Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don't want to lie to my kid about Santa

497 replies

timeforachangeofname · 12/12/2016 06:50

I don't feel comfortable lying to my future kids about Santa, but I don't want them to ruin it for everyone else either. Has anyone managed to bring their child up not believing in Santa, without them ruining it for believers, or am I going to have to lie to them for the sake of others?

OP posts:
AnnPerkins · 12/12/2016 13:29

Santa is a GAME! A sparkly, tinselly, use-your-imagination game that we play every year with the mince pies and stockings and carrots for Rudolph

^^This is how Christmas always was for me. And I loved it. I don't remember ever believing in FC. I always thought everyone just played the game.

DS wants to believe at the moment but he won't for much longer. We will always play the game after he stops believing though. Like we do with Jack Frost and the Tooth Fairy, who he absolutely doesn't believe is real.

BowieFanMk2 · 12/12/2016 13:28

Yeah, we never did the "Santa only brings you stuff if you're good" thing. We always said "Santa will bring you gifts he thinks you need. It might not be exactly what you wanted but he thinks you'll need them" which covered us for any time we couldn't get hold of what we wanted, but it also made them understand that some of their friends may have got 'lesser' presents but they never saw it as a bad thing but something positive.

Nicpem1982 · 12/12/2016 13:25

Savage

I *agree re the stocking thing that's exactly why we do santa the way we do.

I think that the santa debate much like any parenting choice is about balance and the lesson here is respecting other people's parenting choices and what ever explanation you choose to give your child it's probably a good time to explain every family is different and that's fine too

In my small circle of friends we each have a different take on santa

savagehk · 12/12/2016 13:09

We aren't doing the Santa / FC thing but to those who are considering it or do already, one thing that I have picked up elsewhere is that if you stick with the 'Santa brings presents to those kids who are good' line, some kids whose parents can't afford the latest fantastical whatever it is could feel they've been 'worse' than another kid whose parents did. So if you're going to do it, perhaps stick to the 'Santa does stockings' thing, or that your parents buy you the gifts from Santa (or some other middle ground).

Re various upthread posts - I don't lie to my 4yo about other things either. It seems bizarre to invent this whole story and stick with it for (potentially) years. If he asks questions about other things, even difficult ones, he gets answered in a factual and age appropriate way. And yes, we have handled death and pregnancy so far with that approach (the pregnancy one is going to need a little fleshing out soon, though!). And saying that the picture they drew is good - it is good for a toddler / 4 year old, no one's saying it's a piece of fine art?

I certainly don't think that religious parents do Santa more than others do (as someone suggested). If anything it detracts significantly from the actual Christmas story.

welshgirlwannabe · 12/12/2016 12:47

Also having read more of the thread now can I just say that there is a difference between 'lying' to a just running toddler that mummy can't catch you and lying to your child by telling them a completely fabricated story and geeing them up until they buy it.

DameDiazepamTheDramaQueen · 12/12/2016 12:44

Have you ever seen a tiny child when they get up in the morning and Santa has been?

Yeah, that's because of the big pile of presents!Grin

welshgirlwannabe · 12/12/2016 12:37

I'm not British or Christian and so don't celebrate Christmas. We celebrate another holiday that is more low key and has no santa type characters.

Anyway, when my son was little I just explained that different people like to believe in different things and it's rude to tell them they're wrong. So even though we don't believe in santa other children do and that's okay. Tbh that's the same way I explained heaven and jesus and the easter bunny.

He did tell his friend that santa is a myth, but his friend appeared unscathed.

The thing is childhood is magical enough if you just leave them to it. My son had a fabulous imagination. For years he was a space puppy having all kinds of adventures. His favourite thing to play with friends was 'pretend you're...' and they were off. Kids create that for themselves if given half a chance. Not having santa does not equate to a childhood without 'magic'.

DameDiazepamTheDramaQueen · 12/12/2016 12:23

I find the whole insisting FC is a real person quite bizarre and for our family Christmas isn't about who brings us the presents.

FC is a nice story and sums up the spirit of Xmas and that's it, nothing more. Christmas for us is about family, carols and nice food - and presents!

We all have stockings ,even granny Smile

JacquesHammer · 12/12/2016 12:22

I have no idea if he ruined it for anyone and frankly don't care.
It's not my problem that other parents choose to lie to their children

Seems rather more judgemental but hey ho.

Notagainmun · 12/12/2016 12:21

My best childhood memories are of Christmas and Father Christmas. My adult DC can't wait to experience the fairy tale with their own children after having wonderful Christmases themselves. Some very sad and boring parents around lately.

Lweji · 12/12/2016 12:17

Reading the OP, I don't think it's about superior parenting.

We're just saying how we reconcile not saying Santa is real with Santa fun at Christmas. And how not to spoil it for others.

Either is fine, for me. Play Santa or not play Santa. I chose to keep it as a story and just fun.

JacquesHammer · 12/12/2016 12:15

Let's face it - this isn't about Father Christmas at all.

It is about belief in your own superior parenting. Grin

Natsku · 12/12/2016 12:10

My parents put the presents under the tree during the week before Christmas, really helped build the excitement up.

