Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

for being bl***y LIVID with my mother?

91 replies

Callmemadam · 12/02/2007 22:18

My eldest ds (nearly 16) has a brilliant relationship with his youngest sibling (DD2, nearly 5). He and ds2 and dd1 are all away at boarding school, so this half term, as usual, dd2 was crawling all over her big brother, getting tickled, roughed up, having her toys played with, and generally having a riotous family time. Anyway, my mother came over on Saturday afternoon and saw ds1 playing with dd2 and rang him 'in confidence' later that evening to say that 'he should be careful that people didn't jump to the wrong conclusion' if they saw her 'crawling ' all over him . I am still so angry I can hardly speak, partly because I thought it was such a sick thing to say to ds, and partly because she bloody said it 'in confidence'!!! Thank God he was able to tell me why she phones. The sad thing is that - whatever he says - I can tell it HAS affected his relationship with dd2 . To put it in perspective, my siblings and I were brought up in a very non-tactile way, but even so I find the fact that she could come up with such a comment really upsetting................

OP posts:
Sobernow · 19/02/2007 21:17

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

fortyplus · 19/02/2007 21:14

So angry about this - she's not normal!

We can all delight in our children's bodies in a sensual but non sexual way. I still stroke my boys' backs - they're 11 & 13 and we all love it.

I wouldn't dream of even touching someone else's child's body - it would be totally inappropriate.

How dare she interfere in this innocent relationship.

Muminfife · 19/02/2007 21:08

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

Callmemadam · 19/02/2007 20:56

I have GOT to tell you - she's done it again, only worse . She visited at the weekend, and went off with DS for a 'chat'. I found him crying in his room, saying 'grandmaa had planted such a 'f***g sick thought in his head and he couldnt get rid of it'....turns out she had tried to explain to him that little girls 'might get excited' rubbing themselves on someone and that letting her wrap her legs around him when they are tussling or hugging might cause excitement because of where she is . FFS!!!! When I challenged her (and tore her off a strip) she said that she was 'trying to warn him' that busybodies might misinterpret their play, and THEN said didn't I realise that young men get excited too!!!! I just CANNOT believe the way her mind works, and she has NO idea how much damage she has done to DS's relationship with her. TBH I think he is less upset about his relationship with his siblings (thank God) than he is with his Grandma, whom he ADORED. . I asked her why she had brought it up again and she said she wanted to make sure he wasn't embarassed about what she was explaining last week!!!! So she KNEW she was out of order then.... I asked her why, if she thought it was a valid point to raise, she hadn't raised it with me first, and she said that she thought it better not to put the thought into MY head in case I worried there was something in it!! So it was alright to put it into my son's head instead?????

I have explained to DS that we were never huigged or cuddled as kids, and because he has seen my sister who suffers from anxiety and depression I think he does understand that the problem is Grandma's (or I hope and pray he does). But the damage is terrible, and I have NO idea how to continue with my mother ATM at all. Sorry for the rant btw

OP posts:
Angeliz · 13/02/2007 19:26

Poor boy

I haven't read all the posts but got to the part about it being very damaging for him. It is a damaging thing to say and he must feel awful. I hope he can write it off as stupidity and ignorance on your Mum's behalf and not let it haunt him.
I think we could all understand her concerns if it were a new uncle or something (as in someone's new boyfriend, i am always cautious with my sisiters men as she's had so many ) but her own adoring older brother is just daft!

Anisse · 13/02/2007 19:13

I would be furious.

To make sure it hasnt damaged ds and dds relationship I would certainly whisper to ds that your Mother has 'problems' and really needs help with that. Not him.

DimpledThighs · 13/02/2007 19:10

make it clear to evweryone involved that granny is bang out of order and this kind of interferance will not be tolerated.

This is one of the most anger inducing things I have read on mumsnet. If it was me I would be beside myself with rage!

sazzybee · 13/02/2007 19:01

I have to say that 'is granny mad' is the healthiest reaction I think he could have had under the circumstances

Callmemadam · 13/02/2007 17:23

Really appreciate the support, guys! Aloha, great points and I will talk to DS. FWIW she wasn't implying that he was DOING anything, just that having such a physical and fun relationship with a little one would appear 'odd' to onlookers - which made him question what has been an unthinking rapport with all his younger siblings (even though he does beat up on the other teenager sometimes . I just think that that was so sad for him, and also sad because his opening sentence to me was 'is granny mad?' which suggests that the real harm will be to his relationship with her. Xenia, he does have posters in his room and all over the dorm at school, but granny would also be horrified by them, and she most certainly would NOT alow parents sharing baths with children, or for that matter the child seeing its parent naked. Zofloyya - you are so right, 'warped' is what I feel about it too.

