Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect tax avoidance to be treated in the same way as benefit fraud

66 replies

speedymama · 12/02/2007 11:45

Does the govt put as much emphasis on clamping down rich folk who avoid paying taxes as they do on targetting benefit fraudsters?

I ask this because of the current advertising campaign against benefit cheats. I personally think it is just as wrong and in some ways more immoral, for those you can pay more tax but don't to get away with it because they can afford to get round all the loopholes.

Just want to add that benefit fraud is wrong too and should be dealt with accordingly. It just appears to me that society treats benefit cheats with more disdain than those who deliberately seek ways of avoiding to pay tax even though they can afford to pay it, e.g. residents of Monte Carlo who enjoy the trappings of being British.

OP posts:
Dinosaur · 12/02/2007 12:13

On the IHT point - there was something in the Grauniad this morning claiming that only 6% of estates are subject to inheritance tax - which seemed terribly low given that the threshold is only £285,000 and that would hardly buy you a garden shed in large swathes of the country!

Dinosaur · 12/02/2007 12:12

Jimjams, was basing this on the ones I have met through work - but obviously I haven't met your DH and I'm sure he's quite quite different!

Actually, my best friend through work is a tax lawyer and her attitude boils down to "pay some tax, you rich bu88er" .

Jimjams2 · 12/02/2007 12:11

er dinosaur dh is a tax lawyer!

He's more bothered about nice people who will have to sell the house they've been left because they're teachers and can't afford the IHT (or something - I switch off when he starts mentioning actual taxes). And he reads the indie.

wannaBeWhateverIWannaBe · 12/02/2007 12:10

But you have to know the difference between tax avoidance and tax evasion. Tax avoidance is not illegal, so you cannot liken it to benefit fraud. All businesses use some form of tax avoidance, be it putting through a meal out/a cab fair/a computer through the business account in order to not have to pay tax on it. If your company gives you a Christmas present they are using tax avoidance by putting those items through the business accounts and therefore are not paying tax on them. It?s not illegal, and I don?t really see why it?s immoral.

Tax evasion is another matter as it?s illegal and therefore is prosecutable. You cannot compare the two.

speedymama · 12/02/2007 12:10

I agree JimJams. I just find it distasteful that some of these schemes are legal.

OP posts:
Dinosaur · 12/02/2007 12:09

IME a lot of tax lawyers are rabid right-wingers who really take personal umbrage at the State taking any money off rich people at all!

Jimjams2 · 12/02/2007 12:08

but speedymama you can't prosecute something that's legal.

Jimjams2 · 12/02/2007 12:07

And as for money laundering legisltation- it's pretty draconian- and an area where you really are not allowed to make an honest mistake. (no idea whether they would prosecute a reasonable mistake although they certainly have the power to).

speedymama · 12/02/2007 12:06

I think it is a matter of perspective when you consider tax avoidance vs tax evasion.

OP posts:
Jimjams2 · 12/02/2007 12:05

agree with cloudhopper- the IR are pretty terrier like once they have you in your sights.

Cloudhopper · 12/02/2007 12:04

Actually it's not true. They have actually employed thousands of tax collectors to clamp down on the middle classes and self employed. This seems much more stringent than the efforts to clamp down on benefit fraud - in my anecdotal experience anyway.

The rich are the ones who do very well out of it, employing specialist advisers to limit their tax liability. Tax avoidance is different from tax evasion.

speedymama · 12/02/2007 12:02

Consequently, the poor get treated more harshly than those with money!

OP posts:
Ladymuck · 12/02/2007 12:01

HMRC does look very much on a cost/benefit basis. Your example of the Monte Carlo resident is probably legal so that is down to Brown changing the rules (and believe me the ruels tighten up all the time!). However with HMRC the issue is the fact that every investigation must be handled as if it is going to court (which ultimately is the way to get the tax owed), whereas for beenfit fraud they can just stop the benefits until the person has proven their entitlement.

Dinosaur · 12/02/2007 12:00

Tax avoidance is actually lawful (although obviously many people regard it as morally repugnant). Although the Revenue does look out for tax avoidance schemes and closes down those which sail too close to the wind.

Tax evasion is a different matter.

kookaburra · 12/02/2007 11:57

IMHO don't believe they can bothered to look for money they are not getting in than money they are shelling out.
An acquaintance reported her XDH to the tax authoriities for tax evasion (not 'legitimate' avoidance)and they weren't interested. Easier & cheaper to 'clamp down' & get results from a single mum with no tv licence that a confrontation with someone who might put up a fight with lawyers.

Jimjams2 · 12/02/2007 11:51

If someone acts illegally wrt tax they are treated pretty harshly. They certainly don't get away wiith it. If they use a legitimate scheme then fair enough, you can't really do much.

I would imagine there isn't much point running an advertising campaign re tax cheats as its so complicated I doubt anyone would just know.