Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Taboo" sex stories

116 replies

HoopsandEverything · 09/12/2016 09:43

So, I think I may be told AIBU and am a prude, but would like to know what the general consensus is.

So, if a sex story, which is completely fictional involves a 14/15 year old girl - is that wrong or right?

Just words, no pictures. No lack of consent from the girl in the story.

I don't know if Taboo is the right way to describe it either (this is why the whole conversation started, because I had described it as such).

OP posts:
DailyNameChange · 09/12/2016 10:18

And op why are you asking?

LostMySanityCanIBorrowYours · 09/12/2016 10:18

Literotica?

There's some nasty stuff on there.

I write some horrific things in my other (horror/dark fantasy/gothic type stuff) but it serves a purpose in the wider story. It is not for titilation. I would judge someone who wrote the same things for the purpose of arousing their audience.

Rape fantasy, I kind of get. It's a common fantasy for women. I have wrote close to the line on that theme but even then I make it clear a few paragraphs before the action starts that the character has a safe word that will be respected.

But underage stuff, out and out child abuse, violent rape - ick. What kind of person gets aroused by that?

DailyNameChange · 09/12/2016 10:18

Somewhat off topic but the point of lolita is that it is child abuse, but that because the reader sees it through the abusers eyes they are manipulated into viewing it as an equal relationship where she pursues him. Ofcourse if you read it from a criticall view point there are hundreds of clues showing it is clearly abuse and that the abuser has 'rewritten' it to justfy his rape of a very vulnerable children. The films are useless representations of this sadly.

Ofcourse literature about child abuse is unacceptable. Something like romeo and Juliet is different as they are both young teenagers, it is a much more equal relationship, no abuse of power, and no gratuitous sex scene (it's all rather romantic hyperbole that teens love).

Literature about child abuse normalises it and makes it acceptable. It is also victim blaming.

MrsDmitriTippensKrushnic · 09/12/2016 10:18

Are we talking about things written for money or fiction posted on sites such as Wattpad or AO3?

HoopsandEverything · 09/12/2016 10:17

Also, thank you for the education on consent.
Yes, there is a lack of consent because of age then.

So whilst this is a "willing" participant is it rape that is actually being described in this story?

OP posts:
MephistophelesApprentice · 09/12/2016 10:15

Erotics is a sub set of fiction, not somehow distinguished by the emotions it feelings it engenders. If it is OK to stimulate rage or fear with an action that's horrific in reality, there is no difference for lust.

Does Ms Marple normalise the urges of murderers? Does Hannibal normalise cannibalism? Does Gone Girl normalise wives framing their husbands for murder (and committing murder themselves)?

Your tastes are your own, your critiques as valid as any other, but to declare a form of fiction wrong is a claim to authority unpossessed.

ChardonnayKnickertonSmythe · 09/12/2016 10:15

Yes, it's wrong.

Laiste · 09/12/2016 10:14

So does anyone know; is it illegal to publish writings about illegal acts in what is obviously meant to be an erotic outlet?

maddiemookins16mum · 09/12/2016 10:14

I know a bloke who openly admitted enjoying reading those awful misery lit books about abused children, you know the type entitled "Daddy, don't hurt me" etc with the image of a very sad child on the front cover. My estimation of him went right down (especially when he read them at his desk over his Pret sandwich).
.

HoopsandEverything · 09/12/2016 10:13

I haven't seen the story, I believe it's on a website

I have really bad PTSD and things like this set it off. When it was being discussed I felt sick and in my mind it's not OK to write about, even though it didn't actually happen. There were some quite strong views that as it was a fantasy there was nothing wrong with it (as you can't control fantasies).

But if you write it down, it no longer is "just a fantasy" to me.

I totally get that my experiences may be making this a bigger deal that it is, but I am slightly confused some people I know (all be it, not very well) would think this was OK.

OP posts:
HermioneWeasley · 09/12/2016 10:13

Nope, I can't find underage or non consensual stuff sexy and I judge people who do.

FurryLittleTwerp · 09/12/2016 10:10

One of Jilly Cooper's fairly recent novels - the one about the boarding school - has underage sex in it, between consenting teens.

HoopsandEverything · 09/12/2016 10:08

is erotic fiction which contains storylines involving acts that would be illegal if performed in real life OK because it's purely fictional?

Yes, this is what I was trying to say.