FreezerBird · 12/12/2016 12:07

Christmas Eve - tree goes up, as do other decorations. Kids have new pjs, a new decoration each to put on the tree, the snuggly christmas blankets come out and we have an indoor picnic usually while watching the muppets.

Kids go to bed, we put presents under the tree, it's all there when they come down in the morning.

The line "the presents won't be under the tree until you're asleep so OFF YOU GO" may be uttered.

Lweji · 12/12/2016 12:07

But we also do Norad Santa Tracking.

DS doesn't miss much fun, no.

Lweji · 12/12/2016 12:06

Yes, pretty much. DS knows he only gets the presents early on Christmas day because it's the day for presents.
Lately he has pushed for early presents. :)

NickyEds · 12/12/2016 12:03

To those who don't do Santa- what do you do on Christmas Eve? (Genuine question!) Do you put your children's gifts out whenever they're bought and wrapped? Do you say 'after you've gone to bed mummy and daddy will put your presents out'?

HolidayHunterTeam · 12/12/2016 12:03

I haven't read the full thread but I am hoping other peplle point out that lying is an important skill to teach a child. Not just that but also, its important that children know that people lie. For different reasons. Some good and some bad. I think to say santa is a lie you don't want to teach children is a really odd way of looking at the world.

It is completely harmless magical fun that last for only a few years. Why on earth taint it by calling santa a lie?

Natsku · 12/12/2016 11:58

My parents raised us (5 of us) without the Father Christmas story and with the exception of one of my brothers, we didn't ruin it for anyone else so I think its entirely possible.

I would much rather not do the Father Christmas thing either but my OH wants to, and his family does it and we go to their house to open presents and the neighbour comes dressed up as Father Christmas to bring them so its hard to escape.

Ankleswingers · 12/12/2016 11:57

What a depressing thread Sad

ElfontheShelfIsWATCHINGYOUTOO · 12/12/2016 11:56

and the Santa one is a pretty big, years-long lie which I'd rather not do

You may want to do it when you have young DC you seem to be missing the point - they want to believe. And you may be inflicting your own ideas on them when they dont want it.

Kel1234 · 12/12/2016 11:55

I agree, it's a bit of fun. Not really lying. And when they grow up and have children, they will understand why it's done

Iwasjustabouttosaythat · 12/12/2016 11:55

I can see both sides of this. I want to bring DS up to be a rational thinker and we explain in detail the true way things work - nature, machinery, anything we can really. Then suddenly I'm explaining how 8 flying reindeer pull a sleigh through the air... I feel utterly ridiculous and he looks at me with those big trusting eyes and I'm completely skewing his understanding of reality. How does a reindeer fly? Magic is real now? All magic or just xmas magic? Once you start where do you stop?

He loves making cookies for Santa, and leaving them out with milk and a carrot. He loves meeting Santa at xmas parties. Is that enough? Does everyone go into detail about Santa
living at the North Pole with his elf factory? I have no idea how far to take this!

I hate elf on the shelf though and we don't use Santa as a form of control. I remember the story being just wonderful as a child and I want DS to have those memories. I really did wait up and watch for Santa!

I don't resent my parents lying to me about it. In fact it's those lies that show me they did care enough at the time to attempt to give me a nice childhood.

ElfontheShelfIsWATCHINGYOUTOO · 12/12/2016 11:54

I lie to my DC about grandma in Heaven, I don't actually believe in heaven at all.

But saying to my DC that Granny is now bones and nothing else under soil is going to far in my book.

Am I wrong? Should I be sitting down and telling them the cold hard truth. Shall I also break it to them life is pretty shit actually, and grim and nasty and miserable? That one in three will catch cancer and it highly likely it will be them? Shall I continue to smile at MIL or shall I stop that white lie and tell them I cannot stand her? That grandpa is not a silly doddery old food but an alcoholic who can barely function?

timeforachangeofname · 12/12/2016 11:52

Wonder, Juggling and Johnny and others, some great ideas you've got there, so we could still do Santa stuff (coz I'm not anti-Santa really, just don't wanna lie) but in play.

DH likes this idea too! Thanks guys! Time will tell if it will work in reality but at least this way if they end up actually believing then it's not through me lying to them, as I'll have always been honest about it just being a game (just like playing with any other toys or playing make believe), and if they don't, they don't.

Also to the people going on about how I've not conceived yet - I'm a born researcher, and I can't have kids right now (going to start trying next year when we're more financially ready) so I research stuff to help with my broodiness. Santa happens to be everywhere right now, so naturally I got thinking about it.

I'm not saying I'm never going to lie to my kid, who knows what might happen, but I am going to avoid it as much as I can and the Santa one is a pretty big, years-long lie which I'd rather not do. Anyway I still find Christmas magical at my age, I love decorating and the songs and movies, and going to Christmas markets (I've been working at some this year even!)... I really love Christmas, and hopefully that love will pass onto my kids without me having to make up stuff about Santa. I would actually like it if they believed in Santa TBH, I just don't want to lie to them.

Merrymouse I am one of those adult Harry Potter lovers lol!

Knitmeaunicorn thanks, that's great to hear your experience of it!

OP posts: