In the unicef report published last week, UK came out bottom place for bringing up kids, whereas Switzerland feels idillic.
  • I have a great support network of neighbours, and we all look out for each others' kids.
  • We can get to Austria, Germany etc really easily for holidays etc.
  • our family quality of life is really high.
  • we'd either have to live in London (used to live in leyton, Wimbledon, Battersea & tooting, so know it & don't want a repeat performance), or we'd move to a village/subburb with the horror commute involved)

OMG, sorry for the mammoth ramble. It just feels like a no win situation. I can't see anything good about moving back to uk, apart from seeing family more, but seems like comparitively small gain.

If I say no, then dh stuck in job he's fed up with. Then he's unhappy. He already is. And now so am i.

OP posts:
MrsSchadenfreude · 21/02/2007 22:19

Ahem - Xenia, I know you were referring to the OP but - my DH follows me...

Tortington · 21/02/2007 22:15

tbh its hard shit for your dh - the centre of his universe should be his family tell him to get on with it - many people hate their jobs but they dont make their whole family move to another country - that they know is crappier. tell him to get a grip and shut the fuck up moaning

FluffyMummy123 · 21/02/2007 22:11

Message withdrawn

OrmIrian · 21/02/2007 22:10

ernest - just wanted to inject a note of realism here . OK, so I've never lived in Switzerland and obviously it's lovely, but...... my life in the UK is great. It really isn't hell on earth. I really wonder where all this horror comes from. We live on a street where all the kids play out together in the street and in the park, we have neighbours that know each other and help out, my kids go to a reasonable school and are happy there, we live within walking distance of countryside and within 15 mins drive of hills and the coast.In the summer we chuck the tent in the boot and drive off to camp by the sea for the weekend. So far the NHS has always risen to the occasion - OK, we've been lucky and had no major problems, but I have no complaints. We're 50 mins away from 2 busy cities - we're off to Bristol to listen to a classical concert geared for kids.

Yes we have some problems and life is not perfect but please don't think that we are all living in abject terror and poverty. The perception of life here have changed over the last 20 years, far more than the reality.

I can see why you don't want to leave but please don't think it's an impossiblity.

Judy1234 · 21/02/2007 22:09

Well this is what happens when women don't work and are reliant on the male income. Why isn't he following your career where you choose? A lesson for the children may be? You lose that power and balance when you give up work.

Anyway if you do move back here remember you don't have to send them to school. Plenty of people on mumsnet educate their chidlren at home.

MrsSchadenfreude · 21/02/2007 21:54

Ernest, if you want to CAT me, we moved from Belgium "back" to UK (although I last lived in UK for any length of time back in 1987) kicking and screaming in September. Although we own a flat in Central London, which would have been big enough for us, we opted to continue renting this out and move right out to the country. DH works locally, I commute to London.

I don't know what you'd do about the children's bilingualism. The DDs were learning French at school (and doing well), and both had a good grasp of Dutch. Neither are being continued, despite my best efforts at home.

DD2 settled in much more quickly than DD1 (who is 8). DD1 still feels she "doesn't fit in" here and wants to go back to Flanders. As do we all.

School was not a problem - I just rang the local village school, spoke to the headmaster and asked. London is a bit mroe of a nightmare - it's not enough to have an address, you have to prove that you live there as well.

Our quality of life has definitely dropped, but I don't think it's as bad as we anticipated, although we still don't feel settled and have a garage full of boxes.

DingALongCow · 21/02/2007 14:01

Ernest, I am in Fribourg.

I really hope it all works out for you.

ernest · 21/02/2007 12:44

ha ha, zog, my 'positives' list wasn't in order. Already told dh that if we HAD to move, would only condider se england as mil in kent and sil in wimbledon. really, the ONLY positive would be the family . I bring kids back to uk every school holiday and get my knickers and tea then. but we see family quite a lot cobnsidering, probably more than many mumsnetters, we come to uk 3 times a year for a week or 2 each time, and they come here 3 or 4 times a year. in april we're taking pil to Austria for a week.

OP posts:
maisym · 21/02/2007 12:38

Your dh will have to decide either family happy or dh happy with job.

Could he get another job or retrain? Could you work out how much money you neeed every month and plans that involve you having enough cash to stay put. Moving is very costly as well - don't forget this.

I know switzerland very well & can understand you wanting to stay.

GrumpyOldHorsewoman · 21/02/2007 12:32

I agree. I have just moved lock, stock each time DH got a different job (moving up the career ladder) and there is nothing more unsettling and demoralising than keep upping sticks and moving to a whole new life with no local friends, knowledge or support. I am as isolated as I could possibly be, and I am living in the same country as my family and friends, but too far away from them to be able to get to see them on a regular basis. Most of our communication is done on the phone and, quite honestly, we could be anywhere. I would always recommend that you seek viable alternatives, or at least give them a go, before re-locating your entire lives. It is not just your DH's life and career that are important, but your own and your DCs. Hark at me, if only I could take my own advice...

sunnysideup · 21/02/2007 12:31

Ernest, what a situation, I don't envy you!

I do think you should stick to your guns, and drag your feet like mad here. You are idyllically happy, so are your children. Your Dh is putting his happiness above all that.

I think if he gets a job in london he should definitely go alone for now, until he is able to find for you and your children, a community and schools that would match what you need...make it up to him to do this, don't take this responsibility on....he might even cope with a weekend life with you and not want to make the move in the long run. I have a friend who works in sweden in the week and comes home to england each weekend.

I think if I were you I would write him a letter explaining as you have done on here, the things you and the children would be losing by moving.

I think he's got a lot of work to do here to make it ok..it certainly could be. We feel we have a pretty good life here in the south of the UK, by the sea, we are all very happy though I do agree regarding children going to school too young here!

Best of luck.

Zog · 21/02/2007 12:24

Also wanted to say that kids really don't go to school from morning to night! Mine do 8.50 - 3.15; that leaves plenty of time for extra activities, having friends over or just mooching about at home. I think whoever suggested your husband going first, leaving you in Switzerland with some breathing space to research areas & schools had an excellent idea.

Zog · 21/02/2007 12:21

Had to come back to this ernest.

I can honestly say, for my children the thing they love most about life in the UK is close proximity to their grandparents. We had a group of fantastic friends abroad who they had grown up with and the mothers were a vital support network to each other. But IMO, there is nothing like being near to people who love your children unconditionally - it's such a relief.

Family should go straight to the top of your list of pros - tea is irrelevant .

ernest · 21/02/2007 12:08

dingalongcow, where are you?

re other places in switzerland, it's annoying, becasue we were in basel for the 1st 4 years, and he was increasingly working in zurich, so when we decided to buy, dh wanted to move to near zurich. I didn't want to move again, loved where I was, settled etc but agreed. I even suggested half way between zurich and basel but this was rejected. Now the prospect of moving again has come up, only 2.5 years later. I really thought I was going to be in one place for a while this time

If he had listened, jobs in basel would be easier to get to, but as it is would be looking at monster commute. But nothing worse than london, I don't think.

thanks for link, SSShakeTheChi.

I will have to try ans persuade him
a. to stay put.
b. to get job in london and come home at weekends,

and
c. pray a job comes up here.

I just can't leave.

admylin, my dc's are opposite. when we go back, we stay with grandparents. Our dc's are only kids in family on both sides, so are very missed, highly adored and spoilt. So we go to uk, all the relatives travel from far and wide to see them, bring gifts, take them on fab day trips every day etc etc. totally spoilt. So they think UK = presents and ice cream and lovely holidays. Don't appreciate that they wouldn't see nanny every day, that nanny normally goes to work, that they'd be in school from morning till evening 5 days a week, no, they don't get it. Not said anything to them yet anyway, too big and too uncertain. I'll be as open and honest as necessary if/when necessary.

OP posts:
SSShakeTheChi · 21/02/2007 11:54

samstagsschule

I think you will be able to maintain the German of your older dc whilst in London if you can find time/energy. One good thing about major towns is the huge range of cultural activities.

I bet there are a lot of German speakers in London on MN who can tell you more about that - choirs, clubs, Saturday schools and then there is the Goethe Institut.

For the youngest I don't know. Perhaps there is a German or German-English kindergarten which you could try if you wanted to. Perhaps you'll be able to spend holidays in Switzerland or other German speaking countries.

DingALongCow · 21/02/2007 11:48

I can completely sympathise. We have been living in Switzerland for 13 months now and while the first 6 months were hard, I really cant imagine moving back to the UK now. DH's contract is short term- 5 years and we had planned to move back after 2 but are now looking at being here longer. The thought of going back and living in the UK again really makes me feel unwell.

Not sure where you are in CH, but would he/has he looked in other areas of Switzerland. Would you be happy to live in another city or town..but with still the benefits of living here?
The bilingualism thing-I have read some research somewhere about children brought up in another country with a different mother tongue and they found that even if they did not speak the language or left after a few years-that the structure was in the brain and they found it easy to pick it back up when exposed at a later date. Thats probably very confused, sorry..am trying to stop DD smearing jam all over me.

throckenholt · 21/02/2007 11:32

any chance of a compromise - eg moving to Austria or Germany where the system is more like Switzerland and they would still be bilingual in German ?

Mumpbump · 21/02/2007 11:31

I think there is a lot to be said for having two households initially. Your dh might hate the job in England, hate the lifestyle and decide to have another go in Switzerland or (heaven forbid) might not make it through the probation period. I know I am talking far-flung situations, but I think it sounds sensible for him to go and get established and you to use the time to reccie the areas in and around London (I can recommend Reigate area as a nice place to live and quite green!). Also, it would avoid your dh having the stress of moving and starting a new job at the same time which is not good...

admylin · 21/02/2007 11:31

I was wondering what your dc think about it? My 2 dc know the Uk only from holidays (mostly every school holiday) and they love it so much that they would pack up tomorrow and move even taking into account the longer school day, uniform and prospect of school dinners! They know and accept holiday and reality would be different.
Our family is opposite to you, my dh loves Germany and would stay forever but I want to get back to the UK. I can help my dc now with their school work (7 and 8yrs) but in the German system you are lost if you can't help them when they are older too as alot of the school work is expected to be done at home.
I think MN scares me too sometimes when I read the horror threads about bad school, getting places at schools and the cost of living etc. But then I also know that the UK has other sides. Don't forget people aren't as often likely to post on here " just wanted to say our primary school is great", people come on here to have a moan and get some sympathy or advice about negative sides of life.

ernest · 21/02/2007 11:28

zog, I appreciate your post, and the different view point, that's why I posted in the am I being unreasonable topic..
Maybe I should just get on with it.?

I am trying to think of positives.
Getting decent tea.
living closer to family.
marks and spencer.
school uniforms.

really struggling now.

How do we find these nice areas where kids can go out and play? I have read countless, countless threads where mumsnetters say they don't let their kids out, voices of horror at the irresponsibility of lettign a 6 year old out unsupervised. We aren't there. how do we find it? If they're at school the whole time, when do they have time to go out and play. After school clubs? Bloody hell, I don't think so, to be out all day, and then stay for extra? Even the 2 days a week that ds has afternoon school, he's still an hour at home with me for lunch, then a couple of hours more at school. He and his mates all troop off together along the vinyard path to the school....

If I knew it HAD to happen I would be as jolly as you like, I would not mention the downside to my boys, of course not, but am I being unreasonable? I feel like I have to choose between my boys' happiness and family quality of life, and my husbands'.

OP posts:
SSShakeTheChi · 21/02/2007 11:22

I suppose you could try the two household option at first if he really does get a good job offer in London and use that time to check out the options for all of you in London. Perhaps it wouldn't be as bad as you fear at the moment. You could say give it a year and use that year to look at schools, facilities, and get dc used to the idea, perhaps tutor the dc a bit to ease their transition into the UK school system.

One thing I think you could do for now though is to provide dh with a more active social life out of working hours, if you can see a way of doing that.

GrumpyOldHorsewoman · 21/02/2007 11:20

Sorry, as I have no constructive advice to give, but totally empathise as I have been in the same situation myself, albeit within the UK but moving to different parts of the country which has really impacted upon my quality of life. I do feel for you, as I know only too well what you are going through. Would your DH consider a stay of execution, as in agree to give it a certain length of time longer to find another job in Switzerland? Does he know just how unhappy you are at the prospect of returning to the UK? You do really need to talk it out - I didn't with my DH, I just went along with him and now regret it immensely. Although career-wise it has worked out brilliantly for him, but at the expense of a quality of life for our family.

Zog · 21/02/2007 11:20

I had all three of my children abroad and then moved back here when the oldest was 5. I agree with a lot of what you say about the quality of life abroad compared with the UK but just wanted to point out that I don't recognise a lot of what I read about life in the UK on MN!

It really does come down to where you live and what the community is like. There are places where all the children go together to the local school and play out together. There are affordable out of school activities, plus a lot of state primaries offer clubs and activities after school for no additional cost. OK, we don't have mountains and clean air but there is an awful lot about the UK that is downright fantastic.

I'm really sorry that you're heartbroken to leave but this really will be a whole lot tougher for everyone if you don't start looking for the positives in the move. And your children will all be fine, especially if you are .

ernest · 21/02/2007 11:10

i raised possibility of 'commute' like you said. He said he'd consider it for say 18 months, but thinks the strain would be too much.

For me tbh, I don't think it would have too significant an impact - he already works quite long hours and is often home after the boys are inbed, so I'm doing most of the wrk myself. But for him it would be hard to be on his own, and to be disciplined about not going to bed stupid late.

For me it's the lesser of 2 evils. he will only consider short term. we're near Zurich btw, only about 15/20 minutes from airport, so travel here not too diff. Annoyingly, easyjet moved from Zurich to Basel pretty much the same time we moved from BAsel to Zurich.

OP posts:
ernest · 21/02/2007 11:06

I think if he found achallenging job in Zurich, all would be fine. But in the last year or so, not one has come up. Like I say, he's in a fairly specialised role, tha's much more common in London and quite unusual here. He has friends he misses in London. He hasn't made friends here, other than at work, and many of his work friends have moved to positions in US etc, so now he's feeling a bit socially isolated. But like I said, he wants a new job and can't find one here. If he could, problem solved. for now anyway.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread