Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cleaner went through my purse and took money

243 replies

AquaAqua · 18/11/2016 18:12

So to cut a long story short she didn't really steal from us but I still feel really uncomfortable about this. Cleaner comes on a friday morning and I normally leave her money on the table. On the one occasion I forgot in the past I took it round to her that evening. Today I forgot to leave it out when I had to go out for a meeting. I left my bag (by accident!) in my bedroom. When I got back there was a note on the table saying I hadn't left her money out but it was ok as she had taken the payment from my purse and hoped I didn't mind. Now firstly I am in the wrong because I should have left the money out but I feel really uncomfortable that she helped herself, and secondly we have the agreement that she doesn't do upstairs - so I wonder what she was doing even going through my bedroom. She has cleaned for us for quite a while and we have a really good relationship so I don't want to blow this out of proportion but I am not sure how to respond to this.... am I being silly that this is making me worry about trusting her or do I just leave it?

OP posts:
bbcessex · 18/11/2016 19:47

ilovehedgehogs - completely agree. Cleaning is certainly not a drudge job.

LHReturns · 18/11/2016 19:46

Well done Aqua. I also pay my cleaner in cash as she doesn't want bank transfers. I was clear from the start that while I was happy to pay cash I wouldn't always have the cash dead on time each month.

Paying cash is a total inconvenience and probably is tax avoidance in our case (mine works 15 hours a week for £12/hour for us; and another family in a similar way).

I am regularly up to a week late in paying and she would never dig around in my wallet for the cash. Largely because she would never ever be so intrusive, but also because she respects that I put myself out enormously each month to pay her a wad of cash.

If you have only been late twice in a year, then you are doing just fine.

Ldnmum2015 · 18/11/2016 19:45

Well done aquaaqua, I did wonder if there was a man behind it!

brasty · 18/11/2016 19:44

Okay everyone I know who cleans,only does that and does rely on it.

Ilovehedgehogs · 18/11/2016 19:44

£15 here and they can pick and choose their jobs. Mine has started end of tenancy cleans too and that is very good work.

It's a very respectable form of self employment.

liz70 · 18/11/2016 19:42

Good to hear it's all worked out okay, OP. Smile

bbcessex · 18/11/2016 19:41

brasty... of the cleaners I know, cleaning is not a full time job or a career.. so I do think that £12 per hour for a (usually local) part time job / supplementing family money / working around childcare is not too bad, yes. And £12 is average... it can be much more.

areyoubeingserviced · 18/11/2016 19:40

Sack her

bbcessex · 18/11/2016 19:38

Phew... all sorted then Aqua. Good work. Glad her husband was rational. You were right to feel Confused.

I'm sure someone will be on in a sec to say how dare you expect your cleaner to use her credit to text you Grin

brasty · 18/11/2016 19:35

You don't think someone earning under £10k a year is poor?

bbcessex · 18/11/2016 19:34

Ha - bottom two sentences of my post somehow out of sequence!!!!

not suggesting you start a campaign OP Grin

AquaAqua · 18/11/2016 19:34

So there, all sorted, I sent text apologising for for not leaving out money, she responded saying sorry she took money as apparently her dh told her that was 'out of order' but she didn't think I'd mind. I replied saying I felt a bit funny about it if I was honest, if it was ever an issue again I prefer she just phoned me. She came back with a friendly text saying that was fine.

OP posts:
Ilovehedgehogs · 18/11/2016 19:34

It's so patronising to cleaners isn't it? Mine has just got back from watching the Ryder Cup in America Grin

bbcessex · 18/11/2016 19:32

I am laughing at the holier-than-thou posters who have stereotyped a cleaner into being a poor, hand to mouth, "what will Tiny Tim eat for Christmas" type character.

Bending so far over backwards to be liberal that you can probably see your own dusters Hmm. You are the ones who have the issue, not the OP.

My cleaner:
drives to my house
eats at the same restaurants as me
goes away on holiday (I pay her for the time she's off)
gets £12 per hour

OP - you are not wrong in the slightest to be unhappy that this has happened. I've had the same cleaner for 5 years. She is brilliant. Like your cleaner, mine prefers cash but is recently open to bank transfers. I have (on rare occasion) not had the cash handy (usually when she's changed days / done different hours). It happens. CLEANERS DO NOT STARVE if they don't get paid the second they finish. Some cleaners clean in schools, hospitals, offices... they do not get paid the minute they finish one shift. My cleaner has never and hopefully would never go routing for cash if I didn't leave it. I don't know what I'd do but it would drive a wedge.

.

But feel free to start a campaign or maybe produce a charity record for wretched cleaners everywhere Grin.

She prefers cash. Most cleaners earn under the £10k or whatever it is annual tax allowance so they are not trying to avoid tax, as someone up thread said.

Graphista · 18/11/2016 19:32

There's assumptions being made about those of us saying sack her too!

I ABSOLUTELY know how it is to have no buffer, to have employers messing up pay resulting in not being able to pay a bill or even eat! I STILL would never have gone rummaging for the money!

shopaholic999 · 18/11/2016 19:32

This thread is infuriating.

It seems that it is now ok to rifle through someone private property! My dh is self employed, would it be ok for him to start going through customers handbags to get his wage! No it wouldn't, he can go weeks without being paid, it's the nature of being self employed!

If the cleaner wants regular definite wages then she needs to agree to dd or find a job that pays weekly/monthly

PlumsGalore · 18/11/2016 19:31

Forgetting to pay her is close to unforgiveable, but going upstairs without the need, rooting around then taking it, just whoa!

If this happened I would be starting a thread on AIBU....

Ldnmum2015 · 18/11/2016 19:31

I think truthfully I would think about getting a new cleaner, a professional should accept dd, which is easier for both parties. From what you describe, I don't think you have to worry about her snooping before, but as you say and its quite valid, there may be times you forget and it puts you in a situation because the cleaner us expecting cash, and therefore plan her day on that assumtions, ie; she might not bother going to the bank for her bus fare, supplies, dinner etc if she knows there is cash as payment. I am lucky that if a customer forgets, as we all do, I haven't had to rely on it, so I have no idea how to answer objectively to you, if say I had got stranded because i didn't have bus fare. It was a overstep of boundaries though she did leave a note which does show she is honest.

TheLegendOfBeans · 18/11/2016 19:26

Definitely put a smiley at the end of the note though - seriously. Keeps things nice :)

FireSquirrel · 18/11/2016 19:24

I'm really sorry I forgot to leave your money out. But I'm really not happy with you going to my bag-please don't do that again. If there's ever a problem just ring me. See you next Friday. Sorted.

This. She shouldn't have gone through your bag and I wouldn't be at all happy about it, but if this is the first time there's been an issue and she is otherwise reliable and trustworthy, I would put this down to an error of judgement and give her another chance.

Vanillagirl00 · 18/11/2016 19:23

I think I would have felt a bit taken aback in your situation- but to be honest, equally embarrassed that I hadn't left it out. And your 'wrong' came first. The problem wouldn't have arisen if you'd paid her in the first place, which I'm sure she's fairly frustrated has happened twice now, whether she prefers cash or DD isn't that relevant.

She sounds like a good cleaner overall who perhaps misjudged boundaries. But she was clearly needing the money which she had reasonably expected that day.

I'd mention it gently to her, apologise for not leaving the money out and would keep her on if she's otherwise been good at her job.

DipsyLaLa22 · 18/11/2016 19:21

I have had a cleaner for 3 years and have once forgotten to leave money out. It's her choice to be paid in cash, I'd prefer direct debit. She texted me, I was mortified and took it round to her house on the way home from work. Mistakes happen. But, I would have been upset at her going through my purse.

And bourdic, despite having a nice middle class job, my employer has forgotten to pay me in the past. Funnily enough, I didn't throw my toys out of the pram, or get half as angry about it as you are with the OP

SporkLife · 18/11/2016 19:20

I used to work as a cleaner and would of expected to be sacked if I was rooting around in someone's handbag. She could of texted or rang about the money, going into the hand bag is crossing too many boundaries I'd look for another one.

TheLegendOfBeans · 18/11/2016 19:20

FUCKING HELL THIS THREAD - Classic MN caught on a bad moment. It's a wonder there's not been a call for you to go to the scaffold.

Here's the crux: she should've called/texted first. She didn't and now it feels that - smiley note or not - she's breached your trust.

If it was me, I'd explain in a friendly manner that you are sorry for forgetting the cash and that you'll do what you can to ensure it never happens again but that she should've called you.

If your OP had said you got a missed call then she went and did this it'd be less bad; but this would make me feel uncomfortable and quite upset TBH.

brasty · 18/11/2016 19:19

She may want cash for a number of reasons, including not having a bank account. If you are poor, the few forms of identity you may have can make it difficult to open a bank account. Yes I know there are basic bank accounts anyone is supposed to be able to open. And I have heard of those wrongly turned down for one by the banks.

Sometimes mumsnet does show its well off demographic.

But talk to her OP. Things are much better sorted out by being talked about.

Swipe left for the next trending thread