Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Taboo" sex stories

116 replies

HoopsandEverything · 09/12/2016 09:43

So, I think I may be told AIBU and am a prude, but would like to know what the general consensus is.

So, if a sex story, which is completely fictional involves a 14/15 year old girl - is that wrong or right?

Just words, no pictures. No lack of consent from the girl in the story.

I don't know if Taboo is the right way to describe it either (this is why the whole conversation started, because I had described it as such).

OP posts:
OneManBucket · 09/12/2016 14:28

What about Sade? Still widely published and legal to print and own in most countries. Still studied at universities. Still regarded as important literature. Where the word 'sadism' actually comes from. Should we erase his works entirely from history?

People will read Sade for several reasons and I don't doubt there are people who read them for sexual pleasure, but I'd say most read his works for the psychological/philosophical element and they provide interesting debate. It doesn't stop the content being horrific and you can't monitor every reader to ensure their intentions are purely academic.

I don't believe fiction ever has a boundary and I don't believe it should have a legal/illegal boundary imposed. But as with all art it is there for the reader to judge to their own standards and deem moral/immoral and anything else, that's the whole point. If you start trying to draw lines in fiction where would you stop?

SilkThreads · 09/12/2016 13:56

prh47
that is interesting, (re 1875, but a long time ago!)

PatriciaBateman · 09/12/2016 13:51

I think that morally, there is a difference between:

a) a storyline involving immoral acts (including sexual abuse, violence, murder, etc) as part of a true reflection of life (which unfortunately involves all those things), and happens to incorporate them into a story.

b) a story particularly and pointedly focusing on something abusive or immoral in a titillating manner for the purposes of furthering a fantasy for sexual or sadistic pleasure.

I don't think there is anything wrong with a), and I think it is a good thing that even the dark aspects of humanity can have a light shone on them, lest many of us just lapse into ignorance/denial.

However, b) is where it gets controversial for me. Most times, I wouldn't advocate the condemning of any activity (however distasteful) as long as someone isn't harmed. But I'd worry about this kind of material 'stoking the fire' in people who do harbour desires to hurt/abuse others.

I'm also not sure about the road it could lead us down. Would computer-generated child pornography be ok? (god, that makes me shudder, but technically victimless). What about child sex robots? (already discussion about this happening).

I guess for me, the crux of it would be whether those things would contribute to a deterioration in human depravity, and therefore increase the likelihood of actual harm happening (I think this is likely), or whether they would function as an outlet and reduce it (I think this less likely, as generally fantasy, particularly sexual fantasy seems to escalate).

HoopsandEverything · 09/12/2016 13:47

It's a woman (sorry, it's not a man), I think it might actually be two women in fact. I didn't really get into the details because I was having a major fucking meltdown over the fact that I was sitting with a small group of people who thought this was acceptable.

OP posts:
creakyknees13 · 09/12/2016 13:15

Oh and I don't need to chill thanks. A teen and an older man is a sensitive subject for me too although I don't have an extreme reaction

But it would be OK if she was 16? Anyway, and correct me if I am wrong, the OP has not said anything about the age of the man. What if it was another teenager- ie 2 15 year olds? Or a 16/17 year old. It's different if we are talking about a 50 year old man and a teen, I agree, but I don't think we can call sex with teenagers pedophilia, because it does not fit into the definition of pedophilia. As I have said, I would be uncomfortable if my partner got off on things like this, but I cannot see how this type of fiction should be banned. We can't ban everything we find offensive.

MephistophelesApprentice · 09/12/2016 12:44

prh47bridge

You're right, that was me being blinkered by my own cultural assumptions. A lot of it about on this thread.

HoopsandEverything · 09/12/2016 12:40

Apologies, that was for Filled not JAPAB

OP posts:
HoopsandEverything · 09/12/2016 12:39

shovetheholly and JAPAB

I tend to blank out everything to do with young children being sexually abused. I looked it up today, I have no recollection of having heard it before. I doubt anyone would have sat me down as a teenager, or young adult, given what I'd been through and told me about Lolita. I am not even sure how it would be pronounced.

Also had no idea that Romeo and Juliet story was based on young teenagers either.

OP posts:
HarryPottersMagicWand · 09/12/2016 12:34

I've vaguely heard the term 'Lolita' but didn't really understand what it meant or knew anything about the story until I looked it up on the back of this thread. Not everyone has heard about everything.

Oh and I don't need to chill thanks. A teen and an older man is a sensitive subject for me too although I don't have an extreme reaction.

Prawnofthepatriarchy · 09/12/2016 12:34

If it's fiction I can't see a problem. What about murder mysteries? And when it comes to underage sex, you do realise that stories about kids of 16 having sex, totally ok in the UK, would be considered paedophile in much of the US?

The whole point of fiction is that it's fictional. Plenty of American thrillers contain downright salacious accounts of sex murders. Somehow I manage not to call the cops.

JAPAB · 09/12/2016 12:29

^I agree shovetheholly.
Even the name has become synonymous with a sexually precocious girl.
It's literally become part of our language.^

There is always some people who won't have heard of things that you think everyone has or ought to have. I remember one of the young men on a series of I'm A Celeb thinking that WW2 started in the 70s, and Jade Goody demonstrating some similar lack of knowledge about Hitler. It happens.

prh47bridge · 09/12/2016 12:27

though a different name makes it no less illegal in most polities

I don't think that is right. In the majority of countries in Europe a 15 year old is able to consent to sex. In a significant number (including Austria, Germany, Italy and Portugal) a 14 year old is above the age of consent.

MephistophelesApprentice · 09/12/2016 12:07

Attraction to young teenagers is ephebophilia (though a different name makes it no less illegal in most polities or morally incorrect in coercive circumstances). Even Germaine Greer is an ephebophile, or at least published a picture book on the subject.

FilledSoda · 09/12/2016 12:06

I agree shovetheholly.
Even the name has become synonymous with a sexually precocious girl.
It's literally become part of our language.
I am always suspicious of overreactions anyway , 'retching' ? ffs

shovetheholly · 09/12/2016 12:00

OK, I think this thread is a wind-up. No way an adult hasn't heard of Lolita.

creakyknees13 · 09/12/2016 11:58

I don't care what it is in other countries. That doesn't make it right. In some countries it's considered perfectly fine for a 9 year old girl to marry an old man. It's not right just because it isn't illegal there

Chill we're talking about countries like Germany and Sweden here. Hardly some barbaric regimes. 16 is a completely arbitrary age. In the US it is mainly 18- they might think we are sick pedos over here.

HarryPottersMagicWand · 09/12/2016 11:54

"Disagree. In many countries the age of consent is lower than it is in the UK and sex with a 15 or 14 year old would be legal."

I don't care what it is in other countries. That doesn't make it right. In some countries it's considered perfectly fine for a 9 year old girl to marry an old man. It's not right just because it isn't illegal there.

creakyknees13 · 09/12/2016 11:54

I hadn't heard of Lolita, and I've just googled and read the first couple of lines on the wiki article. It just makes me feel really sick. Like retching sick. I think I might actually need to talk this through with someone

You feel sick about Lolita? By the way, Lolita is not some erotic/porno type thing, it's a very highly regarded literary masterpiece. I am also shocked you had never in your life heard of it. But just so you know, I have it on my bookshelf and so do millions of others- it's very well written, despite the creepy subject matter.

If whoever this is about has just read/written about 14/15 year olds, while it would make me question what they are actually turned on by, it's not pedophilia. Pedophilia is being turned on by pre-pubescent children. End the relationship if you feel too affected by it.

OohhThatsMe · 09/12/2016 11:53

I was on Amazon looking for chick lit the other day and was horrified at the amount of step-porn that was on there. Obviously I knew there were pornographic stories online, but I didn't think they'd be sold via Amazon.

JAPAB · 09/12/2016 11:52

Reading about something doesn't mean that you are going to act out those things. Nobody is harmed in the making of the material (unlike visual porn). Therefore, I do not think it should be banned.

There is a lot of Japanese Manga and Hentai out there featuring high school age characters. Animations and drawings so also not featuring real people, but things you can buy off the shelf in Japan are banned in the UK nonetheless.

If the argument is that those who view it and get turned on by it become more likely to do it in reality, then that would probably extend to fictional stories as well.

In terms of what I think ought to be illegal, I have never really been big on policing "thought crimes". People's fantasies are ultimately their own business. It would be preferably if everyone was only interested in adults, but I am not going to support punishing someone if for them that is not the case, and/or they use material that no-one was harmed in the making of such as these stories.

So I guess it all comes down to whether there is such a link between reading and doing.

FilledSoda · 09/12/2016 11:48

"retching sick"?
Yes I think you do need to talk to someone.
Is there a reason why this affects you so strongly?
Why are you posting about this ?
Lolita is a really well know piece of lit

PortiaFinis · 09/12/2016 11:37

But I think the thing is that Shakespeare didn't write R and J to deliberately arouse nor did he deliberately choose to use someone below the age of consent.

I think it is the choice to write about someone who is technically a child and to write about them in a way intended only to arouse. Neither of which Shakespeare did.

HoopsandEverything · 09/12/2016 11:34

No idea salty

OP posts:
prh47bridge · 09/12/2016 11:32

I would basically view them as a paedo

Disagree. In many countries the age of consent is lower than it is in the UK and sex with a 15 or 14 year old would be legal. Technically a paedophile is someone who is primarily sexually attracted to children aged 13 or younger.

Do you view Shakespeare as a paedophile? Juliet was 13. The play was written at a time when the age of consent had not been formalised but was generally viewed as being around 10-12.

SaltyBitch · 09/12/2016 11:26

How had you not heard of Lolita? It's so famous.

Swipe left for the next trending thread