It is definitely fictional and taking place in the story. It is not something that has happened and has been described. Everything is made up.

OP posts:
MrsDmitriTippensKrushnic · 09/12/2016 10:08

It depends on the context - I don't think you can make a blanket statement about it. I think you have to look at who's writing it and why, and the tone in which it's written. I can think of scenarios where it would make me intensely uncomfortable, but I can probably find novels where it happens and it's such a small part of a wider plot that it's all fine and dandy.

LostMySanityCanIBorrowYours · 09/12/2016 10:08

I write and publish Erotica.

There are sites that will publish stuff like this, but the major ones (Amazon especially) refuse. In fact Amazon will out and out ban you from ever publishing with them again if you so much as hint that your character is under 18.

IMO, it depends on the context as to whether this is okay or not. Straight up erotica, intended purely for titilation - no. Stick to 18+ preferably older.

Romantic erotica/steamy romance where the character meets their one true love and they stay with each other forever and ever/where there is a story line that is about engaging the reader and entertaining them as opposed to just getting them off - maybe, if it's done right. Although I'd stick to the safe side and have them wait until the MC were of age (becuase the extra money I get from 'Zon I need too much to risk)

It's fiction, I understand that. The characters are not real, but I feel a bit squicky about people getting off on the thought of minors DTD.

Branleuse · 09/12/2016 10:07

theres a massive difference between fictional erotica, and real images of sexual abuse, and real stories of sexual abuse are written about every bloody week in the shitty womens weekly magazines, and theyre pretty salacious, but theyre completely legal

I wouldnt be impressed with anyone who was into stories about underage sex, but I dont think they should be illegal

FrankAndBeans · 09/12/2016 10:06

There is a world of difference between fiction and erotica. One is being sold purely for people to masturbate over. I am not comfortable with either containing sexual abuse to be completely honest but there is obviously a gulf of difference between the two.
I would consider anyone writing and distributing erotica featuring child abuse scenes to be morally repugnant.

givemegravyonemoretime · 09/12/2016 10:05

I think it would depend on the purpose of the story (as pp have commented), the context, and the other participants.

Under UK law there would be a lack of consent, wouldn't there? Can a 15 y/o legally consent to sex?

An erotic story about a 15 y/o girl having sex with an adult, for adults to read for gratification? I'd say wrong, along the lines of child pornography created using photoshop. It's clearly a story about abuse, and I'd share pp's concerns about legitimising that.

A story which features sexual experimention between two teenagers with no power imbalance etc.? For a teenage audience, as part of a responsible narrative that doesnt normalise abusive behaviour? I'd say fine.

AlpacaPicnic · 09/12/2016 10:05

I suppose to me it would depend on who else is involved in the fictional sex. If it's another teenager then it's a bit ick but no different to say Judy Blume, or Sarah Dessen, or any teen romance/coming of age novel.
If it's an adult, then it's crossing a whole other line. But it is still fiction, but nothing I'd want to read.

JellyBelli · 09/12/2016 10:05

Its not ok.

  1. It doesnt help pedophiles. They are not encouraged to keep photo albums of young children because its not healthy. Neither is fictional pornography.
  2. Its not pornography if its abuse, its abuse.
Andrewofgg · 09/12/2016 10:04

Does anyone want to ban Lolita from being sold?

Or how about Romeo and Juliet given that she was only 14?

Namechangebitch · 09/12/2016 10:04

Romeo and Juliet?

13 yr old girl totally fictional.

What is the context of the story?

FrankAndBeans · 09/12/2016 10:02

I what possible sense is a crime of that scale irrelevant?
Are you stupid? It's completely irrelevant because one is erotica and one is fiction. One is written to play on people's imagination, the other is written for people to get off over. Do you write about scenes of sexual abuse for people to get off on too?

MephistophelesApprentice · 09/12/2016 10:00

There is a difference between describing a fictional event taking place within a story and describing something which is illegal in a story meant purely for titillation.

A: Really? What difference?

B: You don't think atrocities and mass rape are illegal?

C: You don't know for what purpose I write. Titillation may well be included.

MephistophelesApprentice · 09/12/2016 09:58

The example you've given is completely irrelevant. We're talking about sexual abuse here.

I bloody murdered people! Horribly! And did a whole lot worse in that camp, I can tell you. I what possible sense is a crime of that scale irrelevant?

Swipe left for the next trending thread