Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cleaner went through my purse and took money

243 replies

AquaAqua · 18/11/2016 18:12

So to cut a long story short she didn't really steal from us but I still feel really uncomfortable about this. Cleaner comes on a friday morning and I normally leave her money on the table. On the one occasion I forgot in the past I took it round to her that evening. Today I forgot to leave it out when I had to go out for a meeting. I left my bag (by accident!) in my bedroom. When I got back there was a note on the table saying I hadn't left her money out but it was ok as she had taken the payment from my purse and hoped I didn't mind. Now firstly I am in the wrong because I should have left the money out but I feel really uncomfortable that she helped herself, and secondly we have the agreement that she doesn't do upstairs - so I wonder what she was doing even going through my bedroom. She has cleaned for us for quite a while and we have a really good relationship so I don't want to blow this out of proportion but I am not sure how to respond to this.... am I being silly that this is making me worry about trusting her or do I just leave it?

OP posts:
GrandDesespoir · 18/11/2016 19:18

I find it odd that she went ahead and took the money (unusual lack of boundaries) but clearly there was no deceit involved, so in that sense she's probably actually quite trustworthy. If everything is otherwise good with her cleaning and your relationship I'd probably let it go, especially since you slipped up too in this scenario.

Bumplovin · 18/11/2016 19:17

Sorry I meant not wanting a direct debit. Surely a direct debit just ensure s payment is received and avoids error

Want2bSupermum · 18/11/2016 19:17

OP - I have 3 DC, work FT and I pay people on time because I make it a priority. Having kids doesn't stop you from going to the bank each month and taking out the cash you need to pay your cleaner each week they come.

You are very fortunate that you have not had to experience poverty. Just be thankful you are not relying on money coming in on time to meet your bills. Someone on a low wage won't have a buffer. Have some empathy.

jimthecat · 18/11/2016 19:16

I've forgotten to pay my cleaner before. She phoned me and I went back home to pay her.
It's weird she didn't phone but she was probably worried about disturbing your meeting. It sounds like it's an error of judgement. She obviously didn't think she was doing anything wrong as she left you a note to tell you about it.
I'd tell her you were uncomfortable and make sure she understands. I wouldn't sack her for this, especially if you have a good relationship and are happy with her work.

Bumplovin · 18/11/2016 19:14

Can't believe people are saying you can sbsolutely never forget something. We pay our cleaner by direct debit and I once forgot to leave a tenner for the bag of ironing she likes cash for. She just left the bag and a note saying could she come back tomorrow as we'd forgotten she certainly didn't root around the house for cash! Plus she texted me to point out the error and I apologised. It's oy Human to make a mistake sometimes. I also think not wanting cash could be tax avoidance if you pay for a regular service it's much better to pay Dd our cleaner actually insisted on this apart from the ironing money as we don't ask her to do that every time she comes so the amount varies

AquaAqua · 18/11/2016 19:13

Floggingmolly - in my opinion that is a huge assumption about cleaners - my husband is a gardener does that mean we're scraping for money as he reduced to tidying other peoples houses. He would never help himself if a client forgot. I wasn't trying to justify forgetting, I was responding to all the comments about her not being able to get the bus home. I forgot once when ds was in hospital and once this time. Yes I would have answered the phone and she has phoned before to check things etc if I've not been home.

OP posts:
nicenewdusters · 18/11/2016 19:13

It's not your place to judge how badly she needs the money

This cuts both ways. Just because somebody cleans for a living doesn't necessarily mean they're on skid row and don't have the bus fare home. If you go to work without the means to return home whose fault is that? Yes, you may have been relying on your money from that job. But what if there had been an emergency and the house was empty and locked and you weren't a key holder?

Responsibility cuts both ways.

brasty · 18/11/2016 19:11

I think she was wrong to go into your handbag, but I can understand if she was desperate her doing so. When I worked as a cleaner in peoples houses, there were times I needed the money that day to buy food for the evening. It is galling to clean houses off people who are much better off than you, and who "forget" to pay. Incredibly disrespectful. And unless you are earning minimum wage, others on this thread who are self employed probably do not understand this desperation.

ThirstyNell · 18/11/2016 19:11

My cleaner pays her rent in cash every Friday. She has an electricity card which she has to prepay. She is a single mum who supports her family. I have never not paid her, but I'm sure she would would rummage in our coin tray, or look on the microwave where I keep the petty cash, if she was going to be short. She doesn't clean my house for fun. She does it for subsistence. I trust her to be in my house, and take care of my possesions, and a friendly note from her saying she had sorted out payment would be entirely acceptable.
Most appalled respondents to this thread have NO understanding of what it's like to have NO buffer.

OP, show enough humanity to this woman, to understand. She may drive a car, etc., but she's still a cash in hand cleaner- she's skint.

Ldnmum2015 · 18/11/2016 19:10

Agree with 2dogs2kids, you don't know what her cashflow was like that day, she may be relying on the bus fare to get back home, or pay a bill before the evening, she may of even had to give up another booking to come to yours. I think if this is the second time you have forgotten, it sounds like she could wait to evening like last time. While I personally don't think it acceptable to go looking for cash, but she did leave a note, so fundamentally I don't think she was being intentionally dishonest, she prob really needed the cash that day. But where you take it from here I have no idea, you could try discussing, but relationships like this can turn sour really quickly, she also may not of felt comfortable with having to chase you.

