Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be annoyed at my mother's constant rewriting of history??

80 replies

harpsichordcarrier · 19/02/2007 14:53

today's gem (when talking about my sister's dire financial situation) "well of course you were very lucky, me and your dad supported you through university."

WTF???? what the flipdeflippingdoodle is the woman talking about?????

not one brass farthing did I ask for or get from them while I was studying or EVER in fact.

I was so taken aback that I just went "mmmmm" and now I am furious.

please tell me it's trivial and a long time ago and I should not be so mean to an old lady as to disturb her rose tinted spectacles.

OP posts:
Booboobedoo · 19/02/2007 17:42

Machiavellian

Booboobedoo · 19/02/2007 17:41

My MIL does this to me - and she's only known me for a few years.

She tells my SsIL things like 'When Booboobedoo didn't have any money she didn't buy any new clothes for a year' to try and get them to follow my (completely fictional) example.

It isn't true, and I have no idea where she got it from.

She does things like this alot (which as you can imagine is great for relations with SsIL), and I just smile and point out calmly that it's not true. Then I come up with something 'bad' like the fact that I used to smoke loads of pot. I refuse to be a pawn in her Machivellian plans!

CAMy · 19/02/2007 17:38

What's history for, if not to be rewritten?

ProfYaffle · 19/02/2007 17:28

My Dad does this, the other weekend at a big family meal he announced to the assembled company that I'd never given him a penny from my wages the entire time I lived at home, wtf? I stumped up every week and had no hesitation in pulling him up on it. He used to complain about his Mum having her own heavily edited version of his childhood as well

Blandmum · 19/02/2007 17:24

My Mum used to do this too

'I never have a favorate, I loved you and your brother the same'

Ah yes, this would be why you once screamed at me 'Don't you go visiting your boyfriend when he has scarlet fever, you might come back and give it to your brother!!!'

OttergavebirthonValentines · 19/02/2007 17:21

quit speaking to them - saves the stress

CAMy · 19/02/2007 17:13

But you will.

yomellamoHelly · 19/02/2007 16:53

My mun has done this for years. Fortunately I have 3 brothers to compare notes with and know they agree with my veriosn of how things were. FWIW when ds1 was tiny I asked for some photos of me when I was small to put in ds's room along with some we had of dh when he was a toddler. She sent photos of my youngest db. Even dh could tell it wasn't me.
I smile sweelty and swear never to do this to my poor children.

CAMy · 19/02/2007 16:28

I call it selective alzheimers

hippmummy · 19/02/2007 15:51

Ha ha!
Really didn't know it was so common. MIL does it all the time - talks about anecdotes in DH's childhood and he's like 'wtf?... that never happened!'. She usually does it to make comparisons betweenDH and his brother and our 2 DS's.

She also makes up stuff that that my DS's have done - as if I'm not going to remember!!!
Yesterday she said - 'oh, do you remember when DS1 used to come and hug me when you told him off?' - NO - because it never happened

Spidermama · 19/02/2007 15:28

Hello Greensleeves. I thought I'd see you here.

Harpsi, I would have to say something. The books say you have to practise saying it non defensively. ie Rather than 'No, That's not true. You gave me sod all', say something like, 'Is that how you remember it? How odd because I remember it completely differently'.

CAMy · 19/02/2007 15:26

Ah, no, I'm far too young to start a thread like that

hotandbothered · 19/02/2007 15:26

Thought it was just my mum
She's also rolled out the 'we got you through uni' one (many times). No - I got a grant (remember them?) although I think they paid my coach fare home a couple of times...
And the smacking one. 'I only had to smack you a couple of times'. Then why do I remember being permanently scared I would be smacked and many occasions...?
I get worried about it sometimes tho'. Because she talks such rubbish so often, I wonder how much of the family history she's told us is true? She is the queen of embellishment and also tells my sister and me completely different versions of things

Greensleeves · 19/02/2007 15:23

What a marvellous idea. Off you pop then

CAMy · 19/02/2007 15:21

I could say the same to you, Greeny, but I'll resist

Think I'll start a thread titled "Cut the old people some slack"

harpsichordcarrier · 19/02/2007 15:20

maybe I could start doing it to her:
ah mum, do remember how you used to lock us in the coal cellar and make us eat dog food when we were naughty? oh happy days

OP posts:
Greensleeves · 19/02/2007 15:18

Afternoon Cam, fancy seeing you on a thread like this

CAMy · 19/02/2007 15:17

But we will all do it.

Greensleeves · 19/02/2007 15:16

Oooh, there is nothing more infuriating than this! My mother used to come out with the most outrageous falsehoods out of the blue, like "I could count on one hand the number of times either of us smacked you kids!" (um, yes, if we were looking at one particular Sunday afternoon in 1983 perhaps...) or "You got those A-level results off the back of my hard work, they're mine" (from the woman who didn't send a single letter or come to a single parents' evening during my 5 years at boarding school)

I also used to swallow my tongue with rage while telling myself "well, they're getting on a bit now, no point rocking the boat".

Although in my case other factors intervened eventually.

fireflyfairy2 · 19/02/2007 15:11

Oh yes HCC, I preferred it that way. Even now I look on my sisters as parental figures.

CAMy · 19/02/2007 15:10

Yes you are being unreasonable, stop spoiling their fun. I do it myself already, I'll get really upset if anyone points it out to me and worse, expects me to tell the truth.

harpsichordcarrier · 19/02/2007 15:04

fff, your family sounds like mine. I have four older sisters, between 7-14 years older than me, and they did most of my parenting growing up. which was fine, actually

OP posts:
harpsichordcarrier · 19/02/2007 15:03

yes indeed caligula
I used to refer to this very phenomenon as my mother's Stalinist view of history
variants include:
me and your dad never had a cross word
of course you never wanted for anything as children

OP posts:
fireflyfairy2 · 19/02/2007 15:03

My mum constantly tells me how I always had lots of friends, people always knocking on the door for me... yet I never remember having many. I had a best friend & that was about it. She also says that she told us all the important stuff when we were growing up... when in my recollection, it was my 3 elder sisters ranging from 11 to 9 years older than me, that talked to me about periods, babies etc.....

Caligula · 19/02/2007 14:59

LOL

Yes it's unreasonable, because you should be used to it by now.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.