Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

... to think that the parents who moan about a summer holiday playscheme costing £20 for FIVE mornings are tight arses?

61 replies

sandyballs · 15/02/2007 11:49

That works out at less than £5 per morning and the kids swim, paint t-shirts, paint mirrors, do tennis, gymnastics, go-karting on the field, a little circus comes in to show them tricks, an animal man comes in with reptiles etc, there's a disco ..... the list is endless and the kids have a great time.

I've joined the committee this year to help organise it and at yesterday's meeting they were trying to work out the figures and I suggested if money was a problem, they put it up slightly - another £1 or £2 per child, still great value in my mind. Well, the table went silent! A big no-no apparently as they get a lot of complaints that it costs as much as £20 already!

OP posts:
ebenezer · 15/02/2007 23:51

sorry but what really did it for me was when one mother turned up at a committee meeting to whinge about not being able to afford £5 for a morning session for her child to do arts and crafts and then i saw her half an hour later in the spar shop spending just about the same amount on a packet of fags for herself...I rest my case!

Piffle · 15/02/2007 23:32

half term for 13 yr old this week = best part of £1000
mind yu he is off to France skiing with school
you forget how cheap kids are when they're very little

persephonesnape · 15/02/2007 23:28

'day care for 3 children costing £600 per month and that's half your wages - a bloody bargain I'd say. Most people i know with one pre school child have to pay more than this, week in, week out, all year round!'

yes, mine were pre school once and yes my fees for childcare were higher then. I imagine that was because the children needed more one-on one care when they were younger. and there wasn't CTC when my eldest was in pre school, so it was met from our combined family income at the time.

combined family income is the key here because although half my wages may seem like a sweeping statement i support my children by myself - we're not a two income family and for a variety of reasons receive no maintenance. I am exceptionally lucky in my childcare because we do work hard to keep costs down and we attract a lot of grants etc because my children school in a shitty area.

I pay 20% of my childcare so at £600 a month I'd contribute £120, which is roughly equivalent to two weeks food shopping for a family of four for me.

childcare is ridiculously expensive for everyone, but saying that half my income (before tax credits) is acceptable is frankly, daft. how is the mortgage paid? food? why would i bother working? hello the beauty of day-time TV, because i don't have any family to rely on and I have always had to work.

ebenezer · 15/02/2007 22:50

Oh god don't get me started!!! I was on a committee that set up something similar a while back. The cost was very much the same as yours, the activities were great and the kids loved it. The 2nd summer we gave up and abandoned it precisely because of all the whingers. As a full time worker who was giving up my precious free time to help run it I thought ,sod this, and so did most of the rest of the committee. For us, the main problem was that most of the parents using it had NOT worked when their child was pre school, or had used extended family for minding the kids for free and just had NOT A CLUE about what childcare (which this essentially is) costs. They looked at me in amazement when I told them I normally spent £40 a day on childcare!! Persephonesnape - day care for 3 children costing £600 per month and that's half your wages - a bloody bargain I'd say. Most people i know with one pre school child have to pay more than this, week in, week out, all year round! Sorry to rant but this brings back memories of myself and a few others working our butts off to provide something worthwhile for our local kids and ending up wishing we hadn't bothered. So no you're not being unreasonable!!

Kelly1978 · 15/02/2007 18:28

I think it's a bit unfair that parents with mroe children are penalised. Surely even if every parednt only did two mornings, you would have enough helpers?

Kelly1978 · 15/02/2007 18:27

I've got four kids, so it would cost me £80 and I would be expected to help out for what? 4 mornings? I'm afraid I would def be turning my nose up at it!
I loved it until you mentioned the helping out bit. I couldn't really afford £80, but would like the idea of putting them in for jsut a couple of mornings to give me a break but if I had to help, I wouldn't actually get a break at all. And for £80 I could jsut take them on a couple of good days out instead.

mummydear · 15/02/2007 18:22

I do think that even if Mums have to stay that it is good value - but just pointing out to OP why people may turn their nose up.

I would consider taking mine along .

gingermonkey · 15/02/2007 18:16

Oh bugger, I got over excited reading the OP and didn't take the time to read through the rest of the thread. That'll teach me to not read the small print
Mind you, it's £3 to go a play centre (and get nothing included) for a couple of hours so it's still very good value (if you get all the bits and bobs included in the price). Do mums get a cup of tea included in the price and maybe a custard cream biscuit? If you do then I'd sign up

mummydear · 15/02/2007 18:04

But Ginger monkey you will not get rid of yor DD you may have to stay and help out.

thats why the cost is so low as there is alot of parental involvement.

gingermonkey · 15/02/2007 17:58

sandyballs, can my DD come - that's an absolute bargain!!!!! I'd gladly pay £20 a day to get rid of my DD for a bit in the hols The summer camp at DD's school is around £100 a week (and upwards depending on what they do) for 5 full days, which is what I call expensive (but still very tempting)

mummydear · 15/02/2007 17:02

It is good value except when you say that if you have two children then you have to be there 3 mornings ? I think it may not be just the cost but the fact you have to stay there the cost AND the fact that you have to stay there. Two children = £40 and you have to stay there .