QuiteLikely5 · 18/11/2016 19:10

This is not acceptable by any standards. The trust has been damaged and she should not be looking around your house when she had no right to.

In your shoes I would find another cleaner.

I would be questioning her character after this and wouldn't be able to feel comfortable in the future knowing she was roaming around my home.

Floggingmolly · 18/11/2016 19:08

How can you not guarantee you'll never forget again?? She doesn't forget to come and clean your house, does she?

brasty · 18/11/2016 19:08

Honestly not leaving money out for someone who is on a low wage, and probably really needs the money when it was due, is not on. Would you be happy if your boss forgot to pay you?

BurningBridges · 18/11/2016 19:08

This is fabulous news. I'm self employed and sometimes my clients forget to pay me. But this doesn't matter now as rather than ask them if they wouldn't mind paying, I can go round their houses and take the money.

I mean I might have to look round a bit first, but that's another bonus surely. Sorted.

Ilovehedgehogs · 18/11/2016 19:07

Aqua you will have to keep on repeating that she refused dd at regular intervals I think.

Floggingmolly · 18/11/2016 19:07

Would you have answered the phone if she had called you, op, given that you were in a meeting? She should never have had to leave your house without the cash. You forgot twice??
You could have left her without any cash for the weekend; it's not your place to judge how badly she needs the money, and it's fairly crap that you tried to justify forgetting to pay her by reasoning that she doesn't really "need" it.
She scrubbing other people's houses, of course she needs it Hmm

nicenewdusters · 18/11/2016 19:06

I had a job that involved spending time in people's homes, often alone, there was a huge amount of trust. Lots of these people became my friends. I would never, ever, have taken the money from someone's purse. Even if I hadn't been left the money (I was paid in various ways - legitimate business) if there was cash lying around (which there often was) I wouldn't have dreamt of taking it. People did occasionally forget, it wasn't a big deal. Either paid twice the next time or dropped it around.

I don't think this incident suggests your cleaner has been doing anything wrong in the past. But, maybe through familiarity, she now feels able to go into your handbag. It's just unacceptable in any scenario, cleaner/friend/work colleague. For me it would change the boundaries, and unless she realised that I'm not sure I could continue employing her.

As for the OP bashing, totally uncalled for. And RTFF before suggesting dd/standing order - it's not an option here.

AquaAqua · 18/11/2016 19:04

The first time I forgot I was in hospital with ds2.... I am not infallible and with two young children who don't sleep I can be a little forgetful at times. Judging by some/ most of these comments - I think I should probably find a cleaner who will take dd as it seems a bigger issue that I forgot to leave money out. As much as I try to remember I cannot absolutely guarantee I will never, ever forget again... hence why I would prefer dd.

OP posts:
JustCallMeKate · 18/11/2016 19:03

have none of you ever forgotten something?

Oh yes, I've forgotten plenty of things but never someone's wages. I can't believe anyone thinks that's acceptable.

Want2bSupermum · 18/11/2016 19:01

Tata Yes I forgot to pay someone once and I apologized, stopped my work call, ran out to get the money needed to pay them and added $20 to the amount because I had kept them waiting meaning they were still on the clock plus missed their train. It never happened again.

Whatgives · 18/11/2016 19:01

You made a mistake, what she did was intentional. She shouldnt have been upstairs in the first place never mind going through your bag. And for that reason I'd think I'd have to let her go. I couldn't trust her.

littletike · 18/11/2016 19:01

I wouldn't be happy about this at all.

Firstly she had to go looking for your bag to find it and then to help herself is unforgivable in my book. Yes you forgot to leave the money out but if she's that hard up she could've checked before cleaning for you and called you - it doesn't justify her taking money out of your purse.

To those of you saying it's ok would it also be ok for a friend or relative to take money out of your purse that you owe them?

AChristmasCactus · 18/11/2016 19:01

have none of you ever forgotten something?!

No, I've never forgotten to pay for a service. If I could afford a cleaner I would show her some basic respect and pay her on time.

Do you often walk out of shops without paying?

TataEs · 18/11/2016 18:59

ppl saying the OP is disorganised or her memory isn't what it should be are ridiculous. have none of you ever forgotten something?!

Want2bSupermum · 18/11/2016 18:59

I have people working for our family in our home, doing housework and childcare. They are ALWAYS paid in full and on time. Every month I get the envelopes ready and the money is in there so I don't have to be rushing around trying to pay people.

If you had been more organized and paid her, she would not have gone into your purse/handbag to get the money out. I would not sack her but tell her she crossed a boundary by going upstairs and another boundary when she took the money from your purse.

My cleaner is struggling and if I don't pay her she can't make her rent. It is beyond important that she is paid on time and in full. It is called being a responsible employer. Open your eyes people and think about what is going on in other peoples lives. When you hire someone, they expect to get paid on time. To not do so is just unacceptable.

Swipe left for the next trending thread