OP posts:
catsmother · 13/02/2007 15:50

I think the person at fault her is 100% granny, not 99%.

brandy7 · 13/02/2007 15:15

meant psml at the "granny with knickers in air" comment,not on the thread as a whole

Blu · 13/02/2007 15:08

LIke someone below, I would be thinking twice about what has sparked your mother's terror of physical contact in the family, and her concern about brother / sister relations. . I would confront her, but asking why she sees it as a problem as well as pointing out the destruction of trust/ hurt for your ds and the secrecy issues.

brandy7 · 13/02/2007 14:46

pmsl!

Judy1234 · 13/02/2007 14:39

That's the point. Why should families who are happy to be nude together or who think photos of naked children look wonderful (I do, wonderful, not sexual, in an any way) or who cuddle and lie in bed together why should they change their behaviour because a very very few people abuse children?

Sorry, I only made the converse point below because you always have to try to see things from both sides. Getting off the point a bit but some children abused by their fathers where the mother refuses to believe them etc... very nasty difficult cases. As some one else said here he wasn't sneaking in private and he told his mother what granny said so the person at fault here is 99% granny and how weird she is and what a good teenage boy to tell his mother. I hope you all get granny on the floor with her knickers in the air giving her big bear hugs the next time she visits.

Elasticwoman · 13/02/2007 14:33

My Dad used to say "to the pure in heart, all things are slightly filthy". It's like the notice up in the local swimming pool I saw at the weekend, prohibiting the taking of any photographs of children in the water. Why? They are in a public place! The hysteria about child sex abuse is getting out of hand. Not that I'm saying it doesn't ever happen - just not usually in public. The 15 yo was being upfront about what he was doing, not hiding away in a corner furtively. The damage (potentially) done to his lovely relationship with small sister far outweighs the risk that anything untoward was being done or might be suspected by any right thinking person.

WideWebWitch · 13/02/2007 14:13

You're right to be livid. How awful, poor ds.

harpsichordcarrier · 13/02/2007 14:12

ffs. words fail me really, but I would agree that it was sick and vastly inappropriate to say anything in confidence.
if she really did suspect something well then he should absolutely have come to you

controlfreakyandroses · 13/02/2007 14:11

xenia. are you sure you're happy to advocate children bathing with parents as ok activity.... parents do sometimes sexually abuse their children you know.... and you wouldnt want to do it in front of your mum really would you?

brandy7 · 13/02/2007 14:07

xenia youre at it again i see

OttergavebirthonValentines · 13/02/2007 14:06

perrrllllease

Judy1234 · 13/02/2007 12:51

Complex issues. None of us can know. Let's be clear sometimes there is incest between siblings. Let us assume there is no question here but not discount that possiblity in any of our own families. Did she see something you didn't? Did she make something up? I liked the point that it seems a bit sinister how she did it too, didn't it? Is it a bit like the recent study that found that a lot of those who criticise gays are closet gays?

sunnysideup · 13/02/2007 12:18

It's all been said really, but I wanted to add that I also think this was really awful of your mum.

The way she cut you out of the picture and contacted your ds secretly about this is REALLY bad and I think it needs MAJOR dealing with. It's absolutely outrageous that she would do this herself without recourse to you as ds' mum. I think it's because she knows you wouldn't agree with her and she just HAD to say something for whatever warped reason of her own! God, I'm crosser than I thought I was!

However I really think your ds will take his lead from you, so I think be very clear with him that you think it was a WEIRD thing to say, very silly, etc etc etc. He will be fine and pick up the relationship with your dd where he left off, I'm sure. If he needs gentle encouragement I'm sure you'll do this but the good thing is that your dd will expect the same relationship and rough and tumble as before so your ds will be being prompted by her anyway.

I think if it was me I might even write a letter to my mum, if I felt I might not get the point accross in a chat. It's really important that she knows NEVER to undermine your parental role like this again. And to keep her bizarre opinions to herself!

LieselVentouse · 13/02/2007 12:03

If she has a problem with that then thats her problem and she should get it seen to.

Tiggiwinkle · 13/02/2007 11:14

It is awful that your mother could have thought such a thing. Unforgivable that she spoke to your DS in such a manner, especially the "in confidence" bit.
I also wonder if she is jealous of the obviously loving family environment you have created, which is so different to the one she gave you. Perhaps she is trying to destroy it in this way? Definitely speak to her in no uncertain terms about the way you feel.

kimi · 13/02/2007 11:05

I think you need to speak to your mum, it was a bit of a sick thing to say.

Swipe left for the next trending thread