With two or more children it may be cheaper to stay at home if you have to be with them anyway.

Good luck to you anyway

KTeePee · 15/02/2007 16:45

I think it's really good value. I bet those who moan about the cost probably wouldn't think twice about spending a fiver on ice creams and other treats on a day out....

Blu · 15/02/2007 16:36

JustUstwo - yes, I was assuming this was a playscheme designed to look after children whose parents were working - in which case you have to factor in, somehow, the cost of holiday childcare. If it is a 'holiday activity' for children with SAHMs I can see it is more of an optional nice thing you could do if you had the cash.

persephonesnape · 15/02/2007 13:40

so. a fiver a morning - if you were open in teh afternoons i suspose it would be a £10er a day? so £50 a week. x my three children = £150 a week. £600a month? thats half of my wages!!

my children go to an out of school and holiday playscheme - i pay £48 per week for all of them (together) throughout the year - but we work hard fundraising so the cost isn't prohibitive (and yes tax credits would cover 80% of that..) and apply for as many funds/grants/lottery money/european social fund as possible. my children go on trips, cinema, bowling, local parks, swimming, ice skating and generally have a whale of a time while I'm at work. they do go to places that i just couldn't afford to take them.

what ages are you looking at your playscheme covering btw? and although I'ma bit whiny about the cost, well done you for actually getting involved. obviously there should be a lot more cheap/free(!) out of school and holiday childcare, preferably state funded and organised, but until that glorious day, it's people like you getting involved that makes it happen, so thank you!

speedymama · 15/02/2007 13:38

Before I had my DTS I was involved in a youth group. I quit after a year because the ungrateful parents incensed me! Always quick to complain but never got off their backsides to help.

sandyballs · 15/02/2007 13:32

It is in Surrey , but only open to kids at the school unfortunately.

Parents are expected to help, should have mentioned that. If you have one child you are expected to help out for two mornings, two children = 3 mornings, not sure about any more than that, possibly the whole week, which would put some people off probably. The costs would be much higher if we didn't do this.

I agree that many of them probably have no idea how much effort goes into all this type of thing, behind the scenes. I didn't before I started getting involved.

OP posts:
sandyballs · 15/02/2007 13:32

It is in Surrey , but only open to kids at the school unfortunately.

Parents are expected to help, should have mentioned that. If you have one child you are expected to help out for two mornings, two children = 3 mornings, not sure about any more than that, possibly the whole week, which would put some people off probably. The costs would be much higher if we didn't do this.

I agree that many of them probably have no idea how much effort goes into all this type of thing, behind the scenes. I didn't before I started getting involved.

OP posts:
magnolia1 · 15/02/2007 13:27

a fiver each morning i meant

magnolia1 · 15/02/2007 13:26

Blimey it's great!! I have 5 kids so can't afford any type of playsceme around here but would happily find a fiver each.

Not near Surrey is it???/

unknownrebelbang · 15/02/2007 13:25

Sounds great and very good value - is £20 for 15 hours!

BUT a lot of people genuinely don't understand what is involved in organising, and the costs of running something like this.

I certainly wouldn't moan about the cost, it's excellent value, but I'd struggle because I have three, and the other thing that would be a problematic for me personally is that it's three hours a day, and I would need it to be at least four hours for it to be useful to fit in with my job. As a working mum I'd not want to pay £60 for the three and still have to take time off work. When I'm off work I want to spend time with my boys.

Not sure that makes any sense to anyone else.

speedymama · 15/02/2007 13:23

The people complaining probably go on 2 or 3 breaks a year as well as their annual holiday but somehow always manage to find the money for things like that. Some people are just plain ungrateful, imo.

ScottishThistle · 15/02/2007 13:22

I'd say they must be living in another world!...That'll cover the costs of materials & not a lot else...Some people amaze me!

sandyballs · 15/02/2007 13:10

They do have to commit to the whole week, can't do odd days.

OP posts:
pinkranger · 15/02/2007 13:08

i think that is fantastic- where are you!

sandyballs · 15/02/2007 13:08

It runs for just one week of the six week summer holiday. 9.15 - 12.15 Mon-Friday.
I agree that if people have 3 or 4 children, it's quite a lot of money, but then so is doing anything in the summer holidays with 3 or 4 children - cinema, swimming, etc, it all adds up.

I don't think people were saying they couldn't afford it, they genuinely seemed to think it was a lot of money for what they/the kids were getting . Looking at the amount the people involved charge though (cirucs, animal man, disco, go-karts) etc etc, I'm stunned they managed to do it for so little. It probably could be run more cheaply if we cut a lot of that stuff out and stuck to the more crafty activities but not as much fun IMO.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread